HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

davekinkead

170 karma · joined October 20, 2011

submissionscomments
davekinkead··on Hollingsworth for US Senate 2014, implementing direct democracy
I think you've got this backwards.

The patriot act wasn't a result of direct democracy, but getting rid of it would be much easier under direct democracy. Government involves both the creation and ammendment/removal of statutes.

Direct democracy is no more likely to lead to tyranny of the majority than representational democracy (slavery and segregation was an act of representational democracy if you recall). You are confusing two dimensions: direct <--> representative with majoritarianism <--> constitutionalism. Direct democracy is perfectly compatible with all the checks and balances of liberalism and a constitution.

davekinkead··on Hollingsworth for US Senate 2014, implementing direct democracy
> You could grant the use of your vote to another citizen or a group of citizens.

This idea is common in a lot of new ideas about representation (eg the German Pirate Party's Liquid Democracy http://liquidfeedback.org/) yet I'd argue it is also a really bad idea.

One of the key values of any democracy, and direct democracy in particular, is that it values and promotes human autonomy. Instead of being subject to arbitrary powers, the 'people' rule themselves - we are only subject to laws that we ourselves have authored (or delegated to others to author in our current cases). But allowing everyone to vote on everything violates autonomy.

Most people recognise that autonomy requires having some/equal say in matters that materially affect them. Yet few realise that giving others a say in matters that don't affect them undermines the autonomy of those affected. So while laws apply relatively equally to all those in a jurisdiction, the distribution of effect is far from equal.

Proxy voting allows those with little skin in the game to drown out those significantly affected by proposed laws. The fact that people don't have the time to vote on every issue, and so will only likely vote on matters important to them, is one of the major strengths of direct democracy.

davekinkead··on Bank of America Giving Access to Random Accounts
Really? Its far from unheard of.

http://www.smh.com.au/it-pro/security-it/super-bad-first-sta...

davekinkead··on Why Don’t Americans Elect Scientists?
A parliamentary system is one in which the executive and legislative branches are one (EG if the president was a member of congress, and chosen by congress).

@lmkg seems to be referring to a proportional electoral system, not parliamentary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation

As to the implication that proportional systems don't result in individuals representing constituencies or geographic regions, there are numerous hybrid systems that manage to achieve the best of both worlds http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_transferable_vote

davekinkead··on Freelancing: A 6-Month Retrospective
As someone reading this post while working from home on my sunny balcony at 10:30 am and still in PJs, the freedom is worth at least $25k per year.
davekinkead··on Too Hot for TED: Income Inequality
Yeah, because high tax rates always discourage entrepreneurship </sarcasm>

Norway - with one of the highest tax rates & comprehensive welfare states on the planet - has higher rates of entrepreneurship than the USA does. http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/01/20/norway-entr...

If you look at international entrepreneur rates, its pretty clear that there is no relationship between income tax rates and start-up activity (that's not to say that specific tax policies don't make a difference). http://www.internationalentrepreneurship.com/total-entrepren...

For every argument about high tax discouraging risky ventures, there is a counter-argument that high safety nets reduce the risk of start ups.

davekinkead··on GitLaw: GitHub For Laws And Legal Documents - A Tourniquet For American Liberty
+1

It's not cynicism, its realism which must be reflected in the strategy for change, otherwise failure is inevitable.

davekinkead··on CarbonDraft: Github for non-Coders
I'd be keen to try it but it seems your email validation only accepts first order domains which kind of rules out anyone using .co.uk, .com.au etc :(
davekinkead··on Safety Nets for Startups
> If you're going to be working 40+ hour weeks for a boring soul-crushing job, then you might as well get a few perks out of it, such as health insurance.

Part of the problem is that health can even be thought of as a 'perk' in the first place. Most of the safety net effect could be achieved simply by removing the link between health cover and employment. Just do what most of the rest of the world does (where employment status is irrelevant to health cover) and a major disincentive to innovation is removed.

Unless of course, the objective is to entrench dependency to large organizations. In that case, the present system works just fine.

davekinkead··on Bill to make open access mandatory
While not as sexy as fighting SOPA, representatives still need to hear your support for bills like this. Otherwise, opposing bills like http://arstechnica.com/science/news/2012/01/here-we-go-again... will prevail.
davekinkead··on Cars kill cities
Actually, registration and gas taxes don't even cover the damage cars do to tax payer subsidized roads. The real taxpayer funded contribution to transport is almost identical for public and private transport. The key difference is that cars have the roads, public space and pollution subsidized where as transit have the marginal ticket price subsidized.

Here is an example from Australia (heavily car dependent) http://blogs.crikey.com.au/theurbanist/2010/11/24/what-costs...

davekinkead··on Photographers face copyright threat after shock ruling
I wonder if celebs could apply this ruling to pappazzi?

Simply employ 1 pap to photograph the celeb partaking in a typical celeb action (coming out of a rehab centre, cavorting with intern) in typical pap style. Then sue for copyright infringement anytime a similar pic is published in the future.

That said, this ruling makes about as much sense as trade marking a colour http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/11/21/cadburys-chocolate-trade... or illegal numbers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number

davekinkead··on Congressman blacks out his official .gov website
What's more terrifying - Having no control over what your representatives vote on (except to vote them in or out) or having binding veto power?

Too many people confuse direct democracy with majoritarianism. The same checks and balances that exists with representative democracy can also exist with the direct kind. The constitution & the courts can still limit popular will.

One thing is for sure, there is no way SOPA like bills could pass with direct democracy or popular veto.

davekinkead··on How to travel around the world for a year.
+1 do it now. -1 wife & kids don't matter.

We moved to St Anton am Arlberg (Awesome ski resort in the Alps) with a 15 month old & mortgage. Ski by day, work remote by night, best six months in a long time. So good, we are doing another ski season in Japan for 2012/13 (and we have a 2nd kid now).

One of the great things about IT is that you can be geographically free. Leave the hustle & bustle, get in touch with nature/family/yourself/beer and you will never regret it.

davekinkead··on Sweden recognises new file-sharing religion Kopimism
Actually, there is significant case law to support this. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gonzales_v._O_Centro_Espirita_B...

A christian/amazonian group fought the government to import and consume a schedule 1 narcotic in their ceremonies. If sharing information is central to kopism's practices then it seems it would be discriminatory to prevent them from doing so.

davekinkead··on Vint Cerf: Internet Access Is Not a Human Right
You are missing the link between rights and duties. If you have a right to bear arms, then in the positive sense I have a duty to provide you with arms and in the negative sense, I have the duty not to stop you bearing arms. I'll assuming you refer the the negative sense.

If so, what grants you the authority to impose that duty upon me? Why am I not allowed to protect myself by ensuring you don't have the means to harm me?

One way to protect oneself is to ensure no one has the means to do harm to each other. Given that that option exists, then the right to bear arms can't be a fundamental human right because it is clear not fundamental to human existence. If it is a right, then it is a political right that comes from mutual agreement.

davekinkead··on Vint Cerf: Internet Access Is Not a Human Right
You are missing Cerf's point. It may be a desirable but its not a human right. What you are describing is negative freedom: no one should stop me from doing X. But this is very different from a human right: something that is inalienable and fundamental to human existence.

The right to bear arms is a political right (in the US at least) as well as a negative freedom. It is not however, a human right. If it was, the nearly every other country in the world would be violating fundamental human rights by denying their citizens the opportunity to carry a weapon that kills with such ease.

Access to the internet wasn't fundamental to human existence 100 years ago when it didn't exist or even 10 year ago when it did. Its still not fundamental to our existence today - its just very useful.

davekinkead··on Vint Cerf: Internet Access Is Not a Human Right
Any discussion of rights without discussing duties is vacuous because rights can't exist without duties ie: My right to X imposes a duty on you to provide or not prevent me from X.

So if internet access was a right, what is the corresponding duty it imposes and who is that duty imposed upon? Must the state (and therefore you) provide me with a super computer & T1 connection or is free netbook and dial-up for all sufficient? Or perhaps your rich neighbour. Why not TV or radio as human rights?

Claiming these things as human rights imposes unjustifiable burdens upon others when you have no right to do so. If you disagree, please explain why I should be forced to ensure you have access to facebook and where your power of imposition comes from.

But just because something is not a right, doesn't mean that universal access is not a good thing. Plenty of goods such as education, healthcare and sanitation fail the duty test but their universal access is still a very good thing. We may even agree that these things 'should' be a right but in that case the right is a political one based on mutual agreement, not some inalienable human right.

davekinkead··on What Americans Keep Ignoring About Finland's School Success
There is actually a very strong structural argument for why public goods such as education and health, should be distributed equally:

If those in power have to use the same system as those they hold power over, then they have a strong incentive and self interest to ensure that those public goods are of a high standard.

This is not to say that public goods must be delivered by the state, but rather there should no difference in opportunity of access (such as the Finnish private schools that don't charge tuition).

davekinkead··on Driving has lost its cool for young Americans
Actually, its a myth that its a myth that public transport is cheaper (see http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08111140802369820)

Once the massive externalities of private motor and road subsidies are accounted for, private motor is much more expensive per km/mi travelled than public transport (and obviously orders of magnitude more than bike)

In Sydney, AU for example driving costs $0.86/passengerKm while trains are only $0.48 (http://melbourneurbanist.files.wordpress.com/2010/11/glazebr...)

If motorists had to pay the true cost of the service, everyone would be riding bikes.

davekinkead··on Lamar Smith: Campaign Finance/Money
Direct democracy will never work in a complex system. Having a 300 million person committee is about as close to decision making disaster as you can get.

But direct democracy is still the answer IMO. What needs to change first however, is for decision making to become more decentralised - as low as a given problem will allow it.

You can't expect everyone to be informed about all issues (govt has consistently demonstrated that even they can't stay on top of the laws they create). But you can expect people to be informed about the immediate issues that affect them. Most issues are local or regional ones & very few need to be national or international.

Even without direct democracy, decentralising political power whenever possible is a very good thing.

davekinkead··on Lamar Smith: Campaign Finance/Money
Representational democracy also fails for the same reason.
davekinkead··on Hackerly proposals for fixing U.S. politics (compiled by Lessig)
'In these tragedy-of-the-commons types of scenarios, all can be willing to agree to a change of the rules, so long as no actor gains immediate "unfair" advantage.'

That, sadly, is why I am so pessimistic about political change via the current advocacy model. Tragedy of the common's type situations can often be avoided if enough players can agree to a some convention or code of behaviour. The problem with special interest in politics is that even if every politician could agree that the current way the game is played is destructive, special interest would actively work against reform.

Change under the current system is reliant on the altruism of those in power to limit that power.

davekinkead··on Hackerly proposals for fixing U.S. politics (compiled by Lessig)
TL;DR The problem wont fix its self. The system will prevent solutions that limit it. Nothing will change until you do something. That something needs to be withing the current rules of the game.

What I find most amazing about any analysis piece on the problems of democracy and what to do about it is that they are almost always self-defeating. By this, I mean the very proposal to solve the problem prevents the problem from being solved.

The article is correct about what (one of) the problem is. Institutional corruption is analogous to the principal-agent problem except the issue is the asymmetry influence, not information.

But suggesting that the existing 'system' recognise the problem and then take action against itself is pure naivety. If politicians, those empowered by us to represent us, are being corrupted by special interest enough not to represent our interests, then those same special interests are going to ensure that measures to restrict their influence are thwarted. The system can't be changed from the outside without revolution, and revolution won't happen until things get really bad (and then generally turn out just as bad later)

The problem of special interest can only occur when the net benefits (expected outcome - cost of lobbying) for special interest groups exceed the net costs for individuals to fight it. Sadly, the benefit to the few is great and despite a net social cost, spread amongst the population the cost to the many is little.

The only way to solve the problem is to do so in a way that doesn't change the system. One way of doing this (and the only viable option I can think of) is to form a non-partisan political party who's only policy is to do what the electorate tells it. The candidate signs a legally binding contract to vote according to the will of their electorate and some kind of public/electronic forum allows issues to be discussed and voted. As long as everything is sailing along nicely, you wouldn't have to have any involvement if you didn't want. But, if a bad law is proposed (SOPA comes to mind), then there is no way it could pass if the majority was against it.

I'm sure that there will be opposition to this - it is devolving power to the populous and making politicians simple spokespeople, not deciders of the public will - but isn't this what #occupy needs? A way to use the existing system to devolve power to the 99% (well actually to the 100%).

davekinkead··on No Copyright Intended
Did you create any of the following posts? http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=zokier

A hyperlink is a form of distribution so you may want to clarify what you mean by 'you shouldn't distribute anything you haven't created yourself from scratch.'

davekinkead··on No Copyright Intended
If anything, Id say its the kids who understand the normative justifications of copyright better than their elders.

As has been previously mentioned, there is a growing disjoint between the legal status of copyright laws and their moral underpinnings. "Kids these days" are still acting within a moral framework of do not harm even while downloading.

davekinkead··on Daphne Koller of Stanford AI Lab on online education
I think this type of learning will be considerably more effective in quantitative subjects than qualitative ones. Maths especially but essentially any subject that has 'right' answers lends its self well to this as content and tests can be automated algorithmically.

I'm curious however to see how this works in humanity type subjects that require more critical thinking and higher order reasoning. These seem to me to still require human interpretation in order to assess understanding.

davekinkead··on NYC Man Earns $55,000 A Year Peddling Candy On Subway
"He didn't come up with a new and interesting way to sell shit." So now you have to be first to be an entrepreneur? Tell that to Brin & Page.
davekinkead··on We Are All Criminals – or – Why I Hate Traffic Cops
Happy to stand corrected on that one. I had thought that autobahn fatalities were worse than Euro average (noting that Germany but it seems that Germany pays no penalty for unlimited motorway speeds.
davekinkead··on Traveling, Writing and Programming
I packed up the house, wife & 1yo last year to spend 6 months skiing in the Alps. Best thing we have done in many, many years and it actually cost less than the 2 week holiday we had their the year before.

Yes life gets more complicated with partner/kids/mortgage and yes its really hard to see before it happens. But now we've been back in the 'real world' for a year we realise just how abnormal the real world actually is. So we are doing it again next year and hopefully every year (with an extra kid this time).

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →