HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

delsarto

1,116 karma · joined March 30, 2011

submissionscomments
delsarto··on Report from the VMware GPL court hearing
Glibc is a bad example, as they have explict linkage exceptions

There seems to be some thought that vmware are idiots and copied a bunch of Linux code and didn't release it. It's more about when something becomes a derivative work. Much more subtle

delsarto··on Report from the VMware GPL court hearing
What did you expect them to say? Linux is a huge part of what we do?

Here's how I see it. Vmkernel has a driver API. It's documented, versioned, comes with a ddk and has drivers written directly to it.

As we all know, Linux basically has driver apis. They are not as explicit as the vmkernel driver apis; they are not versioned and deliberately unstable - but if you've written a line of kernel code you know they are there.

Now it seems it is OK to ship a binary blob driver that links against Linux driver apis. Nvidia, ati, lots of arm type boards and now zfs. I say seems because, well, so far everyone has pretty much gone along with it. In some of the comments on zfs, I see people go as far to say that the Linux driver APIs are tacitly considered lgpl (ie. similar to why you can ship a binary against glibc - although obviously glibc has made the exception explicit)

Can I do the reverse? Implement a GPL licensed wrapper that converts the Linux driver API to one provided by a binary blob (ie. what vmklinux does talking to vmkernel) and thus use the drivers?

I don't know, I think it's a good question to find an answer to.

delsarto··on South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club
There is a big deal made of this in "The Men Who Built America" [1] which I started watching because it came up on Netflix. Maybe it is new there and people have started watching it

[1] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2167393/

delsarto··on VMWare Taken to Court Over GPL Violation
I don't think it is as clear cut at all, but that makes it much more interesting. I left a comment there, but it bears some repeating I think

ESXi's kernel does not bootstrap itself from Linux at all.

There is no linux kernel as such [1]

ESXi does reuse linux kernel drivers ... a lot of them. But the way this happens is through a well-defined API provided by (proprietary) vmkernel called vmkapi. What you are seeing in the code above is the mapping between various Linux API's and these calls to the vmkernel.

I have no idea about the complaint. VMware's position is probably that anyone can go and write anything they want against the vmkernel's vmkapi interface. Indeed some vendors ship drivers written espeically for this API.

VMware have chosen to write a linux<->vmkapi interface, which then allows them to re-use many linux drivers. All of the linux<->vmkapi interface is released, along with the drivers and any modifications and this is considered sufficient. My guess is that the software conservatories position is that it is not.

Note exactly the other thing happens on the "other" side -- between user-land and the vmkernel. ESXi uses glibc ... but of course that interfaces to vmkernel via standard system calls. Maybe that's part of it too, I don't know.

So this may be a fight over API boundaries and where the GPL starts and stops. That's quite interesting...

[1] There was with the ESX product, which shipped a version of Red Hat. That hasn't been around for ages

delsarto··on Be your own VPN provider with OpenBSD
Most probably it has been added, my notes from this are from 2008 so it's hardly cutting edge! :)
delsarto··on Be your own VPN provider with OpenBSD
I think the fact that this leaks DNS lookups is really quite key because that gives away a huge amount about what you're looking at over your "vpn", not to mention services like netflix that are pointing you to different responses based upon the source of your dns lookups.

In firefox you want to go to about:config page and turn on network.proxy.socks_remote_dns

delsarto··on Dyson 360 Eye
"17,000 rpm with digital pulse technology" ... I guess that means a PWM DC motor controller?
delsarto··on What actually happens when you plug in a USB device? (2007)
When I wrote this, I'm not sure if the iPhone had been released; certainly at that point if you were carrying around something computer-like in your (large :) pocket (more powerful than a PalmPilot) it was something like a Jornada http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jornada_(PDA)

This sort of form-factor came directly out of things calld "palmtop pc's" like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP_95LX

delsarto··on What actually happens when you plug in a USB device? (2007)
(original author here)

Yeah, it was done after I was asked to run a short course on writing drivers, so the focus was on understanding that sort of layer.

But you want to know how old this is? I actually used the word "palmtop" :)

delsarto··on Computer Science from the Bottom Up
(Author of the linked book)

Funny you mention that Petzold book; I read that as an IT student doing airy courses about software requirements and design and realized I had to get across to the electrical engineering building. I didn't have the prereqs for the OS course, so I did the first assignment from the previous year and sent it to Gernot and begged to be let in. He ended up my thesis supervisor.

(The other person I remember not being totally thrilled with the IT courses was Scott Farquhar, of billionaire Atlassian fame)

So that book can change your life, and is the first thing I tell people to read who show an interest in the systems area

delsarto··on Computer Science from the Bottom Up
(author here)

This book was created both from my experiences and the experiences of teaching 3rd year operating systems classes.

Students came in to that class having done a 2nd year class (data structures and algorithms I think) that was done with a lot of C. They really learnt "high-level" C, enough syntax to get by in the their course, but most didn't really understand it -- not enough to read the source to any kernel at any rate. I don't imagine it's done like that today; this was a long time ago.

And most didn't really understand binary and hex, and how it relates to code either. You'd be amazed most 3rd year students didn't know how 2^10, 2^20, 2^30 relates to kilo, mega, giga bytes.

The book needs a lot of editing, something I occasionally get to. But apart from the odd times someone posts it to here or reddit and people consider it like a text book, it's really only ever accessed by people googling for a specific topic. But suggestions are welcome and I'll consider it when I get some time.

And on the "it's not computer science". The first commit was 10 years ago and people have been telling me that ever since. It was originally dreamed up as a course I'd teach to high-schoolers over 10 weeks to prepare them better for university -- the "computer science" degree they were planning to take. Yes, the book is really more about what would be called "systems" in the outside world.

delsarto··on Willem Pinckaers on Akamai's flawed OpenSSL allocator patch
None, it's good work.

But the whole episode, and this post in particular, highlights the issue that enough review is never enough. When is the the code secure? When it is written by someone with a good track record? When it gets reviewed and committed by knowledgeable parties? When it's been running for several years without incident? When it passes coverity? When Willem has time to review it?

When I just think about the embedded ssh keys I've got in my few toy systems; if I discovered ssh was broken (and it's happened; look at the Debian bug) I'd be sinking a lot of time figuring out just how to change the keys everywhere. I should have designed for this from the start; lesson learnt. I bet there's lots of admins out there who wish they had better ways to update certs on a moments notice over the past week...

delsarto··on Willem Pinckaers on Akamai's flawed OpenSSL allocator patch
Yep; not easy at all ... if it were easy everyone would do it :) I think with tools like puppet and orchestration tools like heat, etc it is getting closer to being easier.

I did got to a Netflix talk once where they said that while moving from AWS would huge, they had a plan and I think from memory they said it would take about a week.

delsarto··on Willem Pinckaers on Akamai's flawed OpenSSL allocator patch
A review by a security engineer would have prevented a false sense of security

Everyone involved in this, from the people who wrote the heartbeat code, the people who committed the code, the people at Akami who wrote this patch, this poster ... all would describe themselves as security engineers. Is everyone but Willem Pinckars incompetent?

I think the one lesson to learn is to treat crypto just like you do cloud providers. Make sure you have an exit strategy from day one; the ability to push a button to roll keys, switch algorithms, switch cert providers, etc.

delsarto··on Mtgox.com is gone
I was trying to get a copy of my transaction history at the time, after someone mentioned it might be handy in a class action suit

First the server started responding "this page does not exist" then just blank response

---

http://data.mtgox.com/api/2/BTCUSD/money/ticker

is still online right now

---

http://www.reddit.com/user/SarahCoinBit

It was a pleasure serving this community..marion and myself just got laid off.

(very likely fake...)

---

http://siliconangle.com/blog/2014/02/24/coinbase-blockchain-...

Sources close to the issue, in touch with SiliconAngle, have confirmed that more than 700,000 bitcoins are indeed missing from MtGox’s coffers as has been rumored during the history running up to this shutdown.

---

for anyone catching up, gox.com seems to be sold to mtgox.com in the last few days

http://www.domaininvesting.com/andy-booth-sells-gox-com/

---

http://www.scribd.com/doc/209050732/MtGox-Situation-Crisis-S...

likely fake "MtGox Situation Crisis Strategy Draft" suggesting coins went missing over a long period

---

http://goxbalance.com/

not scientific but interesting

---

http://support.mtgox.com/

has gone down - just a zendesk "no account" page

---

http://www.reddit.com/r/BitcoinMarkets/comments/1yuuok/daily...

good reddit overview comment

---

(11:27:31 PM EST )something changed in the output of http://data.mtgox.com/api/2/BTCUSD/money/ticker; a unicode character

  "value":"96836.53176413","value_int":"9683653176413","display":"96,836.53\u00a0BTC","display_short":"96,836.53\u00a0BTC","currency":"BTC"},"last_local
---

(11:30 PM EST) LTC/EUR showing up in https://data.mtgox.com/api/2/LTCUSD/money/ticker

  "value":"0.00000000","value_int":"0","display":"0.00\u00a0LTC","display_short":"0.00\u00a0LTC","currency":"LTC"},"last_local":  {"value":"0.00000","value_int":"0","display":"0.00\u00a0\u20ac","display_short":"0.00\u00a0\u20ac","currency":"EUR"},"last_orig"
---

http://recode.net/2014/02/24/the-mt-gox-bitcoin-exchange-has...

“Mt. Gox has confirmed it will file bankruptcy in private discussions with other members of the bitcoin community.”

(Re/code has so far been unable to independently verify that claim)

---

http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1yuyx4/hey_charlie_...

takeover rumours from Charlie Shrem

delsarto··on Thoughts from Open Stack insider on fragmentation and politics
A response [1] by Pete Zaitcev, another insider

[1] http://zaitcev.livejournal.com/220213.html

delsarto··on Falcon 9 GEO Transfer Mission
Aborted second time -0:48; engines didn't start this time and someone on the live stream called "abort"

listened back to the stream

"abort abort abort - props con(?) abort"

at about 1h:58m in the stream

EDIT : announcer did say that engineering stopped it because they hadn't done their review. Maybe the "abort abort abort" wasn't as dramatic as it sounded

"We called manual abort. Better to be paranoid and wrong. Bringing rocket down to borescope engines ... Elon Musk (@elonmusk) "

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/statuses/406209289494462464

delsarto··on Falcon 9 GEO Transfer Mission
Just said that they're putting a bit more fuel on in the hopes of trying again if the engineers can figure out what went wrong, their window is about an hour.

Also said that if not today, they have more or less the same window tomorrow

EDIT: someone just said starting the clock momentarily ... looks like they might be going again

delsarto··on HDMI 2.0 officially announced
Hmm how will monster cables and the like sell their stuff when the standard makes clear that existing cables can already handle the greatly increased bandwidth? I look forward to the spin!
delsarto··on Hyperloop
Just FYI, [sic] is used when you're quoting something with a mistake and you wish to indicate that mistake is in the source document, and not added unintentionally.
delsarto··on Hyperloop
The distance is just about what I commuted on a bus for many, many years, also with no facilities.

In peak hour it would probably be fine, when everyone is fairly sensible and not drunk. But after hours, I've had quite a few uncomfortable bus rides due to the various anti-social behaviours of fellow passengers. That was with the hand-brake of a driver who obviously isn't getting involved, but can avoid escalating behaviour by stopping the bus or calling authorities.

I have great faith in the technology! I just wish I had as much faith in the people riding inside it :)

delsarto··on Hyperloop
No toilet, and no way to get off, or even really stand up? I know some personal jets lack such facilities, but they're not exactly open to the public. At least on BART you can move away from the crazy...
delsarto··on Theoldreader.com down for "a day or two" due to database restore
Seeing as digg reader just go "only view unread" and "mark as unread" [1] it's pretty much feature complete for me. I found theoldreader has a bit more "information density" but maybe one day digg will make a compact mode like gmail

[1] http://blog.digg.com/post/55816621304/digg-reader-view-only-...

delsarto··on Why I won’t buy another subsidized Android phone
How is the phone "subsidized" anyway; Apple or Android? Consider, say, buying a 32gb iPhone 5 in Australia on Optus, for a 4GB unlimited plan is $3,120.00 over 24 months [1].

Or, you go and buy the phone from Apple for $899.00, and use Optus prepay for 4gb @ $70/month == (899 + (70 *24)) = 2579 [2] (I noticed this expired after 28 days; so maybe add another month cumulative).

Of course, as Scott Adams says the only reason all these companies exist is the "confuseopoly" they create with various different plans that are the same but slightly different with no clear benefits. So maybe my maths is wrong, but good luck figuring it out in clear terms anyway. In Australia with all the "$20 for $275 value" bull-crap it's especially bad. At least in the US it's just plain "minutes" and M/B.

I think really it's the same with Android phones ... deliberate confuseopoly. I agree with the author; after getting a cheap, underpowered, bloatware, never updated Android piece-of-crap I have a simple rule -- Nexus or nothing.

[1] https://smb.optus.com.au/opfiles/Shop/All/cis/Cis%20Document...

[2] https://www.optus.com.au/shop/prepaidmobile/prepaidoffers

delsarto··on Proverbial Wallets
"Exhibited at Ars Electronica 2009".

It also resists opening when your account is low, and inflates or deflates depending on how much you have in your account. It's more an art project I think...

delsarto··on GCC calls for Iran nuclear plant inspection
"Gulf Co-operation Council raises concerns of possible radiation leaks after earthquake near Bushehr nuclear plant."

in case like me, you wondered what a compiler had to do with Iranian nuclear policy.

delsarto··on Bitcoin falls from $266
I signed up for mt.gox about a week ago, at that time the verification queue was >10,000 and I'm still about 5000 now. My plan was to buy one bitcoin to gamble with; presumably that was the plan of the several thousand others in the queue as well. So, based on that, with something like 1000 new verified (hence able to easily trade) people coming into mt.gox a day, I'd expect this to go on for a while...
delsarto··on Australia Post's free Amazon locker-style service
except they don't deliver on Saturday, don't pick-up mail from your mailbox and a letter costs 60c instead of 44c
delsarto··on JavaScript video technology only 17 years in the making
This seems to work by periodically grabbing a data file like http://www.dsny.com/g2/data/arizona/13m.1, and then the javascript appears to extract base64 encoded .jpgs out of that which it plays back to make the video?

What's interesting is that each of the jpg's appear to have big black portions, so it's obviously doing a sort of overlay/compression type thing and stitching complete images back together.

Anyone got any clues on the audio part?

delsarto··on The Industrial Design of Lenovo's X1 Carbon

  THE THINNEST 14" ULTRABOOK™.
  THINKPAD X1 CARBON
  Less than 3 pounds
  Carbon fiber construction
  Embedded 3G connectivity
  Lenovo RapidCharge
  X1 CARBON AVAILABLE AUGUST 2012
August? Why announce it now? As if the literally 40 or 50 different models of laptop on the Lenovo website aren't already confusing enough...
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →