HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

czl

240 karma · joined January 14, 2016

submissionscomments
czl··on Super Heavy has splashed down in The Gulf of Mexico
Before World War I, Britain observed Germany's rapid rise and perceived it as a threat to its own global dominance. This situation is a classic example of the Thucydides trap, named after the ancient Greek historian who noted that when a rising power threatens to displace an existing great power, war becomes more likely. In this case, Germany's growing industrial and military strength was seen as a direct challenge to Britain's hegemony.

Germany, on the other hand, wanted to emerge as a stronger power than Britain while avoiding direct conflict. German leaders pleaded with Britain to remain neutral and not declare war on Germany. However, from the British perspective, war with Germany was deemed necessary to suppress its increasing power and maintain Britain's position on the world stage.

British leaders may not have actively sought to start a war, but they believed that confronting Germany was crucial to protect their national interests. See my reply to sibling comment with more details.

Today there is a similar situation with China being the rising power and America seeking to suppress it.

czl··on Super Heavy has splashed down in The Gulf of Mexico
Rocket landing on the moon does not count? Luna 9 in 1966 was the first spacecraft to achieve a controlled soft landing on the Moon.
czl··on Super Heavy has splashed down in The Gulf of Mexico
While Britain's decision to enter World War I was indeed triggered by Germany's invasion of Belgium, it's important to consider the broader context. In the years leading up to the war, Britain had engaged in a naval arms race with Germany, driven by fears of Germany's growing military and economic power. British leaders, including Foreign Secretary Sir Edward Grey and First Lord of the Admiralty Winston Churchill, viewed war with Germany as inevitable and believed it was better to fight sooner while Britain still held a naval advantage.

Britain's system of alliances, particularly the Entente Cordiale with France and Russia, made it likely that any conflict involving these powers would draw Britain into a larger war. When the July Crisis erupted following the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, British leaders did little to prevent the escalation of tensions. Despite last-minute efforts by some, such as German Chancellor Theobald von Bethmann-Hollweg's plea for British neutrality, Britain remained committed to its alliances and the belief that war with Germany was necessary.

It's worth noting that other European leaders, such as French President Raymond Poincaré and Russian Tsar Nicholas II, also played significant roles in the outbreak of the war. However, Britain's long-standing rivalry with Germany, its naval arms race, and its commitment to alliances that would likely trigger a larger conflict all contributed to its readiness to enter the war when the opportunity arose.

czl··on GLM-4-9B: open-source model with superior performance to Llama-3-8B
Based on size (parameter count) they are in different categories. GLM-4V-9B is in the "light-weight" competition. gpt-4o-2024-05-13 is in the medium or heavy "weight" competition.
czl··on Super Heavy has splashed down in The Gulf of Mexico
> Allies did not initiate war and did not want war.

An argument made that WW2 was continuation of WW1 and that WW1 was wanted by British leadership who were locked in an arms race with Germany that they could not sustain much longer and wanted a war with Germany while they were ahead so the assassination that triggered WW1 was the pretext tobstart WW1. If you disagree please try to answer why leaders are regularly assassinated and that does not cause a world war.

czl··on GrapheneOS implements a destructive PIN code feature
Are "images" of encrypted devices possible? How much does this help when an "image" of the encrypted device exists? Perhaps there need to be different sessions stored with different unlock codes for each session? (Much like some carry "fake" wallets to hand over during robbery.)
czl··on Microsoft AI spying scandal: time to rethink privacy standards
Yes, for a search to be considered narrow, the resulting group should be small and specifically defined by precise criteria, not encompassing a significant portion of the population. *Notice once criteria are stacked groups can get small.* E.g. Which young males on your street (or in your building) who like Trump but not Israel were protesting at city hall today? Big datasets let authorities / advertisers / ... answer questions like that. The answer will often be a tiny "narrow" fraction of the population (of your city / state / country / ...).
czl··on Largest Autonomous Ride-Hail Territory in US Now Even Larger
Yes that and remotely read the road situation via all the sensors (cameras, lidar, etc) and figure out what reasonable path to input. Automation of "turn the wheel" / "press the pedals" is trivial by comparison.
czl··on Largest Autonomous Ride-Hail Territory in US Now Even Larger
Mechanical turk chess was also amazing in its day so I do wonder how often there is a remote human driver vs not. Not that there is anything wrong with that. Getting semi-automated remote driving working at scale is an accomplishment.
czl··on Researchers identify major driver of inflammatory bowel and related diseases
> All of a sudden I've gotta go.

Not to dismiss your observations but to supply an alternative explanation for your belief about them: Do you remember your embarrassing experiences vs the not embarrassing ones equally well? A selective memory can give the illusion of correlation. Moreover once you have some belief you may become better at finding and remembering confirming evidence for that belief.

czl··on Researchers to retract landmark Alzheimer's paper containing doctored images
Indeed. Another example of this is Forbes featuring outlier successful people on its front cover who have later turned out to be involved in criminal activities or scandals. (1) Elizabeth Holmes, founder of Theranos, who was once celebrated as a tech visionary but later convicted of fraud. (2) Sam Bankman-Fried, founder of FTX, who faced multiple fraud charges following the collapse of his cryptocurrency exchange.
czl··on Researchers to retract landmark Alzheimer's paper containing doctored images
FYI: Some have suggested that Mendel's data might be too perfect, indicating possible manipulation or fraud. (1) Mendel's results are unusually close to the expected ratios of 3:1 for dominant and recessive traits. Some argue that real-world data often show more variation. (2) In 1936, statistician Ronald A. Fisher analyzed Mendel's data and suggested it was "too good to be true." Fisher believed the results might have been altered or selectively reported to better match Mendel's hypothesis. (3) Despite these concerns, many of Mendel's experiments have been replicated, and his fundamental findings remain valid. Most scientists believe any discrepancies in Mendel's data were not due to intentional fraud but possibly unconscious bias or error.
czl··on Microsoft AI spying scandal: time to rethink privacy standards
> not like there's a human on the other side reviewing what the user is doing

With LLMs looking at all this data if you want to persecute or narrowly propagandize those who are X (X = pro-israel, anti-israel, pro-trump, anti-trump etc) it can be done much better than before. The "humans on the other" side will be using all this data to narrowly find people.

czl··on Epoch Times CFO charged in $67M crypto money laundering plot
See "This Chinese Cult is Not Your Friend - the Falun Gong story" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JaPzJKycxc
czl··on Microsoft Rolling Out New Windows Subsystem for Linux "WSL" Features for 2024
> There was never a way to tune RAM usage AFAIK.

Wsl2 has a config file setting for ram usage. WSL1 just shares the windows RAM.

czl··on Revealed: Israeli spy chief 'threatened' ICC prosecutor over war crimes inquiry
> does not constitute genocide

Crimes are decided by courts and when countries are involved international courts / international judges become involved. To threaten or bribe or ignore judges does not look good. I am not saying this was done. I am only speaking about how it looks.

> If Israel had the intent to exterminate all Palestinians, it possesses the means but clearly lacks such intentions.

Do you doubt some groups in Israel want Palestinian to “disappear” and only wish they had some pretext to justify it? Say some Israeli group carries out some attack with the result that many die now what fraction of Israel should be killed / destroyed? How much collateral damage to Israel is acceptable? Perhaps specific members of that group should be punished instead? And if you can not punish them right away you take your time and do it when possible?

> On the other hand, Hamas has explicitly stated its intention towards Israelis in its charter, and actually executed to the best of their ability genocidal ambitions against Jews on October 7th.

No one civilized supports Hamas or their methods. The question is about those who live in Gaza that are not Hamas and how much collateral death and destruction is acceptable. You may call it a “defensive war” but consider how that war looks outside Israel and how Israel will look after it has “won” that war.

I support Israel but believe current Israeli government is making a mistake with how they are dealing with Hamas due to all bystanders being hurt. I also think Israeli government screwed up allowing settlers in West Bank and having to dilute military to protect these settlers leaving border with Gaza less protected. The results of these bad policies speak for themselves.

czl··on OpenAI didn’t copy Scarlett Johansson’s voice for ChatGPT, records show
Did I claim coincidence? The openAI sky voice has been available among many other voices since last September and I shared evidence that there are other actors who could claim the voice is more similar to their voice. Yet you think the voice actor from the film her has a right to prevent the use of the sky voice now? On what basis? I doubt most people who watch the film her even know who did the voice acting. And per the evidence I shared above the claim about it being that same voice vs another popular actor is weak.
czl··on OpenAI didn’t copy Scarlett Johansson’s voice for ChatGPT, records show
Listen to the voices side by side:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1cwy6wz/vocal_comp...

And here is voice of another actress ( Rashida Jones ):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=385414AVZcA

which actress do you think is similar to the openAI sky voice?

czl··on Nvidia announces financial results for first quarter fiscal 2025
FYI: This isn't a case of the sunk cost fallacy. The sunk cost fallacy involves continuing an investment due to the amount already invested, regardless of future potential. What you're describing is more related to regret aversion and hindsight bias.
czl··on OpenAI didn’t copy Scarlett Johansson’s voice for ChatGPT, records show
Yes they tried to copy film Her yet the voice ai character in the film you think was original? No other films predate that film with female AI voices? And would the actor have claim on the fictional character they played in the film vs film “owners”?
czl··on OpenAI didn’t copy Scarlett Johansson’s voice for ChatGPT, records show
Listen to the voices side by side:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1cwy6wz/vocal_comp...

And here is voice of another actress ( Rashida Jones ):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=385414AVZcA

If you click through and listen please reply and answer these questions: which actress do you think is similar to the openAI sky voice? And what does that tell you about likely court result for Johansson? And having reached this conclusion yourself would you now think the other actress Rashida Jones is entitled to compensation based on this similarly test?

czl··on What's the difference between a motor and an engine? (2013)
Motors primarily convert electrical energy (or fluid/air pressure in the case of hydraulic/pneumatic motors) into mechanical motion.

Engines primarily convert chemical or thermal energy into mechanical power. The term is also applied metaphorically to a central component that drives a process or system.

> Pretending that they are anything but synonyms now is ridiculous and I'm glad the article pointed out that they are used that way instead of pretending that the older definitions still have merit like so many prescriptionist folks do.

So you are ok with having your opinion about this recorded in online forum's database motors and easily discovered by users of Google's search motor?

czl··on What's the difference between a motor and an engine? (2013)
Go further back and there were machines called "siege engines".
czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
You asked the good question about why they may have acted as they did and I attempted to answer it. In hindsight based on results it may look reckless but decisions need to be judged based on that is known at the time they are made and the public reaction was not a foregone outcome. The openAI sky voice has been available since last September why was there no outrage about it back then?

You can listen to the voices side by side:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1cwy6wz/comment/l4...

And here is voice of another actress ( Rashida Jones ):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=385414AVZcA

This test is not blind but YOU tell me which you think is similar to the openAI sky voice?

> And they failed with an actor who sued Disney shortly after they paid her $20 million to make a movie.

OpenAI did not fail. They suspended the sky voice and backed down not to further anger a segment of the public who views much of what OpenAI does in a negative light. Given the voice test above do you seriously think OpenAI would lose in court? Would that matter to the segment of population that is already outraged by AI? How are journalists and news companies affected by AI? How might their reporting be biased?

czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
> even Johansson's family and friends couldn't tell it apart are somewhat telling.

You can listen to the voices side by side:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1cwy6wz/comment/l4...

And here is voice of another actress ( Rashida Jones ):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=385414AVZcA

This test is not blind but YOU tell me which you think is similar to the openAI sky voice? And what does that tell you about likely court result for Johansson? And having reached this conclusion yourself would you now think the other actress Rashida Jones is entitled to compensation based on this similarly test? Because there are no other women with similar voices? What might support from friends and family of Rashida Jones be an indication of?

czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
Civil trails are based on a preponderance of evidence (aka 50%) burden of proof standard (vs beyond reasonable doubt standard in criminal trails).

I can see a civil judge or jury being given evidence showing very few listeners think the voices match in _blind voice tests_.

Here for example you can listen to the voices side by side:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1cwy6wz/comment/l4...

And here is voice of another actress ( Rashida Jones ):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=385414AVZcA

This test is not blind but YOU tell me which you think is similar to the openAI sky voice? And what does that tell you about likely court result for Johansson? And having reached this conclusion yourself would you now think the other actress Rashida Jones is entitled to compensation based on this similarly test? Because there are no other women with similar voices?

czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
I put the "NOT IN REPLY TO YOU" since I meant that as a thought experiment of a possible future that where a similar situation may arise. Notice it is not freedom of thought that is in question. What is in question is freedom to share your sensations with others. You are watching a live football game and you share the sensations (what you see / hear / smell) with friends and family who are not there, etc. add to this technology that enables perfect memory of you sensations and instantly sharing them. In that possible future many will litigate and complain that their copyright and broadcast rights are being violated and they must be compensated much like what is happening with generative AI today. Sure this is scifi today. So were "flying machines" and "moon visits" and magic of our global communication pocket devices, etc. Gpt4o is a bunch of matrix math being done on high purity ore and refined sand powered by the sun / wind / splitting atoms / ... A century back few would believe it. Even a decade back, any predictions about a real AI like gpt4o working in just a decade, would you believe such predictions?
czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
So the voice of the AI in the film "Her" who do you think has more rights to it being reused elsewhere in association with AI? The voice actor? The film owners? Why then the current news?
czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
OpenAI wanted to imitate the AI from the film Her. When you show that film to 100 random people how many will know who did the voice for the AI in the film? I myself had no idea. Moreover there are people now running blind voice similarly tests of similar voices of various other possible female actors. Guess what these blind voice tests show?
czl··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
> and until the court settles the questions at hand, Open AI and its ilk are operating in a legal gray area.

My understanding of western law is that things are ok unless law forbids it. So they are operating in an area that under _current_ laws is ok but because of what may be at stake many wish the current laws were different and are willing to use litigation and lobby efforts to that end.

This is NOT IN REPLY TO YOU but a general observation: Imagine the litigation that will happen when brain implants enable brain to brain sharing sensations and thoughts. Imagine the horrible copyright abuse! How will the publishing industry and sports industry and Hollywood control the rampart piracy?!?

← PreviousPage 7 of 10Next →