HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

czl

240 karma · joined January 14, 2016

submissionscomments
czl··on PlanetScale Offering $5 Databases
You did a good job explaining their view. What I am doing is explaining the view of users and judging by your last post I have not yet done a good job so let me try again:

If elimination of a service plan is expected to push enough users to a _more_ profitable service plan why would a business not do it? Does it matter if the plan to be eliminated, generates _some_ profit?

Hope this helps!

czl··on Falling panel prices lead to global solar boom, except for the US
If every line were buried, California's huge problem with fires would stop? The real cause is not the lack of prescribed burns and better forest management?
czl··on We are building AI slaves. Alignment through control will fail
> There's no such thing as "moral" in nature, that's purely human-made concept.

Morality is essentially what enables ongoing cooperation. From an evolutionary standpoint, it emerged as a protocol that helps groups function together. Living beings are biological machines, and morality is the set of rules — the protocol — that allows these machines to cooperate effectively.

czl··on PlanetScale Offering $5 Databases
If a free plan attracts users that can be upsold is that free plan not profitable _vs_ paying for advertising?

If such upselling is done via rug pull tactics it damages your reputation vs never having a free plan in the first place.

If a new bank offered you free or discounted banking would you move over your accounts and payments and credit cards? What if that bank has a reputation for upselling via rug pulling?

For users the cost of switching can mean that services that are free or cheap are not worth it if they are expecting a rug pull.

czl··on PlanetScale Offering $5 Databases
You were buying flow for your sales funnel with a free plan now you want to attract users with a low tier plan. Your reputation was hurt with the first rug pull so why be surprised that users expect another rug pull from you in the future?
czl··on PlanetScale Offering $5 Databases
Your $5 plan may be gross margin positive but incentives are to push users into higher margin plans and from this pov this new plan looks much like your previous free plan which was rug pulled. Offering a free service to buy users then imposing migration costs on these users when you rug pull damaged your reputation. Next time perhaps grandfather existing users instead. If you want this new plan to be taken seriously update your terms to promise you will not rug pull again.
czl··on The next chapter of the Microsoft–OpenAI partnership
Conventional LLM chatbots behave the way you describe because their goal during training is to as much as possible impersonate an intelligent assistant.

Do you think this goal during training cannot be changed to impersonate someone normal such that you cannot detect you are chatting with an LLM?

Before flight was understood some thought "magic" was involved. Do you think minds operate using "magic"? Are minds not machines? Their operation can not be duplicated?

czl··on People with blindness can read again after retinal implant and special glasses
Those that fail to block uv can leave your eyes exposed to more UV than if you were not wearing any sun glasses.
czl··on Ultrasonic Chef's Knife
Pull through sharpening creates an edge that does not last. This channel has great explanations about this and what to do instead: https://youtu.be/pagPuiuA9cY
czl··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
> Whoever wants to come to America should be able to freely come, treated the same as anyone else.

So just open USA borders to anyone that passes screening (security / health / etc)?

What about gov subsidized welfare / healthcare / education / ...? Would you end all that? If not end it how would you handle the situation with current citizens vs the influx of foreigners who will expect these things be provided for them? And if those who show up start to vote for communism or some other ism that you do not like what will you do?

czl··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
Long term shortages are evidence of supply controls or price controls. If nurse compensation was allowed to rise to its natural level the shortages would solve themselves. High compensation pulls people into a profession. Suppressing compensation with imported labor cures a short term problem but creates a bigger long term problem.
czl··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
Wages must rise to simulate local supply. If instead a foreign worker is hired and wages do not rise the local supply is not stimulated and the foreign worker being a short term solution causes a growing long-term problem: a growing inadequate local supply of high skilled labor.

And if foreign workers are a "better deal" because they take more abuse (due to terms of their immigration) this further disincentives fair competition and makes the long-term problem larger.

czl··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
The question to ask is why it costs so much to become a doctor in the USA vs other countries and then work to address that.

A serious problem should not be treated with a band-aid and if you think a band-aid is ok do not be surprised the problem gets worse.

czl··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
If you have an auction or allocate the immigration quota based on highest immigrant worker compensation the quota will be filled by those most in demand being hired by those with the most urgent need for them.

That top companies can offer the highest wages and attract the best talent is desirable -- think how things would be if the opposite was true.

czl··on Trump to impose $100k fee for H-1B worker visas, White House says
Why is a lottery necessary? There is a quota so why not fill it with those being paid the highest compensation? What's wrong with a market solution? It would bring in those who are most in demand. What better way to measure demand than prices?
czl··on Grok 4
This isn’t just about opinions randomly changing. Musk’s views seem to have shifted in response to changing facts -- like the passage of a major spending bill, whichtie directly into his concerns about government debt. So it's not surprising that his stance evolved over time.

The way the bot reflects his views is a bit awkward, I agree. I assume it’s something the Grok team will want to improve. One possible reason for the behavior is that if Twitter data was used during training, and Musk is a dominant voice there, the model may have learnedto rely heavily on his posts -- especially if that helped it predict or score better during training.

To Musk’s credit,he’s pushed for more transparency. That at least lets people see these odd behaviors and raise questions. With other models, like OpenAI’s or Anthropic’s, it’s harder to tell when something similar might be happening.

And while Musk definitely says someoff-the-wall things, his track record overall is hard to ignore-- whether one agrees with him or not.

czl··on Grok 4
> Months ago this model would have promoted Trump, but now it'll call Trump disastrous for the economy.

There’s a well-known quote often attributed to economist John Maynard Keynes: “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?”

czl··on Techno-feudalism and the rise of AGI: A future without economic rights?
> best way to implement democracy is via random selection

Long ago I had the same thought as you and a question occurred: the life anyone is born into is a lottery, so hereditary rulers == democracy?

czl··on Whole-genome ancestry of an Old Kingdom Egyptian
“Pure” usually means having genes from a narrow, selected group, so the offspring show predictable traits—like size, intelligence, or appearance. That’s why dogs and farm animals are called “purebred.” But making pure breeds often requires inbreeding, which, unless done carefully, can cause serious problems.
czl··on DDoSecrets publishes 410 GB of heap dumps, hacked from TeleMessage
Aka "halo effect"
czl··on AlphaEvolve: A Gemini-powered coding agent for designing advanced algorithms
> And it will start with people are not respected or valued for their work, so they can leave, once left, they will not be replaced or replaced lower skilled folks and at some point that position stop existing altogether.

Automation changed farming for the worse? Farmers today are not respected / valued for their work? Farmers were replaced with low skilled labor? Do you think the job of a farmer (aka "food grower") will stop existing?

I do not predict future only look at what happened in the past and my answer to each question above about farming is the opposite what your comment would imply if it was applied to farming.

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
> No sale. Less consumption.

What makes "Less consumption" a good goal? What are biospheres if not cycles of consumption? When our planet becomes sterilized due to some disaster will you celebrate "Less consumption"? Obviously not. EFFICIENT consumption is a good goal so we maximize what we desire and minimize the undesirables.

> Advertising does not care about your best interest. Advertising tries to make a sale and advertising is considered successful if a sale is made even if no problem was solved.

Yes. In a capitalist economy all act in self interest. This is clearly s bad system except if you have experience living under other systems and there the direction of migration should be a clue about what people prefer.

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
> If I don’t know a product or service exists, why do I need it?

Do you not purchase things / services you do not need?

> My life is fine as it is, I don’t need stupid advertisements for stuff that won’t enrich it.

How might you reply to a someone from a few thousand or few hundred or even few dozen years ago that has your attitude? Might you be tempted to advertise to them what they are missing? Would they not be interested?

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
100% agree with your three points.

When you "visit" Google / Facebook / YouTube / other online properties do you think you are "going to a place that's all about having people sell me things"?

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
If you do not know a problem is a problem why search for a solution?

If you do not know a product / service exists why would you search for it?

If "search" is your answer what do you suppose advertisers are doing? Are they not searching for customers?

Advertising is an expensive search with many externalities on society. These externalities are wasteful hence the search for a better way to do it. Google / Facebook / ... I think are funded by solving this problem.

czl··on Fraud, so much fraud
> On the topic, I subscribe to Grey's law "Any sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice" so I see idiots as malicious. In the very best case, idiots in positions of power are malicious for accepting the position and thus preventing someone more competent from getting it. It really doesn't matter what their intent is. Deep down, stupid people know that they're stupid but they let their emotions get in the way, same emotions which prevent them from getting smarter.

I think you have things backwards. Being dumb is the default. It takes ability and effort and help to get smarter. Animals and children are dumber than us. Do you think they realize it?

Perversely many who are dumb are trapped thinking they are not dumb:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effec...

A dumb person (like a dumb child or animal) are what they are one should not attribute malice. Better to try to see things from their point of view and perhaps help them be smarter. This is what I try to do.

Your other remarks are 100% just the point above was sticking out hence my comment.

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
> but is this a common framing?

Yes a common misconception about economics so much so it has a Wikipedia page to explain it.

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
> So in addition to the complete destruction of personal privacy and the normalization of the panopticon, it's also making you materially poorer. But hey, at least ads are more relevant, sorta, almost, sometimes!

Can a capitalist society operate without advertising? How are people to learn about products and services that are available? Yet today poorly targets ads waste the time of everyone involved. If ads could be made relevant without invading your privacy would you be against that?

czl··on Automatic Content Recognition Tracking in Smart TVs
> an advertising dollar doesn't disappear: it's paid to someone.

Window breaking gangs could make a similar same claim about their activity boosting GDP might they not?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
> Still, the brain grew to maybe 2-4 times the size over this period.

I read somewhere that the human brain makes up only about 2% of body weight but uses 20% of the body’s energy. While brain size has increased over time, brain size does not determine intelligence. The brain’s high energy use, constant activity, and complex processes are more important. Its metabolic activity, continuous glucose and oxygen consumption, neurotransmitter dynamics, and synaptic plasticity all play major roles in cognitive function. Intelligence is shaped by the brain’s efficiency, how well it forms and adjusts neural connections, and the energy it invests in processing information. Intelligence depends far more on how the brain works than on its size.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →