HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

davvolun

271 karma · joined May 9, 2013

submissionscomments
davvolun··on Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is About to Change
> Facebook knows many drug purchases are coordinated openly on college groups

How does Facebook know this, if they still have to search them out?

> ...once this law is naturally expanded upon.

Yeah, I can see that. Slippery slope and all that. On the other hand, I feel like e.g. Facebook needs to have an incentive to police their community. I, at least, don't see a clear path to prevent Cambridge Analytica-style abuses, not through legislative changes, not in this political environment...

davvolun··on Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is About to Change
Maybe I'm not being clear...

In the absence of clear, well-considered privacy laws (which I'm not the least bit hopeful for, particularly internationally consistent..), Google will have access to this data. As a randomly chosen user, there's probably nothing I can do about this (assumption being the average random user can't figure out how to enable e2e encryption). So Google will be data mining my data, if they choose to. And note I'm only choosing Google here because the user I replied to used Gmail as an example, I don't think Google is particularly unique or special in regards to using their user's data for profit.

Under those assumptions, if Google finds something illegal, they should say something, right?

There are a number of "outs" here. Privacy laws, Google giving me the ability to opt out/encrypt my data, ...

Do I want this? Hard no, but that's really not my point.

davvolun··on Avoid Else, Return Early (2013)
Seriously.

TLDR: use guard clauses (when appropriate for readability and cognitive load)

davvolun··on Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour
I suppose I should say, "Hanlon's Razor often applies to sentencing, only occasionally to guilt"
davvolun··on Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour
That's an interesting corollary... Hanlon's razor applies to sentencing, but not to guilt.
davvolun··on Facebook is America’s scapegoat du jour
NE-02 sent an electoral vote to Obama in 2008, whereas the other 4 NE votes went to McCain. In 2010, NE-02 was gerrymandered (arguably) and all 5 votes have gone to Romney (2012) and Trump (2016) since then.

Admittedly, that's sort of an exception that proves the rule. Only NE and ME don't operate under a winner-takes-all, they've so far only split their votes once each (2008 in NE and 2016 in ME), and their votes -- certainly splitting their votes -- has never impacted the result of a Presidential election.

davvolun··on Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is About to Change
I'm really not trying to be facetious,

> If Google knows that sex traffickers are using gmail to coordinate their sex-trafficking activities, they'd be liable for "knowingly facilitating" sex trafficking

Is that not...good? If Google is reading my emails to sell me stuff (and I've given them permission to do so by using their service), and sees (reasonable) evidence I'm engaged in illegal activities, don't they have a responsibility to report that? Is that not the same thing as a GeekSquad technician stumbling across child porn on a laptop they're fixing?

Further, if Google doesn't want to knowingly facilitate, then they shouldn't know -- give me the ability to e2e encrypt my messages and stop reading my emails. Haven't they opened Pandora's box here by going that extra step further and data mining my email?

davvolun··on What America looked like before the EPA, in photos
I don't know that I'd turn to the software industry for insight on development and maintenance. Things have changed, but AFAIK we still don't have that silver bullet.
davvolun··on CIA new nominee director Gina Haspel ran a torture site and destroyed evidence
Maybe I'm just playing devil's advocate, but is what Obama did significantly different from Union soldiers under Lincoln's orders during the Civil War? The form of warfare has changed dramatically, but wouldn't that be something of a parallel?

P.S. I don't want to sound like an apologist regarding Obama's actions here. My personal feelings are that he was largely better than Bush, but not without fault.

davvolun··on Firefox 59 released
I can't really comment fairly here as I've gotten used to Chrome for the last 2+ years, but is there really not an extension in Firefox for this, even if it's not natively supported? Seems surprising to me.
davvolun··on After Decades of Growth, Colleges Find It’s Survival of the Fittest
I think the point is moreso, connecting correlation to causation is really, really, really, really hard, even for simple stuff. And sample size doesn't change that, it may even make it harder (see Simpson's Paradox re: 1964 U.S. Civil Rights Act). I don't know that the_watcher is arguing against college, more noting the underlying assumption and playing devil's advocate.
davvolun··on Securing your Linux web server
It came off as confrontational to me..., and I don't see the irony (may be poor choice of word on that though, reductio ad absurdum perhaps?)

I would think someone working in marketing at American Apparel or some fashion magazine or something could get something useful in weaving their own cloth or sewing their own clothes. Similarly towards someone reading Hacker News and running their own server.

davvolun··on It is possible to detect and block Chrome headless
Isn't that the same argument regarding ripping music CDs? If I pay for the musicians, manufacturing and distribution costs to put a CD in stores, etc.

Although, I think you're framing it wrong, you're not obligated to give the content, someone is just choosing to consume it in a way you hadn't intended.

davvolun··on One-on-one meetings are underrated, whereas group meetings waste time
When the response during meeting discussion is always "let's take that offline," then it's a waste of time. First off, no one is "online," stupid buzz-speak, but more importantly it's useful for some issues to have a small group of people work it out together so everyone is on the same page.
davvolun··on Accessing Publicly Available Information on the Internet Is Not a Crime
I've done some scraping work -- one of my rules of thumb is to always assume the worst of their site and try to be as gentle as possible.
davvolun··on High-Level Problems with Git and How to Fix Them
A decade's worth of experience vs beginner-level experience could explain the issue. Not saying it does, just that it could.
davvolun··on Introduction to web scraping with Python
I don't understand what this comment is referring to. Google's spider respects robots.txt, just block all paths and google will not crawl your site. So too for Bing, Yahoo, Baidu (some complications though, I think), Yandex.... Most of the major spiders respect robots.txt.

Is there some major Google web scraping effort I'm not aware of?

davvolun··on IGN acquires Humble Bundle
Braid was one of the three games included in "Indie Game: The Movie." What exactly would Jonathan Blow have needed to do to "market it as an indie", giant glowing arrows on the title screen saying "this is an indie"?
davvolun··on Ivy: a minimalist static site generator in Python
> https://pypi.python.org/pypi/ivy-python

Ivy: a lightweight software bus

I can't disagree. You can't even easily filter down searching 'ivy python' or similar

davvolun··on Firefox 56 supports headless mode on Windows
You could also install X server and run tests with an entire graphical stack. But if you don't have to....
davvolun··on The Foreign Visa Crackdown Is Putting Americans Out of Work
> There aren't many immigrants there

WHAT are you talking about?

> Landscaping is mostly white, maids are mostly white, and construction work is mostly white

I can't say anything about landscaping or maids, I've never noticed, but construction work is not mostly white, or at least, you can't simply discount the number of non-white construction workers.

In my experience, immigrants in the Midwest are simply more segregated than in other places.

davvolun··on Enough with the dead butterflies
I've never seen such a shocking injustice I cared so little about!
davvolun··on 'Check Your Backups Work' Day
Aaaand just found my personal backups at home haven't been running for about a month.

ALWAYS CHECK !

davvolun··on New H1-B Visa bill doubles the salary requirements to $130K/yr
Completely unrelated.

Having never viewed India Times' website before, can I say, I really like their method of pulling in infographics and backing up their statements. I'd like to see a lot more of that in the States.

davvolun··on Typing Practice for Programmers
Wha, what? vim and emacs aren't about typing speed, they're about action speed. 99% of the reason I love using vim is because I can do exactly what I can do with a combination of mouse and keyboard actions, but without leaving the keyboard. And many IDEs have, for example, vim extensions so you can get the best of vim without manually building up your vim environment and extensions (although learning e.g. PyCharm is no different than learning and building my own vim env -- I use both).
davvolun··on Hollywood as We Know It Is Over
Monsters (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monsters_(2010_film)) is my response to that. The problem with "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" wasn't that it was low budget, it was that it decided part-way through to become (relatively) high-budget. A carefully constructed film with $500,000 budget made $4.2 million back on good, but limited, effects. The problem is Hollywood's approach; instead of making a handful of single-A movies, it's all either B movies or AAA.

Video games were (?) having the same problem, so-called "indie" developers have largely stepped in to make single A-quality titles.

davvolun··on Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf]
Not technically correct:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_United_States_H...

davvolun··on “Oculus removed the headset check from the DRM in Oculus Runtime 1.5”
Are 'punitive damages' medieval? If Oculus takes anti-consumer measures, then reverses course and consumers jump back on board as if nothing ever happened, why wouldn't they re-enact those measures once they have the leverage to do so? If HTC does capture the lion's share of the market, and they see there were no long-term consequences to enacting those anti-consumer measures, why wouldn't HTC do the same?

These companies aren't your friend. As is always stated, they exist to make money, whether that's in the best interest of the consumer or not. That's capitalism, that's fine. Certainly in this space, I don't think anyone is realistically arguing that there is some better method (would the R&D emerge to create and market VR in a communist society? Seems unlikely to me). That doesn't justify not taking punitive action against anti-consumer businesses/actions (Facebook, e.g.); for the system to work, consumers need to be avidly pro-consumer.

davvolun··on Design better databases
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1732348/regex-match-open-...
davvolun··on Biggest patent troll of 2014 gives up, drops appeal
So your patent only matters if you can afford to sue someone stealing your patent? Isn't that swinging too hard the other way?
← PreviousPage 8 of 11Next →