HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

curtainsforus

106 karma · joined October 25, 2020

submissionscomments
curtainsforus··on Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade
Get rid of child care laws, then. No taxation without representation!
curtainsforus··on They're made out of meat (1991)
We observe causality in our universe and day-to-day lives. If FTL movement is possible, you might expect at least some particles to be doing it, and that there'd be closed timelike curves or causality breaking happening already in nature, and we don't.

It's not clear what 'breaking causality' would look like. It's like saying what if you made 0 equal 1?

curtainsforus··on Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade
Public nudity laws are authoritarian!
curtainsforus··on Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade
Class is cultural before it's monetary. You can give Billy-bob a million dollars- a rich hick, a hick remains.

Every class tranche uses fashion to differentiate themselves from the tranche just below, while imitating the tranches above. The upper class used to wear fancy clothes to differentiate themselves from the middle class; the middle class started wearing the clothes of the upper class to try and join them; boom, ghetto chic becomes popular among ivy-leaguers. (They don't have to worry about being mistaken for actual lower-class people; the cultural differences are big enough that that isn't a concern).

This helps maintain in-group selection with all the wonderful effects it has.

curtainsforus··on Making Code Faster
The operating systems that get fatter and slower every year?
curtainsforus··on Japan tested a giant turbine that generates electricity using deep ocean current
The grid prefers smooth, even, intertia-backed turbine-generated power to the choppy screams of a million inverters.
curtainsforus··on India defuses its population bomb: fertility falls to two children per woman
>Suppose the population falls to say, 2 Billion or something like that. Is that a big problem?

There are problems with that, yes. That's fewer geniuses, who are in short supply. I like humans. The more humans, the better, quality of life being equal.

curtainsforus··on Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
If you're wrong, surely you'll have materially harmed some people by encouraging them to do something they don't like?
curtainsforus··on Myocarditis associated with Covid-19 compared to mRNA vaccines
I could imagine a world where no respectable journal would publish a conspiracy theory like 'the vaccine is worse than covid for under-25 males', and no respectable academic would touch the question because it's too radioactive. Academia is politicized. We've already had plenty of cases of medical academics getting hounded off e.g. twitter for supporting non-mainstream positions, questioning vaccine rollout timelines, or entertaining the lab leak.
curtainsforus··on Journal of Controversial Ideas
Push the button! The rainforest is evil.
curtainsforus··on Launch HN: Turion Space (YC S21) – Space debris removal and satellite servicing
Unless it's using a low-thrust-high-efficiency drive such that significant inclination changes take a year.
curtainsforus··on Ask HN: Employer is requiring vaccine, but I have a medically documented issue
Then what you're doing right now should be illegal!
curtainsforus··on How Dwarf Fortress is built
That's why many players had methods for 'taking care of' migrants
curtainsforus··on We should build for wildlife as well as people
>Humans dramatically increase and multiply the amount of suffering in the world I don't believe that. All the animals that are alive today would die in pain in anyway, no matter what humans do. Every deer that's shot is one not eaten alive by wolves, or starving to death. Does it matter whether a bird drowns in an oil slick or thrashes in the mouth of a crocodile? Animal life is nasty, brutish, and short. Even if we killed a large fraction of the animals on the planet in a painful way, that would be a blip in the colossal historical tapestry of pain, and as there'd be fewer animals in the next generation, it would probably be morally neutral from a consequentialist perspective: the overall, average amount of suffering would be constant.

>there's already suffering in the world, so why do anything about it?

No, that's not what I'm saying. If I care about suffering, I only care slightly (instrumentally) whether it's caused by humans or nature. You seem to care a lot, but I don't. If I 'm going to decide to care about the suffering of animals generally, then that's going to lead me to certain conclusions.

If humans are going to take responsibility for animal suffering, we should take responsibility for all animal suffering, meaning we should reorganize/destroy the ecosphere, replacing it with something more moral. We should also become able to be wise stewards of the new world, of course.

But if I put myself into the mindset of "I care about the suffering of animals", then going from that to "humans should be hippies and let nature be, man" seems pretty evil. If the suffering of animals is bad, then nature is bad and should be stopped.

>For the most part, a balance is achieved. Animals and plants take what they need in order to survive, and there's no other way for them to survive No, animals and plants take as much as they can get, and most of them don't get enough. The ones that don't get what they need in order to survive die, by starvation or by being got by a predator. The balance here is on a see-saw greased with the blood of living things: if I built a system like that, where little furry animals reproduced until there was no food left and then competed increasingly frantically, with some of them eating the others, and then turned around to you and said "look, they've reached a balance! As many of them die horribly as are pumped out! :)", you'd call me a psycho. You're only excusing it because it's natural. It's mathematically beautiful, of course!

>The argument isn't to rid the world of suffering, because how could that even be accomplished?

Wipe out the natural world: Evacuate humans and scans/genomes of all the animals we're interested in somewhere else and build a paradise there; then wreck the surface of the earth so that nothing bigger than a bacterium can survive. Maybe we could engineer runaway global warming, to turn earth into something resembling Venus? Deliberately irradiate the whole surface to the point that nothing survives? Build lots of orbital mirrors to increase the solar irradiance and boil the oceans? Grey goo? Dream big!

If this sounds horrible to you, then I guess you have an aesthetic preference for forests. That's fine, but remember that forests and jungles are hell-pits of torture.

curtainsforus··on We should build for wildlife as well as people
Of course, in the long run our goal should be to destroy the ecosphere. But yes, we need to survive till we get there.
curtainsforus··on We should build for wildlife as well as people
There's lots of labor-intensive ways to boost yields without monocultures, fertilizers, and pesticides, right? Planting complementary crops together, planting trap crops at the edges of fields to catch pests, things like that.

How long till robots can do that sort of work? At that point, you can have super-green-bio gardens (fields) worked and pruned 24/7 at the cost-over-time of the robots (and whoever/whatever oversees them, plus manure I guess).

We already have a version of this- called a combine harvester- but the more sophisticated farming tech gets, the more it can reduce reliance on e.g. pesticides without reducing yields.

curtainsforus··on We should build for wildlife as well as people
>Not without destruction or suffering

Imagine a world without humans. Every day, millions of animals that are able to feel pain die in horrible agony as they're eaten alive; die of hunger or disease; are afflicted by horrific parasitism, or birth defects, or any of a hundred different horrors.

Earth is a giant ball of suffering, and has been since the first animal with a nervous system sufficient to feel pain evolved. It seems pretty hubristic to lay that at the feet of humanity.

Yeah, if we don't coordinate we might wipe out some species, collapse some ecosystems. So? Those ecosystems have beautiful parts in them, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder; and in any case, their beauty is built on the ongoing torture of (presumably) sentient animals. In that case, bring on the mass extinctions, I say; in fact, we should probably speed them up. Shoot or nuke animals instead of letting them starve to death or be eaten alive.

Maybe we can re-introduce animals once we've made them immortal and immune to pain.

(I don't actually want this, I like nature and forests. But I like them because I find them beautiful, and I perceive their value as originating from humans (and to a lesser extent sentient animals) finding them beautiful. I don't care about them for some other metaphysical reason, and nature is beautiful <=> humanity is evil isn't a viewpoint I've ended up with. )

curtainsforus··on We should build for wildlife as well as people
The whales died in agony before, as did the birds, and those delicate insect bodies are crushed, eaten, and dashed as quickly as they're made.

Nature's a beautiful edifice built on the back of hundreds of millions of years of suffering. You could make the argument the most moral thing to do, if you care about the well-being elephants and the turtles and the chickens, is to re-organize it as quickly as is practical and wise.

curtainsforus··on Water transformed into shiny, golden metal
I find the tone he takes in his debunking videos pretty annoying (although I agree with him on almost all of his stances on what's a scam/vaporware and what not), but when he's actually talking about his own science/science in general he's very listenable.
curtainsforus··on The most precious resource is agency
That doesn't mean it's impossible to create artificial intelligences, though, which was Dreyfus' point.
curtainsforus··on The most precious resource is agency
Not without people to do it with. And the people that the parent poster is talking about aren't nomads.
curtainsforus··on Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project
Would very many HN'ers get up in arms about someone copying an iphone? It's not like apple needs more profit.
curtainsforus··on Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project
There's more freedom of speech than other western countries, there's a greater ability to bear arms than other countries...
curtainsforus··on Please commit more blatant academic fraud
Should you try to overcome your survival instinct?
curtainsforus··on Please commit more blatant academic fraud
The most important thing about humans is which ones I'm allowed to attack.
curtainsforus··on James Bond Unmasked (1968)
Talking about nazi dogwhistling is spreading theories about a conspiracy hidden in plain sight with the goal of destroying the western order, taking over the world, and executing the genocide of several peoples.

Thus, you yourself are guilty of antisemetic dogwhistling.

curtainsforus··on James Bond Unmasked (1968)
You agree with fox news on half of your points?
curtainsforus··on Now your car is a cybersecurity risk, too
Also, the spyware TV's can be sold at a discount because they make money back off selling the user's data.
curtainsforus··on Physicists identify the engine powering black hole energy beams
From the perspective of an outside observer, nothing ever reaches past the event horizon- it just asymptotically approaches it. The same goes for the whole mass of the black of hole- from an outside perspective, it's smeared across the surface.

There isn't an object that messes with the warping of spacetime- the black hole IS the warp in spacetime. If changes in spacetime couldn't propagate away from the black hole, it wouldn't exist.

curtainsforus··on Vegan cheese has quietly but steadily infiltrated mainstream supermarket shelves
You have canines. We're evolved to eat meat.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →