HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

davvolun

271 karma · joined May 9, 2013

submissionscomments
davvolun··on Sweden Has a 70 Percent Tax Rate and It Is Fine
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermaphrodite
davvolun··on Availability of the Government of the United States
Absolutely, this is not really over money. I think if you look at the past few decades, Democrats have been better at being fiscally conservative, for whatever reason, but this is a battle over principles, not money.
davvolun··on Photographs of Hidden Spain
You don't see why ineffective government action that fails to do the one thing it was designed to do, but inconveniences everyone else would draw so much ire?
davvolun··on He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him
Right? I see Chris Cillizza deliberately drop the concluding sentence of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez' comment to deliberately take it out of context[1] or a single CNN journalist fabricating sources for years[2] (not to pick on CNN too much, I don't think they're any worse than most news orgs, and they're better than a good few). And I think, there are some problems there, this deserves addressing, but to take that and scream FAKE NEWS in tweets every third day; that's just stupid.

[1] https://thehill.com/homenews/media/424190-ocasio-cortez-accu... [2] https://www.cnn.com/2018/12/20/media/claas-relotius-spiegel/...

davvolun··on Why I Am Not an Austrian Economist
You say potato, I say potahto. The end result is the same, and not really relevant to my point that I really don't think anyone (in this thread) is arguing for Austrian economic theory, nor do I think anyone is threatening anyone here.

Could be wrong, just my opinion.

davvolun··on Why I Am Not an Austrian Economist
If I say Hitler was clearly a persuasive speaker, does that imply I believe Nazism?

Per my understanding, Austrian economics would presumably argue that

(1) babies are parasites (2) parasites should be eliminated (3) ergo, babies should be eliminated

AnCap CLEARLY comes to the conclusion that babies should not be eliminated, but makes no argument whatsoever on (1) or (2). In other words, if given the presumed premise of Austrian economics, the conclusion is thus flawed. You attributing this intellectual argument to the user as though they were a believer in that school of thought makes no sense to me.

This whole conversation is frustrating because I can't find anything notable you've written here which I disagree with other than that you're ascribing AnCap to this point of view.

> I also like that pretty much everything is readily available on mises.org. I wish all "schools of thought" would be this forward thinking.

"Forward thinking" in terms of making all of their information readily available; not forward thinking in terms of the entire school of thought.

And now you're claiming that AnimalMuppet is threatening to report you or get you kicked off HN. No one said that! AnimalMuppet was referencing the guidelines to say, instead of assuming that AnCap would like babies dead, read it assuming that AnCap doesn't want babies dead, and draw your conclusions from there.

davvolun··on He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him
What part of that responds to anything I said? I haven't even said (1) whether I believe the effect or not or (2) whether I have or have not experienced that effect myself. You're assuming I've made a statement one way or the other.

In the absence of scientific research, the "theory" is as true and useful as any saying "two in the hand is worth one in the bush", "a penny saved is a penny earned", ...

davvolun··on Why I Am Not an Austrian Economist
I think you can respect the authority of a professional without this type of attack. How do you know the person you're responding to isn't a tenured Professor of Economics somewhere? To respond to an article on the internet, do we all need to present our credentials?

Second, wtf?! At no point does the person you're responding to say they would let a baby starve to death. Period. They respect the idea of trying to deduce an ethical framework from first principles, but then very clearly disagree with the logically deducted conclusions. Whether it's because the framework is based on incomplete or false principles, or there is flawed logic in the process, or whatever, OP clearly does not agree with the framework.

I don't know if you didn't read carefully or what, but you're waaaay off base here.

davvolun··on Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums
That sounds crazy, I can't find any information to back up that statement. Need source.

I'm finding something back in the 90s/early 2000s that might be related; the city was handling marketing and ticket sales, so maybe there was something there (if the city fails to sell so many tickets, they have to pay). But from what I'm seeing, that hasn't been true for about 15 years.

davvolun··on Sweden Has a 70 Percent Tax Rate and It Is Fine
So, what...U.S. should stop at around 62% upper marginal tax rate?

There's a huge difference between 70% and the current U.S. marginal rate of 37% for over $500k. Argue homogeneity, small, relatively rich population all you want, we're talking about nearly double the tax rate!

davvolun··on Digitized Books from 1923 Now Available at the Internet Archive
Looks like there's a lot of McGraw-Hill Book Company (now McGraw-Hill Education, not sure if that has something to do with it) books on archive.org, particularly from the "Public Library of India." I'm wondering if these came through some digitization effort that slipped through copyright, or maybe the original digitizer had obtained specific permission for these volumes? Definitely not obvious to me.

https://archive.org/search.php?query=creator%3A%22McGraw-Hil...

davvolun··on He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him
You don't need it to be a "well-researched psychological concept" if you've personally experienced it, but that does absolutely nothing to convince me, and further, you should carefully weigh your own anecdotal experience versus others' experiences. Maybe the reporting in your particular case was just really, really bad? How would you know? Maybe 99.9% of journalism is completely accurate and you just happened to fit into the 0.1%... if you can't definitively disprove what I'm saying, then I don't think you should be so confident in your conclusion.

As for "it would find any traction if it didn't ring true with a lot of people." A lot of people throughout history have believed a lot of unscientific things. I don't believe we've reached a point of enlightenment where we no longer do that. Science not infrequently finds the truth is not what we expected, not what our intuition would lead us to believe.

davvolun··on Digitized Books from 1923 Now Available at the Internet Archive
What's the book?

There's lots of reasons why a work after 1923 might be in the public domain, but as of this year, everything before 1923 is in the public domain. I would guess FOSS/FLOSS software is probably the most likely thing people might recognize as "public domain-like" (due to the issue of taking something public domain, then copyrighting your original work on it e.g. Disney's erstwhile business model).

Copyright could have been abandoned, creator hasn't pursued their claim, it could have been specifically released by the creator, "copyleft", ...

davvolun··on Things You Can’t Say About Assange or WikiLeaks
I did not interpret the parent comment to be arguing against you, rather, I thought it was supporting your case -- Wikileaks is fully aware of their hypocrisy and is trying to stifle internal (and external) discussion about it.
davvolun··on He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him
Wow, thanks for linking to that.

Note that the "Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect" is a discussion point by a popular novelist, not a well-researched psychological concept. Frankly, without deeper research into the concept, it's a quote from an famous person.

davvolun··on Sweden Has a 70 Percent Tax Rate and It Is Fine
"It's just a simple fact of human nature" is, of course, the other right-wing dogwhistle.

"It's just a simple fact that there are only two genders"

"It's just a simple fact that white people and black people don't get along"

"It's just a simple fact that the white man was given the burden of caring for the rest of the world"

If your argument can be used to justify oppressing non-cis genders today as well as it could be used to justify oppressing African Americans during the Civil Rights Movement or earlier, I don't know that I consider it a strong argument.

davvolun··on How Did Our Medical Notes Become So Useless?
I was told your permanent record wasn't a real thing!!
davvolun··on Torrents with public domain paywalled papers from before 1923
For various reasons, I'm not able to provide a source for this. Suffice to say, just because it seems likely that you would end up winning the case doesn't mean someone with deep pockets won't do everything they can to keep you from doing it.

Does that apply to OPs argument? I don't think so; but just like Aaron Schwartz, lawyers can be quite creative when their clients are willing to pay.

davvolun··on California wants to tax text-messaging
*faxes or home phone service

oops

davvolun··on California wants to tax text-messaging
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_tax_revenue_by_state

(2015) California Revenue per capita is $10,408. Texas, the second largest state by economy in total money, is $10,204 per capita, the average is $10,234. Incidentally, California is very slightly "better" at 16.6% GSP than Texas at 17.1% GSP, and further better than the average of 18.3% GSP.

If this is a "money grab," they've got room for it, compared to other states -- say Delaware or most of the South, for example.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._state_budgets

Meanwhile, California spends $4,636 per capita on the state budget, ranking 15th lowest of the 50 states. So again, not really "burning through cash."

As is mentioned every time California's or blue states' budget and spending are brought up, blue states tend to give more federal money whereas those fiscally conservative red states tend to take in more federal money.

As for if this is the way to do it; yeah, seems a little like extra taxes on faxes home phone service at this point -- diminished returns at best.

davvolun··on What Minimum-Wage Foes Got Wrong About Seattle
To play devil's advocate (you can read my response to OP to see how I feel generally about the overall argument), it does seem to correlate that more homogeneous societies, e.g. Japan, Norway, have lower crime statistics, or lower violent crimes.

Possible reason being, the more likely you are able to socially connect with your potential victim and the less likely you are to see them as the "other," then the less likely you are to feel justified in causing them harm.

KKK feels justified because other races are inferior, the rich feel justified in exploiting the poor because poor people are lazy, e.g.

davvolun··on What Minimum-Wage Foes Got Wrong About Seattle
Are you serious? That's almost the basis for our (U.S., Western) form of government.

"Social contract arguments typically posit that individuals have consented, either explicitly or tacitly, to surrender some of their freedoms and submit to the authority of the ruler (or to the decision of a majority) in exchange for protection of their remaining rights."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract

The only thing you're actually arguing against is applying it mindlessly regardless of any other concerns, as in, the reduction of violent crime is sufficient in and of itself to be a "better end" -- in actual fact, we've seen separate but equal doesn't work.

As an aside, look at people like Marcus Garvey. As an attempt to resolve the conflict in America between black and white, complete segregation has been seriously proposed; it was not (entirely) stopped or prevented due to ethical/moral arguments. As a slightly silly example, you have a family who has been living in a home for 100 years, but the neighborhood they live in has shifted. Perhaps you use eminent domain to remove them. Now multiply that by thousands -- will they all move peacefully? Where are you getting the money for this? etc. etc.

> Even if there are good effects from legislated prices, that doesn't necessarily mean the government should dictate employment contacts.

Doesn't necessarily mean it shouldn't either. I would argue the better solution would be mandatory union participation. Unions would equalize the power imbalance between the individual worker and, say, McDonald's, without the government dictating terms. But I'm guessing you, or people who also support your argument, would balk at that as well.

davvolun··on A single-page app is almost always worse than a multi-page app
Still better than supporting IE6.
davvolun··on A single-page app is almost always worse than a multi-page app
The Web has been doing lots of things poorly for a long time as well. I know I've seen some implementations of date-pickers I don't like, and more old school implementations without date pickers that were just clumsy.
davvolun··on A single-page app is almost always worse than a multi-page app
The comparison doesn't make sense though. There's absolutely no reason you can't build an interface using single-page that functions to the end-user identically to any multi-page form. You can't necessarily do the reverse (multi-page to emulate single page), but that is also irrelevant to the top level -- if the SPA has 10 times the complexity to build an identical UI, then it's probably going to be harder to maintain for no value to the end user (which isn't to say no value).

What I got is that they built different UIs and found one of those UIs was better than the others; that says nothing about single-page vs multi-page. Maybe it was easier for them to build the "winning" UI as a multi-page app, but I didn't see that being said.

davvolun··on 42 percent of new cancer patients lose their life savings
Do any of those numbers refute my point?

Instead of saying "take a look at what's already been linked" either link something that refutes my point or make a clear argument that does so.

The statement was: > To play devil's advocate, looking at 5-year survival rates by country, you'd be 15-20% more likely to survive in the US after you contract cancer than in the Netherlands. YMMV.

I asked "Did you factor wealth into that?" and then backed it up with a hypothetical that shows how it could matter. I see no comments regarding whether the numbers given factor wealth in or if anyone can clearly show it doesn't matter. You want to challenge my claim that quality of healthcare is correlated with ability to pay, fine, but "look it up" isn't an argument.

davvolun··on 42 percent of new cancer patients lose their life savings
What study? Did it break down other factors for survival or are you arguing that the 350 million Americans all have exactly the same chance of surviving cancer?

I don't know why you're quoting "anecdote," you gave a textbook example of anecdotal evidence, which is not data. My uncle Bob survived testicular torsion, therefore all uncle Bobs will survive testicular torsion. How many people in the U.S. with that exact same cancer did not receive that particular experimental drug therapy? Did that one person, or even all the people included in the trial, change the survival rates in America during that time period?

davvolun··on 42 percent of new cancer patients lose their life savings
I responded to another commenter, Simpson's Paradox -- 67% average doesn't mean that I can expect 67%. Healthcare efficacy is correlated with wealth (i.e. cost of healthcare and ability to bear that cost). To get 67%, let's say the top 67% of Americans have a survival rate of 100% and the bottom 33% have 0% survival rate. The average is 67%, but I really hope I'm not in the bottom 33% and get cancer.

I don't know what you think a "large fraction of the population" equates to, but in this theoretical, 33% of the population being guaranteed to die isn't exactly ideal.

davvolun··on 42 percent of new cancer patients lose their life savings
Yes, but let's say in the U.S. the numbers are 100% survival for the richest 50% and 0% survival for the other 50%. Clearly the average survival rate is 50%. Now let's say the Netherlands has a flat survival rate of 50%. If I don't consider wealth, it doesn't matter which country I get care in. If I'm at 49.999% of wealth in the U.S., the difference is 0% survival vs 50%.

We know healthcare quality and healthcare cost are correlated, e.g. http://www.pnhp.org/news/2016/july/wealthy-get-more-health-c... , I think we can intuit that ability to bear cost and wealth are correlated. Outliers aside, I don't think you're going to argue to me that a homeless man in Detroit has a chance of getting the same quality of care as Jeff Bezos.

Simpson's paradox -- how you split up those percentiles matter, the question is how much.

davvolun··on 42 percent of new cancer patients lose their life savings
Did you factor wealth into that? I would hazard a guess that the bottom 20%-40% in the U.S. would have a considerably lower survival rate than the average for the rest of the country.
← PreviousPage 5 of 11Next →