771 karma · joined September 8, 2014
It seems to be the standard criticism of smart phones today; but it's in pretentious art form.
Boy Scouts of America Hiking Safety Recommendations:
- Always tell someone where you are going and when you will return.
- Never hike alone or at night; use the buddy system.
- Dress properly for the weather and environment.
- Wear sun and insect protection
- Take an extra pair of socks in case you need to change.
- Obey traffic signs and signals.
- Avoid hiking along roadways.
- Stay on the trail.
- Be alert to your surroundings.
- Don't litter as you hike.
- Be alert to dangerous animals, insects, and plants.
- Never touch a wild animal.
- Take 1 pint of water for each hour you will be hiking.
- Never drink untreated water.
A) Meditation takes concerted effort (by definition). B) Meditaiton has been shown to increase empathy: http://nccam.nih.gov/research/results/spotlight/060608.htm Conclusion) You can put effort into improving yourself and improve yourself (in this case: become more empathetic toward others).
> They're compounds which have debatable (and unresearched) longer term effects on those who imbibe them,
25 years is pretty long: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment#Doblin... But we do need more.
> and which have fairly established negative impact on people who take them and are at risk for developing a serious mental illness. (family history, etc.)
Yes. If you have a family history of schizophrenia (or other severe mental illnesses), you shouldn't try psychedelic drugs. They can precipitate schizophrenic episodes, psychotic breaks, and the like.
Other than that, I totally agree. I was just trying to clearly and succinctly discount the enlightenment-in-a-pill attitude.
Generally, no. You can't become better by taking a drug, but they're not talking about bettering themselves. They're talking about healing. If your intention is to better yourself with the aid of psychedelic drugs[1], you'll only get out what you put in, and psychedelics will mostly only inspire you to put forth the effort. edit: You still have to work at improving yourself through other means.
> For each individual who says psychedelics have made them a better person, there are hundreds who make the same claim about religion.
Well, not that many people are willing to try psychedelics.
> And I think we can all agree that the risk of biological side effects is much lower with religion.
Every year more people are killed in the name of religion than by psychedelics. Psychedelics kill noone. Their LD50 is usually too high.
> If I were going to follow your advice and try MDMA, shouldn't I follow my father's advice and try religion first?
Sure, but please try more than one religion, and check out philosophy too. You can choose whether or not to try MDMA in the same way that you can choose whether or not to go sky diving.
[1] This is not an inherently misguided idea, but in uncontrolled environments, psychedelics can be quite dangerous.
There has been some promising research with psilocybin: http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/Press_releases/2006/07_11_06....