HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

czl

240 karma · joined January 14, 2016

submissionscomments
czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
> Also, lighter bodies (relative to size) make us (in our natural form) extremaly capable long distance runners.

Humans' ability to run long distances effectively is due to a combination of factors, with the ability to sweat being one of the most crucial. Here are the key adaptations that make humans good endurance runners: a) Efficient sweating: Humans have a high density of sweat glands, allowing for effective thermoregulation during prolonged exercise. b) Bipedalism: Our two-legged gait is energy-efficient for long-distance movement. c) Lack of fur: This helps with heat dissipation. d) Breathing independence from gait: Unlike quadrupeds, our breathing isn't tied to our running stride, allowing for better oxygen intake.

Lighter bodies (relative to size) plays a role but there plenty of creatures that have light bodies relative to size that are not great at long distance running.

czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
Reaching light speed isn't just an engineering problem—it's a fundamental issue in physics. The laws of physics (as we know them) prevent any object with mass from reaching light speed.

Notice however that our minds, like the instructions in DNA and RNA, are built from atoms, but they aren't the atoms themselves. They're the information in how those atoms are arranged. Once we can fully read and write this information—like we're starting to do with DNA and RNA—light itself could become our vehicle.

czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
> biology will create constraints. If you're male, you may be able to bench 200kg, but probably not 500kg unless your biology allows it.

On evolutionary timeframes what biology allows can evolve and the hard limits are due to chemistry and physics.

> there are costs to developing large brains. The benefits would not justify the costs, over evolutionary history.

> Large brains come with a significant metabolic cost. They would only have evolved if they provided a benefit that would outweigh those costs

Google "evolutionary spandrels" and you will learn there can be body features (large brains of whales) that are simply a byproduct of other evolutionary pressures rather than direct adaptation.

czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
> There IS a correlation between intelligence and brain size (of about 0.3).

Here is a page that shows what such a weak correlation looks like visually:

https://resources.nu.edu/statsresources/correlation

It also explains that a correlation of r = 0.3 means only about 9% of the variability in one variable is explained by the other. This makes me wonder: can intelligence really be estimated within 10% accuracy? I doubt it, especially considering how IQ test results can vary even for the same person over time.

Kids and teens have smaller brains, but their intelligence increases as they experience more mental stimulation. It’s not brain size that limits them but how their brains develop with use, much like how muscles grow with exercise.

> a chimp brain is not likely to produce (adult, healthy) human-level intelligence. > Human brains consume significantly more calories than chimp brains.

If brain size and calorie consumption directly drove intelligence, we’d expect whales, with brains five times larger than humans, to be vastly more intelligent. Yet, they aren’t. Whales’ large brains are likely tied to their large bodies, which evolved to cover great distances in water.

Brains can large like arms can be large but big arms do not necessarily make you strong -- they may be large due to fat.

> But generally, over the last several million years, human intelligence has been rising sharply.

Yes, smaller-brained animals are generally less intelligent, but exceptions like whales and crows suggest that intelligence evolves alongside an animal’s ecological niche. Predators often need more intelligence to outsmart their prey, and this arms race likely shaped human intelligence.

As humans began living in larger communities, competing and cooperating with each other, intelligence became more important for survival and reproduction. But this has limits. High intelligence can lead to emotional challenges like overthinking, isolation, or an awareness of life’s difficulties. Highly intelligent individuals can also be unpredictable and harder to control, which may not always align with societal or biological goals.

As I see it, ecological niche drives intelligence, and factors like brain size follow from that. The relationship is dynamic, with feedback loops as the environment changes.

czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
> Evolutionary history points towards brain size being limited by a combination of what is safe for the female hip width and also what amount of energy cost can be justified by increasing the size of the brain.

If bigger brains lead to higher intelligence, why do many highly intelligent people have average-sized heads? And do they need to eat much more to fuel their high IQs? If larger brains were always better, wouldn’t female hips have evolved to accommodate them? I think human IQ might be where it is because extremely high intelligence vs. what we on average have now) often leads to fewer descendants. Less awareness of reality can lead to more "reproductive bliss."

czl··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
> I don't see why progress will be a straight line and not a sloping-off curve.

Technological progress often appears linear in the short term, but zooming out reveals an exponential curve, similar to compound interest.

> You shouldn't see the progress we've made in vehicle speed and assume we can hit the speed of light.

Consider the trajectory of maximum speeds over millennia, not just recent history. We've achieved speeds unimaginable to our ancestors, mostly in space—a realm they couldn't conceive. While reaching light speed is challenging, we're exploring novel concepts like light-propelled nano-vehicles. If consciousness is information-based, could light itself become a "vehicle"?

czl··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
Adding a parameter X to your definition expands it as follows:

> When Bob invests labor into X to generate financial gain, and Tom utilizes the results of Bob's labor on X without compensating Bob at his requested rate.

However, this definition becomes problematic for many values of X. Consider cases such as:

* Fashion styles * Business models or store layouts * Factory or house designs * Cake decorating techniques * Cooking methods * Agricultural practices

In these examples and many others, the concept of "owning" the fruits of one's labor becomes murky. *Intellectual property laws were originally conceived to benefit society as a whole, not just individuals.* As our understanding of innovation and creativity evolves, we may find that some communities flourish better with more flexible approaches to intellectual property.

czl··on Google Pixel 9 Pro
The output from an LLM is like the path a marble takes across a surface shaped by its training data and answers to “why” questions just continue the marble’s path. You may get good sounding answers to your why questions but they are just good sounding answers and not the real reasons because LLM’s lack the ability to introspect their own thinking. Note: Humans do not have this ability either unless using formal step by step reasoning.
czl··on AI solves International Math Olympiad problems at silver medal level
> I assume the just hire humans to solve…

An incorrectly formalized problem is a different problem and a solution to any formalized problem still useful for AI training because such solutions can be mechanically checked for correctness and this does not require the hire of humans. What requires humans is the initial formalization process since that is more a language translation task which requires nuance and judgment and is difficult to mechanically verify.

czl··on Trench collapses have killed hundreds of workers in the US over the last decade
> If we made all car occupants wear a helmet we would reduce head injuries for occupants in car crashes. But that would be ridiculous.

Effective helmets would likely need to be tethered due to their mass. I believe modern car race helmet are tethered to the vehicle frame.

czl··on Siblings miss crucial life-extending treatment because of CrowdStrike outage
> my information was exchanged only between the two parties with my consent, on an encrypted channel

Say WhatsApp is found to have a security hole that has been leaking data to 3rd parties. What may be the fate of dentists / doctors that decided to use it an "encrypted channel" for medical records? Are doctors / dentists not fat targets for lawsuits? What might the guidance be from their lawsuit insurance policy?

czl··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
Correct. We use paper receipts for shopping and paper ballots for voting. Automation is fast and efficient, but there must be a manual fallback when power fails or automation is unreliable.

This wisdom is echoed in some religious practices that avoid complete reliance on modern technology.

czl··on Siblings miss crucial life-extending treatment because of CrowdStrike outage
Imagine a news story about a dentist that violated HIPPA (or equivalent) laws because they used Whatsapp / Facebook to share medical records. Will this news story be about a hero vs someone who got into trouble?
czl··on Global IT outage shows dangers of cashless society, campaigners say
To maintain stable short-term prices, active regulation of currency supply is necessary. Without it, currency value fluctuates with supply and demand, making prices unstable.

In the long term, a small amount of inflation is needed to discourage hoarding. Without it, people might treat currency as an investment, leading to unstable prices like we see with gold and Bitcoin.

Currency should be stable, like standard measures (Kg, Foot) that don't change in the short term. It also functions like a store cart for shopping. If carts become scarce, shopping is difficult. Therefore, there must be an incentive to return the cart for others to use.

Another purpose of currency, albeit controversial, is to manage debt accumulation. Historically, societies faced growing debt and used "debt jubilee" events to reset, which disrupted commerce. Modern societies address this through currency inflation.

If gold or crypto were effective currencies, prices would be advertised in Bitcoin or gold. The fact that they are not suggests they don't serve well in this role.

czl··on AI paid for by Ads – the GPT-4o mini inflection point
> Effectively, they (LLMs) can't think new thoughts.

This is true only if you assume that combining existing thought patterns is not new thinking. If they can't learn a certain pattern from training data, indeed they would be stuck. However, their training data keeps growing and updating, allowing each updated version to learn more patterns.

czl··on AI paid for by Ads – the GPT-4o mini inflection point
While it's true that the volume of bad writing is increasing, our ability to analyze and refine this sludge is also improving. Just as spell check and grammar check give instant feedback why not AI instant feedback about writing quality / originality / suitability / correctness / … ? If instant feedback can improve spelling and grammar why not these other things?
czl··on AI paid for by Ads – the GPT-4o mini inflection point
> There is the old Carlin bit about "for there to be an average intelligence, half of the people need to be below it".

This is true for the median, not necessarily for the average.

czl··on AI paid for by Ads – the GPT-4o mini inflection point
Yes, do not rely on it for assessments. It generates ratings of 7 or 8 because those ratings are statistically common in its training data.
czl··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
The idea is to have the current system create a backup paper trail from which you practice resuming from for when computers go down. Nothing about current process for you need change only that you be familiar with falling back to paper backups when computers are down.
czl··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
> It is a critical problem if your entire record of life-saving drugs you've given them in the past 24 hours suddenly goes down.

Will outages like this motivate a backup paper process? The automated process should save enough information on paper so a switch over to paper process at any time is feasible. Similar to elections.

czl··on Self-Awareness Might Not Have Evolved to Benefit the Self After All
The concept of a Universal Turing Machine (UTM) suggests that, given enough time and memory, it can compute anything that is computable. By extension, if human cognition is computable, a sufficiently advanced computational system could, in theory, model and explain it.

This doesn't necessarily mean we'll easily achieve this understanding, as the computation required might be extremely complex and time-consuming. But it does suggest that the explanation of cognition isn't fundamentally beyond reach, even if we're using the system to explain itself.

czl··on Self-Awareness Might Not Have Evolved to Benefit the Self After All
> we just assume everyone knows what we know.

Yes, the "Curse of knowledge" cognitive bias can cause the intelligent to be unintelligible.

czl··on Self-Awareness Might Not Have Evolved to Benefit the Self After All
> an organism is the one saying "I" and not the cells or tissues

An organism is a colony of cells and in that colony only some cells are responsible for thinking / communication.

czl··on Trump injured but ‘fine’ after attempted assassination at rally
Aim enhancing guns exist. Example: TrackingPoint Precision-Guided Firearms: uses a computer-controlled firing system Tracks targets and calculates variables like distance, wind, and angle. Only fires when the gun is perfectly aligned with the target Can hit moving targets at distances up to 1,200 yards
czl··on Modern-day spying: sometimes old technology is more secure
> it proved the correct decision through virtue of the fact that the story continued (and they weren't all killed off in episode one).

In the show’s fictional plot, the decision seems correct because the story continued and the characters survived. However, we shouldn't judge decisions in real life by how they are portrayed in fiction. In modern fiction, decisions are often shaped to please audiences, not to reflect real-world correctness. Thus, it may not be wise to judge these fictional decisions by the same standards we use in real life.

czl··on U.S. SEC Wins 'Shadow Insider Trading' Trial
In a free economy decision power over wealth accrues to those under whose watch wealth compounds fastest. You may disagree with the inequality that results but history shows it is difficult to compete economically with groups that run free economies.

Hopefully you can vote politically during elections, you can vote economically with every dollar you spend and you can vote with your feet by switching countries.

If you have an idea about some paradise that will operate much better under the economic rules you believe in ask yourself why this paradise does not yet exist if it is so much better. If your economic paradise does exist why not just move there? Surely those having your "wisdom" will be highly valued there.

czl··on U.S. SEC Wins 'Shadow Insider Trading' Trial
The purpose of a currency is not for investment but to keep circulating in the economy. Low steady inflation ensures this happens. Inflation also clears up debts which would otherwise compound. Nobody forces you to store wealth long term using the currency and it would be dumb to do so.

If you disagree with the taxes being collected either vote to change how that government spends your money else vote with your feet and find another country. There are tax free jurisdictions. Why not go live there if the tax you pay bothers you?

czl··on Ask HN: Has anyone successfully pivoted from web dev to AI/ML development?
Embedded software?
czl··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
> then he would be voted out of office in (max) 4 years.

Assuming the abuse of power does not prevent this.

czl··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
> Was it the murder of their mistress? Then obviously not official.

Why obviously? If mistress is causing "harm" to other official actions would it not be official duty to prevent this harm? You and I may not buy such a defence but a sympathetic audience of allies?

← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →