HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dankoss

202 karma · joined February 28, 2013

dankoss.com - engineer, musician, athlete.
submissionscomments
dankoss··on The Ghost in the MP3
The information present here isn't really "lost" as much as it can't be heard in the context of the other sounds in the original recording. These forms of audio compression take advantage of auditory masking[1] which means those sounds likely wouldn't be heard in the original.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auditory_masking

dankoss··on You gotta be rich to own a cheap car
This was me a few years ago. While I could have bought used, the premium for a known history of the car was worth it since I knew I would keep it for 10+ years. You pay more to reduce some risk over the lifetime of the car.
dankoss··on Luna – Hack your sleep
Any chance you could integrate it with a Hue or similar to do a light-based alarm, given it has wifi?
dankoss··on Soylent’s Next Chapter
Maybe they can use some of their millions to ship orders faster than, I don't know, 3-6 months? Get it in the Amazon supply chain and have next day delivery. I'm still waiting on a reorder from a month ago and haven't heard anything since I emailed customer support.
dankoss··on Why Do All Records Sound the Same?
The irony is that digital audio has much more dynamic range than vinyl, and yet modern productions use much less of it in order to psychologically sound better / louder.
dankoss··on Why Do All Records Sound the Same?
Nitpicks: "A great deal of quality is lost as those huge files are squished to the CD format, before being further squished into MP3s on your iPod." Not true, AAC files at high bitrates are proven to be indistinguishable from the original. http://xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html

"Every part of the signal chain—from earbuds to digital/audio converters—is improving and getting cheaper." Like other technologies, digital audio had rapid improvements in the first 10 years but has mostly leveled off as we have reached the limits of physics, signals and sampling. Good audio equipment is still expensive and power hungry in every part of the chain.

Technology won't save what are fundamentally psychological issues. We respond emotionally to louder signals. We like songs that sound similar but not identical to things we've heard before. We listen to things that our friends like. All of this points to why top 40 songs sound the same, but "all records" is pretty broad. There has never been a better time to create something new in music, and yet we lean heavily on what has worked before -- in songwriting, in arrangement, in production -- so that others will like and identify with the creative output.

dankoss··on Why I Quit OS X – Geoff Wozniak
I'm seeing this same exact issue on my MBPr13. Occasionally I'll wake the laptop and it will show gray garbage on the screen, so I'm suspecting some kind of video issue / interaction with scrolling in Safari. It really got bad with the 10.10.2 beta, so I'm hoping they fix it with a point release.
dankoss··on Poll: Do you use an ad-blocker?
I use OpenDNS from my router to block ad domains on all my devices, as well as Adblock. You have to add some custom domains to hit the major sources, but it works reasonably well when you're at home.
dankoss··on iOS 8 reviewed
I use OpenDNS from my router to block ads on all my devices. You have to add some custom domains to hit the major sources, but it works reasonably well when you're at home.
dankoss··on Motorola Moto 360 Teardown
Yes, Anandtech covered it here: http://www.anandtech.com/show/7235/moto-x-review/4

Running the 55x for voice detection/recognition consumes far less power than an OMAP core, since it has to be running all the time.

dankoss··on Amazon Local Register
Fidelity Amex offers 2% on everything with no limit.
dankoss··on Cheap FPGA Development Boards: What to look for
In my experience FPGAs are broadly used as "glue" chips to interface between microcontrollers, DSPs, codecs, and other hardware elements (encoders, LEDs, etc). Technically these are called CPLDs but depending on how much work they do, they may use a larger family with more logic cells and memory.

Basically if you need to interface with any digital hardware that isn't natively supported by your microcontroller/CPU/DSP, you'll probably want an FPGA to do it unless you have enough resources to write a bit-banged interface in the micro.

dankoss··on Homemade Speakers
I'd suggest that the reason mini speakers are popular has to do with aesthetics since they are often paired with a television in a multipurpose room. And with the advent of 5.1, having five full range speakers, wiring, and a subwoofer in a small living room doesn't pass the aesthetic test.

Bose and other manufacturers have done a good job of developing tricks that fool undiscerning listeners into thinking their system matches the performance of a full range system. But there's no tricking out the physics of low frequencies. Baffles and complex tube resonators can have limited positive effects but they often cause problems in other areas.

That said, unless all you care about is sound quality, the aesthetics and performance of a Bose system can in many cases be very attractive.

dankoss··on Homemade Speakers
All sound waves are directional, but the point made by acousticians is that in any enclosed space with dimensions smaller than the wavelength in question (56 feet for 20Hz), low frequencies are effectively non-directional because they fill the entire space (with nulls at various points). The wavelength of high frequencies means you can orient their direction in the room.

Of course you won't hear this outdoors because the sounds are not in an enclosed space.

dankoss··on Ask HN: Local vs. remote salary gap
I'd suggest the reason people don't want to talk about how much they make is that it's a reflection of their self worth, and there's always someone who can anonymously claim to make more.
dankoss··on Ask HN: What do you listen to while coding (and how)?
I listen to a variety of stuff on Spotify now but when I listened to EDM more exclusively I would hit the di.fm online radio stations.
dankoss··on A Nice Cup of Tea by George Orwell (1946)
You can get strong, flavorful tea, just not in bags. If you steep your own loose leaf tea, you can make it as strong as coffee with nearly as much caffeine. Unfortunately loose leaf is more expensive.

And I agree, both coffee and tea are better without additives.

dankoss··on HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music
It's certainly easier to DIY these days for some things -- electronic music comes to mind, but there's no replacement for a properly treated studio with all the appropriate equipment on hand. You get what you pay for.

> many artists do not actually need professional mastering

Almost everything sold commercially has been mastered, the only stuff I have heard unmastered is on Soundcloud/Youtube for a reason. Having a skilled third party polish a track is essential.

> why not make your music free

Why is this acceptable for a musician but not for a film director, actor, programmer, or any other career professional? Should all films now be made DIY with volunteer actors and we'll just have hobbyist special effects and post added? What are these hobbyists supposed to do to pay rent and eat?

Music is an expensive business, and digital downloading hasn't changed that. That's why it's frustrating to hear people feel entitled to free music, even if there's not much we can do to change it.

dankoss··on HipHop: A "Popcorn Time" for music
As someone looking to do this myself I can tell you. Any good studio these days charges at least $100/hour for time recording. Even if you walk in ready to go, it can take 4 or more hours to record one song. More if there are complicated production tasks like auditioning different guitar amps or vocal mics.

At some studios, their price includes an engineer, but often a good engineer charges extra. Once the song is recorded, a separate mixing engineer will take the raw tracks and make a finished mix. Then a mastering engineer will polish them further for different markets including radio or AAC. And if you need or want a producer, arranger, cowriter, or session player, you have to pay them for their time. All the while you need to eat and pay rent as an artist or band.

$10k is an average budget for a short album, and consider to break even an artist must sell 13,000 songs if independent through iTunes, more if they split revenue with a label. How many artists have less than 13,000 fans? This is why many record deals today include touring revenue as part of the contract, because they know they can't sell enough downloads to recoup the cost.

dankoss··on Why Your Cell-Phone Bill Should Be Going Down But Isn't
I'm not talking about data use, I'm talking about instantaneous data rate. Base stations are designed to handle a particular maximum throughput for a given number of users relative to the available spectrum in that area. The maximum throughput needed for many users on a 4G tower will be much higher than it is for 3G, it isn't the same or less.
dankoss··on Why Your Cell-Phone Bill Should Be Going Down But Isn't
This article is seriously flawed. Yes, 4G transmission is more efficient for the allotted wireless spectrum, but users are guaranteed to be using more bandwidth, so the effective number of users per tower stays the same or decreases. And it costs more, not less for 4G rollouts.
dankoss··on Headphones and Earphones Benchmarking Test Files
They most likely have the Cirrus CS4207, which is quite good.

http://www.cirrus.com/en/products/cs4207.html

http://ifixit.org/blog/5515/macbook-pro-retina-15-teardown/

dankoss··on Do Men Suck At Friendship?
I agree with this but, my problem is that most people have only one or two major interests so friendship is completely one-dimensional based around a single activity. So when conversation drifts off the common topic or activity, there isn't much to do or talk about. People interested in sports may not also be interested in video games, etc.
dankoss··on The Invention of the AeroPress
I hadn't noticed the scratches affecting the taste on my unit (now 3 years old). But it could also just be the coffee flavor leeching into the plastic over time.

I find that with drip coffee, it's much harder to tell the difference between bean varieties and burr ground vs conical. The AP brings out the flavor as intensely as you can stand.

dankoss··on Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself.
Not sure what point you're trying to make here, but I was responding to your post implying that 192kHz sampling rate improves transient response. It doesn't improve it at all. While there is sampling "distortion" by way of quantization error, this error is inaudible because we're sampling at 24 bits, beyond the dynamic range of human hearing. High sample rates actually REDUCE audio quality because they sample ultrasonics that will interact within the audible range and potentially damage speakers or pick up EMI interference.

It has been proven over and over via ABX testing that high res formats are completely indistinguishable from a 24b/44.1kHz master. And further studies have proven most audio engineers can't distinguish between lossless audio and 320kbps MP3. That's what the Xiph link elsewhere in the thread shows.

dankoss··on Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself.
I tried to find the context for that image but there wasn't anything on the site. The image is most certainly incorrect -- or more likely, looking at the output of the analog electronics after the DAC.

Sampling theory says that a perfect square wave can be represented at any frequency below Nyquist. That doesn't mean that the codec or the analog electronics are capable of responding instantly at those frequencies, but that has nothing to do with the fact that a 1kHz square wave can be perfectly sampled with a 44.1kHz sample rate. The image is simply incorrect.

Transient response in the real world is generally limited only by the acoustic transducer response of the system, because everything else has the ability to respond much faster than audio rates. With Pono, this means that the earbuds or headphones you use with the player will have a greater affect on the transient response than the electronics inside.

dankoss··on Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself.
> nobody here is both qualified and willing at the same time to tell you what you need to know about this topic.

Maybe people who work in professional (not consumer) audio? Who design these systems for a living?

dankoss··on Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself.
Hearing damage as a result of loudness; the electronics have little to do with it. If you set up a 96dB (16 bit) system such that you can hear the lowest bit toggling, your maximum volume will be 96dB above that. 96dB SPL is loud but not painful for average listening.

If you set up a 20 bit system (120dB) so that you can hear the lowest bit toggling, 120dB above that will most certainly cause hearing damage if used for very long.

144 dB (24 bit) or more SPL will cause near instantaneous damage and pain.

dankoss··on Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself.
The methodology might be flawed, but the point stands: We can't use the full dynamic range of a 24 bit signal for audio. Great converters have 20-21 bits of range and if we fully use this range, hearing damage will start at maximum volume levels. If the volume is kept the same between the two files, there is a 48dB drop in level - not inaudible, but there are very few source materials that will actually use the extra dynamic range. On top of that due to fletcher munson curves we will only hear content in the 1-4kHz range at that low volume level.
dankoss··on Skype TX
Interesting, this looks like it is intended to replace ISDN lines between studios for high quality calls.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →