HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cyrusradfar

1,128 karma · joined October 31, 2012

I'm Cy, coding since I was six. I build products and explore new experiences. Have been a founder and startup tech leader.

I'm currently working on dev tools for agentic engineering and software-first simulated hardware design. Writing and researching as a means of growing.

Projects:

  - Intraview (intraview.ai) give Agents the ability to co-create code tours in VS Code to speed up onboarding and alignment on code-bases

  - Unfudged (unfudged.io) is source control without the commits so Agents (and you) can recover from mistakes.
  
  - Writing / research (cyrusradfar.com) is where I do market research, guesstimating the future and keep searching the glorious unknown canvas of knowledge.
Live in Portland, OR. Previously lived/worked in both DC, and SF.

Find all my projects, writing and contact methods at https://cyrusradfar.com

submissionscomments
cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: Do businesses want to leave the cloud and return to installable apps?
We're having a discussion on belief at this point. I appreciate your perspective and think, in many cases, your prediction would be right. In others, it won't. There's no determinism to these things.

The point of the discussion for me (can't speak for you) was to ask if there's an opportunity, and I am not deterred to think there is.

Is it easy, no. But it's straight forward to approach from a product perspective.

There's strategies one may deploy to make it harder or more painful for a big company to copy because they'd have to swallow a large number of downsells into the new offering.

Maybe the insight from this thread, is that one must consider high-value low-product-effort features that, often, force upsells in the cloud solution that one could offer in an installable one.

cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: Do businesses want to leave the cloud and return to installable apps?
I think of pricing and packaging as a separate lever than product. Yes, if a big brand copies a solution and the one-time pricing and packaging -- they will take some of that group away.

The issue is that many times the company would LOSE existing revenue and that's often a non-starter during planning.

If your one-time price is $49.99, and their existing monthly fee is $19.99 per month, they're not going to offer a $49.99 option. It would harm their core business too much.

cyrusradfar··on GLP-1 drugs linked to lower death rates in colon cancer patients
Agreed.

I'm a big fan of intermittent and water fasting. Have seen things in my blood work that doctors would require me on meds to reverse. Outside of that, I can't speak to the positive impacts on my mood, and general ability to focus.

The simplest solution to a lot of problems is consuming less with the assumption that, most of us (maybe not you), have a lot of spare energy sitting around.

A lie that we don't unlearn as we grow up is we "require" three meals a day. This is true for children who need obscene amounts of energy to grow, but, not for us desk-bound adults.

In the end, giving the body a break to heal by fasting or just consuming significantly less is going to leave more resources for the body energy to deal with other things.

cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: Do businesses want to leave the cloud and return to installable apps?
Thank you. There's a lot of insights y'all are honing. Appreciate that.

Do you think small businesses, e.g. the bodega on the corner, the local barber or nail shop have those concerns?

cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: Do businesses want to leave the cloud and return to installable apps?
I think that there's a large market of business (cardinality, not revenue) that run off a single computer today. Meaning the business owner leverages some fractional accounting, ops, fulfillment support, but do the books, payroll, buy things for the business themselves.

Yes, they connect through a browser to cloud software.

I recognize when you're large enough to have operations, accounting, etc. and see the value of SSO, in those contexts.

cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: Where did the tech people on Twitter go?
I killed all social media a year or two ago other than LinkedIn. Was super burned out and it is great outside of constantly getting sent links to platforms I can't see things.

w.r.t. to Twitter - I was early on Twitter in 2007, deleted the account and just restarted my Twitter last week. Thankfully, got my old handle @cyrusradfar.

Folks shared there's a lot of tech folk on there. I haven't engaged yet but am building up the energy to try. Wish me luck :)

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
My next release is focused on having a sidebar UI and launcher that'll probably make some of your issues go away. This would allow you to

  - relaunch old tours
  - open/manage feedback 
  - open help which will (fingers crossed) include some videos and getting started

Really appreciate the thoughtful feedback. Thank you!

Following up:

Double clicking on something you said, "I could only get the MCP to work via Claude, not Copilot or Codex" -- did you mean that getting it to actually connect or having the Agent use the MCP properly after it's connected.

cyrusradfar··on Marble Fountain
I appreciate the work. It's really beautiful and checks so many of my "oddly satisfying" boxes as a builder. It seems it hit those for you too, obviously.

Separately, the timing of seeing this is uncanny. I've been using marble runs to explain probability to my kids and was filming a marble run conversion lesson. Seeing this at the top of HN felt like someone was reading my minds.

cyrusradfar··on Tabloid: The Clickbait Headline Programming Language
I actually felt pretty impressed they kept to the non-clickbait standard of the community and still crushed the post :)
cyrusradfar··on Reverse engineering Codex CLI to get GPT-5-Codex-Mini to draw me a pelican
Was a fun idea and fun read. Thank you.

Did you consider expanding the number of models by getting all calls through open router?

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
Hi @jay_devs! Thank you.

> Wish I could provide more in-depth feedback to help improve it

I've got updates on this thread here, email me at support at v1 d0t co, or you can tell your agent to write up/synthesize your thoughts and submit feedback to intraview (assuming you have the extension installed).

If you're saying you don't have time -- totally get it and no presh! You made a builders day by giving it a go.

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
That's really insightful. I think the goal is faster comprehension for the developer. Whether it's a PR in an area of code you haven't seen in a while and you want a refresher, a bug that you have no clue where to start, or you're onboarding -- in all cases, you can't start without a mental model of what's going one.

I'm solving may be for folks like me who would prefer to have the guide IN CODE. It's a new experience to me as I've never used an in IDE code tour.

I think what I'm experiencing is it's way more helpful for me to have the guide navigate through code so I can explore a little at each step and get a lay of the land.

How people learn is personal, and what I hoped for when I was building this was more of an experience where I'm walking through with a teammate.

I considered trying to have a voice AI read or explain each step. I also considered allowing another person to drive your IDE through mirroring what they're looking at. Both were cut at the idea phase because it felt it was feature bloat on a concept that I didn't know anyone (but me) really wants

Open to any more ideas or feedback! Thank you so much for dropping in

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
Ah, shucks! Thank you. Means a lot to me to have folks giving it a go. I recognize how much our attention is strained these days.

I'm trying to figure out whether folks really want this as more of a documentation tool for onboarding, or for "on-the-fly" transient digging: bugs/root cause, PR Review support, co-designing, or code style review across a section. The inline feedback is what's been clutch and sticky for me both within tours, and outside.

If you have feedback and install it or have issues you can email me at support at v1 d0t co --

If it's more of an idea, feature request, or potential bug you can ask your agent (once MCP is connected) to "Send feedback to intraview team" or something similar to be clear you don't want to add feedback for the Agent (which it can also do) and it'll send us a Slack message.

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
Hi! Thank you :) Great question and it's one that's full of assumptions so tell me where you think I'm wrong.

Tours are stored as a flat file (JSON). When you open a tour, you open it with the Agent and on, re-opening, it goes through re-validation (as is done during the tour). In the case where lines shift in files because the file includes start/end ranges and line text (verbatim), this will cause the tour to be invalidated and the Agent will need to rebuild it. There are a lot of "dead code" cases where this won't catch a tour update, today.

The tour file contains a ton of meta information, as well, so each time the Agent opens it -- it could rebuild the tour with the same intents. The original user request, synthesized request, success criteria, concepts that are going to be taught.

This is a first pass solution for now. If there's more interest, there's a much more interesting tech solution with managing pointers to references and invalidating the tour on a broader range of criteria.

Part of what I need to learn is:

  - A. Are tours something that folks use as ongoing "interactive" documentation, e.g. a set of onboarding tours
  - B. Are tours ephemeral that folks use to hash out how to approach a feature, bug or review a PR.
At the moment, it's more optimized for B as that's how I've been using it but A is a very cool use case because one could imagine opening a new repo and having N tours that you can just start up. I was considering reaching out to open source projects to create tour-files and request a PR after they confirm interest (not spam them) to test A.

Your thoughts are welcome and appreciated. Have a lovely Friday.

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
Hi, I just didn't test with Co-pilot but it should work as I think it's using some flavor of GPT4 or 5, both of which were able to use the new tools. I've tested more with GPT5 through cursor.

Given we're all here to learn, I'll share more details on the testing matrix:

IDE: VSCODE, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Roo

Agents: Claude Opus/Sonnet/Haiku, OpenAI GPT-5/GPT-5-codex-[low|med|hi], etc...

Theme: Then when you hit UI, if you use themes there's at four that are very common including default light/dark modes.

cyrusradfar··on Apple nears $1B Google deal for custom Gemini model to power Siri
WHAT -- just had to Google and you're absolutely right! Makes sense that time has moved forward.

https://www.theverge.com/2023/10/26/23933206/google-apple-se...

I'm still using numbers from a post I wrote in 2016

https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/24/apple-lays-the-groundwork-...

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: I scraped 3B Goodreads reviews to train a better recommendation model
I'm not asking him to hide the book recommendations, I'm talking about the "intersect" user feature not doxxing people reading them.
cyrusradfar··on Show HN: I scraped 3B Goodreads reviews to train a better recommendation model
I think this is cool and super fast -- kudos on whatever tech you needed to tackle to make it so.

I don't see anyone saying safety or ethics, so I'll just put it out there that it has some safety and ethical considerations you should consider.

Consider "inflammatory" books and how they could be used to harm a group of people. Although I recognize folks post this "publicly", I think the intersection feature provides more than Goodreads.

Let's say, people who have read "Mein Kampf" & "The Anarchists Cookbook" or some other combination that say "Antifa" to the current regime.

I'd recommend you have a list that you consider private, always and allow Users to add to that list so it's more scalable. If folks try to intersect with anything in that list, you can warn that you don't allow intersection with private books.

Anyway, super fun demo!

cyrusradfar··on Show HN: Dynamic code and feedback walkthroughs with your coding Agent in VSCode
OP HERE -

Thanks to the folks who upvoted, happy to answer questions or discuss any ideas!

You're also welcome to PM me on LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/cyrusradfar

thank you!

cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: How to deal with long vibe-coded PRs?
Trigger: Shameful Self Promotion

I created a tool in VSCode for this called Intraview. It allows you to create a dynamic code tour to provide feedback.

It works with your existing agent and creates a sharable tour that you can navigate and provide feedback step by step.

Rationally, this is much easier than reviewing the diff, because you can prompt to break up the PR logically so you can approve in functional pieces.

cyrusradfar··on Apple nears $1B Google deal for custom Gemini model to power Siri
Coincidentally, Google pays Apple over a billion dollars a year (est. at 1.5B) to be the default search in iOS. Could be re-titled.

Google closes their trade deficit to half a billion dollars per year.

cyrusradfar··on [dead]
On the link, I shared a demo, if you are more of a show than tell type: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROBvFlG6vtY

Looking forward to a thoughtful conversation!

cyrusradfar··on Waymo to expand robotaxi service to Las Vegas, San Diego and Detroit next year
Yes! Very excited, anyone know when it's coming to Portland and Seattle?
cyrusradfar··on The Case That A.I. Is Thinking
I think the challenge with many of these conversations is that they assume consciousness emerges through purely mechanical means.

The “brain as a computer” metaphor has been useful in limited contexts—especially for modeling memory or signal processing; but, I don’t think it helps us move forward when talking about consciousness itself.

Penrose and Hameroff’s quantum consciousness hypothesis, while still very speculative, is interesting precisely because it suggests that consciousness may arise from phenomena beyond classical computation. If that turns out to be true, it would also mean today’s machines—no matter how advanced—aren’t on a path to genuine consciousness.

That said, AI doesn’t need to think to be transformative.

Steam engines weren’t conscious either, yet they reshaped civilization.

Likewise, AI and robotics can bring enormous value without ever approaching human-level awareness.

We can hold both ideas at once: that machines may never be conscious, and still profoundly useful.

cyrusradfar··on It's insulting to read AI-generated blog posts
It seems I'm going to be contrarian here because I really prefer AI-supported (obviously reviewed for accuracy) PR comments over what I had seen before where I'd, often, need to reach out to someone to ask follow up questions on requirements, a link to a ticket, or any number of omissions.

I have worked at smaller firms, mostly, early stage (< 50 engineers), and folks are super busy. Having AI support in writing better thoughtful commentary, provide deeper context is a boon.

In the end, I'll have to say "it depends" -- you can't just throw slop at people but there's definitely a middle ground where everyone wins.

cyrusradfar··on Claude Code on the web
this is a great point. The inner / outer loop is big. I think AI pushing PRs is kind of like pushing drafts to the public in social media. I don't want folks seeing PRs and such until I feel good about it. It adds a lot of noise, and increases build costs unless your CI/CD treats them differently which I don't know anyone doing.
cyrusradfar··on Claude Code on the web
great points @simonw - I, incredibly, haven't ever tried --dangerously-skip-permissions yet for any "real" projects. I generally find that it stops itself for good reason.
cyrusradfar··on Notice of Service Closure
Collective formally responded on LinkedIn with:

We're sorry to hear about Bench shutting down, particularly coming into tax season.

As a company that specializes in solopreneur finance (formation, accounting, tax and payroll) we know that this time of year is stressful as is. If Collective can support or help you and your business in any way, please reach out at http://collective.com, join one of our Q+A sessions, or reach out to me at hooman@collective.com.

If we're a good fit for your business, use the code HERETOHELP to get a discount off of your membership.

We have years of experience working with former Bench customers and our team is working through the weekend to help any small businesses who need urgent help. We're here to support you.

If you're an employee that was impacted, we also have lots of job openings at www.collective.com/careers.

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/hooman_financial-solutions-re...

cyrusradfar··on Mistral Large
1.5 was probably released too late to be tested.
cyrusradfar··on Ask HN: Rollbar for Swift not thread safe, need alternative
Hey

Bias: I work at Rollbar.

We are actively planning revisions to resolve this open issue. Transitioning may be an aggressive position assuming you’re happy with other SDKs. Feel free to email us at support@rollbar.com so we can keep you up to date a the progress.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →