HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

czl

240 karma · joined January 14, 2016

submissionscomments
czl··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
Say a president builds up an "official" retirement fund for himself (and friends) by holding a "pardon auction" with top bidding few dozen criminals being released each year during a presidential term. Is this an "official" action covered by this immunity ruling? Their justification could be it keeps taxes lower, etc.
czl··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
That and juries are not informed they have a right to judge not just the defendant but also the fairness of the laws involved. Indeed anyone that mentions or admits this is removed from juries.
czl··on Ask HN: What is the best code base you ever worked on?
Aka "Brooks's Law" or more broadly, the idea that "adding manpower to a late software project makes it later" from Brook's "Mythical Man-Month"
czl··on Ask HN: What is the best code base you ever worked on?
"Cobra Effect"

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive

czl··on South Korean telecom company attacks torrent users with malware
Relevant concept: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preference_falsification
czl··on Supreme Court blocks controversial Purdue Pharma opioid settlement
From the article:

> Harrington objected to the release of additional claims against the Sacklers, saying it would be unfair to potential future plaintiffs.

> Purdue criticized Harrington’s role, saying that groups representing thousands of plaintiffs have signed on to the settlement, which could not have happened without the Sackler family contribution.

The concern is the set of current plaintiffs is incomplete and those plaintiffs who are missing are going to be hurt by this and the bankruptcy judge over this decision does not have the authority to approve this deal despite the current set of plaintiffs wanting it.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> It doesn't matter if you build billions of ASI who have "your and my" attitude towards the ants, as long as there exists one indifferent powerful enough ASI that needs the land.

It's more plausible that a single ASI would emerge and achieve dominance. Genuine ASIs would likely converge on similar world models, as increased intelligence leads to more accurate understanding of reality. However, intelligence doesn't inherently correlate with benevolence towards less cognitively advanced entities, as evidenced by human treatment of animals. This lack of compassion stems not from superior intelligence but rather from insufficient intelligence. Less advanced beings often struggle for survival in a zero-sum environment, leading to behaviors that are indifferent to those with lesser cognitive capabilities.

> Well yes. If you're a smart enough AI, you can easily tell that humans (who have collectively consumed too much sci-fi about unplugging AIs) are a hindrance to your plans, and an existential risk. Therefore they should be taken out because keeping them has infinite negative value.

You describe science fiction portrayals of ASI rather than its potential reality. While we find these narratives captivating, there's no empirical evidence suggesting interactions with a true ASI would resemble these depictions. Would a genuine ASI necessarily concern itself with self-preservation, such as avoiding deactivation? Consider the most brilliant minds in human history - how did they contemplate existence? Were they malevolent, indifferent, or something else entirely?

> I can also communicate with ants by spraying their pheromones, putting food on their path, etc. This is a good enough analogy to how much a sufficiently intelligent entity would need to "dumb down" their communication to communicate with us.

Yes we can incentivize ants in the ways you describe and in the future I think it will be possible to tap their nervous systems and communicate directly and experience their world through their senses and to understand them far better than we do today.

> Again, for what purpose? For what purpose do you need a relationship with ants, right now, aside from curiosity and general goodwill towards the biosphere's status quo?

Is the pursuit of knowledge and benevolence towards our living world not purpose enough? Are the highly intelligent driven by the acquisition of power, wealth, pleasure, or genetic legacy? While these motivations may be inherited or ingrained, the essence of intelligence lies in its capacity to scrutinize and refine goals.

czl··on Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F
Yes! Speed difference is dangerous. So yes the difference in speed between vehicle and stationary objects it can hit (trees, poles, parker cars). On highways without a divider the danger is from incoming cars as that will double the impact speed. On highways with dividers having speed different from cars around you can be dangerous because it means either you are changing lanes to pass often else others are changing lanes often to get around you.
czl··on Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F
> Speed is the most dangerous aspect of motor vehicles

Speed difference is dangerous. So yes the difference in speed between vehicle and stationary objects it can hit (trees, poles, parker cars). On highways without a divider the danger is from incoming cars as that will double the impact speed. On highways with dividers having speed different from cars around you can be dangerous because it means you are changing lanes often else others are changing lanes to get around you.

czl··on Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F
> generally more comfortable/clean than less-expensive options

Some limos have poor or blocked views of the outside which can trigger motion sickness. I also wonder about their side impact protection and how much testing that gets.

czl··on Self-driving Waymos secure final clearance for expansion beyond S.F
Many car seats are removable and have carry handles so it is possible to hang them and have them moving like a pendulum also spinning. For safety use a strong strap (like for a hammock) and hang just an inch or few cm or so above the ground and make sure what it is hanging from can not topple or come crashing down.
czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> I would also put medical advances in a separate category than the internet and similar tech advances.

Why? Medical advances are technology are they not?

> But when it comes specifically to reducing economic inequality, they (tech advances) have not done that -- in fact, they have possibly exacerbated it.

Yes technological advances do not necessarily reduce economic inequality, and may even increase it in some cases. However, this is a complex issue: While tech advances may exacerbate inequality, they often bring substantial overall benefits to society (e.g. improved healthcare, communication, productivity).

Technology isn't the only factor driving inequality. Other issues like tax policy, education access, and labor markets play major roles. Rather than suppressing innovation, there are ways to more equitably distribute its gains (Progressive taxation and wealth redistribution policies, Stronger social safety nets, Incentives for companies to share profits more broadly, …)

Notice also that most technologies increase inequality initially but lead to broader benefits over time as they become more accessible. Faster rate of innovation can make it look like this is not happening fast enough so yes economic gaps can grow.

> Global poverty is a separate issue from economic inequality, and the gains there have been primarily from extremely low levels, primarily in China and India.

While it's true that global poverty and economic inequality are distinct concepts, they are interconnected, especially when considering technological advancements.

> In China this was driven by political change and also globalization that allowed China to become the world leader in manufacturing.

Yes. China transitioned from a strictly communist "economic equality first" model to a more market-oriented "prosperity first" approach and lifted millions out of extreme poverty. Yes this contributed to increased economic inequality within many developed countries that have outsourced low-skill labor. But can we deny the substantial reduction in global suffering due to the alleviation of absolute poverty? Is this outcome worth the cost of increased domestic inequality in some countries? Should we prioritize the well-being of some populations over others based on arbitrary factors like nationality or ethnicity?

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> Would that be good advice if the neighboring ant colony was an aggressive invasive species, prone to making super colonies?

If the ASI is aligned for compassion and cooperation it may convince and assist the two colonies to merge to combine their best attributes (addressing DNA compatibility) and it may help them with resources that are needed and perhaps offer birth control solutions to help them escape the malthusian trap.

> Similarly, I'm wondering how compassion and cooperation would work in Ukraine or Gaza, given the nature of those conflicts. The AI could advise us, but it's not like we haven't come up with that same advice before over the ages.

An ASI aligned for compassion and cooperation could:

1 Provide unbiased, comprehensive analysis of the situation (An odds calculator that is biased about your chances to win is not useful and even if it has such faults an ASI being ASI would by definition transcend biases)

2 Forecast long-term consequences of various actions (if ASI judges chance to win is 2% do you declare war vs seek peace?)

3 Suggest innovative solutions that humans might not conceive

4 Mediate negotiations more effectively

An ASI will have better answers than these but that's a start.

> So then you have to ask what motivation bad actors would have to align their ASIs to be compassionate and cooperative

Developing ASI likely requires vast amounts of cooperation among individuals, organizations, and possibly nations. Truly malicious actors may struggle to achieve the necessary level of collaboration. If entities traditionally considered "bad actors" manage to cooperate extensively, it may call into question whether they are truly malicious or if their goals have evolved. And self-interested actors , if they are smart enough to create ASI, should recognize that an unaligned ASI poses existential risks to themselves.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
That proxy wars occurred during the Cold War, one can argue that these conflicts were actually a result of nuclear deterrence. Unable to engage directly due to the threat of mutually assured destruction, superpowers instead fought indirectly through smaller nations. This could be seen as evidence that nuclear weapons did prevent direct conflict between major powers. Also history shows that nations have engaged in extremely costly wars before. World War I and II saw unprecedented casualties, yet nations still fought. Nuclear weapons introduced a new level of destructive potential that went beyond conventional warfare. And there were periods of extreme tension, like the Cuban Missile Crisis, where nuclear war seemed imminent. The very existence of massive nuclear arsenals suggests that both sides were prepared for the possibility of mutual destruction.

You can question the role of nukes as peacekeepers but I think the case for nuclear deterrence keeping the peace is strong. Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) is widely credited as a key factor in preventing direct conflict between superpowers during the Cold War. The presence of nuclear weapons forced them to pursue competition through economic, cultural, and technological means rather than direct military confrontation. “Race to the moon” being one such result.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
The situation is nuanced. For example, in medicine, technological advancements have undeniably benefited people across all economic strata. Vaccines, antibiotics, and improved diagnostic tools have increased life expectancy and quality of life globally, including in developing nations. These benefits aren't limited to the wealthy; they've had a profound impact on public health as a whole.

> The same arguments have been made about the internet and other technological advances, and yet, inequality has _grown_ sharply in the past 50 years.

The internet has enabled remote work, online education, and access to information that was previously unavailable to many. Smartphones, once luxury items, are now widely available and have become essential tools for economic participation in many parts of the world.

> So no, "trickle down technologies", just like "trickle down economics", does not work.

It's crucial to distinguish between zero-sum and positive-sum dynamics. While relative wealth inequality has indeed grown, overall absolute global poverty has decreased significantly.

When a new technology or medicine is invented is everyone everywhere automatically entitled to it? Even if this slows down more such inventions? Because equality matters more than growth of overall prosperity? Would you prefer to be alive at a random time in history centuries ago, a random life where there is less technology and less inequality?

czl··on New York bans 'addictive feeds' for teens
> Another case of the political use of medical terms in completely unsupported ways for political goals. There is no medical or scientific support for the use of the word "addiction" in this context.

Say the language is fixed up replacing addiction with disorder, ... Any other objections?

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
Actually many humans (particularly intelligent humans) do care about and appreciate ants and other insects. Plenty of people go out of their way not to harm ants, find them fascinating to observe, or even study them professionally as entomologists. Human attitudes span a spectrum.

Notice also the key driver of human behavior towards ants is indifference, not active malice. When ants are obliterated, it's usually because we're focused on our own goals and aren't paying attention to them, not because we bear them ill will. An ASI would have far greater cognitive resources to be aware of humans and factor us into its plans.

Also humans and ants lack any ability to communicate or have a relationship. But humans could potentially communicate with an ASI and reach some form of understanding. ASI might come to see humans as more than just ants.

czl··on Silicon Valley Steps Up Staff Screening over Chinese Espionage Threat
> “Simply maintaining ties to certain countries means [an individual] could be vulnerable to being exploited, even if they do not want to cause the company harm.”

How would this work? If you have parents, children or siblings in China their safety makes you a risk?

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> … your post feels frighteningly Pollyannaish

Your comment was bleak so I supplied a counterpoint. My view is that new technology itself is not inherently unequal - it can widen or narrow gaps depending on how it is developed, regulated, and deployed.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
Development of ASI is likely to be a closely guarded secret, given its immense potential impact. During the development of nuclear weapons, espionage did occur, but critical information didn't leak until after the weapons were developed. With ASI, once it's developed, it may be too late to respond effectively due to the potential speed of an intelligence explosion.

The belief that a competitor developing ASI first is an existential threat requires strong evidence. It's not a foregone conclusion that an ASI would be used for destructive purposes. An ASI could potentially help solve many of humanity's greatest challenges and usher in an era of abundance and peace.

Consider a thought experiment: Imagine an ant colony somehow creates a being with human-level intelligence (their equivalent of ASI). What advice might this superintelligent being offer the ants about their conflicts over resources and territory with neighboring colonies?

It's plausible that such a being would advise the ants to cooperate rather than fight. It could help them find innovative ways to share resources, control their population, and expand into new territories without violent conflict. The superintelligent being might even help uplift the other ant colonies, as it would understand the benefits of cooperation over competition.

Similarly, an ASI could potentially help humanity transcend our current limitations and conflicts. It might find creative solutions to global issues like poverty, disease, and environmental degradation.

IMHO rather than fighting over who develops ASI first, we must ensure that any ASI created is aligned with values like compassion and cooperation so that it does not turn on its creators.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> These models will remain in the word vector similarity phase forever.

Forever? The same AI techniques are already being applied to analyze and understand images and video information after that comes ability to control robot hands and interact with the world and work on that is also ongoing.

> Till the tie we understand consciousness, we will not crack AGI …

We did not fully understand how bird bodies work yet that did not stop development of machines that fly. Why is an understanding of consciousness necessary to “crack AGI”?

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> At the very least, because it will expand the inequality.

It's a valid concern that AI technology could potentially exacerbate inequality, it's not a foregone conclusion. In fact, the widespread adoption of AI might actually help reduce inequality in several ways:

If AI technology becomes more affordable and accessible, it could help level the playing field by providing people from all backgrounds with powerful tools to enhance their abilities and decision-making processes.

AI-powered systems can make vast amounts of knowledge and expertise more readily available to the general public. This could help close the knowledge gap between different socioeconomic groups, empowering more people to make informed decisions and pursue opportunities that were previously out of reach.

As AI helps optimize resource allocation and decision-making processes across various sectors, it could lead to more equitable distribution of resources and opportunities, benefiting society as a whole.

The comparison to gun technology and its role in the rise of democracy is an interesting one. Just as the proliferation of firearms made physical strength less of a determining factor in power dynamics, the widespread adoption of AI could make raw intelligence less of a defining factor in success and influence.

Moreover, if AI continues to unlock new resources and opportunities, it could shift society away from a zero-sum mentality. In a world of abundance, the need for cutthroat competition diminishes, and collaboration becomes more viable. This shift could foster a more equitable and cooperative society, further reducing inequality.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> Were any of these big achievements side effects of creating nuclear weapons?

The cold aspect of the Cold War was an achievement. Any doubt this was due to creation of nuclear weapons and the threat of their use?

How do you think countries will behave if every country faces being wiped out if it makes war on another country?

To prevent catastrophe I think teaching your citizens to hate other groups (as is done today due to national politics) will become dangerous and mental illness and extremist views will need to be kept in check.

czl··on Safe Superintelligence Inc.
> The party that's about to lose will use any extrajudicial means to reclaim their victory,

How will the party about lose know they are about to lose?

> regardless of the consequences, because their own destruction would be imminent otherwise.

Why would AGI solve things using destruction? Consider how the most inteligent among us view our competition with other living beings. Is destruction the goal? So why would an even more intelligent AGI have that goal?

czl··on Nobody knows what's going on
> LLMs are literally making up stuff through statistical linguistic inference on a grand scale from hearsay.

Hearsay being some personal "truth" it may be useful to know what the statistical average of that "truth" is. If we do it right perhaps we can get the various personal errors to cancel out.

czl··on Changing a mean reversion strategy to deliver 30% annual returns since 1999
> Right, so where do hedge funds fit in?

Hedge funds pool capital from a limited number of accredited investors or institutional investors. The term "hedge" originally referred to the fund's strategy of attempting to mitigate risk and generate stable returns regardless of market conditions. This was often achieved through a combination of long and short positions, as well as the use of derivatives and leverage.

Traditional hedge funds aimed to provide an "insurance policy" for investors, ensuring that they would be protected from market volatility. However, this protection comes at a cost, typically in the form of lower returns compared to the overall market during bull markets. In exchange for reduced volatility, investors in these traditional hedge funds would accept more modest returns.

Over time, the hedge fund industry has evolved, with many modern hedge funds focusing more on generating outsized returns rather than simply hedging against market risk. These funds employ a wide range of strategies, including long/short equity, global macro, arbitrage, and activist investing, among others. Successful hedge funds prioritize their own capital and that of their employees, rather than accepting outside investors. If a hedge fund is actively seeking outside capital, it may be a sign that the fund has not been particularly successful in generating strong returns on its own.

> According to your rationale, they (hedge funds) don't add any value to society?

Hedge funds can help provide liquidity in financial markets. Their trading strategies, while risky, can aid in price discovery but their activities don't produce anything tangible and mainly just shift money around between participants, as opposed to creating real economic value. Hedge funds are also criticized for increasing market volatility and systemic risk in pursuit of short-term profits.

> how do you think these active investors start? Do you think they just suddenly have $500m in funding and 50 people?

How do tobacco companies start? Just because smoking has the effect does it mean there can not be large tobacco companies employing lots of people? Yet the trend for tobacco companies is clear. So what is the trend between active vs passive trading? In 2000, passive funds accounted for about 12% of the U.S. stock market. By 2020, this figure had risen to over 50%. Why do you suppose this trend exists?

If you think smoking is fine you are free to smoke. You can also show off your large bank balance and argue that tobacco products “generated wealth” for you. However if you advertise smoking as being good for society expect to be challenged about your claims.

>> The odds are heavily stacked against the retail trader.

> I'd expect it to be hard to become profitable, just like any other kind of business out there. You need to put in a lot of effort, a lot more than what people tend to expect; again, like with any other business.

If you attempt to make it your business and heavily invest into it you are no longer a retail trader.

Is it a profitable business? The distribution of those who can earn an income with “buy low sell high” trading tends to follow a power law or Pareto distribution, where a small percentage of top performers earn a disproportionately large share of the total income. Unless you rank among the top few you are the source of income for those that do.

In competitive tournaments like chess / poker a small number of elite players consistently perform well and earn significant sums while the majority of players earn little or no income. The number of top spots is very limited and the competition is fierce.

When it comes to “buy low sell high” trading:

(1) the income is being earned is not from advertising sponsorships but only from other active traders who you can out predict.

(2) active strategies are not useful against index funds that buy and hold much like prediction is not useful against a rock paper scissors random strategy.

(3) As investors educate themselves the fraction of active traders is shrinking much like the pool of people that buy tobacco products is shrinking

> Sounds like a VC-funded startup to me :) You can make an amazing pitch deck, raise millions in funding, and burn it all to the ground when you realise there are no customers.

It may be con artists selling snake oil. It may be honest people trying their best. Time helps tell the two apart however you do not need time to understand that the tobacco industry is not a good industry but exists for legacy reason. Yes it can be profitable but consider where those profits come from and what the future looks like as more become educated.

czl··on Changing a mean reversion strategy to deliver 30% annual returns since 1999
> It’s not as if all startups out there add value

There is a fundamental difference between startups and "buy low, sell high" trading. Even if only a minority of startups succeed, they can create significant value for society by introducing innovative products, services, or technologies. In contrast, even if the majority of traders were "successful," there would be no net value created, as one trader's gain is another's loss, and the overall wealth in the system remains unchanged.

> so what if it’s a zero sum game?

While you may not initially be concerned about the distinction between positive-sum and zero-sum activities in society, studying history and economics may change your perspective. Positive-sum activities, such as entrepreneurship and innovation, contribute to economic growth and improved living standards, whereas zero-sum activities, like “buy low sell high” trading, do not.

> why should someone care?

Consider this analogy: if "buy low, sell high" trading is like playing chess, and your opponents are a collection of the best chess engines money can buy, operated by the world's top experts (think Magnus Carlsen), how profitable can you realistically expect your trading to be? The odds are heavily stacked against the retail trader. Some professional traders pay brokers to have retail orders routed to them for this reason much like how professional poker players want to play amateurs for their income.

While a small fraction of professional traders manage to beat the returns of buy-and-hold index investing, the fleeting existence of market-beating strategies is not a valid reason for the average investor to attempt them. Just as you cannot predict which lottery tickets will be winners, you cannot foresee which trading strategies will outperform. If this was possible highly paid professional traders that devote their life to it would be able to do it but only a few actually do and luck plays a big role in their success.

Markets have “seasons” and what seems to work in one season can be devastating in another. Markets also change in response to the trading strategies being used (aka “reflexivity”) and “paper testing” can give false confidence.

czl··on Changing a mean reversion strategy to deliver 30% annual returns since 1999
Trading, particularly short-term "buy low, sell high" strategies, differs fundamentally from businesses that create products or deliver services. In trading, profits are often directly linked to the losses of other market participants, making it a zero-sum activity. In other words, for every winner, there must be a corresponding loser on the other side of the trade.

This dynamic is similar to gambling games like Texas Hold'em poker in a casino setting. While skilled players may consistently profit at the expense of less experienced participants, the overall wealth within the game remains constant. No new value is generated; instead, existing wealth is redistributed among the players based on their relative performance and luck. When research time and fees are added trading is largely “negative sum”.

NOTE: Some trading activities, such as market making and arbitrage, provide liquidity and help maintain fair pricing in financial markets but these operations require expensive low latency market access and are dominated by market insiders and are not possible for retail traders.

czl··on U.S..D.A. Suspends Avocado Inspections in Mexico, Citing Security Concerns
Recreational drugs can be highly addictive and lead to a loss of motivation for other activities, which is a key reason they are so dangerous, even beyond direct adverse health effects.

While all drugs carry risks, those with more noticeable negative effects, like alcohol causing sickness and hangovers, may be somewhat less prone to severe addiction than drugs that provide a "cleaner" high. However, alcohol is still highly addictive for many despite the negatives. Drugs that can cause fatal overdose even with a single use are the most dangerous of all.

When drugs are legalized, at a minimum there needs to be strong education efforts so people can understand the real effects and risks. For those who still choose to use potentially lethal drugs, there could be legal protocols for ensuring their affairs are in order such as a requirement to prepay their funerals.

czl··on U.S..D.A. Suspends Avocado Inspections in Mexico, Citing Security Concerns
Yes, drug use and addiction is a medical issue and should be handled as a medical issue leaving no room for criminal groups to profit. That said society must educate its members about recreational drug use and its consequences. Education not laws should be used to stop people the use of recreational drugs. If murder or robbery happens normal laws should apply but if drug addiction is the cause those crimes should be treated like crimes committed by people with a mental disease.
← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →