HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dahart

19,138 karma · joined October 19, 2011

submissionscomments
dahart··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
The error rate could be higher, which I mentioned already, but who knows how much higher. I don’t see how speculating about the error rate helps anything. Did you mean to say the error rate is usually much lower than 11%?

> except for things that are life threatening for which no better test exists.

This was precisely why I chose the FIT test example. There is, in fact, a more reliable test than the FIT test. Several, it turns out. Reliability isn’t the reason for the FIT test’s popularity.

dahart··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
> therefore all tests with error rates are equally bad

I did not say that, nor even imply it.

Oh I don’t doubt there was funny business or fraud. What you’ve added is what the parent comment was missing; the reasons beyond the error rates.

> the test you Google is a false negative rate, which a simple fact that test can’t reliably diagnose everything even when run properly.

Yes I mentioned above it’s a false negative rate, right? And false negatives are potentially more dangerous for survival than false positives. Again, I was just reacting to the narrative about people getting scared by false positives, as if that was the primary problem. Your comment supports my claim that the error rate was not the primary problem, no?

dahart··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
I don’t know a thing about Holmes, I’m just reacting to your framing - don’t all medical tests that real people rely on have error rates? Doesn’t an 11% error rate suggest something that was real and mostly works but maybe wasn’t ready for prime time? The error rate could have been higher, perhaps. You only listed false positives, while the much more concerning problem would be false negatives - people who didn’t get scared or act when they should have. Still, a medical test error rate on its own doesn’t suggest deceit or fraud. People receiving terrifying but wrong results is a common problem that already exists in medicine.

Google tells me the FIT test for cancer has a false negative rate of between 8% and 26%. That appears to be likely worse than the Theranos numbers you cited here.

dahart··on How the Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
This has gotta be a reference to something, amirite? Do I need to watch the movie, or is it something from Nathan For You or somewhere else?
dahart··on I Love Software Rendering
> you will never render something really big. And CPU look is much much better.

Why do you believe these things? In VFX and film, the GPU shaders and rendering is identical to CPU, they use the exact same programmable shaders on either side, so there is no difference in look or capability. Today’s GPUs have out of core streaming and caching and access to host memory. Pixar showed off their pixel-matching between GPU and CPU at Siggraph this year, and mentioned that today’s consumer GPUs are big enough to render IIRC ~98% of their scenes without much ‘out-of-core’ tech. Lots of film and VFX studios are using GPUs in production today to render pretty big shots. I think your story is a bit out of date; GPUs being size limited was somewhat true in the past, but is quickly going away. The CPU vs GPU look question has never been true for VFX or film, and was only true in games if you chose different rendering algorithms.

dahart··on The Lightbulb Computer
Legal counsel at multiple companies have always advised me to not do a patent search before writing up an invention. I guess often the lawyers do the search, and the inventors don’t.

That said, this project isn’t well summarized as merely “tiny projectors”. Many patents have been granted for systems that include parts that are also patented. Indeed, I can see recently granted patents that include digital projectors. And many products have good sales without being patented; patents are not the end-all of invention. So I feel like you’ve been much too quick to dismiss.

dahart··on Our $445M Series D
You knew before you did any writing there was a good chance you’d be rejected, right? Why did you do it anyway? Why did you apply to this company? Did it have anything to do with their reputation? Or salary?

Lots of people are minimally qualified, and that’s not what they want, so their initial filter works for them. At least that should be your first assumption, no? Better depends on perspective, right? If you think you know a universally better way, what’s stopping you from building it? (If it’s money, be aware that money is available for people who know better ways, but you will have to do a lot more than 5 hours of writing to get it, and you’ll have to be okay with rejection.)

dahart··on Our $445M Series D
> “Job interviews” in tech used to be casual conversations of a few hours.

In 30 years of interviewing on both sides, as candidate and as hiring manager, I’ve never seen that myself. I don’t doubt it’s happened. I can’t speak to what’s normal everywhere. But I can say for sure that either a half day or full day of formal interviews (usually depending on both team and company size) has been absolutely standard in my experience, both in Silicon Valley and elsewhere, for decades.

On top of that, all of my jobs I’ve ever had, even when I was a shoe-in because I got the interviews via networking, they all involved multiple days worth of email and phone calls and resume prep and benefits negotiations, and (later in my career) sometimes legal negotiations like non-compete exclusions.

I’ve had lots of casual conversations during the process, but I’ve never been hired on a casual conversation alone, and never seen someone else hired that way.

dahart··on Our $445M Series D
100%. Especially with rampant AI interviewing, or even just more automated application spamming, it’s surprising that people are complaining about making it to the interview stage and having to spend time there, the stage where chances of getting the job have increased a hundredfold. If companies automated the process more, then the outcome is guaranteed to be that us candidates get less say in whether we’re hired and how we’re viewed. There’s some serious strawmanning here imagining that 9 hours of interviews is somehow mandatory and likely to happen with dozens of companies at a time. That very unlikely event would be a massive opportunity, and of course would not last long because with that many interviews, you’d get a job immediately.
dahart··on Our $445M Series D
> if every company had this policy, 90 unpaid interviewing hours.

You’d be so lucky! You could then actually prioritize and choose the companies you might want to work for. If you’re spamming applications and waiting for a low callback rate, the expected value of job offer quality is low and the amount of control you have over where you find work is low.

I’m always so curious when people frame interviewing as unpaid work why they think about it this way; it doesn’t seem like a helpful framing. For someone out of work, looking for a job is a full time unpaid job no matter what, and interviews are a good thing - a chance to talk to people and show them you’re hireable. If you spend your time applying but not interviewing, that’s a signal that your strategy needs to change.

Companies don’t make money on the time they spend interviewing you, they aren’t getting direct financial value out of it either, in fact it’s a cost for them, they lose money on the immediate transaction, but they make it back in spades when they hire good people, just like you make it back in spades when you get hired. Interviews are considered an investment by them, and you should consider whether viewing them the same way and acting on it might actually increase your odds.

dahart··on Our $445M Series D
> I’d rather an LLM auto-reject my application

Be careful what you wish for. You might end up with no writing exercises and a 100% automated rejection rate with no way to figure out why or talk to someone.

Yes obviously you need to choose how to allocate your finite time, that was always true, so think about whether it’s truly effective to apply to so many jobs. You aren’t required to apply to 5 jobs per day, right? You want to maximize your chances of getting 1 job, right? Is it possible that fewer, longer interactions with people (and not LLMs) might increase your chances?

Also consider that getting enough bites on your resume that you have to choose between companies is a great problem to have. Don’t forget that interviews and writing questions also cost the company time, and they’re not asking unless they think there’s a decent chance of success. Nobody is asking anyone to write 5 hours of unique material per application without filtering resumes and talking to candidates a little bit first, so it’s extremely unlikely you could end up with the problem you’re complaining about even if you wanted to.

dahart··on I would like the value of my home to rise, while my property taxes fall
I wouldn’t count somewhere I don’t want to live being cheaper as the prices of all other homes falling… ;) Nor as lack of need to stay either - if real estate prices were the only thing keeping people around, cities might not exist.
dahart··on Man discovers his parents' coffee machine used 1TB of data in 10 days
> And of course practically every website you visit is doing a full session recording with mouse movements and key presses captured.

Well yeah at the very least, that’s Google Analytics and/or similar alternatives.

Most individual websites outside of Google/Facebook/Amazon don’t get any data other than what you do on their website, so it doesn’t seem quite as creepy to me as a device on your home network port scanning and sniffing other traffic.

Google and Facebook can and do ‘spy’ a lot, of course, but otherwise the browser does protect you from most trivial spying by random sites. Not that that’s reason to feel any safer; the few people actually spying on what you do everywhere on the web are the ones with the most resources. This is all going to get way weirder with AI logs, I’m guessing.

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
Just need to say that is an amazing essay, and it’s being favorited to re-read later as needed. Thank you. Aside from being hilarious, it’s fascinating and also reminds of how little I know about statistics (and intelligence, and other things too). I didn’t realize the argument against g was so thorough, but I’m convinced. BTW his subsequent post also hit hard https://bactra.org/weblog/524.html
dahart··on What is going on with ceiling fans
> This company had designed cars for about 120 years at that point but still seemed to commit easy mistakes…

Oh take a look at the recall list of any car company in the world and you will find they all make simple mistakes, constantly. Probably a consequence of price pressure at all times. While cars are lasting longer than they used to on average, I feel like it’s been getting worse in some ways with cars lately turning into computers and good car/engine companies lately turning into bad tech companies without that much tech experience who outsource important parts and do lousy integration. And yeah, building assemblies or modules with non-replaceable parts is becoming more common.

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
> I’m not sure why it matters whether we use an absolute scale. In another couple years, LLMs will trounce everybody on every topic.

Whether intelligence is innate or trained, and what the absolute scale is, matter tremendously for national education policy, not to mention food, pollution, finance and everything that contributes to outcomes. Your examples are mainly based on differences in training. The main difference between particle physics and fractions is school, not cortical thickness, right?

Personally I also care whether the narratives we share and the public conception of intelligence is true and accurate or not. There absolutely are cultural biases surrounding intelligence that affect society and affect how people treat each other. If intelligence is trained, then we know we can focus on training. If intelligence is largely genetic and not training (or SES or nutrition, etc.) then grouping kids by ability is more justified than otherwise. If the biological component of 2 standard deviations above the mean in intelligence is relatively small (like it is for many other physical traits) then the term “gifted” is exaggerating reality, in addition to any mis-attribution of the source of the difference that the word implies.

Is LLMs getting better a reason to stop learning or stop caring about education & education policy? LLMs only got where they are by humans showing them everything humans wrote, right? I don’t see how LLMs improving changes anything with respect to teaching humans or measuring human ability. One thing that LLMs or AI in general might help enable is teaching kids at their own pace. The whole reason we teach kids in groups by age is because it’s easy and scalable. If each kid had her/his own teacher, then making the timing of the curriculum adaptive becomes feasible. Maybe AI-supplemented teaching will open this door, though there are still valid reasons to keep kids interacting and learning along with other same-age kids.

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
> I don’t know what this means

A hypothesis or model that’s unfalsifiable broadly means it’s unscientific. You can read the Wikipedia section I liked to, and follow the citation if you want.

“John Horn and John McArdle have argued that the modern g theory, as espoused by, for example, Arthur Jensen, is unfalsifiable, because the existence of a common factor like g follows tautologically from positive correlations among tests. They contrasted the modern hierarchical theory of g with Spearman's original two-factor theory which was readily falsifiable (and indeed was falsified).”

Horn, John; McArdle, John (2007). "Understanding Human Intelligence". In Cudeck, Robert; MacCallum, Robert C. (eds.). Factor analysis at 100: historical developments and future directions. Mahwah, N.J: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. ISBN 978-0-8058-6212-6.

Musical and artistic ability both have in fact been associated with intelligence by many people for thousands of years; many musicians and artists have been called “geniuses”. I don’t know what intuitive sense you’re referring to wrt music, but you’re certainly not speaking for us all.

> I get riled up when I hear opinions that many lead to support for abolishing gifted programs.

Ah I see! Thanks for explaining; this is a critically important piece for me to understand why you’re reacting so strongly. I don’t support abolishing accelerated programs, so relax; I think you’re making some assumptions and jumping to conclusions. I have heard here on HN from parents reporting there are public schools in California and elsewhere that have been doing away with accelerated academic programs, and many parents and kids are extremely frustrated.

Note the paper I linked to at the top supports you:

“Ability grouping, which is perhaps the next best-supported practice in gifted education, is likewise implemented relatively rarely. This failure of schools to use practices that are known to be effective is not the case in other areas of special education, where the use of evidence- or research-based best practices is often mandated in policy”

FWIW, I was segregated into a small accelerated program in the 5th grade, and dropped into a high school, which came with its own set of problems. They didn’t use the word “gifted”, though, and I’m glad.

My feeling on the why the word ‘gifted’ is bad is two parts: it incorrectly assigns ability only to nature, when we have plenty of evidence that intelligence has many environmental factors, and calling it ‘gifted’ might be dramatically overstating how much smarter the top 5% of kids are compared to the mean or the bottom 95%. I agree there’s some utility in classifying kids, or at least understanding their individual educational needs and letting them go at their own pace. Calling them “gifted” (like the article we’re commenting on explains) sends the wrong message, both in terms of accuracy and in terms of what parents and educators should do about it.

Kids who are classified as ‘gifted’ don’t necessarily perform well in school, the Wikipedia article on g points out. And intelligence factors change somewhat over time. It would obviously be bad to measure all 5 year olds only once and then put them on educational tracks that can’t ever change, to decide who’s “gifted” and who’s not and assume there is zero fluidity, right? But that’s the history of the word “gifted” - it was chosen by someone over a hundred years ago, and it was specifically chosen to underscore the idea that there is an innate and unchanging raw intellectual ability. We know better now, and we should pick terminology to match, right?

BTW might be worth discussing that kids who aren’t “gifted” benefit developmentally from social interaction with kids who are “gifted”. This does make education policy legitimately more difficult.

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
> it’s very possible that g helps with musical ability and painting ability too.

The development of g rests on that assumption, but the measured correlations vary, and the correlations are lower for music & painting than between, e.g., STEM subjects.

Also interesting - the cross-subject correlations g measures actually decrease as intelligence increases. The smarter someone is (as measured by psychometric tests), the more likely they are to be “smart” in a single subject and not all subjects. This is an interesting self-contradiction in the whole theory.

> It makes perfect sense to me that socio-economics would correlate.

Yeah, I totally agree. But, it’s very important to know that the people like Spearman and others who developed IQ and g and other concepts of intelligence in the 1920s were specifically looking for the innate biological component of intelligence that explains “gifted” ability in the absence of nurture and environmental factors. That’s where this use of “gifted” came from - it’s pre-supposing that intelligence was not heavily influenced by the wealth of your parents, and they didn’t know how important nutrition and pollution were at the time. This is why I think using “gifted” is problematic. From that paper I linked to: “Reframing ‘gifts’ as ‘talents’ underscores both the domain-specific nature of these abilities and that their extent should be viewed as dynamic rather than static or preordained.”

One question that occurs to me - who are these gifts bestowed by? There are two obvious answers: nature and God. I think nature is historically what is meant by ‘gifted’ in the context of education, but I’ll speculate there’s at least a little bit of historical religious influence on the choice of that word. Given that we know that SES, nutrition, environment, education, parenting and many other factors have real measurable influences on both intelligence and outcomes for people, the nature & God explanations are somewhat lacking, right?

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
The concept of g is not without plenty of critique, like IQ its origins are from eugenicists, that it doesn’t track known biology, and that it’s unfalsifiable. The concept of g is that there’s a correlation in performance across multiple subjects, the evidence does not show the correlation is 1.0 - the average correlation is more like 0.6. g is particularly bad at explaining musical talent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)#Criti...

I’ve never read something arguing that intelligence doesn’t exist (and I certainly wouldn’t buy such an argument). I just don’t think intelligence is one dimensional, thus rankings can be misleading or sometimes damaging when used to determine the educational curriculum of a child.

My issues with intelligence tests are that they only rank, they do not measure absolute intelligence, and they assume (against the evidence) that intelligence is 1-dimensionsonal and rankable. The ranking part means that terminology like “gifted” is making a huge assumption and priming people to think about intelligence incorrectly. IQ of 130 (“gifted”) is, by definition, 2 standard deviations above the mean. An adult male that’s 2 standard deviations above the norm in height is 6 foot 2. A whopping 5 inches taller than the mean of 5’9”. The 6’2” man is a little taller than the average guy, not a lot taller — even though they are taller than 95% of men. There’s no reason to believe that the distribution of intelligence, especially the hereditary/biological component of intelligence, is any different.

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
Okay it’s fair to question calling ‘effort’ part of intelligence; what I meant is that nurture/environment and experience and motivation are a large part of what gets measured with any and all psychometric tests. And we do know that practicing for IQ tests can raise scores somewhat.

FWIW, I wasn’t arguing against the idea of intelligence being heritable or having a biological component. Intelligence is heritable, but also there are large environmental and nurture components as well. Using the word “highly” might be technically accurate but somewhat misleading, the heritability of IQ for example averages around 50% across many studies (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ).

I was just pointing out that the way we measure intelligence does not measure intelligence itself directly, it only ranks people. We don’t know how much smarter someone who’s IQ 150 is than someone who’s IQ 100, we only know how many people are smarter than either score. Calling someone with a high IQ profoundly gifted is not actually supported by the ranking metric we’re using.

High intelligence does exist, I completely agree. What “high” actually means is debatable. But why is being amazing at art or music different from having high intelligence? Not sure I agree, and I think that statement is suspicious and deserves some justification. I think a lot of people would consider Bach and Mozart intelligent.

The actual reference to different brain structures in the Wikipedia article also mentions the positive correlation between socioeconomic status of children and their measured intelligence. That’s enough to question what’s actually being measured, and whether a correlation between cortical thickness and IQ really does represent a correlation between cortical thickness and intelligence, or something else.

dahart··on Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children
> When adults consistently praise a child’s intelligence rather than their process or effort, mistakes stop feeling like normal setbacks and start feeling existential.

Isn’t this a good reason to stop using the term “gifted”? Isn’t it now widely acknowledged that effort (among other things like creativity and self-conception) actually is part of intelligence?

“Gifted” children are historically identified and classified via IQ tests (typically with the threshold IQ >= 130 - though the definition of what ‘gifted’ should mean is being debated), and using “gifted” for smart kids emerged and was popularized in the 1920’s when IQ tests were being developed by people who basically believed in eugenics, in the heritability of intelligence, and they wanted to identify the kids with the smart genes. [1] Using language like ‘profoundly gifted’ and ‘genius’ for high IQ has always been (mis)leading since IQ is a ranking, not an absolute measure of intelligence.

I just searched and found an interesting recent paper arguing that ‘gifted’ is problematic and attached to science that is no longer valid, and should be improved or replaced. [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_giftedness#Overvi...

[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36278606/

dahart··on Loss of cell identity drives human aging: Two new papers
Some people certainly have been diving into nuclear & green for decades, and we now have far more wind, solar, and hydro power than we did several decades ago. Nuclear has been flat for only 2 decades and is about to start growing.

“We” certainly have had control the whole time, “we” have been consciously creating greenhouse gas emitting machines while knowing the consequences. It is the economics. The delay in environmental consequences combined with the immediate financial benefits of easy power & transportation made the choice too tempting for some.

The kind of control you’re talking about is self-control. We’ve always had the option to stop our bad behavior, and we chose not to. And we still have the option to exercise self-control with AI. The question is whether that option might disappear soon. Can AI get good enough that we will actually lose the choice to regulate ourselves?

dahart··on Don't be fooled–LLMs don't reason
> while the chains of thought chatbots produce look like deliberation, research has demonstrated that the bots often concoct them after the fact, reaching an answer by one route but reporting another.

Doesn’t research show humans often do this too? There’s a pretty famous paper from the 70s about that [1], and lots of subsequent evidence. We also have choice blindness [2], we confabulate reasons [3], and we even change our choices (sometimes negatively) after trying to introspect [4].

[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/229060046_Telling_m...

[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16210542/

[3] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5986841/

[4] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2016668/

dahart··on How I changed teaching after AI managed to do all my homework assignments
Things are being massively changed by AI. That’s what this article is about, the article you seem intent on poo-pooing. I only asked you a question about your stance, it was not an attack. My question was aimed at trying to uncover why you’ve cast insults toward teachers multiple times, and implicitly the one who authored this article. The only ad-hominems were yours, and they started with your first comment.

What heavy assumptions are you referring to? If you mean assuming that kids probably won’t skip university and instead will be self-motivated enough to use AI non-stop for several years in order to teach themselves enough to get a job as a biologist or a ballet dancer or a civil engineer, and if you mean assuming that companies and organizations probably won’t suddenly start accepting self-AI-taught candidates as being the same as having a degree… if these are the assumptions you’re referring to, then you’re right - I am assuming those things and I believe them. No matter how AI changes things, it’s a pretty heavy assumption you’ve made to think kids will self-motivate an education just because information is available, especially given that was always possible and still chosen so rarely that it effectively doesn’t exist. And it’s a pretty heavy assumption to think that universities and organizations will change together in a way that can vette the merit of prospective candidates any time in foreseeable future. AI will change a lot of things, but you’re underestimating our social structures and what things like the accreditation system do for the workforce and the economy. You can argue it’s got problems, but assuming like you did that AI can replace it anytime soon is a very heavy assumption.

If the pencil comment and suggestion to take away computers wasn’t literal, then you’re right, I have no idea what you meant. Feel free to explain. If you can’t, then I’d agree, there’s no further purpose.

dahart··on How I changed teaching after AI managed to do all my homework assignments
I disagree that’s the problem, and I don’t think your claim is true. Degrees are still extremely valuable, and income stats alone prove it conclusively. I don’t find your suggestion very interesting, not because colleges are gatekeeping, but for the reason already stated: because most people do not and cannot teach themselves and curate their own educations at a university level, and because even if they did, which they don’t, it still wouldn’t help them get jobs or advanced degrees in today’s workforce. It might be an interesting suggestion if that happened with any statistical significance, but it doesn’t, and isn’t a realistic path for education for society.

Figuring out how to teach kids is exactly what this article is doing. How do you propose to teach kids, when they refuse to put in the work, and reach for AI for everything? Your suggestion to make them use pencils seems naïve/ignorant/obtuse; this article is written by a computer science teacher. You can’t force people to use only pencils for homework (as the article points out), and it would be ridiculous to use pencils for writing computer programs in 2026. That suggestion is a non-starter. FWIW, the impression I’m getting is not that you have any helpful suggestions for education, but that you don’t have experience teaching and don’t understand what’s happening in schools right now.

Who is protecting jobs programs under the guise of something nobler? This seems like a straw man unrelated to your previous comment. I’m getting the feeling you’re anti-education for some reason, maybe have some bone to pick with the university system, is that accurate? Asking kids to teach themselves or forcing them to use pencils are not going to be successful ways to improve education.

dahart··on Font where each token is equal-width
Looking at the first several examples, shorter (one, two, three-) letter words are not stretched to the full ‘fixed’ width. It’s the whitespace around them that is fixed. The only example in the first three screenshots of splitting a word into tokes is ‘vibes’ which turns into ‘vib’ and ‘es’. I’m skeptical of the -ing and -tion words being single tokens as shown.
dahart··on Ten lines of code that changed my world
The BASIC print+goto loop might have been my first ever program too (in the 80s) but one thing for sure for me: it was definitely not “Hello, World”. I and others filled the screen with any number of silly things, random words, jokes and juvenile phrases, whatever, but for some reason, “Hello, World!” was a C thing, and I remember seeing it for the first time in a C class in high school, and then much more often in college.

I have memories of ‘poke’ as well. On the Atari 800 you could poke memory to change the keystroke repeat rate and delay before repeat started, so obviously we would turn down the delay to zero and turn up the repeat to max (it was maybe 60 characters per second), so anyone trying to type couldn’t hit the keys quickly enough to avoid repeating. You’d have to power-cycle the machine to fix it, so it was hilarious to 11 year old me.

Similar to his description of ‘poke’, but different mechanism - using debug.com on an IBM PC jr to edit the Ultimate III save files, and give myself maximum money and lives.

Good times!

dahart··on Font where each token is equal-width
Cute idea, but is this fixed width words, and not fixed width tokens? Isn’t an ‘ing’ ending normal a separate token from the root? Isn’t ‘strawberry’ two tokens?
dahart··on How I changed teaching after AI managed to do all my homework assignments
Why is that interesting? How often does that happen? Has it happened even once? Seems like fantasy; this has been possible for a long time, and despite it being possible, it almost never actually happens. Before AI, kids willing to orchestrate their own education could use the internet to become experts in anything. Before the internet kids could use libraries and books to become experts in anything. But how many take the time and effort to match a 4 year degree? Statistically, approximately zero.

One major problem: how do you get a job for which a degree is required, if you teach yourself via books/internet/AI? How do you get into graduate schools for which a degree is required? How do you envision advanced degrees working without funding or labs or mentors?

All of education is undergoing dramatic seismic shifts because of AI right now. Attempting to insult teachers for talking about it doesn’t reflect on teachers, it reflects on you.

dahart··on How I changed teaching after AI managed to do all my homework assignments
Who’s insisting that? Where does 25 come from? 4 year degree attainment is just under 40% in the U.S., and most of them finish by 22 or 23.

People are choosing to go to university. It might have something to do with having better job options and statistically higher pay…

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →