3,381 karma · joined June 24, 2010
Titanium was useful when we needed very high strength on a very large part - a good example is the trunnions that attach payloads to the space shuttle cargo bay. These are large metal bars a little over 3 inches in diameter and maybe a couple feet in length. Aluminum is not strong enough. Steel would be punishingly heavy. (do the math - these things are beasts). So titanium can be a good fit for stuff like that.
But most steel parts were small - things like bolts, rod ends an the like. They tend to be specialized with very specific detailed requirements for things like fatigue, frictional characteristics, and that sort of thing. Because they are small, the weight just isn't that big an issue. Bigger stuff was almost always aluminum, which is actually a lot stronger than most folks realize. At least, the good stuff is.
Titanium also has some other odd properties that make it troublesome in space. I wasn't a materials guy, but they were always bitching about "hydrogen embrittlement" and the fact that large titanium parts do not burn up on re-entry like aluminum does, which presents a debris hazard to people on the ground. (I don't know how big a problem that really is, but people didn't want to be dumping space junk on top of people's heads. Honestly, I just took this on faith - people were concerned about it, but it always struck me as odd.)
We did occasionally use titanium, but usually some sort of steel was a better choice when strength was the issue. It's just the way it works out. It's also worth noting that for the work I did, cost was never an issue (NASA) - material costs were basically insignificant. We could use whatever we wanted.
It doesn't sound like that was the arrangement, but it should have been.
Am I a business guy who learned to code? An engineer who learned business? I have degrees in both and have taken jobs in both fields. Or am I just someone who took an interest in these things and learned as much as I could about both of them?
I have an MBA and I write code. In my experience, coders overvalue their contributions and business guys overvalue theirs. But in the end, the business guys usually win. You have to think like a business guy.
When I do contract code, I'm under no illusion that I am a critical piece of the business. In fact, the only thing that has any sort of ability to lock me in is typically that switching costs are high- developers hard to find and it's expensive to get a new one up to speed.
That's just the way things are. If you're not an integral part of the business, you are replaceable.
To take it a step further, should entrepreneurs pay ordinary income tax on their gains when they sell their company if they didn't invest any of their own money? It's the same thing. Carried interest is just a fancy name for sweat equity.
What is the difference between that and carried interest? The only thing I can think of is that it's not taxed as ordinary income before being invested, which is a fair criticism. On the other hand, you don't get a tax benefit if you lose that money in the CI case (which happens a lot), so it balances out at least to a degree.
I think you can argue that capital gains shouldn't be taxed differently than income at all (not sure what I think of that, honestly), but if carried interest has to be in either the "income" bucket or the "gains" bucket, it looks more like gains to me.
Further, if you always pay your creditors first, there is no point in capitalizing with debt - you give up significant value by doing so. It is normal and healthy for some companies to finance themselves perpetually with debt.
Edit: Ok, so there are still some non-believers. Think of it this way. You own a profitable company with no debt. Your accountant tells you that you'll increase the company's value if you are 50% debt and 50% equity. This is a consequence of our tax code. Sounds like a good plan. Now what? The company already pays dividends and has as much cash as it needs for operations. You borrow money (which banks are happy to give you because you can more than afford the debt service), and pay out the proceeds as dividends. You are now have all that money in your pocket, and your company is basically worth the same amount (value = equity, which is now 1/2 what it was + debt) - a little more, actually, because of the tax consequences of the debt.
This is totally normal. Sometimes the optimal debt level is zero. Sometimes it's 90%. If companies are pulling huge amounts of cash out as a result of debt financing, it's only because they had a sub-optimal capitalization to begin with. Again - nothing nefarious here. It's all just a way of adjusting risk and optimizing returns to the shareholders.
Think of it as a portion of their salary that they are contractually bound to invest in the fund, with deference to the limited partners.
Do we really want to have fund managers without skin in their own funds? Carried interest is the only way to do that that does not favor the fantastically rich - who have enough advantages already. Ask yourself what might happen to the private fund industry (VC, PE, hedge funds, real estate, etc) if managers were not able to get carry. How would their compensation change? Which funds would benefit? Do we really want that?
http://www.amazon.com/The-Trillion-Dollar-Meltdown-Rollers/d...
Edit: also, this version, updated in early 2009:
http://www.amazon.com/The-Two-Trillion-Dollar-Meltdown/dp/15...