176 karma · joined January 11, 2016
Not sure what you mean, I didn't see Napster fighting for censorship nor Craigslist fighting for FOSTA.
"You cannot use any personal identifying data from any visitor who is a one-time visitor."
If an IP address is "personal identifying data" (as the author subsequently states), then every visitor is a one-time visitor. You can try tracking unique visitors by something else, like some user agent data, but it's less accurate. Ignoring IP means optimizing a site for click-to-sales becomes a lot more vague.
If a site converts each unique IP to a hash, then that's one way to get a unique visitor, but then which hash method do you use? MD5 is hackable to anyone having a list of hashes to IP addresses, and anything else can be more complicated and less standardized, so therefore more prone to bugs and bad coding, and therefore more costly to the business.
"You cannot load any 3rd party service, because by doing that you would be sending personally identifying data to those services (like people's IP address)."
If you can't even load 3rd-party software because they can see IP addresses, then you can't have any tracking, including aggregate, unless you build your own, which can be highly costly and is inherently inefficient with many pre-built solutions already existing and refined, even if they're open-source.
This restriction seems just as unreasonable as the first, also based on IP, and I'm not sure the politicians who made this restriction understand the web.
"You cannot even do personally identifying internal analytics."
If this is true, then you're cutting out a lot of site optimization and sales navigation because you're not always going to be right about what people want or how they will click things on the site. Without IP tracking, you can't follow where someone is going or tie that user to a bug, just get an aggregate of many, which can be vague.
"The reason is that a first time visitor hasn't done anything that could be considered consent, so you have nothing to work with."
This is incorrect, the user has given consent to make available any info the browser provides, which has to include IP address so the server knows where to send the response. If a politician doesn't understand this, then someone hasn't explained it to them.
It is a natural right of a website and publisher to use IP addresses, because they are required for web communication and identifying abusers. How they use it beyond that is what should be regulated, not just the visibility or collection of it.
"I don't think publishers realize just what this means."
I don't think the politicians understand just what this means either.
"Only Windows 7 x64 systems patched with the 2018-01 or 2018-02 patches are vulnerable. If your system isn't patched since December 2017 or if it's patched with the 2018-03 patches or later it will be secure."
"I discovered this vulnerability just after it had been patched in the 2018-03 Patch Tuesday. I have not been able to correlate the vulnerability to known CVEs or other known issues."
If Google's Android really can't tell the difference between a physical user and a software app, there's something seriously wrong with Google or Android.
Also, QA and dev teams use Incognito for "clean" testing, and screenshots here are very valuable for showing others what you're seeing (especially if they're not in the same office or area), such as when they're pasted to a ticket board.
I honestly don't see the reason for this restriction; if it has something to do with Recents (which the source code change ticket implies), then I don't know how that makes sense either, as I have Chrome tabs in Recents disabled, and I can't see how this benefits the user unless Google employees' significant others busted their salacious Incognito usage... but that's punishing the innocent as well and telling every user they're not capable of "doing it right" even if that's their knowing intention.
This should be ILLEGAL, I don't give a crap about "getting the government out of our lives", well guess what, they need to step in and prevent these slimy "business" practices from happening or punish the corporations trying to exploit their captive audience.