HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

davekinkead

170 karma · joined October 20, 2011

submissionscomments
davekinkead··on We Are All Criminals – or – Why I Hate Traffic Cops
This issue is really why we should have laws: the post argues that speeding is ok because lots of people do it and it doesn't hurt many people. I say that is completely wrong.

Speed kills - Road deaths in the US in 1 month are more than all US terror related deaths in the last 20 years. And just because lots of people do something doesn't make it right.

Do we need speed limits is a different question however - I can imagine a world without speed limits (but severe punishment for any harm done to others equivalent to violent crime, or even sharp knives sticking out of the steering wheel - a sure way to encourage people to drive safely).

Disclaimer: I love driving on the autobahn (but germany still has one of the worst road fatality rates in Europe)

davekinkead··on We Are All Criminals – or – Why I Hate Traffic Cops
Wow - bad logic and selective evidence.

Firstly, just because lots of people do something, doesn't make it acceptable. An act is wrong because of the harm it does, not the frequency of its distribution amongst a population. By the author's logic, murder would be ok just in case more of us did it. You may think speeding is fine but sadly for the rest of us, your choice to speed imposes a harm on to others.

And regarding that harm - speed kills. Yes, there is a strong relation between speed variance and fatalities so its be fair to argue that focusing on traffic flow & speed differentials is important. But there is an even strong one between average speeds and fatalities. Ignoring absolute speed is misleading - especially in urban areas where the survivability of being hit at 20 vs 30 mph is an order of magnitude different.

And finally, 'The speed limit assumes a level of stupidity that the average person does not possess.' Again, wow. Im pretty the author doesn't go around killing people because he realises 1) its morally wrong & 2) its rational for us to all agree to not kill each other because my loss of freedom to kill is more than offset by my not having to spend my every waking moment wondering who's going to kill me. Yet, some people still murder others. We do need laws to protect us from the harm of others, even if we ourselves would not have engaged in that harmful behaviour anyway.

davekinkead··on ShowHN: Identity.io, Opt-out of data brokers and regain control of your privacy
You may want to check your front page links. Having most of them direct to http://www.identity.io/comingsoon while your virtualhosts file is out of whack (so prompt to download a httpd/unix-directory) doesn't inspire confidence that you will protect my identity.
davekinkead··on Please Poach Me
I'm not trying to crush your startup dreams but you should stop right now and immediately talk to 20+ recruiters or hiring managers about your app before you invest any more time or money.

I built a prototype for a similar idea about 18 months ago - it imported your linked in profile, your network could write skill specific references which back-linked and allowed recruiters/employers to search for skills/experience/geography/salary range they wanted to generate an anonymous short list of candidates in seconds; they could browse shortlisted CVs, read references and they only paid when a candidate agreed to release their details to the recruiter. Great idea eh?

The problem was, just about all the recruiters & employers I talked to about it (in Australia) weren't that positive. Their reasons were: * network effects - it only becomes useful once plenty of candidates were in it. * many recruiters already had their own database of candidates that they didn't want to share or duplicate. * many recruiters needed near immediate response (they had 48hrs to fill a role). Waiting for candidates to respond to a request was a negative for them. * some recruiters saw it as a threat and didn't want to support that kind of system. * Companies often wanted a full service solution so while this could generate a quality shortlist for them, many wanted hand holding.

HR is ripe for disruption but execution is everything. What does your app do that paid access to searchable linkedin profiles doesn't?

davekinkead··on “But The Client Wants IE 6 Support”
Except certain Australian Federal departments with 70,000+ staff who are stuck on IE6 because their IT boffins only want to use 'secure' web browsers and IT policy doesn't give them any choice in the tools they use.
davekinkead··on Anonymous Cancels Operation Cartel as Los Zetas Track Hacktivists
Wouldn't it be safer & a hell of a lot cheaper if drugs were regulated according to their harm? Grass is no worse than alcohol or tobacco, while cocaine doesn't cause any more social issues than those.

The cartels only exist because the illegality of those drugs creates massive profit margins. Remove that and many of the problems are solved.

davekinkead··on Klout Is Odious
No but its true - she hasn't even created an account but when I logged in last week it said she was one of the facebook profiles I no longer influence!
davekinkead··on Klout Is Odious
Last week Klout told me I no longer influence my wife. I could have told them that years ago :(
davekinkead··on It’s Not China; It’s Efficiency That Is Killing Our Jobs
The author confuses money for wealth when they are two very different things. Look at the teleporting chef example - if food production could be done so efficiently that only a few chefs around the world were needed, then social wealth has increased. There would be a massive pool of surplus labour that the now redundant chefs could put to use elsewhere.

As others have noted, the newly redundant chefs would be out of work temporarily and if that is the only skill they had, then they would be at a disadvantage relative to everyone else. Yet that disadvantage would be many more times offset by the benefit us non-chefs would accrue (from cheaper meals for example) and still allow the redundant chefs to do something else.

That's the nature of capitalism - creative destruction. The process is beneficial collectively, but some individuals benefit or loose more than others. And that's why (most) countries provide some sort of redistribution mechanism to smooth out those individual inequalities. The solution to any dehumanizing effects of the capitalist system is not to limit the market's ability to drive innovation and efficiency, but rather to ensure everyone enjoys those benefits more equality.

davekinkead··on 50% of All Workers Made Less than $26,000 in 2010
Seriously? Income = social contribution?

By your logic, all volunteer work is worthless. Likewise, a mother raising their child to become a good citizen has no value if they are not paid for it.

To put this into better perspective, consider the hypothetical that parents didn't toilet train their children. What would the cost to business be if they couldn't externalize this training to society?

davekinkead··on What If We Paid Off The Debt? The Secret Government Report
Australia faced the same issue over the period 2006-2009 when the national debt became a surplus. The bond market didn't implode as this article would predict. Rather the govt simply continued to issued bonds and bought other assets to keep the market alive.

The bond market actually did very well - in 1998 there was approx $167BB of govt debt issued while in 2008 there was $480BB.

http://www.brr.com.au/event/43083/recent-developments-in-the... for a boring speech about it by the RBA governor

← PreviousPage 3 of 3