13,030 karma · joined December 29, 2013
Work | https://www.nucleics.com
Play | https://www.tillett.info
There is also great value to be gained just from building the model as you are forced to estimate the various factors that will drive the business. Whenever I have gone through this exercise I have picked up at least one important assumption that I had missed.
Even if the IFR turned out to be 0.5% in the end (I hope it is) this is still a lot of dead people.
2. Coronavirus are rather unusual for pathogens in that our immunity to them fades very quickly (less than a year on average) and you can get reinfected again. The question is if SARS-CoV-2 the same. We only have limited data so far, but if you have a look at figure 3 of this pre-print paper [0] you will see the antibody response has faded significantly 60 days post infection.
3. I think it was pretty dramatic in Wuhan, Northern Italy and NYC, but I guess this is one of personal opinion. What is certain is if the number of cases had doubled the system there would have broken down completely.
4. We seem to be in agreement.
5. The reports coming out of Sweden suggest that the economic damage there is just as bad as those countries that went into an official lockdown [1,2]. All Sweden seems to have accomplished is the killing of a large number of elderly Swedes.
Most people are not idiots and they won’t put themselves at risk of getting COVID-19 if they have a choice, but there are enough idiots that won’t self isolate to cause problems. If the economic difference of going into lockdown is the same as not, then why not help idiots not be idiots.
0. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.15.20066407v...
1. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/30/coronavirus-sweden-economy-t...
2. https://www.thelocal.se/20200428/swedens-central-bank-leaves...
1. The true IFR is hard to estimate at this point, but looks to be around 1%. This is a very difficult question to answer with the data we have and all the limitations.
2. There is little evidence that we can reach herd immunity levels of infection with a Coronavirus like SARS-CoV-2 as both the unconstrained R0 is too high and the immunity too short lived.
3. The IFR has a threshold where it dramatically increases when the number of new cases overwhelms the hospital capacity. We have seen this to a certain extend in Wuhan, Northern Italy and NYC.
4. As treatments improves the IFR should fall. This mean if we can shift an infection to the future we should see less people die. Flattening the curve is more than just avoiding overwhelming the hospital system, it is also about shift cases to a time when we have improved treatments.
5. Sweden has shown that it doesn’t matter if you have an official lockdowns or not, most people will self isolate on their own. There is little extra economic damage from imposing official lockdown policies since all the damage is done by people avoiding infection on their own.
The harmless strain doesn’t have to spread naturally better than the dangerous strains and it is likely any harmless strain would not spread better. We can artificially spread the harmless strain around so even if it is less contagious than the dangerous strain we tip the ecological balance in favour of harmless strain. This is really how an attenuated vaccine like the Sabin polio vaccine works from an ecological perspective.
The risk of the virus mutating is there right now. It is much less likely that a harmless strain becomes very dangerous than a dangerous strain become very dangerous. This would be a bigger jump in evolutionary space.
Ultimately as the immediate downvoting of my OP suggests this idea doesn’t appear popular. This doesn’t mean that it is not a scientifically valid approach that could work.
There is a possible ecological solution - we drive the dangerous strains to extinction by deliberately spreading a harmless strain. Unfortunately few people seem interested in investigating this idea.
With the economic cost to the USA alone running at $500 billion a month are we really constrained by resources?
I have spoken to many scientists and clinicians about this. There is a great deal of activity going on to put this into action.
Nobody who knows anything about Coronavirus vaccines thinks it will be easy, but just because something is hard should not be a reason for not trying, especially when the reward for success is huge. All I can say is I am glad Salk and all the other Polio vaccine researchers didn’t just give up without trying because it was difficult.
Sure you can develop a putative attenuated strain in the lab, but how are you going to collect human data on it quickly? The spread of a natural attenuated strain gives us something that no lab-generated strain can - human data right now.
Just a small correction on the 69 deletion strains - they are all in gene coding reasons, but they are both frameshift and non-frameshift mutants.
How could it possible be harmful to check the clinical history of the patient that was infected with these deletion strains?
The bigger point I was making is that there are many deletion mutants out there. We should be looking for more and checking if they are attenuated or not. We might be very unlucky and find there are none, but that seems rather defeatist given we haven’t even tried.