HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

danhor

1,136 karma · joined April 2, 2020

submissionscomments
danhor··on Nintendo is suing the creators of Switch emulator Yuzu
You need the decryption keys, and yuzu only gives you instructions on how to extract them from your own switch (and is careful to stress that point). But nothing stops you from searching for the keys on the web and getting them from there.
danhor··on All Aboard the Bureaucracy Train
One of the most egregious issues with the second avenue extension is that the underground portion is way larger than comparable systems. A large part of this is backoffic space (which should be overground and consolidated, like everywhere else), which no minority interest group is interest in. And you can see that: In the next Phase they have reduced the backoffice space (which no passenger will ever notice) due to cost pressures (saving over a billion, I think) and no one complained.The same is true for many other examples.

This is also noticable elsewhere. When looking at german planning, they reference other german projects and rarely projects of the sourrounding countries, and thus often don't notice the lessons learned there.

danhor··on The Brennan self-balancing monorail [video]
Ideal (in the sense of fully compensated) is worse, but ideal in the sense of at the right time, with smooth interior motion, is much better. A "perfect" tilting train shouldn't feel much different than superelevation to the same level, but it does.

One of the issues with the German tilting trains is that they try to compensate up to 8° without track knowledge (BR 612) thus the first carriage (the one after that less so) swinging abruptly to compensate when entering or exiting a curve. Not sure how the class 390s solve that problem.

danhor··on The Brennan self-balancing monorail [video]
> By “leaning in” to curves, you make the ride more comfortable, not less.

That is the intention, but many people report discomfort due to the non-ideal adjustments, at least for the tilting trains in germany.

danhor··on LineageOS is currently installed on 1.5M Android devices
I've found that many applications work without Play serices or simply complain but work. Whatsapp even offers an .apk for Download with a self Updater and everything else can be installed with "AuroraStore" (third party play store client).
danhor··on Plastic bag bans work
All of my of my on-the-go shopping without thinking about it beforehand have much smaller quantities than the one I specifically think about (especially because in Germany I usually take some bottles with me to deposit at the store), for that a smaller, foldable bag in my backpack has served me very well.
danhor··on Plastic bag bans work
> And of course, the complainer's personal use of polluting energy is always objectively correct and morally just.

Please tell me where it's possible to live in modern society right now without any use of polluting energy. Seems to me like https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/we-should-improve-society-som...

> immediately offsetting a product/service's carbon footprint.

What offsetting do you find acceptable? Most carbon offsets sold are complete bunk, thus costing very little. Stuff we can be sure about (like DAC) are well over 500€/ton right now, implemented now this would be sure to lead to riots, especially since it'll probably affect people with less income the most (relative to their income). A carbon price is a great mechanism, but one this high is (IMHO) unworkable and there needs to be accompanying measures to ensure that the carbon price isn't so low as to be ineffective, not strain citizens to much and not make local industry non-competitive.

If we only implemented it for non-strictly-necessary stuff (like meat, flights, big cars, cars outside rural areas, living and heating a larger dwelling over 18°, ), it would still be very unpopular (and probably lead to riots)

danhor··on I used to not worry about climate change. Now I do [video]
The carbon impact of PCs is negligible for almost all people, and possessions are only a smaller portion of emissions (with the exception of high embodied carbon things like electric cars).

Important things you can influence for a low carbon footprint are:

- How do you heat and how much? Gas heating is surprisingly bad in the US due to the high amount of methane leakage

- Do you drive a lot in a combustion car, or even worse, fly?

- What kind of food do you eat? As a rough guideline, dairy and meat is pretty bad and beef much worse. Also the stuff that has to be brought in by plane.

Living in nature often makes it harder to have a low carbon lifestyle and the things often associated with "good for nature" like reducing plastic waste and organic products are often worse carbon wise.

danhor··on GM to Shut Down Ultra Cruise
People are less fine with risk if it's less controllable by themselves. Every mode of transport where people don't directly control their fate is held to a much higher safety standard (and partially as a result) much safer. Aviation, Trains, Busses, ... .
danhor··on Wind turbines are friendlier to birds than oil-and-gas drilling
This is nothing that regulation can't solve. German regulations prohibit wind farms with such periodic shadowing if it occurs more than 30 minutes a day or 30 hours per year for a house.
danhor··on Wind turbines are friendlier to birds than oil-and-gas drilling
> That just my view of the aesthetics…

As wind turbines aren't a very rare sight, I think it's reasonable to assume that most have already seen a wind farm in person. Newer generations in Germany also only flash when planes are nearby.

> Nobody ever bothers to talk about what will be done with these football field sized blades (I’m guessing at least 100k of them by now?) when they’re decommissioned?

At least I've seen a lot of talk about it, most of it ending in "we're trying to reuse them for something else with mixed success" or "recycling is possible, but not yet done on a large scale, but we hope it'll increase".

> do you think any of the companies who signed these 30 year leases will be around to de-com the turbines when they start falling apart? (Answer is no)

At least in Germany, where wind turbines from 20+ years ago are being replaced by newer ones (due to the much higher power output), this hasn't been an issue yet. In contrast to oil and gas sites, after the wind turbine has seen it's EOL the land isn't worthless for the purpose, but a new wind turbine can be installed. Thus for most sites this isn't much of an issue. This isn't to say that regulation is a bad idea (and I'm wondering why leases were signed without a clause to obligate the operates to remove them), but I don't see the fundamental point of conflict, since the land isn't worthless afterwards for energy purposes.

> Then there’s the never ending problem of freezing…

At least your first two sources suggest that electric heating works (but unfortunately not if it's doable from the energy generated by the wind turbine itself, but I assume that to be the case, otherwise it doesn't make any sense), and the third suggests a fault of the power connection of the initial fault (and quite a bit of tabloid rambling that I didn't read, I have to admit).

danhor··on First new U.S. nuclear reactor since 2016 is now in operation
Pretty much all relevant ceuntries also pleged to triple renewable capacity in 8 years, which seems mostly doable, while with the typical (western) construction timelines for nuclear they would have to pretty much start tendering the new plants now, while currently mostly only vague promises exist.

China, which the country building the most nuclear right now, is falling behind its own plans and downscaling its nuclear ambitions in favour of renewables.

danhor··on Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, report finds
> whether it's more expensive than peaker gas plants.

While running only a small percentage of the time. Some only operate a few hundred hours a year, let's say 300 hours (around 3.4% of the time). These low operating hours are much more likely to happen as short term storage and renwables get expanded. French nuclear reactors run around 60% of the time and have very little variable costs. Thus new nuclear reactors would have to be only 5% of the cost of gas peakers when run most of the time, as would be economically reasonable, to beat gas peakers.

danhor··on US nuclear-fusion lab enters new era: achieving 'ignition' over and over
> We are probably AT LEAST 50 years away from a near 100% non-nuclear "renewable" world.

For electricity (which is the only energy category where nuclear makes sense) I see no reason to be this pessimistic (of course, depending on your definition of near 100%, but let's say 95%). Solar and Wind have strong growth prospects and are very economical, with reason to believe in further price reductions (especially for solar). As we've seen at COP, a lot of countries are planning to strongly build out renewables (a simple tripling, disregarding a lot of factors, leading to 45% share of renewables by 2030) and only a few are planning a much slower expansion of nuclear.

Storage shows a lot of promise and very successful initial deployments for short duration storage and I see no reason to be more (or even as) optimistic about future development of nuclear & fusion reactors than chemical energy storage.

> It's almost as if all the people working on these projects and funding them aren't complete morons, and the world quite so reductive, like half of hacker news seems to smugly dismiss EVERY time any fusion article is posted.

Or there's a reason why this is mostly funded by governments as a foundational work, presumably with hopes that fusion will be largely viable in the long term. If governments funding this work were hopeful that fusion would be economically viable within 15 years, you'd expect very large funding increases (especially from the private sector) and a reduction in investment for transforming the electricity grid away from big central power producers to more geographically diverse renewable supply.

danhor··on Cortex A57, Nintendo Switch's CPU
At least regarding the homebrew, I disagree completely. While it took a while for the vita to be thoroughly hacked, it has been thoroughly hacked. And the benefits are numerous: Using normal SD cards, expanding the the integrated psp hardware into a virtual psp, reformatting of the internal storage, extending it by replacing the 3G modem.

Meanwhile the switch had the big bootrom usb stack exploit, but everything apart from the original SoC doesn't have a publicly known easy exploit (there are mod chips, but nothing like the 3DS/PS3/Wii U/Vita/PSP/...). There also wasn't that as much "cool" stuff to do as on older consoles with homebrew due to the hardware simply being an android tablet with controllers (which doesn't make a difference as a console, but makes it more boring homebrew wise). So there is the usual stuff (savegames, different controllers, piracy, themes, overclocking), but nothing unique to the switch.

danhor··on A Matter of Millimeters: The story of Qantas flight 32
I wouldn't say it's simply cost-benefit analysis. It's also scale of accidents.

A whole lot more people die from car accidents, yet there are few reports on national news on accidents. So fewer people care. Meanwhile each time there is an aviation disaster, 100s of people die and it's all over the news for weeks. Similarly with train accidents and nuclear accidents. There where only 2 very large ones but they still haunt the field to this day, while (for example) the deaths from solar installations by people falling from roofs are mostly ignored.

Large accidents have to be avoided, a lot of small ones are more acceptable.

danhor··on Dieselgate, but for trains – some heavyweight hardware hacking
I'm not sure if you've ever used modern software. It's sometimes amazing just how unreliable it is. Web browsers crash every few weeks, windows is known for regularly needing a reboot, evince regularly crashes on me, you can't call 911 with some of cell phones, ... . This reminds me of https://danluu.com/everything-is-broken/ .

The clearest example of the difference of reliability is looking at public digital signage (on transit and elsewhere). If it's based on LED segments or something similarly basic (with old-school embedded software development) it will basically always work. New LCD Screens inside trains/busses and outside working with a modern software setup (using an OS, often with a pc architecture, quite often just displaying a website) are broken ~10%-20% of the time. Looking at (for example) busses, a large portion of the time the screen will either be blank, not display anything, old information or just wrong information. Going inside fast food restaurants with large LCDs for the menu, often something is broken, frozen or something else.

It is of course possible to make modern software more reliable. It's just much, much harder than making embedded software or PLC programming reliable. Software can be easily made more complex, but it's hard to make it non-complex or to wrap the complexity so it isn't an issue anymore. The ecosystem isn't set up for non-complexity.

danhor··on Dieselgate, but for trains – some heavyweight hardware hacking
That is also my impression as well. The softwareization of trains has led to deep regressions in both basic reliability and interoperability/flexilibity. Many modern trains suffer from software issues for basic driving [0] and delays when getting the software approved [1]. But the loss of compatability is in my opinion the worst regression. Modern EMUs basically only work together with other EMUs of the same batch. Even the same model ordered by two different companies often don't work together and basically forget about trying to use EMUs of different companies or ordered over a decade apart together. Meanwhile pre-digital everything it was common to use e.g. trams of different generations together and rewire them to work with each other. Older train cars work together without issues, good luck trying to use an IC2 and a Railjet together (or a RailJet and ICE-L). Even certain locomotives and train cars would often only work with each other.

It is way harder for different computerized systems to work together due to the higher complexity and more obfuscation (a traditional logic circuitboard is often easily reverse engineered. Reverse engineering software is a very specialized task). This is also very noticeable in other sectors, where interoperability has become much worse due to moving to proprietary digital protocols.

This is in part due to the difficulty in getting software approved as compared to previous tech (due to software being so intransparent) but also because of truly lacking quality. One of the reasons Bombardier was so deep in trouble was bad software, even leading to a contract of over 40 ordered trains just being cancelled ([2]).

In my opinion building reliable (and understandable) software is way harder than building logic or even mechanical systems. I don't know what the solution is, but it's been a problem for a long time.

[0]: https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/de/2013/02/12/belgische_bahn_storn... [1]: https://www.augsburger-allgemeine.de/augsburg/Neue-Zuege-auf... [2]: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardier_Talent_3#%C3%96BB

danhor··on The new Paris métro
Those benefits have eroded a bit over time. Rail vehicles have become pretty good at acceleration and deceleration, with acceleration often being limited due to passenger comfort. Similarly high(er) grades of 8%-10% are now quite possible with high-performing vehicles.
danhor··on My First PCB (2019)
I think most people the US and europe have switched over to chinese manufacturers like jlcpcb or similar for small batch-size PCBs, since they're cheaper and more user friendly. I would've expected them to ship to most of the world, is that not the case?
danhor··on Sweden plans new nuclear reactors by 2035, will share costs
Interestingly enough the source for the first graph in the article shows the opposite: https://www.eia.gov/international/data/world/electricity/ele...

Even more staggering is that from 2020 to 2021 solar+wind grew by ~15%.

danhor··on Montreal’s new rapid transit line saved millions per mile
NYC subways were all built by the city, but most were not operated by them. There are privately built subways around the world (especially in Japan), but globally it's a rarity. This isn't a surprise, considering that subways are long term investment (and nobody can get money cheaper than a government), should be built with a long term plan to increase network usefulness (and thus the usage of each individual line) without competition between individual lines [1] and, especially if built outside already dense inner cities, should be accompanied by densification along the line to justify the investment (look at china or the danish finger plan for some examples). The operations can be private (they don't have to be, there's no clear "best way"), but the planning, financing and building should at the very least be heavily overseen by the government.

Outside of already very dense cities which heavily discourage using a car (think large asian cities, not montreal), you won't see newly built underground lines built privately. People aren't as captive today and even in the 1900s londons subways weren't very sound financially as companies.

[1]: Transit systems benefit strongly from integration between lines and modes, as well as making interchanges as painless as possible. This is mostly antithetical to multiple companies building lines inside a single city, which often ends up with little fare-integration and annoying interchanges. This can also happen with government built lines, but is less likely.

danhor··on Starlink plans to launch texting service in 2024, voice/data in 2025
At least in germany this isn't the case. The cell coverage on trains is almost a meme by now (even though it's overstated) and and small communities/other attractions in very rural areas (rural for germany, a highway is still usually <50km away) often have very marginal to no cell coverage.
danhor··on USB Power Delivery for Hobby Projects
At least the Wii U can just be powered using a 15V PD trigger. The maximum current requirement of 5A isn't met, but works just fine. Since the Wii needs 12V I would add a DC-DC converter but I don't see any reason why it shouldn't work.
danhor··on Raspberry Pi 5: available now
VQFN is quite possible using a soldering iron (the difficulty is the soldering pad underneath, but that isn't necessary and doable with suitable PCB design) . IMHO QFN is much easier to solder (and rework) than LQFN because bridges between two pads are easier to get away than bridges between the pins of QFP.

Pretty much no MCU in the same price range contains a DAC and most comparable MCUs don't have integrated OpAmps. The external flash has it's disadvantages, but it's also much cheaper to have huge amounts of flash. Typical 1$ MCUs can't include external flash in their address range, so it also can't be added in a similar way.

The RP2040 isn't suitable for a lot of floating point tasks, but floating point tasks on MCUs are not that common. FPGAs are often used as DSP-monsters and floating point isn't very nice on them.

If you need fast processing, with real multitasking, flexible (digital) pheriperals (PIOs can also simulate timers and up to ~22 total timers are nothing to scoff at), some nice fixed point DSP stuff (hardware divider, interpolators), gobs of (external) flash & RAM and great software support the rp2040 is pretty much the way to go as a default micro-controller.

For ~1$ it's a pretty compelling offer which is hard to beat with non-chinese chips.

danhor··on Austria rail operator OeBB unveils new night trains
The specialized stops are an issue (and have gotten very rare), but the speed limit from the car train is an issue but especially the highly cyclical nature of the demand for car transport on night trains, much more so than normal sleeper trains. Most of the rolling stock used for transporting cars is very old and not getting replaced (because you can't recoup the cost), while there have been quite a few orders for new sleeper trains.
danhor··on AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B
USB 3 the protocol isn't backwards compatible with USB 2, USB 3 ports just include both USB 2 and USB 3 pins (what one might call dual stack). You can easily connect two differnt devices one to the USB 2 pins and one to the USB 3 pins. If you only want to connect USB 3 devices, there is no need for USB 2 Pins, as done on the PS4.

There is also no specified way to convert USB 3 to USB 2, but some have tried, with mixed results.

danhor··on The Sound Proof Booths of Silence
High-end equipment certainly increased sharply in price in the last few years, but few people gaming on PC spend anywhere near that amount of money. If you just went to play most games on a reasonable framerate (30fps) a Steam Deck for 400$ is perfectly fine.

For those with high-resolution screens and 144fps the equipment is not affordable to most but not necessary.

But an already existing phone is cheaper for sure

danhor··on Apple iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max
While Steam itself certainly has DRM infrastructure, it's not required and easily bypassed. Valve allows other 3rd-party DRM solutions, but I'd argue that the built-in DRM is one of the less important aspects of steam.
danhor··on Apple iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max
AAA-like titles were previously tried at the beginning of the App Store, mostly ports of older titles. Most Indie Games would also run fine on most Smartphones, but never succeeded. Stuff that sold great on the Switch. I think the lack of "official" nice, high-quality, hasslefree Gamepad, continuing cooling-issues and especially the expectation of consumers for low prices on Apps results in the Market for "real" games on Phones remaining very small.

Apple tried to counteract it with Apple Arcade, but that hasn't worked out.

← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →