HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

davvolun

271 karma · joined May 9, 2013

submissionscomments
davvolun··on New bill ensures Jailtime for CEOs that lie
That's an entirely different class of thing though, possibly civil vs. criminal, I believe. If I'm signing a contract with you, and you tell me "no one is going to ever offer you a deal like this," even though you fully know many people would offer me a better deal, that's not illegal.

This is more akin to the chief of police making an announcement that a building is safe to enter, knowing there is a gunmen ready to shoot people as they enter. I don't know the exact definitions here, IANAL, but I'm pretty sure my scenario would be legally actionable.

Similarly, freedom of speech is limited at least in one way by "imminent lawless action."

I'm not sure about the issue you mention regarding CBP, but I believe there are certain differences between how the law treats citizens and non-citizens. The Exclusionary Rule, disallowing evidence illegally obtained, doesn't apply to civil matters, including immigration, apparently (https://www.halt.org/things-cops-do-that-are-illegal-what-a-...).

Law enforcement can omit or lie about your Miranda rights, but they can't use evidence obtained from what you say without reading your rights. So if a cop saw you shoot someone, and you're still holding the gun, they don't really need to read you your rights; they don't really need anything from you at that point.

davvolun··on Ohio Was Set to Purge 235,000 Voters. It Was Wrong About 20%
Republicans say Democrats just want to get all the poor people/illegals registered to up their vote, Democrats say Republicans want to suppress votes to keep control.

I think most Americans have a problem with the government keeping lists about them. How that makes sense in the modern age of driver's licenses, SSNs, and the Patriot Act, I'm not sure, but as long as people here are so against the idea, it's kind of dead-in-the-water.

davvolun··on After 'South Park' Censorship Episode, China Deleted the Show from the Web
Words vs action have nothing to do with what I was saying, and I don't see where you've made a convincing case that they should be separated.

As for Barr and Gillis, both ABC and NBC acted immediately to get rid of them when it looked like they would hurt their bottom line. Is that "cancel culture" to you?

> If I made vile jokes about Trump and his kids, I’d get a Netflix special.

Which kids? Who is out there making fun of Bannon, or are you saying Eric/Don Jr/Ivanka/[that other one] are off limits?

I'm not aware of anyone targeting any under age Presidential children..........

Oh except when Malia was being called out for drinking under age, I guess. Or, here's former Presidential candidate John McCain making a joke about Chelsea Clinton (https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2008/sep/02/women.j...). So I guess if you make a joke about Trump's kids, you get a Netflix special; make a joke about a Democrat President's kid, run for President?

davvolun··on On the way to being the most downvoted post ever on StackOverflow:Meta
I recall responding to the statement "English is just as gendered as...", but clearly that's not what you wrote. That's my fault.
davvolun··on On the way to being the most downvoted post ever on StackOverflow:Meta
What are you talking about? English is verifiably not as gendered as Spanish, at the very least.

All nouns in Spanish require a gender article (el/la or los/las). In English, you do not have to figure out whether "día" should be prefixed with el or la -- and in the case of "día" despite it ending in "a" which usually implies feminine and la, it's actually masculine and is properly "el día."

That doesn't even bring into it examples like ellos/ellas ("they" or "them" in English) referring to a male group or a female group where the standard rule is to use ellos if referring to an unknown group or even a group of 100 women and one man, the only application of ellas should be when you can verify every single member of the group is female.

davvolun··on After 'South Park' Censorship Episode, China Deleted the Show from the Web
You had me until "cancel culture"

Exactly how many irreverent comedians who achieved significant success and are not really accountable to anyone, telling it like it is, have been cancelled by the cancel culture?

Cosby, TJ Miller, Louis CK, Jeffrey Tambor, James Franco, ...? A good list of people who did morally reprehensible things of varying degrees, from illegal to merely opening their employers to civil liability, and in my mind, they should be "cancelled." Maybe you can argue some of these, I don't think so.

Azis Ansari? I don't know how tranchant his "speaking truth to power" has ever been, but he did a Netflix special this year, and I would need pretty compelling evidence to believe that's your smoking gun. I predict he'll be just fine in a few more years.

Kevin Hart? Maybe. Again, not much of a politically-motivated comedian, but getting removed as Oscar (?) host was damaging. Nonetheless, it looks like he had 5 movies/specials in 2019 and has work scheduled for 2020. Besides the car crash, I think he'll be alright.

Dan Harmon (like James Gunn) was a political hit job and didn't go anywhere.

Am I missing anyone?

Outside of e.g. #metoo, some people didn't like Dave Chappelle's recent Netflix special. I'm not a fan of him "punching down" at trans people myself, but, I don't think it's anything he hasn't said before. Nonetheless it was trending in the top five for most of last month, I think he is, and will continue to be, doing fine.

I just don't see where people attribute all this power to "cancel culture." Chik-fil-A, Nike, ..., all doing just fine despite on-going boycotts from "cancel culture."

davvolun··on 9th Circuit holds that scraping a public website does not violate the CFAA [pdf]
IANAL, but I think you're misunderstanding "without a legitimate business reason to do so"

"Be Restaurant" blocking Deliveroo because they can't continue operating with the loss of revenue due to high fees is a legitimate business reason. "Be Restaurant" blocking Deliveroo 2: Electric Boogaloo because I don't like their owner, but continuing to allow Deliveroo access would be, presumably, disallowed.

Also there's nothing stopping "Be Restaurant" from offering an exclusive delivery contract to Deliveroo and forcing Deliveroo 2 out, or requiring a minimum fee for all delivery services, Deliveroo and Deliveroo 2 included.

Of course, I think this is all in a very different area from a restaurant; we're talking about a service provided on the internet. I believe LinkedIn has many, many other recourses here, but, as I see it, the courts are just telling them, this aint it chief.

davvolun··on 50 U.S. states and territories announce broad antitrust investigation of Google
> 4. Anyone not browsing on Chrome gets an upsell to install Chrome (MS got roasted for this with Windows Media & best used on IE)

Every time you install a new copy of Windows and switch the browser to Firefox/Chrome/whatever, you get prompted "are you sure you really want to switch from Edge? It's amazing!!!1!" Then there's the fact occasionally it will still open things up in Edge -- search for 'Amazon' in Windows Start (is that what we're calling it still?) and do "Search the web" or "Web results" and it will open Edge (in Bing). Apparently my default apps are Mail for Email, Maps for Maps, Groove Music for Music Player, nothing for Photo viewer, nothing for Video player, and Google Chrome for Web browser. I've never opened Mail, Maps or Groove Music, I've never had a problem with photos and videos opening in my preferred viewers, and Windows doesn't seem to entirely respect the Web browser setting anyway...

Antitrust against Google? Sure, but MS is still doing it's antitrust thing 20 or so years on; I'm not aware of Apple being significantly different either. Outside of the OS vendors, all of the tech companies are trying to "maximize profits" by spying on users, forcing lock-in, degrading others' services, whatever.

Point being? I don't know -- "Big Tech" sucks and there's either no taste or no competence in government for shutting down these little tricks and loopholes. Something needs to change, but I don't know how or what. Join EFF, donate money? Maybe...

davvolun··on Epstein’s Links to Scientists Are More Extensive Than Previously Thought
I wasn't making an appeal to authority, I was noting that, like I said in my first sentence, Buzzfeed and Buzzfeed News aren't the same thing. I then go on to say, for whatever it's worth, at least one study in journalism considered Buzzfeed News to be quite good; I very clearly neither agreed nor disagreed with that decision. It should also be obvious to the reader that there aren't any studies in journalism on the accuracy of Buzzfeed listicles, which would relate back to my original point, that Buzzfeed is not Buzzfeed News, for what it's worth.
davvolun··on A Message about iOS Security
Given the dire situation of security, this can't be a "let the market figure out the solution" situation. When it comes to whether Google's IoT devices work with Amazon's, I would personally love for them all to work together, but for profitability, maybe that's not in Google's best interests. That's fine.

But for security, they need to be working together. This is definitely a "rising tide lifts all boats" situation.

davvolun··on Duty, Democracy and the Threat of Tribalism
"More than half the population is happy with" is not the same as "good."

I fully believe in (representative) democracy, and with an extremely complicated issue like Brexit it needs dedicated politicians researching the issue and, ultimately, selling a solution to the public. I'm not deeply in tune with the parties in the U.K., but my general feeling has been that Labour has no fucking clue what to do, so all of the U.K. is just jumping into a yawning bottomless pit for no good reason.

davvolun··on San Francisco Declares the N.R.A. a ‘Domestic Terrorist Organization’
Excuse me for asking you to show your work, but how does this limit anyone's freedoms?

Further, are you not aware of the difference between San Francisco and say, Cupertino, Mountain View, Palo Alto... do I need to go on?

(Nevermind the astronomical housing prices and the relatively easy and affordable public transit into the city, making it more than feasible to work in the city and live elsewhere...)

davvolun··on Why Index Funds Are Like Subprime CDOs
Of course at 1%, or really, any sufficiently small and centralized number, it becomes easier and easier to game the system...

I'm thinking specifically of attempts to artificially inflate crypto coin valuations for members, then quickly sell off before anyone catches on. Should be, I would think, impossible to do that across a large area of the market, but if everyone is investing in index funds, it might be, I would guess.

Nonetheless, for my situation, index funds are the best rational solution. That or hiding all my money under my mattress.

davvolun··on Duty, Democracy and the Threat of Tribalism
> Sometimes there aren't any solutions that more than half a constituency are happy with

Which is part of the reason why most democracies in history are representative democracies; they represent the interests of their constituents, not their constituents personal choices.

A representative should properly make the decision that, in their view, presents the best possible result for their constituency, not "what their constituents would choose if they were elected."

davvolun··on Duty, Democracy and the Threat of Tribalism
That is effectively fixed by amending the statement

> Nations with ardent and sincere allies

And, clearly though certainly teetering toward "no true scotsman," an ally who is only superficially allied (Germany and the USSR during the first half of WWII, or the Allies and USSR after the war) should not be considered an "ally," for all intents and purposes.

And I think it's clear in that specific example you gave how well selling out their allies worked for U.K. and France. If "greed" is your only motivation, eventually your greedy allies will sell you out as well. See, Prisoner's Dilemma or pretty much the entire field of ethics.

davvolun··on Epstein’s Links to Scientists Are More Extensive Than Previously Thought
I'm not going to defend whether this particular instance is good journalism, but Buzzfeed is not Buzzfeed News. A 2017 study in Journalism found Buzzfeed News was comparable to NYT, for what that's worth.
davvolun··on Google's software mistreats or harms the user
> calling server-side autocomplete on a field you explicitly are typing in strikes me as about as sensible and forthright as calling an Amazon text field that takes my credit card number a card skimmer

Exactly, and waters down the impact of the termminology. If "card skimmer" is anything that can read a credit card, than the term is meaningless for security.

If "keylogger" is anything connected to the web that responds to a keypress...

GNU is risking turning into the boy who cried wolf here.

davvolun··on Personal Website for Programmers
So you're saying you wouldn't want to hire someone who put in the absolute minimum effort to meet the desired functional requirements without wasting time/money?

I think the functional requirements in this case are to impress someone who doesn't code, an HR person, etc. Because a qualified programmer manager shouldn't be particularly impressed with any personal homepage put together in a reasonable amount of time for the sole purpose of impressing a hiring manager.

There's places where it's worth it to "think outside the box" and then there are places that -- well, there's a reason we have boxes, because they work well for what they're designed to do.

davvolun··on Personal Website for Programmers
If it accomplishes the minimum functional requirements without additional time/money, isn't that the point?
davvolun··on Svalbard is as close as you can get to a place with open borders
re: issues with the Ken Burns documentary: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/why-we-need-new-civil...
davvolun··on Svalbard is as close as you can get to a place with open borders
> And there is a very large internal migration from states like New York to states like Virginia

I don't feel particularly qualified in this area, it's an interesting question though; but, this really needs a citation. I think you're making a very strong claim here, that there is a "very large" migration from New York to Virginia -- although I have a problem with the qualifier "states like" -- what does that mean? Blue/red states? Northeast/South? Does "states like Virginia" include Florida, because that feels like a pretty strong outlier for the rest of the South.

In any case, here's a little information I've found, which I don't have the time right now to seriously analyze to support or refute your statement

* https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/04/moves-from-so... * ttps://www.census.gov/data/tables/2018/demo/geographic-mobility/cps-2018.html

Then there's the issue of comparing median income, without including average or standard deviation in the analysis. And while I can see the value of adjusting for Regional Price Parity, I would be curious to see a county-by-county breakdown of New York state -- I would guess the burough of Manhattan ("New York County" apparently) would also be a dramatic outlier, statistically, compared to the rest of the state.

Lies, damn lies, and statistics, I need to see a lot more to feel convinced of either argument.

davvolun··on Svalbard is as close as you can get to a place with open borders
Having just finished re-watching Ken Burns' Civil War for the first time in 20 years or so, like a freshman psychology student who now understands the motivations of the entire world, there is a line in the documentary, stated I believe by Shelby Foote, that stuck with me

> Before the war, it was said, "The United States are." Grammatically, it was spoken that way and thought of as a collection of independent states. After the war, it was always "the United States is," as we say today without being self-conscious. That sums up what the war accomplished. It made us an "is." *

I certainly, today, think of the U.S. as a whole, not as a collection of independent states, and consider the issue of states' rights to be a generally pointless debate.

* Ignore the issues for a moment with the documentary itself and with Shelby Foote, who has stated Nathan Bedford Forrest is "one of the most attractive men who ever walked through the pages of history" -- seriously, I don't even know what to do with that. And I don't know if they did their footwork -- a textual analysis of, say, newspapers prior and subsequent to the Civil War saying "the United States are" compared to "the United States is." From what I've seen regarding issues with the documentary, I would question it, but I don't know for certain. Some things they seem to have done good scholarly work on; others, not as much.

davvolun··on Luxembourg to be first European country to legalise cannabis
If prostitution was legal, or decriminalized (I believe sex workers and advocates prefer decriminalization over legalization), everywhere, it wouldn't be much of a tourist attraction.
davvolun··on FTC: Equifax might run out of cash, so please take the credit monitoring
While I agree that this factor is stupid -- either it wasn't well-thought or it was intended to be a way to avoid fairly compensating victims, whatever.

That said, they are paying a total of about $700M, in fees and compensation and so. The actual amount is probably going to be less -- if every single person took the $125, then the $31M for credit monitoring wouldn't be used at all. But for comparison, in Q2 2019, Equifax report about $900M in revenue. So they lost a full quarter of profit out of this.

Is that fair? Does that actually give sufficient incentive to keep this from happening again, by Equifax, or by TransUnion/Experian? I don't know.

I can say I'm not happy about this, the golden parachutes are bullshit, how they sat on the hack and then tried to scapegoat an engineer over it is infuriating, but I'm sure they are scrambling to lock down their security now, if not before, and I can't realistically see the current CEO letting something like this happen again.

Although, as they say, lightning never strikes the same place twice -- they'll lock down these avenues, but what are they going to miss? Can we actually trust them not to leave other vulnerabilities? We don't really have a choice, do we? I can't opt out of their "service."

davvolun··on A janitor at Frito-Lay invented Flamin’ Hot Cheetos (2017)
I mean, it's a nice side effect of diversity, I really don't think Flaming Cheetohs, or finding Takis in every supermarket near me, are why diversity is so important.
davvolun··on America has never gone this long without hiking the federal minimum wage
There's a response to the parent comment that has real data on increasing the minimum wage. It's only two papers on one location, but until we see at least the same kind of thing on UBT, it's all wild speculation.

I don't want to be in the location that passes UBT only to see it fail wildly, but we need that data. I would certainly argue an economy the size of the U.S. or China (as if...) shouldn't experiment without better data.

Personally, I seriously doubt UBT will fail wildly, and I want to see it move forward, responsibly.

davvolun··on When Employees Use Software That IT Hasn’t Approved
Exactly, well stated. In the end, the only reason a business cares about security at all is because if they don't, it will come back and bite them, hard; e.g., Equifax.
davvolun··on When Employees Use Software That IT Hasn’t Approved
Of course that's the real question with the actual story in the actual article -- could they have implemented their security on the temporary infrastructure, or "good-enough" security, if the CIO knew about it?

In that story, is the blame on the VP for going ahead instead of getting dialogue started between CEO, VP and CIO? Is it on the CIO for just saying "no" instead of recognizing the need and the value? Is it on the CEO for failing to empower the VP and CIO to get that conversation started themselves?

And then, it's all well and good to worry about the bottom line first, until you're sitting in Equifax's shoes right.

davvolun··on When Employees Use Software That IT Hasn’t Approved
> The CIO admitted that he had been approached and explained that he had informed the VP that IT already had a project with SAP to deliver what the VP needed. “Yes, but that won’t be ready for me to use for three years, and I need something today,” retorted the VP. The CIO was silent. Then the CEO asked the VP, “I’ve known you for ten years. You don’t seem like someone who would do something to harm the company. Why did you do this?” The VP hit right back: “Since I started this digital customer acquisition program, we’ve increased revenue $1M per month. Before we were losing revenue. If you want, I can shut it down right now. What do you want me to do?”

Maybe not for this particular project, but another interpretation of that is "who cares about security if we're making money" which is a very dangerous argument as well.

davvolun··on Apple is now a privacy-as-a-service company
In practice, if not in theory, I think Android works the same way. Yes, there are other app stores, and yes you can install untrusted, but in practice, most people just use the Play Store (requiring a Google account) and if they allow untrusted or use another app store, it's not the default.

I'm not arguing Apple and Google are the same, far from, but in this area, they seem the same to me for the majority of the population. (Android user)

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →