HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

delroth

3,137 karma · joined December 3, 2009

NixOS developer and infrastructure maintainer. Dolphin Emulator (https://dolphin-emu.org/) developer. Ex-infrastructure Security Engineer, now on a long break away from full time employment.
submissionscomments
delroth··on Guix Reduces Bootstrap Seed by Half
No, that's what reproducible builds are all about: https://reproducible-builds.org/

Debian is currently sitting at around 93% of packages being reproducibly built. NixOS is close to 99% of the minimal install image set (https://r13y.com/).

delroth··on Explanation of the state of uBlock Origin and other blockers for Safari
I can't follow your reasoning. How does Google's business model justify allowing 3rd party Chrome extensions to snoop on user traffic?
delroth··on OpenBSD/loongson is still alive
One option is to get one of the many OpenWRT compatible routers -- something like 80% of them will run on a MIPS CPU (though the trend is starting to switch to ARM for more recent platforms). That's how I got started with MIPS development several years ago.

Or if you want to go less standard (e.g. won't run Linux), get a modded PlayStation 1 :-)

delroth··on Nvidia CEO says Google is the only customer building its own silicon at scale
Project Zero is a tiny subset of Google's security team. And while they do have an unusual concentration of extremely competent security researchers, it's not like they are the only competent security researchers/engineers in the company. Similar research happens internally, at all levels of the stack, including designing silicon (e.g. Titan chips that were shown publicly).
delroth··on Why GNU/Linux Viruses Are Fairly Uncommon
r13y.com tracks the progress for NixOS reproducibility (well, for the tiny subset of nixpkgs that forms the minimal ISO image at least).
delroth··on The PGP Problem
And downgrade attacks are mitigated by MTA-STS: https://www.hardenize.com/blog/mta-sts

Not supported by everyone just yet since this is a new standard, but Gmail at least supports it.

delroth··on Google CTF 2019
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capture_the_flag#Computer_secu...

https://ctftime.org/ctf-wtf/

delroth··on Only 13% of UK adults trust big tech firms with handling anonymized NHS data
Anyone got a link to the actual poll and/or the precise questions that were asked? As far as I can tell the original source for this article is a press release from a UK digital healthcare company [1]. There is a fairly obvious conflict of interest there, since big tech firms here means "our competition". It could very well be leading questions, results cherry-picking, etc.

[1] https://www.sensynehealth.com/insights/yougov-survey-shows-u...

Disclaimer: I work at Google, not on anything related to health or AI or ML.

delroth··on VLC 3.0.7 and security
> If you've listened to some of my talks or spoke to me (I'm sorry for you), you know I'm a bit critic of those programs, because they give money to find the issues, not to fix them.

>> What about you give money to VLC instead of random hackers?

> Well, security is important, so this is cool for our users, but still this is a mixed bag, for me.

I've asked that question to Julia Reda a few months ago, and I think the answer was pretty interesting. It boils down to the absence of companies that provide this service ("security bugfix bounties") and are also willing to deal with basically being an EU contractor. So instead the EU-FOSSA bounties went to HackerOne, which is not perfect but is a step in the right direction that could be implemented immediately.

Also note that Google does provide bounties for security patches and hardening (https://www.google.com/about/appsecurity/patch-rewards/ -- VLC or ffmpeg are not in there, but many base libraries are) and for integrating FOSS projects into their fuzzing frameworks (https://www.google.com/about/appsecurity/patch-rewards/autof...). I don't know of any other company providing this kind of bounties for FOSS devs.

delroth··on Zanzibar: Consistent, Global Authorization System
https://mobile.twitter.com/LeaKissner/status/113669152310428...
delroth··on Zanzibar: Consistent, Global Authorization System
Zanzibar is basically the brainchild of a Bigtable Tech Lead + a Principal Engineer from Google's security and privacy team [1]. This led to a very sound and robust original design for the system. But it also greatly evolved over time as the system scaled up and got new clients with new requirements and new workloads.

[1] https://twitter.com/LeaKissner/status/1136626971566149633

delroth··on AMP pages displaying your own domain
https://blogs.bing.com/Webmaster-Blog/September-2018/Introdu...

Disclaimer: I work at Google, nothing related to AMP or search.

delroth··on Exercises in Emulation: Xbox 360’s FMA Instruction
They do. A trivial example is input recording for replays -- if you don't have a very similar FP implementation, the replays will desync: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XxGg1TCpYrc

Collision detection is sometimes also very FP sensitive. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hwuz2U1JV8 fixed by https://github.com/dolphin-emu/dolphin/pull/390

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEbmrwnYaXs has a few more examples we've documented.

delroth··on RPCS3 PS3 Emulator – January 2019 Progress Report
Not even. There was an emulator for the Wii U while the console was still seeing new releases, and no "chasing" happened. Similarly, there are at least 2 Switch emulators in development, and I haven't heard of any legal trouble from their side. Same for the 3DS, etc.
delroth··on We Need Chrome No More
> Wait, is this accurate? I remember back when Chrome was released, people were talking about how it used parts of both WebKit and Gecko, and the exact specs of which rendering was used changed based on the website.

You are misremembering. Chrome never used Gecko.

> I remember not liking Chrome the moment it came out. Google had poured money into Firefox for years and then suddenly came out with (an initially) closed source competitor. Sure it's open source now, but it didn't start that way

This is completely false. Chromium and its associated source code were released to the public at the same time as Chrome. See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromium_(web_browser)#2008

delroth··on Google Ends Forced Arbitration for Employees
Note that the OSPO policies have largely changed since you've left Google. What you describe was definitely the situation as of 3-4 years ago, but don't describe how open sourcing code or contributing to FOSS projects works these days.
delroth··on Where Glaciers Melt Away, Switzerland Sees Opportunity
Quite the opposite, it's a perfect example. Nuclear is also the safest means of energy production if you account for deaths caused by pollution, mining, and other indirect factors.

And similar to air travel, people think it's unsafe because of constant fear mongering and focus on incidents that are statistically insignificant. There were more people who died at Fukushima because of the evacuation procedures than the expected long term death toll from radiation exposure (and, notably, there were 0 deaths directly caused by the incident).

delroth··on Google Edge TPU Devices
What is your source for Google having moved on from MapReduce in 2004 (date when the MR paper was published)?
delroth··on Jabra: we know our Bluetooth headsets don’t work with laptops
There is support for better codecs on Linux, it's just not shipped by default on most distros unfortunately. https://github.com/EHfive/pulseaudio-modules-bt
delroth··on No more XS4ALL is unthinkable
I'm perfectly comfortable sending my DNS traffic to 8.8.8.8. I have a pretty good understanding of how Google handles my DNS data, and I don't have any specific reason to trust Cloudflare better.
delroth··on No more XS4ALL is unthinkable
Same experience here. Tweeted at them saying my latency to Hetzner had regressed by 10ms (w/ smokeping graph as proof). They replied the next day saying "we fixed it", and actually improved latency by an extra 5ms from my previous baseline :-)

It's still a magical feeling for me to have a stable 0.8ms latency to 8.8.8.8 (0.7ms if I plug in directly to my media converter without any switching equipment in the way).

delroth··on We are Google employees – Google must drop Dragonfly
This is very relevant: https://theintercept.com/2018/09/21/google-suppresses-memo-r...
delroth··on Dutch DPA: Uber fined for data breach
Nothing to do with GDPR, in fact the breach predates it (2016). The Netherlands already had regulations in place that mandate reporting data breaches, through the Dutch Data Protection Act.
delroth··on Every 7.8μs your computer’s memory has a hiccup
You say "gaming consoles", but really I think I've only seen it in the Xbox 360. Was it deployed anywhere else that I missed?
delroth··on Google’s cloud business under Greene was plagued by internal clashes
GCP has zones in India, Singapore, HK, Taiwan and Tokyo (+ Osaka planned). https://cloud.google.com/about/locations/

Disclaimer: I work at Google, am technically part of Cloud, do not work on anything related to GCP.

delroth··on Mtime comparison considered harmful
You're looking at the 90th percentile, he's looking at the 99th percentile. Claiming things like "everyone uses UTC internally" is obviously wrong when many people just a few years ago were still setting up systems in localtime when dual booting with Windows. Upgrading to ext4 is also not a rare edge case.
delroth··on Ask HN: Does Shareware still work in 2018?
https://www.patreon.com/seriallos (number 17) is software. So is https://www.patreon.com/RaiderIO (number 99).
delroth··on JavaScript is now required to sign in to Google
/64 and /48 are pretty much on the same order of magnitude as IPv4s in terms of difficulty of acquisition, and I don't know why you would ever look at more than /64 when most major operating systems randomize the last 64 bits anyway (RFC4941).
delroth··on JavaScript is now required to sign in to Google
Most bad actors doing abuse at scale have access to large networks of proxies on residential or mobile IPs, usually backed by malware on workstations, laptops and mobile phones.

Even as a newcomer without the right contacts on the black market you can get started with very little upfront investment, using services like https://luminati.io/ (they pay software developers to bundle their proxy endpoints within their apps).

delroth··on Executive accused of harassment at Alphabet 'X' unit is out
Your sources disagree with your statement.

In [1]: > The updated version of Google’s code of conduct still retains one reference to the company’s unofficial motto

[2] is not about Google and explicitly says: > Google, which will going forward be a subsidiary of Alphabet, is retaining the creedo however.

← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →