HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cyphertruck

221 karma · joined November 26, 2019

submissionscomments
cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
“ LN fundamentally changes nothing. Its still uses bitcoin Tx it just combines many Tx and does the on-chain settlement at a later point thus reducing the number of on-chain Tx increases speed and reduces fees.”

That’s changing everything.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Lightning network is just a brand name for the cryptography that was needed to make Satoshi’s payment channels work.

So, while Satoshi’s opinion isnt really relevant to bitcoin’s future, since you brought it up, Satoshi clearly didn't think layer one was the inly way yo go.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
“Bitcoin bros” is a pejorative.
cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
I don’t understand the recent preference for taking assertions and declaring them “obviously objectively verifiable fact”.... but that is a good indicator they are false.

Bitcoin can and has scaled. And that is a fact, from Segwit and Taproot to Lightning the capacity and cost have improved dramatically.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Good. I hope you git rid of your hair dryer as well.

It’s not too late, you can get back in, though you will have a tax bill. Maybe it can be a wash trade.

But if FUD that’s dishonest about bitcoin mining scared you off then you haven’t learned enough about bitcoin yet.

This us how bitcoin seeks the strongest hands. HFSP

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
What you described doesn't even address the reason PoW exists. So, I’m sorry but it sounds like you are repeating something you heard without understanding the issues at hand. I suggest you read “There’s nothing cheaper than proof of work” by Paul Storzc
cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
You can easily make rpowerscoin. But it won’t be bitcoin. And its existence will have negligible impact on bitcoin.

There have been 100,000 clones of bitcoin (according to someone who claimed to have counted)but none are genuinely successful. Even forks if bitcoin fail despite spending millions on propaganda.

Think there might be a reason?

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Yes it did. It has been going on for ~50 years, and bitcoin is the culmination of work spanning that period.

Bitcoin was not the first cryptocurrency. It was the first good one, though.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
I looked into the “mathematical proof” a couple years ago, all I could find was hand waving and sleight of hand. This convinced me it was a scam.
cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Wasnt a slur, but a representation of his position. It should be a slur, though, as monetary inflation is a tax that hurts the poor the most.
cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
We have not had low monetary inflation since at least the Ford presidency.

You are confusing the consumer price index for “inflation”. It’s understandable, this lie is one of the earlier examples of fake news.

When the fed prints money it goes to wall street and politically connected people. (This is quite literally the definition of fascism- a private economy run by government)

Wall Street profits from the inflation, but the rest of the people get poorer.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
“This has been particularly noticeable in computers over the last three decades, but Moore's Law isn't a supporting argument for the benefits of monetary deflation.”

Asserting that an argument is not an argument is not a rebuttal.

The claim that people having more purchasing power will stop the economy is self serving for inflationists and never supported by evidence.

In fact the opposite has been the case time and time again.

As I proved in the example you simply ignored.

So, like I said, I have never seen an argument. Just these kinds of self serving assertions.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Inly if you redefine “rich”. Increased purchasing power makes you richer, giving you a chance to build wealth. Inflation robs this from society and is oppression. I really don't care to be gaslit about economics.

Bitcoin fixes this.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
You are arguing that the kings if the past with lots if gold starved, simply because their gold could buy more food over time. People don’t forgo food for decades to put more money into index funds despite the broad market increasing in value consistently over time.

Computers get cheaper every year such that even inflated dollars can be held to get a better computer next year.

And yet the technology industry has not ground to a halt. Food is low tech, cell phones are high tech.

It is obvious- this argument in favor of government being able to debase the currency to fund wars and somehow that’s good for poor people is never going to hold water.

But here is another thought- no matter how much you call it stupid, or fuedalistic, leftists gave been making this argument fir over a decade now and Bitcoin has only gotten stronger.

You may even be able to make it “illegal” if you ignore the constitution and laws, but you cannot stop it.

Bitcoin will be the tool that liberates the people out from under your technocratic thumb.

Thats what I find most exciting.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
The block size is not a limiting factor in transactions. And it was quadrupled in 2017.

The biggest problem with bitcoin is that scammers spread FUD to justify their scam coins and too many people believe the FUD.

You are repeating FUD here and basing it in your non-understanding of how bitcoin works.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
I think you are not understanding how bitcoin works, and this exact problem of double spending was better solved by bitcoin. You dont need to trust a third oarty or “online service”, you can dimply run a bitcoin node. If it is that important a raspberry pi and SSD is cheaper than your average credit card terminal.

The credit card network, by the way, is much worse in this regard.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
The costs of mining are both capital to acquire the equipment and replace it when it is obsolete... and energy. It’s not just energy. Recently that capital cost is about %50 of OpEx, but of course it varies. We cannot predict the future cost of electricity, but we can predict that technology will get cheaper, more generic and thus more ubiquitous. This is what I meant by “cheaper”.

I expect it will be cheap the way wifi is cheap on a raspberry pi. They just include it because you may use it and it’s cheaper to include it than to make both a version with and a version without the WiFi module. (If you inly use WIFI, then the sane argument goes for the redundant-to-you ethernet port.)

You are right about difficulty factor, but that just adjusts how fast blocks are won based on past 2 weeks.

Even when price of BRC has crashed, hash power doesn’t instantly go away.

Also an attack lets you re-organize recent blocks only. Increased depth gets more expensive pretty quick.

If mining chips are cheap and ubiquitous, then an attack us very hard, because you have to beat all the existing honest chips with your attack.

If mining is cheap to attack, the rewards of such an attack will be low.

If bitcoin is valuable, it will be expensive to attack.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Null transactions require mining. The question is if nobody wants to mine who will mine? Old mining chips are already so cheap they cost less than a cheap bitcoin transaction. It would not cost much to mine just to preserve the value of your holdings.
cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
Not sure how you measure an increase in mining demand, but given that we have had three halvenings now, doesn't that imply mining isn’t going away? They are getting less bitcoin, yet still mining. I don't think it will be a shock by then. Put another way, the shock in 2012, 2016 and 2020 have all made mining very profitable in the following years resulting in mining booms in 2013, 2017 & 2021 (so far.)

Transaction volumes over time have risen as well. If bitcoin has amy value to society in 113 years, people will pay to transact it. Whether that is one expensive transaction a month or a million every block I don’t know— but I think the latter is more likely.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
First off, thank you for making fair criticisms. Unfortunately some of your information is old.

You don’t need a bitcoin backed token, lightning does it.

Transaction rates are not artificially kept low. In fact most the vast majority of the time bitcoin has excess capacity.

Privacy- this is a legitimate concern but it is improving, slowly. Taoroot and Lightning are both privacy improvements.

So your daily transactions aren't meant for bitcoin. A distributed ledger that replicates all data globally for eternity is not an appropriate method for recording coffee purchases. Though I have done it. Bitcoin makes sense for settlement, and lightning is appropriate for coffee.

That said, I regularly clear bitcoin transactions for $1 or less in fees, and it is cheaper then every other form of payment in the world. You may think a SWIFT transaction is “free”, but its merely the cost is hidden. And don’t forget the inflation tax, that is a global wealth tax on any money held in an inflating currency. So compared to that, $1 to send $100 is cheap.

Online Only- I don’t think there is a solution to this criticism, but not sure what the issue is.

Lightning allows speed without double spend problems. Personally when moving large (for me) amounts of money I font mind waiting an hour for the confirmations. I certainly won’t trust a payment without them.

But bitcoin is voluntary, it doesn't have to be perfect in every regard.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
That article is from 2013 and so we must grade it on a curve. He makes several wrong assumptions about how bitcoin works because he’s thinking it is based on trust, and he is an inflationist.

I have yet to have an economist explain to me why deflation us bad- computers getting cheaper is good, fixed income people being able to afford things us good. Inflation mainly allows government to hand out money yo wall street in exchange for bribes at the expense of everyone else. That’s not good.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
As an engineer with twenty years experience in this space and nearly as long studying the economics of it, I have yet to see a replacement for PoW that solves the problem that PoW solves.

Proof of Work is trustless decentralization.

Proof of stake is trusting the dudes who premined the coin and sold you a “fix for bitcoins inherent problem” to hype their ICO.

If you were right, after 10 years one of those PoS currencies would be winning. Can you even remember the proof of stake currencies from 2011?

Why did they fail? After all they had a huge economic advantage over bitcoin mining as they cost effectively zero electricity.

Can you answer that question?

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
To answer that question you have to make assumptions about the cost of mining, the cost of attacks and the cost of hash power at a point 117 years from now. But we know in the future hash power (technology) will be cheaper and thus bitcoin security will be cheaper, while bitcoin will be more valuable (or non-existing — it has to be either or).

Also remember if you have wealth in bitcoin you would likely mine at a loss merely to secure your own bitcoin.

I can’t imagine mining going away.

I think every appliance in a household will end up mining a little bit and it will be intrinsic to the fabric of the economy. The way the internet is now.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin Is Time
In Bitcoin, the “local currency” equivalent to your “MyDogeCoin” example is called The lightning network.

Simplifying a bit to support your analogy:

Bitcoin lets you lock coins on the chain for a certain amount of time. Two people can do this, then trade bitcoin transactions back and forth without submitting them.

For example, I lock coins and give my coworker a bitcoin transaction I have signed giving him $10 worth of bitcoin for my share of the days lunch. Next day he fives me one for $13 for his share, and I give the restaurant $43 for the bill— all these transactions are literally trading bitcoin IOUs, but in a nearly trustless way.

This means a great deal of transactions can happen off chain without the risk of theft.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin is a disaster
Bitcoin is inflating, and will for 130 more years, though it is seeing increased adoption and is riding in price.

But in answer to your question,I’m glad you picked food fir your example— would you starve to hold onto your bitcoin?

Is your computer ten years old because next year better ones will come out? Or did you bite the bullet and upgrade because your time preference made it worthwhile?

It is true, deflation encourages savings, but that is the essence of capitalism, savings keeps people better able to avoid poverty in the event of a bad year, and capital accumulation makes you more able to do a startup and retain control.

Part of the reason there is so much VC money is inflation (VCs get new dollars cheap and carry trade through startups)with a hard currency like bitcoin the fotmula would be reversed, and founders would retain more ownership.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin is a disaster
I can’t see the flagged post, so don’t attack me here, I’m just going to explain the bitcoiner view.

Your presumption that inflation is good and that bitcoin needs to be able to support whatever “social policies” governments decide is antithetical to the purpose of bitcoin.

Bitcoin was created to escape currency debasement because it is how the people are impoverished. Currency debasement is the engine that creates wealth inequality. The Catillion effect means that people who get the newly printed money (eg wall street) benefit from it, while the regular people only pay the cost via reduced purchasing power.

Bitcoin is really a savings technology that allows people to escape debased currencies, like the zimbabwe dollar or the Venezuelan peso.

It also has censorship features and other useful properties, but this is the aspect most at odds with the assumptions in your post that the other user apparently disliked.

cyphertruck··on Bitcoin is a disaster
The SegWit project quadrupled the max block size in 2016. Since then there’s never been significant backlogs.

Even with record high prices, one hour transactions are less than a dollar. Maybe even a $0.10 fee will clear in that time.

I don’t know why this claim it never happened persists, except certain people who wanted to tule over bitcoin have spent millions employing an army if bots to spread the lie.

cyphertruck··on Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain a buy out offer
You must get a lawyer now. Below us my thoughts given several decades experience As founder-

You have a strong position here, since you built the products. Don’t walk away. The ultimatum is counting in you being non-confrontational and wanting to cave.

This cofounder has betrayed your trust at this point, so some sort of exit is needed. Non-technical is a lot easier to hire- you can get marketing or whatever expertise he has easily.

He should be the one leaving. Maybe offer to buy him out at current equity value paid over 20 years at %6 interest, secured only by company stock.

If he forces the issue he will destroy the company in the ensuing lawsuit. So this is a mutually assured destruction situation.

What is the ownership of the software? Did you retain rights to it? If you are forced out can you recreate the company quickly using the software you already created?

Get a lawyer, now. You need an advocate who is ready to play ball and who can be the “bad guy” for you.

Your cofounder will likely try to spin it, try to portray any resistance from you as evidence of bad faith, etc. Don’t let him.

cyphertruck··on MicroStrategy's Bitcoin Debt Bet
Typical HN, my salient points are downvoted to hell but this comment is not.

That’s why this site is one actual hackers avoid.

cyphertruck··on MicroStrategy's Bitcoin Debt Bet
Fake news. Anyway, at dome future point people will search HN for bitcoin price predictions.

I have a million dollars on this one.

Mock me now, and next year you will have forgotten this conversation ever happened.

And thus you will not learn from it.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →