71 karma · joined June 1, 2026
Edited to add: we must have followed different links though, mine only had three questions obviously.
Makes you wonder what else you're missing.
Oops.
Edited to add: hm. I just got 67%. I guess my college degree is a waste. Should have gone the humanities route instead.
Who exactly do you think wants to stick their neck out and say, "I work for a passive index fund. The whole premise of our career is that we don't try to play the market. But just this one time, I'm going to play the market anyway, and I'm going to use your money to do it."
Sorry, not happening. If you don't like the fact that this stuff is going to be included in the index, then your only option is to stop buying the index. Of course they think they would think they're right. Everyone doing active investing always, every time, thinks they're right. They will buy the index the way they always do, and then they will say, "If you don't like it, take it up with the index."
Watch the scene in Big Short at the bond rating agency for an indication of what's really going on here, is my guess.
"Clicking through now feels like expressing distrust in the tool, rather than just doing your homework."
This is off. Just between us, the "AI" does not have feelings. It does not care if you express distrust in it.
I guess I'm getting old but "gender reveal smoke bombs," this is really a thing?
This ought to be a wholly unsurprising analysis. I would say it feels like 2007-2008 again except that nobody feels particularly complacent nowadays.
Also Wargames came out in 84 about a computer taking over the national security apparatus and launching a nuclear war.
So I guess you could say there was a wide range of opinion about what these newfangled things were going to do to society.
Having said that I guess you have a valid point. Once major institutional investors decide an index has basically gone corrupted, then they won't actually buy the index fund anymore. They will just buy all the stocks in the index, and underweight the parts they think are tainted. That's what I would do, anyways.
Your career would be over.
Or at least, you would have to transition over to an active fund!
But the story is not about all indices being wrong, the story is about index management being corrupted. Like bond ratings on mortgages in the run-up to 2008.
On the other hand, do you want to be the one who says, "As a rule we follow the index, but this time we decided to break our own rule, and as a result we lost X% of returns"?
Better wrong with everybody else than wrong on my own.
Well, I do not know if that is illegal, but I certainly know that it is true!