HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dansalvato

576 karma · joined May 16, 2022

Creator of Doki Doki Literature Club, FrankerFaceZ, and more. Amiga and retro PC enthusiast.

Personal site/blog: https://dansalva.to

submissionscomments
dansalvato··on Coding the anime "woosh" screen on Amiga
I was born in 1991, and we had an Amiga 1000 before eventually upgrading to a PC running Windows 95. So, I was always nostalgic for Amiga, but my passion grew once I began to understand more about the unique and powerful chips driving its capabilities.

Today, I work full-time as an independent game developer. I think it's fair to say that making an Amiga game has been a lifelong dream of mine, and I finally have the skills to make it happen. I want to help demonstrate that with today's tools and proliferation of knowledge, we can breathe new life into our beloved classic hardware by creating gaming experiences with modern design principles.

dansalvato··on Coding the anime "woosh" screen on Amiga
Amiga has its strengths, but I find that the SNES outperforms it in video games, because the SNES graphics chips were designed for video games first and foremost.

One major reason is sprites: Amiga can display 8 4-color sprites, or 4 16-color sprites, and the colors are shared with the bitplanes.

SNES can display 128 16-color sprites, and the sprites get 8 palettes all to themselves.

This leads to much more colorful-looking visuals on SNES. Since Amiga is all bitplanes, enabling more colors and higher resolution results in a massive performance hit. Most game entities would need to be blit on top of the background, and then the background "restored" every frame that entity moves. SNES' native support for multiple tile layers and good sprites means that the CPU can do a lot less work to achieve a lot more.

Amiga can do some very cool stuff that SNES can't, especially with the blitter, but SNES is much more practical and powerful for video games.

dansalvato··on AMD Zen 5 CPUs Reportedly Made on TSMC's 3nm Process, Mass Production in Q3
I often see sentiment that x86 architecture itself is fundamentally a bottleneck, compared to ARM/RISC, when it comes to efficiency and performance per watt. Does someone with the right expertise have insight to share on this? I'm curious what the factors are here. I would imagine that a factor is that most ARM implementations we see (like from Qualcomm, Nvidia, and Apple) are full-on SoCs which will naturally have efficiency benefits. But I'd love to learn more about this before "taking sides" and declaring that so-and-so architecture is the future, or whatever.
dansalvato··on Amiga Emulator: WinUAE 5.2.0
Thanks for your insight, you are more knowledgable on this than I am. I guess it speaks for itself that I don't tend to see the Amiga community strictly taking sides, and most are just tired of seeing this happen at all.
dansalvato··on Amiga Emulator: WinUAE 5.2.0
> At that point, Cloanto started worrying that people would buy Hyperion's AmigaOS 3.2 to boot emulators and they'd lose their market for selling legal 3.1 ROMs wrapped in Amiga Forever

This sort of glosses over the main point, which is that Amiga Inc., later Cloanto, repeatedly took Hyperion to court in an attempt to stop them from developing and selling updated Amiga software (and I believe hardware too, in some cases). I think this has been happening in some form or another for 20 years.

We live in a world where Apple—Apple!—released the source code for Apple Lisa OS, yet Amiga Kickstart ROMs are closed-source and cost money to download.

I'm sure Cloanto has done good work, but in any other retro community, this stuff would be open-source community projects.

Likewise, Hyperion could probably open-source AmigaOS 3.2, etc. without putting a dent in their revenue if they chose the correct open-source license. I don't know if they would, but the fact is that they can't even try, because they only have the right to release AmigaOS updates (which they also had to fight in court for years), and not to distribute source code.

I haven't been around for as long as many Amiga enthusiasts, so let me know if I got any details wrong here.

edit: See Gorilla1000kg's replies for some good information as well. I've met Mike, and he seems like a good guy and truly cares about Amiga. I don't know much about Hyperion, but they clearly do amazing work on AmigaOS. It just sucks that these beloved classic platforms are so intertwined with business interests.

For what it's worth, I haven't really seen any infighting about this in the Amiga community. We get excited when we hear about new releases. When there is news about some lawsuit over Amiga assets, the sentiment is just "We're tired of this bullshit".

dansalvato··on Amiga Emulator: WinUAE 5.2.0
WinUAE is an outstanding emulator. Amiga is already such a complicated machine before you even consider that there are ~10 official models, hundreds of peripherals, and thousands of different configurations.

Toni Wilen has been involved with WinUAE since the late 90s and has been the lead developer for ~20 years [1]. It's one thing that he's still at it now, but it's crazy to think that he first got involved at a time when Amiga was still a fairly widely-used and supported platform (by third-parties; Commodore kicked the bucket in 1994).

It's unfortunate that WinUAE is Windows-only (hence the name). There are cross-platform ports (the leading one is FS-UAE), but maybe this fragmented development is a symptom of the project being almost 30 years old at this point.

As a somewhat hardcore enthusiast, I'm thrilled by HN's continued interest in Amiga hardware and software.

[1] http://obligement.free.fr/articles_traduction/itwwillen_en.p...

dansalvato··on Sent – Simple plaintext presentation tool
I hear you, I regret making such a generalization, and my negatively was uncalled for. Thanks for reminding me to check myself.
dansalvato··on Sent – Simple plaintext presentation tool
"suckless" is a perfect name for this software suite—not because of the name's literal meaning, but because they are advertising their insufferable elitism right on the tin.

Yes, building software to solve a limited set of problems can lead to great software. But for god's sake, if your core philosophy is that you're better than everyone else, then you're primarily going to attract developers and users who also think they're better than everyone else.

The result is that instead of contributing to a mission that conveys a useful message, you just dig an elitist moat around yourselves that people can't float across unless their egos are so inflated that they're buoyant.

dansalvato··on Cosmic Desktop Is Slated to Debut with Pop _OS 24.04 LTS
That post you linked was a crazy read, it just kept going and going. I've never really had issues with GNOME, but knowing so many users share the sentiment of it being a hostile developer environment makes me want to check out other options next time I install a Linux distro.
dansalvato··on Dude, where's my self-driving car?
Same, I was quite happy with the adaptive cruise control on my Tesla Model 3. I decided to try enabling FSD beta, and it's basically a disaster. I've experienced it:

* Get confused about its lane position and swerve around in the lane

* Attempt to get into the left lane despite a right turn coming up in a few seconds

* Try to change lanes into a lane that doesn't exist, off the side of the road

Once a month or two, I decide to give it another fair chance, and almost every time, it seems to want to do something stupid and/or dangerous.

dansalvato··on Orbital's Hartnoll brothers look back
I was born in 1991 and have no perspective of the 90s techno/rave scene, but I somehow discovered Orbital around 2008, I think while looking around for electronica albums mastered in 5.1 to try out on my new surround speakers.

I listened so much to The Alltogether (2001), which I guess I preferred over their older stuff because I found it a little more dynamic and exciting. For the longest time, I had no idea they were such a cornerstone of the genre's history!

I was pretty thrilled to discover that they were back at it in recent years. I'm glad they're doing well. I have no point to make, just sharing my own personal anecdote despite being so far removed from the scene that originally drove their fame.

dansalvato··on OpenFPGA
I recently bought an Analogue Pocket and I think it's a great piece of hardware, but I'm really not a fan of this company's business model. This page has told me nothing I actually want to know about OpenFPGA.

Here's my question: If I'm developing an FPGA core, why should I develop for OpenFPGA instead of MiSTer? I want to know why it's better for preservation that I develop for OpenFPGA. Is it a more portable platform that has a more guaranteed future? I need to be convinced that OpenFPGA solves problems that make it a more likely choice than MiSTer 10+ years from now.

If someone with more experience than me in this space can answer the above, I would be really grateful. I'm astounded that Analogue's page on OpenFPGA is all marketing fluff without actually answering this.

dansalvato··on How Programming Languages Got Their Names
The gist I linked is shared by Andrew Kelley, creator of the language. My best guess is that he rolled something similar to 'zig' and was reminded of the Zero Wing reference before deciding to take off with Zig (for great justice).
dansalvato··on How Programming Languages Got Their Names
Zig apparently got its name from this: https://gist.github.com/andrewrk/73742bf4b8ed795c85ce

Just rolled the dice on 'z' + vowel + consonant + consonant until something good came up.

dansalvato··on Working in the Vision Pro [video]
I've done some experimenting with this. If a window is in focus, it occludes real-world objects, even those that are in front of the window. The real-world object becomes maybe 5% visible, so you can just barely see it.

If the window is not in focus (like if you're not looking directly at it), then it goes 50/50 with real-world objects, so any real object in front of it becomes sort of a "ghost" in order for you to still be able to see the window. It never tries to occlude apps behind real-world objects, except for your hands, which do full occlusion, as shown in the video.

dansalvato··on Working in the Vision Pro [video]
I've been wearing AVP extensively these past few days, experimenting with using it for all kinds of things. As of now, I don't find it more efficient or seamless at doing much of anything.

1. There is no window management whatsoever. It would be great if I could stick apps to each other, or tile them in a frame, but I can't do that. I also can't stack windows—if I put one window behind another, the only way to access it is to move the front window out of the way, or to close it. Kind of ridiculous, because I'm pretty sure that problem was already solved in the early 80s, if not ealier.

2. The field of view is really narrow. I have a 32:9 curved monitor, and I can easily look at the "side" apps by tilting my head just a few degrees, with my eyes doing the rest of the work. AVP demands tilting your head much more in either direction to see the window content, making it much harder to momentarily glance at.

3. I've had awful luck with the MacBook screen projection. Others may not have this issue. After a couple minutes of using it, it begins to heavily stutter to the point of being unusable. The keyboard handoff randomly disconnects. And AVP doesn't yet support bluetooth mice, only trackpads (either the MacBook's built-in trackpad, or a Magic Trackpad).

At least for normal desk work, AVP does not improve speed or efficiency in any way—it does the opposite. Hell, when I'm projecting my MacBook screen, I have to resist the temptation to just use desktop apps for everything, because they're so much faster and easier to use than the floating visionOS/iPadOS apps.

It's the iPad all over again. If you're a seasoned PC power user, using AVP will only hurt your efficiency in the same way that it would to try offloading some of your work to an iPad.

With that said, it does make certain things more enjoyable. Apple clearly didn't make this device as a solution to existing problems. The point is that it's a new relationship that we get to have with technology, which will possibly change the way we want to use technology.

But for real, Apple hasn't launched a first-gen product this limited in use since the original iPhone. It has a long way to go before it actually starts making digital life more efficient, except for some highly specialized use cases.

dansalvato··on How Doom didn't kill the Amiga
I do some Amiga collecting, and I recently bought an Amiga 2000 that came with a ReadySoft A-Max, and even Mac networking hardware: https://amiga.resource.cx/exp/amax

This tells me there must have been decent interest in Mac emulation as early as 1989, when the A-Max released. And it didn't plug into the expansion slot, so it evidently would have worked fine on an A500.

The A2000 primarily focused on PC compatibility, though. Commodore shipped "bridgeboards", which were x86 CPU cards that plugged into the A2000's expansion slot. Not only did this let you run DOS in a window on your Amiga, but it could virtualize hard disks and printers, and you could even expand it using the A2000's built-in ISA slots for that very purpose. Pretty dang cool, and maybe a good value proposition for offices mainly running DOS but wanted something better for desktop publishing or anything graphics/video-related.

dansalvato··on Apple Vision Pro and ADHD
Author here—you’re not wrong, I’ve been a gadget enthusiast my whole life, and I deliberately left in the tone that I’m trying to justify owning an Apple Vision Pro, despite its flaws.

I was also serious that the flaws are part of the charm for me, because it really does harken back to the “gadget age” of the 2000s. It takes me back to being 15 years old, wearing a Fossil Wrist PDA, trying to be productive with Palm OS using a fingernail-sized stylus. I really loved that sort of thing, and it’s been really hard for me to recapture that feeling this past decade.

AVP is a device that, so far, has brought me joy and makes me think about my relationship with technology. If not for the price tag, it would be a no-brainer for me to keep. But as I continue to mess around with the device, the price is constantly ringing in the back of my mind, making me want to justify it, even though I may not be able to in the end.

dansalvato··on Apple Vision Pro and ADHD
It’s well known that habits and mode of thinking change with environmental cues, and I find that extends to a digital environment as well. If you have a device that’s distinctly a “work” device and you’ve only ever used it for focused work, then your brain will hopefully catch on and keep you within that mode of thinking a little bit more effectively.

However, I find that with ADHD, a good “system” doesn’t solve all my problems. There is then the fundamental problem of regularly using that system, which it turns out ADHD also makes a serious challenge. So, yes, good systems have tremendous value, but just prepare for the undertaking of staying committed to the system you’ve set up for yourself.

dansalvato··on Apple Vision Pro and ADHD
Things aren’t “slow” in the sense that they’re unresponsive. The UI actually feels great to use—it’s a lot of fun, it’s fluid, and it responds very well to my actions. It’s just that I’m not as fast navigating apps on the Apple Vision Pro compared to using a mouse or a touchscreen. Frustration only occurs when trying to perform a certain action and getting a different result, which doesn’t happen much for me (except in iPad apps with poor compatibility).
dansalvato··on Vision Pro's killer feature? It's a wearable Mac
Speaking from first-hand experience, there is some latency which makes the virtual display a lot less comfortable to use, and it's capped at 60Hz. It's effectively a coat of paint over Apple's typical "screen mirroring" feature, which is excellent for showing people stuff, but not necessarily for using it yourself.
dansalvato··on Well-Known Secrets of AmigaDOS
> Yes, it's so weird how that 7 MHz thing ran a perfectly usable graphical environment with a command line shell within the GUI and all.

Perhaps not as advanced as AmigaOS, but Commodore 64 famously had GEOS for a good few years in the second half of its lifespan, which ended up being very popular for that machine. On a 1MHz 6502! Although I don’t know if it came with a command line.

dansalvato··on Well-Known Secrets of AmigaDOS
The Amiga I grew up with only ever had AmigaOS 1.3, but I’ve heard a lot of praise surrounding ARexx, a scripting language that I believe shipped with 2.0 and later.

From the AmigaOS wiki:

> The ARexx programming language can act as a central hub through which applications - even those created by different companies - can exchange data and commands. For example, using ARexx you can instruct a telecommunications package to dial an electronic bulletin board, download financial data from the bulletin board, and then automatically pass the data to a spreadsheet program for statistical analysis - without any user intervention.

On a more personal note, I’ve been working on a game for classic Amiga over the past couple years, and it feels like such a novelty to have OS bindings for things like memory allocation and file handling while working with a machine from 1985. Especially for file handling, I have the assurance that my game will run off of floppy, hard disk, or even a RAM disk on any generation Amiga, because I get to use modern file path logic via the DOS library.

dansalvato··on Testing how hard it is to cheat with ChatGPT in interviews
I went to a high school (in the US) that was full of extremely passionate and engaging teachers. After I graduated, I had a conversation with one of them about the curriculum, and she told me that their number one job was effectively to teach whatever will be on the standardized tests used for college admissions.

I've had some amazing teachers whose passion shone through and cultivated students' genuine interest in the subject matter. Unfortunately, there is only so much that can be done when, at the end of the day, your curriculum is designed for the purpose of getting a good standardized test score.

dansalvato··on Apple Vision Pro review: magic, until it's not
One thing I find with Apple devices is that they have an ecosystem of extremely passionate developers, and all their other "new paradigm" platforms also initially shipped with no software (Mac, iPhone, iPad). The mainstream usage of these devices is really based on what developers built for them in the first couple years after release, not the use cases Apple tried to sell us on.

The shortcomings and skepticism surrounding the AVP is pretty reminiscent of the above examples' own initial releases. Unless AVP is an exception to the rule, I think both the hardware and the software will start to get extremely good over the next few years. But that is unavoidably predicated by a flawed gen 1 being released.

dansalvato··on Apple Vision Pro review: magic, until it's not
> I wonder what Jobs would have done.

I think every "new paradigm" Apple product had similar growing pains. The Mac launched with only 128kb RAM, the iPhone lacked basic functionality and ditched physical keyboards, and the iPad was "just a big iPod". Also, in all cases, there was no software for them at launch.

Every time, we seem to ask "What is this good for?" or "How will this ever be good when it has these fundamental limitations?" But then, a few years down, it's suddenly commonplace, even indispensable.

I think that like the new paradigms before it, it's hard to imagine a clear future for this product. But they always seem to find their way after Apple gets them out the door. Not saying I'm convinced there will be a headset in every home, but I think the "spatial computing" paradigm is far more likely to find a path forward than it is to die.

dansalvato··on Show HN: Wren – simple yet extensible task management with CLI, Telegram, HTTP
Seems like there's a lot of criticism in the comments about this not being "simple". When "simple" is used to describe an app, it can either mean "easy to use" or "minimal infrastructure". People are interpreting it to mean the former, but it's clearly the latter.

I use Obsidian for notes and pen and paper for task management (Bullet Journal), but I always love poking around at productivity apps that value this kind of "simplicity". It's joyful to use my computer as a personal tool to do things the way I want to do them, rather than being at the mercy of whichever app sucks the least. The sad reality is that we're moving ever further away from that style of computing, which makes me value apps like this.

My one piece of constructive criticism would be to rework "Integrations" as "Extensions", maybe each in their own Python module that interfaces with a core API. For example, right now I see the GPT summary integration as a `get_summary()` function in core.py, but it feels like it shouldn't belong there. Spinning off the "integrations" into separate extension modules would not only help with the messaging of Wren being simple, but they would also serve as good examples for users to build their own extension modules. Hell, having a Wren extensions folder in .config would be awesome, like if you could just drop .py files in there to add new extension commands to Wren.

Those are my two cents, keep up the good work!

dansalvato··on What makes switching to GNU Linux almost impossible for many?
Adobe also thwarted me from daily driving Linux a few years ago when I gave it an honest attempt. I'm practically hoping that Microsoft pulls some shit to step on their toes, like develop competing products, so that Adobe has a real incentive to get its users off of Windows (like Valve does). Microsoft has gotten increasingly aggressive these past 5 years in force-feeding their ecosystem of services to Windows users, and it's making the desktop UX worse for both savvy and non-savvy users.
dansalvato··on ZX Spectrum Raytracer
Amiga is famous for The Juggler, an animation by Eric Graham which did exactly that in January 1986. It became an Amiga "mascot" of sorts and the animation was used to advertise the machine in computer shops, magazines, etc.

Here is a page with some info and a video of the animation: http://www.randelshofer.ch/animations/anims/eric_graham/Jugg...

dansalvato··on MNT Reform: a hackable laptop, not for everyone
I'd love to hear from people interested in a device like this to get an understanding of what they'd imagine doing with it. I'm pretty far removed from the world of hardware hacking, so my imagination is limited. Is the completely open nature of the device more about principle, or is it enabling users to do interesting things with it that they can't do with other devices (e.g. Framework Laptop or a standard Raspberry Pi)?
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →