This makes sense, as the models are an average of the code out there and some of us are above and below that average.
Sorry btw I do not want to offend anyone who feels they do garner a benefit from LLMs, just wanted to drop in this idea!
614 karma · joined October 31, 2016
Socials: - github.com/ydennisy - linkedin.com/in/dennisyurkevich - x.com/ydennisy_
Interests: AI/ML, Data Science, DevOps, Entrepreneurship, Programming, Startups, Web Development
---
This makes sense, as the models are an average of the code out there and some of us are above and below that average.
Sorry btw I do not want to offend anyone who feels they do garner a benefit from LLMs, just wanted to drop in this idea!
> If you already have the fundamentals neccessary to call yourself a software developer
Yes, but do you not need to learn more? Do you not need to train what you know to keep it at your fingertips?
I think most would agree our memory has gotten worse since we have access to digital phone books, web search etc. This is because the mind does not need to store these things anymore.
The process here would be the same, your coding ability will degrade over time if not used.
> I also think if your product idea is so sensitive to a launch timeline that precludes manual coding not to fail, then you have a bigger problem.
I think here you just over reached with your point. If I can test and iterate x features / ideas vs 10x in the same month longer period, its fair to say that 10x would be deemed a better velocity with more chance of success. It is not based on my "idea".
Not sure I agree however, just reading LLM replies is not learning, it may feel like it but its not going to sink in. To truly learn you must grind hard at something for it to be lodged in your mind.
At least this I believe to be the case for most of us humans...
If you are going to write the code, you need to understand the full problem space, at which point you can see the simple solution.
If I need to figure this out, writing the code is not a problem and Claude becomes mostly an annoyance.
I still feel that for large project, and large changes within those projects - I should write the code myself.
The code outputted often runs, especially after a few attempts of fixes etc. However when I read the code later, I can see often it could have been done in a much simpler way.
Maybe this is just a naive opinion it I do not get why you must target a framework at all VS just pure CSS/HTML and later allow people to convert into their framework.
I feel that at the design stage a framework should not be discussed, since that is an implementation detail.
One question is why the coupling to Next/React? I feel a design tool should not be coupled to a web framework at all.
This is cool for links, but often I also want some nuggets/ideas to be saved.
What you suggest is a nice UC for sure, but not sure it will make any of us smarter in the long run.
But do you not believe there is some value in trying to store some of what you found / learnt each day, to allow you to make some new connections in the brain the following days?
With data I think that is very hard, I wrote a SQL query (without AI) which ran and showed what look like correct numbers only to years later realise it was incorrect.
When doing more complex calculations, I am not clear how to check if the output is correct.
Also I believe there are some open source directories and Anthropic themselves are planning to launch or have launched a directory, so an NPM for MCPs.
I would love to hear how people use this product once they have stored the links!
Would be interested to hear how people are getting on with Tana (https://tana.inc/), the tool from which this idea was borrowed.