HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cynicalkane

6,541 karma · joined October 11, 2009

submissionscomments
cynicalkane··on Reading too much political news is bad for your well-being
[1] sounds like a good quote, but keep in mind that the author of that quote was a tacit supporter of Leininsm and Stalinism, and initially supported East Germany's murderous repression of union labor.

In practice many people who "hate politics" are, I think, at least partially motivated by not desiring to get into conversations with people who would call them "illiterate" and "imbecile" for, yanno, not supporting evil authoritarianism and the nonsense pseudophilosophy that motivates it.

I think many people would not "hate politics" were it not for the nature of the politically-motivated to look down on those who disagree.

cynicalkane··on The ballooning money supply may be the key to unlocking inflation in the U.S.
I don't think this is exactly it. One can try -- and try fruitfully, for these theories have been useful in practice -- to match 'money' and 'inflation' and 'debt', in their macro senses, to everyday experience, with the caveat that they're aggregate concepts that affect individuals and various productive activities differently, and that they (money especially) can behave a little weird.

What happens instead is that people have feelings about what these concepts are supposed to mean, and then use that to make a political statement. The reason armchair- and pseudo-economists are so eager to say things like "Money is really about X" or "Money is really about the opposite of X" is they want to hijack the word 'money' and the meaning it has in the brain and turn that into politics.

These confident takes are more directly engaging, whereas economic pronouncements are wonky and weird in a way that's more relatively neutral or at least not obviously political, so the gravitation is towards the bad and confusing takes.

cynicalkane··on Amazon’s Alexa for landlords is a privacy nightmare waiting to happen
This is correct. If some given set of landlords can get away with charging $50 more per month, they'd already be doing it. Some individual landlords might be irrational, but as a whole property isn't a market where people leave money on the table.
cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
That's deeply disingenuous. It's not like this guy was telling the truth everywhere else. The lies were numerous.

That's what Gell-Mann amnesia is, really: we believe what we want to believe, and forget the quality of the source.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
I feel like there's some form of Gell-Mann amnesia here. Why say a book is right about a lot of big things when it is frequently wrong about those things which can be verified?
cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
The "straw-man" concerns one of the most hateful, vapid and odious ideas that humanity that ever devised. Corbyn failed to confront it.

Conspiracy theories, whataboutism, insults -- these are less than nothing, yet the spineless Corbyn and his supporters dare claim leadership over better people, and fabricate whiny paranoid stories of their persecution. Given that there are liberals and leftists who are not comfortable with pointless evil, everything else is insignificant.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
No. The "real solution" is to oppose anti-semitism with all due expediency.

I don't care if it was exasperated by "saboteurs". If Corbyn can't adopt this basic moral position that all humans ought to adopt, I don't care to hear any excuses at all.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
I hate this sort of defense-by-attack. Corbyn needed to defend Labor from anti-semitism by... eliminating neoliberals? How about by eliminating anti-semites?

It's like, what are the priorities here?

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
I mean, Graeber is right in that he was being trolled. But Graeber lies when he says he tried to ignore DeLong and Graeber lies when he characterizes DeLong as obsessively harping on one inaccuracy.

Graeber's fit of apoplexy wasn't just in that one HN comment. His "ignoring" DeLong was an uninterrupted train of obsessive, one-sided, and often bizarrely misdirected anger and insult. The only "ignoring" was that Graeber, in all his raging against DeLong's trollbot, did not bother do any raging in the form of citing facts or other defense. As DeLong puts it:

> Graeber, of course, makes no attempt to defend his claims in his chapter 12. He doesn't because he can't. Chapter 12 is in fact riddled with errors.... It really appears to be just too easy for people like David Graeber to imagine that they are in a two-month extended conversation where there is a human mind on the other side, when actually they are just the bird pecking itself in the window glass[1].

That incident was a piece in a longer flamewar in which Graeber, essentially, behaves in the obsessive and intellectually bankrupt manner he accused DeLong of behaving.

[1]https://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2013/04/david-graeber-april-f...

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
That reads like a post-hoc justification to me. Most people practice ignoring people by, well, ignoring them. If they don't, they will explain what's "really going on" by just explaining it, not with prolonged fits of unwarranted and uncharitable apoplexy.

As I described elsewhere, Graeber is also lying when he said he made any serious attempt to ignore DeLong at all.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
You can refer to dang's link to Graeber's flamewar with Brad DeLong on here. It begins and ends with insults sandwiching a suspiciously uncharitable characterization of the subject.

This suspicion is founded: many of Graeber's claims are also false; in particular, Delong provided a litany of elementary falsehoods in Debt, in which Graeber's inaccurate claim about Apple is merely of especial characteristic inaccuracy--but that's beyond the scope of this post. Zooming back out, if one leads and ends with hateful insults which they cannot justify, that ought to be viewed with deep suspicion. No, DeLong is not a "con-man" who "suckers" people because he wants to call out a book which he feels, and can earnestly argue, is deeply wrong.

Near the end of this long, screenfilling rant, Graeber claims he has been trying to "ignore" DeLong. I didn't know such fits of apoplexy were how you ignored someone.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber has died
"He also got into flamewars on Hacker News"

It's disappointing to see 'flamewar' contexualizxed after 'provoking interesting discussion'. Reading through Graeber's long, contradictory, insult-filled, self-important rants, I'm not sure what would motivate this contextualization.

Normally, I might assume good faith, but Graeber's polemical behavior characterizes both a significant part of his work and a significant part of his participation on his site. The contextualization of this kind of unhinged and hateful behavior as some sort of intellectualism is something I find especially repulsive and pernicious.

cynicalkane··on What harm do minimum wages do?
Consumption is the income and wealth that you end up using. Measuring wellbeing by consumption is the standard economic perspective, since it describes how much of society's goods and services one ends up using.

More simply, if you save then spend, wealth-based measures will rate you as better off than a person with higher income who just spends. That doesn't make sense.

cynicalkane··on Statement on Google’s conduct by founder of CelebrityNetWorth.com (2019) [pdf]
> I do know that when I confronted Cutts about the penalty here on HN he lied about it - which does lead one to wonder about his motive

The preamble to this post hints of paranoia, but this is where we know for sure. There's no reason to believe Cutts would have any personal knowledge or involvement or motivation, except that he knew another person who might have had some weak interest in maybe doing something. Of course, the poster feels that, having drawn this chain of connections, that he must be right and Cutts must be lying.

The poster feels entitled now to personally attacking a specific well-known search engineer, one who has been active here in the past. This seems like a conduct violation on here or any reasonable discussion site.

cynicalkane··on Nobel Laureates Aim Too Low on Global Poverty
The Nobel Foundation recognizes the economics prize as a Nobel prize.

So, yes, it is a Nobel prize because the guys in charge of Nobel prizes say it is. It's also awarded by the guys who award the other Nobel science prizes (the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences).

cynicalkane··on Eyewitnesses describe brutal beatings by HK police
> pushed it into an inflationary debt crisis and eventually created Nazism

The hyperinflation of the early 20s has a lot of sticking power in the mind, but it was the severe deflationary crisis of 1929-32 that immediately preceded the rise of Nazism.

cynicalkane··on Camera sales are falling sharply
It's not just that. The lens itself doesn't have enough resolving power. When light passes through a tiny aperture, it becomes irreversibly blurred, enough to be detected by the micron-scale pixels in the camera sensor.

Camera phones will try to re-sharpen the image, but some information is always lost. It's especially obvious looking at things with fine detail and sharp edges, like tree leaves against a bright sky.

cynicalkane··on Disneyland’s Disastrous Opening Day (2015)
> What it was was the first theme part based on a particular set of core values.

That's what makes it a 'theme park'. Previous large-scale amusement parks didn't have central defining themes, though there were older examples of small-scale theme parks.

By modern standards, 'old timey carnival' might be a theme, but obviously it wasn't at the time.

cynicalkane··on The Evolution of the Male Falsetto
Really?

I'm not sure where the debate would lie; falsetto is a clearly identifiable physical voice register that, without deliberate training, sounds quite different from the usual 'modal' voice. Futhermore, there is generally no 'in-between'--it's either one register or the other. Some singers can switch between the two without audible seams, but it's very difficult.

cynicalkane··on Alaska’s Engineering Colleges Prepare to Slash Programs, Lay Off Faculty
Property, income, and sales taxes are all part of the cost of living and doing business. Raising property taxes won't hurt the general public any more than raising the other two. Taxes aren't a menu where you need a little of column A and a little of column B, just because. It's all money coming from the economy in some form and the important part is what you're incentivizing or disincentivizing.

In fact, there's a minor but respectable economic school of thought that property taxes should be greater than 100% of all taxes, and the excess should be redistributed to the disadvantaged. Property taxes disincentivize hoarding and wasteful use of valuable property, which is A Good Thing.

cynicalkane··on Terence Tao's Raw Notes After His Princeton Comprehensive Exams (1999)
When I was a math major at U. Chicago, there was at least one professor who did this.
cynicalkane··on New Taxes and Higher Density Aren't Fixing Vancouver's Housing Problem
> Today's luxury apartment is tomorrow's affordable one.

Moreover, today's luxury apartment turns yesterday's luxury apartment into a less expensive one.

cynicalkane··on Hiring Is Broken
A breadth-first search is a pretty basic algorithm, but even if you don't have it "memorized", the question is simply: here's a data structure, we need to traverse it in a certain order. Traversing data structures is so common that, even without a formal CS education, I'd expect an engineer with years of experience to have the strategies in a sort of unconscious memory, like a rock guitarist who plays the right chord progressions without knowing what they're called.

A candidate who freaks out upon being asked that question is not a candidate whom I'd trust to be a good problem solver. Solving a problem with simple constraints is something that happens all the time. If you don't know how to approach that, you could just "look it up", but how would you even know what to look up?

cynicalkane··on South Korea's program of higher wages and taxes – so far, it's not working
> the economy is powered by money changing hands

The economy is powered by creation and exchange of value. Money changing hands is mistaking the incentive for the act itself.

Most economic schools of thought advocate stimulus during recessions to stop a slowdown of money changing hands, but this is a short-term measure. Money isn't the economy and there's no reason to believe making money fly around willy-nilly will help the economy in a permanent way.

cynicalkane··on Facebook is not equipped to stop the spread of authoritarianism
Did you read the article? Much of it was about authorities cracking down on free speech on Facebook. The article is saying the opposite of what you think it’s saying.

But as an aside, free speech is the biggest thing keeping the press alive. The “mainstream media” has much more to fear from authorities than from fringe alt-politics. This has been true through history and it’s true now.

cynicalkane··on Robinhood Checking Moved Fast and Broke
A financial lawyer should fully understand the consequences of misleading consumer financial products, especially post-2008. First, you aren't allowed to do that anyway. Second, consumer finance is one area where cleverness is virtually not allowed.
cynicalkane··on I Bootstrapped My Side Project to $6k/Month (2017)
C. S. Lewis writes along similar lines in The Great Divorce and The Screwtape Letters, two very different books, but both of which of I'd credit as changing my life. The common theme in both is that to be damned is not to sin greatly, but to become comfortable with the abandonment of good.
cynicalkane··on There is more to high house prices than constrained supply
I’ve noticed with doomsayers it’s always deflation or hyperinflation. It never occurs to them that the Fed can do something that’s in between the two, such as what they’ve been doing for almost forty years since Volcker stamped down inflation.

Central banks in practice can print as much or as little money as they want. In the third world, they often do. Well-functioning banks like those we have in the Western world can do better, such as the way Iceland was able to deal with their entire financial system collapsing in one day. But it’s always intrigued me the way people talk about QE as though there’s something artificial. Artificial is exchanging pictures of George Washinton for goods and services. Everything else is an implementation detail.

cynicalkane··on NYC subway and bus services have entered 'death spiral', experts say
This is wrong in many ways.

* Unionized workers make very good money in New York.

* Unions are a primary political driver behind those expensive contracts.

* There's more to unions than conductors. Construction and maintenance, for example.

* The unions routinely put up strong opposition to any meaningful expense or quality control. They also strongly oppose any modernization attempts that might threaten their jobs. They've opposed electronic signaling and control for decades. The worse the subways are, the better it is for them.

* Unions are politically untouchable. No matter what the consequences for the public, people are willing to leap to the defense of the noble workingman. Actually, the noble workingman who needs a "living wage" is riding the subways, not maintaining them. The poor and desperate are found among the five million people who ride the subway every day. Transportation is a public good. It shouldn't be beholden to a small group of highly paid laborers.

cynicalkane··on Uber Revenue Slows as Quarterly Loss Surges to $1.1B
I personally haven’t experienced any of that nonsense using Lyft. Your mileage may vary. But here in NYC, Uber’s reputation has fallen considerably.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →