HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

curiousllama

5,638 karma · joined February 24, 2020

submissionscomments
curiousllama··on Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large Language Models
> What if we just limited the science of birds to explaining how limb-flapping could produce levitation? Hmm yes. Birds are kind of like helicopters, it seems. Who’s to say that they are not basically one and the same? Moving on.

Well said. I'm gonna steal this explanation.

Also reminds me of the famous Carbonara quote: "if my grandmother had wheels, then she would be a bike" [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-RfHC91Ewc

curiousllama··on Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large Language Models
"LLMs can mimic the language patterns necessary to express 'Theory of Mind' concepts" != "Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged"

Let's imaging I have an API. This API tells me how much money I have in my bank account. One day, someone hacks the API to always return "One Gajillion Dollars." Does that mean that "One Gajillion Dollars" spontaneously emerged from my bank account?

ToM tests are meant to measure a hidden state that is mediated by (and only accessible through) language. Merely repeating the appropriate words is insufficient to conclude ToM exists. In fact, we know ToM doesn't exist because there's no hidden state.

The authors know this, and write "theory of mind-like ability" in the abstract, rather than just "theory of mind."

This is a cool new task it ChatGPT learned to complete! I love that they did this! But this is more "we beat the current record BLEU record" and less "this chatbot is kinda sentient"

curiousllama··on The entire prompt of Microsoft Bing Chat?
Details, details
curiousllama··on The entire prompt of Microsoft Bing Chat?
I can totally imagine this in a google doc with a tongue-in cheek comment thread:

> Is this really necessary?

> Let’s just be safe

curiousllama··on Ask HN: I just want to have fun programming again
I remember I had the most fun when my code sucked. I made all sorts of silent tradeoffs because I didn't know that I was trading things off.

"Look! I built a whole App that does the thing! Isn't it cool? Oh, yea, you need to use this gnarly url and - crap - yea, use chrome. Refresh it... Hold on, let me restart the Raspberry Pi... Got it! Look at that! So cool! Wait - did someone HACK this?"

The grown up version of this might be just building for one platform, and one happy path. Who cares if lots of people can't use it? If it's popular, you can turn it into a job then. But until that happens - just make the computer do something cool!

curiousllama··on Etsy is awash with illicit products and mass produced goods (2021)
Low key, I would buy a spell for my friend, as long as I got a video or certificate or something proving the spell was actually "cast"

Sounds like a great sibling gift tbh

curiousllama··on Meta to ask many managers to become individual contributors or leave
God help them if there's a few dozen Director-turned-IC folks running around trying to "redefine industry practice" or something because they got overpromoted as a manager
curiousllama··on Microsoft announces new Bing and Edge browser powered by upgraded ChatGPT AI
> I wish I could just explain to ChatGPT what I need copied and pasted from one document to another or what needs to be filled out

Is this something in the same problem space as ChatGPT? I'm not sure an LLM would be well suited for that, but could be wrong.

curiousllama··on Why the conventional wisdom on how to grow muscles is wrong
Someone higher up posted this link - every good coach I've seen recommends something very similar to this

https://www.reddit.com/r/Fitness/comments/37ylk5/a_linear_pr...

curiousllama··on Ask HN: Feeling Hopeless and Lost at 23
> But now, I really want to go back to school and learn things the traditional way because it feels too overwhelming.

It’s hard to give advice without knowing why you feel overwhelmed. Is the job crazy hours? Too much new stuff to learn? Different than you expected?

How are your colleagues - supportive, engaged, helpful? Or aloof, focused on their own work, perhaps critical at times?

What’s your feedback at work like - positive + encouraging, or negative and highlighting weak spots?

The solution could be anything from “see a therapist” to “be more proactive” to “this is just what imposter syndrome feels like.”

curiousllama··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
This is an interesting idea I hadn't considered before
curiousllama··on Meta Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2022 Results
A few long term bull arguments:

- They have the worlds largest messaging platform (WhatsApp) that is basically unmonetized rn.

- They are one of 3-5 major players in AI. Amazon was one of the 3-5 largest internet companies... and then created AWS. (e.g., they released-then-unreleased a GPT3 clone before ChatGPT, because they got slammed in the press for ethics. doesn't mean they can't build a B2B business with it.)

- The regulatory landscape is shifting towards tech nationalism. Yea, there'll be regulation, but nationalism will limit the scope + create a moat against upstarts.

Recessions are great times to build new businesses - if you have cash on hand. They have cash.

curiousllama··on Ask HN: How do you test SQL?
> Try and write any complex SQL as a series of semantically meaningful CTEs

I find this helps a heck of a lot with maintainability + debugging as well

curiousllama··on India’s population will start to shrink sooner than expected (2021)
Are they consistently biased one way? Multiple Aadhar would seem to bias down, while the double-child would bias up.

The first censuses in the US were basically "a dude rides into town, asks how many people live there, then leaves" and got surprisingly close to recent estimates.

I just wonder if this is a matter of "there's error everywhere, it's basically stochastic, the # is close enough"

curiousllama··on Builder's Remedy goes into effect in many California cities tomorrow
An important caveat here is that these small groups are only "nuked from orbit" for the time period that they're out of compliance with a law that has existed for 50 years.

I totally agree that "people living together in a small area" can pretty much do what they want. The only issue is when that starts to screw over other folks, and when all the other small areas get together to do the same.

Then it's pretty reasonable for the state to go "you can't just never build houses. That's a decision that screws the rest of the state" and enforce that decision

curiousllama··on I want to lose every debate
I used to think this too, but found it was mostly a manifestation of my intellectual cowardice, not a coherent position itself.

An open-minded willingness to change one’s mind is admirable. But if you change your mind too often, you end up thinking less yourself - you’re outsourcing learning. It should get incrementally more difficult to change your mind the more you learn. Otherwise, you’re just collecting facts, not actually understanding anything.

Besides, you don’t really hope you’re wrong, and it’s a bit arrogant to say so. Have you ascended above these petty emotions of the flesh? Being wrong is A Bad Thing, and “I believe I’m wrong” is an oxymoron.

I think a better approach is “I’m always willing to change my mind, and hope I never have to.” I’m often wrong, about things of which I’m unaware, and I always pursue the opportunity to be less wrong.

But it’s a worse title.

curiousllama··on I lost $209k of my own money trying to start a business
“Normally, it’s done manually, and requires months off notice. Be we can do it digitally, on short notice”
curiousllama··on White House plan to foster equity and excellence in STEMM is all about equity
Economic disparity is a mechanism through which structural racism works.

If we purposefully impoverish black people (e.g., via Jim Crow), the destitution of their kids isn't _just_ an economic problem.

And note that this is the literal case: I know a bunch of poor older folks whose parents struggled to get good jobs because of Jim Crow policies.

curiousllama··on Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining?
Everything isn’t declining. Things were never great, by any modern definition. We just have an expectation that things are supposed to be easy breezy nowadays, and it turns out people are still people.

Like, are you telling me that NYC landlords in the 90s weren’t trying to scam their tenants? That Philly police in the 80s were clean, efficient, trustworthy public servants? That there was less fraud in the .com boom, or before the Great Recession, then now with AI-SaaSchain nonsense?

I used to go to a burger place where the cashier would just tell me to fuck off if I ordered too slow. I can’t imagine trying to tell that dude he forgot _napkins_ in my bag.

I totally get the urge to rant too. People suck. But don’t lose hope! Because people always sucked, and it’s nothing new.

curiousllama··on France's largest semiconductor company got nationalized in plain sight (2022)
Yea, it does. Eg the clause to distribute shares is basically a poison pill with extra steps

This reads like a board scared of a hostile takeover, which seems reasonable given geopolitics rn

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/poisonpill.asp#toc-what...

curiousllama··on 1min high-intensity exercise 3x a week improves fitness as much as 3x aerobics (2016)
Having dabbled in a couple different exercise disciplines, I’d encourage very small updates to your priors from this study.

Every bodybuilder knows that you have to push to failure and rest a lot between sets. The term for low-intensity or unrested lifting is “junk volume.”

Every runner knows that 80% of your volume should be easy. It’s called “80/20 training.”

Every CrossFit bro knows you need both intensity and volume - and maximizing that over time is what’s important.

They all work, but in different ways + for different reasons.

There’s lots of studies that try to break the mold. Usually, they’re limited by the impracticality of a large N, or perfect adherence, or exogenous factors, or avoiding hype. It’s a limitation of the field. It just means things will go slower. Don’t worry too much about any one study.

curiousllama··on Apple CEO Tim Cook requests and receives a 40% pay cut
Doesn't Zuckerburg not take a salary?
curiousllama··on The strange and awful path of productivity in the US construction sector
Couldn’t this just be survivorship bias? We already locked down all the cheap crap from the 60s. It’s only the rare, well-built buildings that are still around.

We’re building more cheap crap, sure, but also a few rare, well-built buildings.

curiousllama··on It's legal to hit children in school in 19 American states
There’s actually formal combat rules, similar to dueling. It’s fairly progressive for that part of the world
curiousllama··on What to do when you’ve ruined your life
I remember in my 20s going from Having it All Figured Out to single, unemployed, drastically reduced social circle, living in my parents basement, got depressed & anxious, got out of shape, took smoking back up - all in 6 months time. It wasn't all connected, but it did happen all at once, and I definitely let it snowball on me.

The best advice I got was to solve one problem at a time. I went all in on getting a job. Then getting an apt. Then getting in shape. Then reconnecting with friends. Then dating again. Then quitting smoking again.

I definitely had to lean on family/friends for help. Especially my parents, who had their adult son back in their basement for a few months, and a few friends/former colleagues, who worked their networks on my behalf.

> I have expertise in Ruined Life Reclamation

In hindsight, the person who gave me the best advice definitely did have some expertise themselves.

curiousllama··on Ain't it funny how the knight moves?
Love it. Anyone found a strategy better than “choose a path that will get you there that has a square in the largest quadrant, and jump from there”?
curiousllama··on Databricks cofounders weren’t interested in starting a business (2021)
Account executive - very senior salesperson.
curiousllama··on Ask HN: Where are all the parties?
This is a good point. There’s definitely a different baseline ROI for different people.

But still, I was surprised how much of “how to make people like me” was pretty explicitly learnable.

But your point does still stand. If you’re happy where you are - you have “other, better options” - def doesn’t make sense to invest in something where you’re not gonna get the return you want.

curiousllama··on Ask HN: Where are all the parties?
> your post reeks of DINK and youth

Did you notice that they’re talking to a new grad?

“I can’t believe a young person would suggest youth oriented thing to another young person!”

curiousllama··on Ask HN: Where are all the parties?
For sure. Assuming you have a few friends to start:

(0) Reach out to everyone. Everyone. That old college acquaintance you just noticed is in your city? Get coffee/happy hour. You never know who's looking for more friends.

(1) Encourage people to invite/bring their friends when you organize something. Hit up one friend for happy hour/food. "You've mentioned [coworker] a few times before - would he/she want to join us?"

(2) Host (implied) large group gatherings. Easy to say "come over, and bring whoever!" I like sports, so I host for the super bowl, World cup, March Madness, etc. - but could be anything. Throw parties for other peoples' birthday/going away/coming-to-the-city. Advance level: some bars are often open to "hosting" an event - they'll just rope off an area if you promise X people will show up.

(3) Host recurring events. Board Game nights, poker nights, dinner parties, wine club, etc. Great way to deepen relationships.

(4) Start group chats. Much easier to maintain a relationship with 4 group chats than 20 individuals. If one can't get critical mass, post the plan in another.

(5) Be actively welcoming. Make a point to intro yourself to new people/social stragglers on the edge, and greet people by name when they show up in a new-ish space (e.g., my friend brings his new gf to a board game night; she doesn't know many people here; stand up and say "Hello Janice! Great to finally meet you. How has your week been?"). Forge connection, don't just co-exist in the same space.

I'm sure there's more...

← PreviousPage 8 of 30Next →