492 karma · joined March 16, 2018
I do think that's like the most extreme difference you could find in any given day.
Caracas is reportedly green-ner than Medellin, but obviously under a dictatorship thus mostly not available to digital nomads.
You also have Buenos Aires, designed from the beginning to be green (only in certain places I think? but still very green in those places)...
The good thing about hill cities such as Medellin (sadly not a format available for big cities say in Europe or the US) is that you can choose your altitude, and at around 2000 thousand meters (the city starts at ~1500m) the air quality is not so bad, used to be worse years ago (maybe you lived there 2 or 3 years ago), but now it's much better.
> You can talk with any locals and they say that the climate is noticeably different than it was in the past.
Yeah, the city is much warmer compared to say 10 years ago, whether this is due to the city growing into previously-forest areas or /global/ warming I don't know... but yeah, locals agree it was MUCH colder 10 years ago...
> Medellin is surrounded by mountains and the contaminated air cannot escape.
See comments above about living at 2000m altitude (up in the mountains a bit away from the high-rise buildings and such, think of Beverly Hills or something like that.).
> The hills are steep and old busses spew black smoke.
As of now, there's almost no remaining old busses spewing black smoke anymore, but there's some cargo trucks still doing it.
> Saying Medellin's temp decreased by 2 degrees Celsius based on "Mejorar el microclima hasta 2°C" is a misinterpretation. I think this article is quite misleading.
I wouldn't know, but locals do say that it was a much more colder city in the past...
...or maybe just fewer cars because of global recession...
But the prices of "nationally-distributed" "things" (e.g. laundry detergent right?) pretty much adheres to the national trend...
...however rent in Medellín has gone up in these past 2 years too, like in some places it has gone up to double, gotta account for inflation (in USD terms you know) too but still...
Truly they don't, but even inside Medellin the precipitation rates are not as great as the lands around...
...because of the deforestation that /already/ happened, say, 50 years ago...
Ain't no commercial high rise neighborhood (semi-common in Medellin) that can "pull in" as much precipitation as a virgin forest no way, and you can see this if you visit there and then you visit an actual virgin rain-forest...
...but of course, this is what they are trying to alleviate and if the outskirts of the city are super-green it can help...
Btw all of the outskirts aren't super green but a lot of them are...
Whether you think that's "good" or "bad" it is what happens...
Now, if you think that's "bad" then you should ask your government to ban AirBNB /ON TOP/ of rent controls else the whole thing just doesn't make sense...
...I'm not being pro-AirBNB or anti-AirBNB but I'm pro-logic and pro-democracy (whatever 51% want in a given city is what the government should follow...)...
A lot of people would argue about "local, small-time landlords"'s capacity to expand you know...
As I said in other threads, maybe limit capacity to N-properties for each Canadian citizen, maybe 5 I don't know.
If you're a Canadian citizen you would have to go through one, even if just a lawyer that lawyer could only "sponsor" up to N non-Canadians to buy properties in Canada (or N properties for just 1 non-Canadian, whatever that lawyer or notary prefers...).
So N houses can only be owned or sponsored by only 1 "SSN" holder...
So even if you have for example 20 Chinese foreigners, they would have to be sponsored by at least N "SSN Holders".
If a "SSN Holder" buys up an 'unnatural' amount of land/houses, look into it... then maybe check who is he sponsoring (other Canadians or just 20 Chinese buyers?) and then decide from there. By "Chinese" I mean "Chinese without the equivalent of Canada's SSN" btw, no exclusion obviously should be performed against "Chinese"-descendant Canadian citizens.
For any readers... this system is already implemented in the USA for bank accounts, and it works, so it could realistically be implemented in Canada but for property... even easier still I think...
Also please don't share if you think it will be burn out by tourists... (any reader please read my other 10 comments on this thread I'm not intrinsically anti-tourist).
...and mostly siding with the "common" people but actually proposing sustainable (economically, not talking ecologically in here at all) solutions...
...but your comment just made me think of...
...what if the government focuses on making housing cheaper...
...repeal all or most zoning laws etc...
...that's one solution, with its dis-advantages of courses but...
...if that's what people want...
...if that's what Canadiants want...
...subject it to maybe one national vote or not...
...if people decide "ok let's do away with zoning laws" then that's their prerogative right...?
Require "ultimate beneficiary" disclosure (easy for the government to do), require this ultimate beneficiary to have the equivalent of a SSN.
Or, for foreigners (if you still want to allow that...), have a "vouching" system where 1 Canada national (holder of whatever the SSN equivalent is) to sponsor up to N non-Canadians, cap N.
The sponsor can be a Canadian lawyer or notary signing on behalf of "Chinese person #18940" but they would still be capped at N.
Not sure if this works or not, but there's also a distinctive refusal of average Joe go live in the country you know, so that also drives up the demand for real state near cities as opposed to the vast available land area Canada (or the US) occupies.
All of this could be applied in the US as well, they already do it with bank accounts for what it's worth, look it up...
Are the tourists really opting for the AirBNBs over hotels though?
I think it's mostly digital nomads (whatever you like to think of them they're different from just "normal tourists") occupying AirBNBs...? (With like monthly rentals and such)
Thing is people want to have friends and SOs over you know... which is not possible in "traditional" hotels...
Legit concern and I've seen it happen...
I mean, the "digital nomad" market is pretty big and sure it will include a lot of "whales", thus "beating out" the local market...
Not sure how that includes Montreal but for example it might not include Geneva for example I think...? _thinking_emoji_
...you can receive visits and treat that place as your "own"...
That's a really big advantage for digital nomads...
...they can receive friends they made at this new city, or sex workers... (regardless of how you feel about that it's a reality)...
But 1-week tourists are still probably staying at hostels or hotels...
So maybe allow visits at hotels and then you kill off a lot of the AirBNB market...?
Sad thing (for the people against tourism, which might be the majority in certain places...)is that those don't vote... (1 person 1 vote) but they do lobby/bribes...
Again, I'm just saying listen to what the majority want... you know... good old school democracy...
You cannot know whether this is true for all tourist/nomad hotspots (by being a hotspot they're actually suffering), e.g. Portugal/Colombia/Vietnam.
However... I still support whatever the people in those cities decide... so if they decide "no tourism" then they should be heard...
Exactly! It contributes to rising rent costs...
Now, FWIW, I prefer the adapt-or-die mentality, so I'm not anti-tourism, but if a majority of people in a certain place decide "no tourism", then hey more power to the people, they should decide whether they will accept tourism or not, not the tax-dollar-receivers...
Like tourists bring in "bad" consumer practices, such as buying stuff/food at "tourist traps" thus actually driving up prices, instead of them going to whenever the "locals" are used to go and still contribute to the local economy.
Best example I can think of paying overpriced shitty food at some tourist trap restaurant because you don't know better because you're a tourist, meanwhile locals go to their "known" places that aren't anything remotely similar to a "trap" you know?
Spirit of the law vs word of the law and all, you know... jeez