HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

deogeo

6,740 karma · joined November 28, 2018

submissionscomments
deogeo··on How to fight lies, tricks, and chaos online
Ironically, that section itself contains an extremely misleading statement:

> The data also showed that the Conservative Party received significantly more airtime than the Labour Party. In 2012 Conservative leader David Cameron outnumbered Labour leader Ed Miliband in appearances by a factor of nearly four to one (53 to 15)

No mention that in 2012, Cameron was the Prime Minister, so naturally he'd receive more attention.

deogeo··on What DoorDash pays, after expenses, and what’s happening with tips
> DoorDash's "innovation" is the black box to obscure the fact.

Classic information asymmetry exploitation, only in this case, they're the ones that created the asymmetry.

deogeo··on Washington pressures TSMC to make chips in US
I don't know about Northrup Grumman, but General Electric, also a major defense contractor, could fire anti-Iraq-war hosts from MSNBC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_Donahue#MSNBC_program
deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
> I'm confused about how you got to your first point. You cited figures from the survey paper that show a spike at 0% genetic (meaning that a bunch of the people surveyed think there's a very low genetic influence on intelligence),

No no no - the spike is not at "very low", but at zero. While the people that believe there's some genetic influence, are about evenly distributed between thinking that influence is anywhere from 10% to 90%. In total, more believe there's some influence than zero influence.

> I wouldn't call that scientific support for the notion of race as a meaningful category.

Neither is it a consensus debunking it. And what the idea used to be is irrelevant to the current understanding.

> argue that there's any way to say that there isn't an overwhelming environmental cause for disparities in socioeconomic status/IQ/incarcaration rates/etc between blacks and whites.

But I never argued that. A and B aren't mutually exclusive.

As for Occam's razor, well, claiming that of all the genetic distance caused by geographical separation for tens of millenia, none of it affects intelligence or personality - that just doesn't seem very likely to me. It's not the case for dogs [1], why should it be for humans?

[1] https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/canine-corner/201304...

deogeo··on The technology pushed into schools today is a threat to child development
> universal public education is a recent thing.

Not that recent - it's been around since the 1750s:

"The education reform was met with hostility particularly by peasants who wanted the children to work in the fields instead. Maria Theresa crushed the dissent by ordering the arrest of all those opposed." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Theresa#Education

deogeo··on How The New York Times Verified the Iran Missile-Strike Footage
> which is that an authoritarian regime is never a good thing.

Yes, it is better for a superpower to fabricate evidence for a war [1] resulting in an estimated six hundred thousand dead [2] (and a few corporate-friendly laws [3]), than letting an authoritarian regime stand. But I'm sure this time, things will work out better.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationale_for_the_Iraq_War

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Iraq_War

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/100_Orders

deogeo··on Iran’s attack on Iraq shows how precise missiles have become
On US bases* in Iraq, that are there (or are used by the US), because the US invaded Iraq.
deogeo··on “Customer support at Tesla is even worse than I claimed last time”
I don't know why you're being downvoted, because what you said is more or less correct:

"But section 19 of that EU directive explicitly allows sellers of digital goods to ask users to waive that right before they make the purchase, provided the digital goods are delivered immediately." -- https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/03/sorry-europe-you-stil...

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
> Looking at the SD in the survey responses suggests that the position of the researchers polled in this survey wasn't accurately represented by the quote you posted.

There's one or two charts in the article, showing how many experts believe the IQ gap is 0% genetic, how many believe it's 10%, and so on, up to 100%. There's a large spike at 0%, then a noisy, mostly equal distribution up to 100%, where it drops back down to near zero - i.e. almost no hereditarian believes environment plays no role. So yes, there's no consensus, but the view that IQ is hereditary is well represented among experts - moreso than the opposite.

The Flynn effect disproves nothing, much like the increasing average height doesn't imply height isn't heritable. As I don't believe IQ is 100% determined by genes, there's any number of explanations that are consistent with heritable intelligence - changes in culture, environment, upbringing, nutrition, air quality, levels of athleticism, etc. For example:

"Similarly, researchers have shown that differences in the ways boys and girls spend their time (e.g., playing with Legos) (Bornstein et al., 1999), toy selection (Goldstein, 1994), and computer videogame experience (Quaiser-Pohl et al., 2006) are responsible for differences in their spatial abilities, also loaded on g."

> The example you use to critique the video I posted is also not very generous

The example was to show the video author was being deliberately misleading, going out of his way to hide data that opposes his conclusion. Meaning everything else in the video is probably similarly cherry-picked.

> what is intelligence anyway and how can it be measured, if at all?

I don't see how minor fuzzyness in the definition of intelligence casts any doubt on clearly defined IQ scores, especially when IQ has been shown to be such a useful and important measure - IQ is very predictive for success at other tasks also considered to require intelligence, such as academic achievement - this is referred to as being g-loaded. Moreover, the more g-loaded a test is, the more heritable performance on it is [2].

> Another relevant question is what exactly is the scientific support for "race" as anything other than a meaningless label[0]?

Race is simply how closely related people are, at a very coarse level, where clusters correspond to races. See this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22052174

[1] https://www.cato-unbound.org/2007/11/13/stephen-j-ceci/signi...

[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4437459/

deogeo··on Researchers find inverse correlation between advertising and life satisfaction
> their task is to simply provide information

Hilarious, when advertisements provide so incredibly little information, except how the product looks when held by attractive people, or driven by them along empty roads. And what little information they do provide, comes in tiny font after an asterisk at the bottom of the ad, that they were legally forced to include.

deogeo··on Mathematicians divided over hiring practices requiring promotion of diversity
> Carrie Diaz Eaton, a computational scientist at Bates College, agrees. Building diversity, she says, requires “explicitly encouraging our junior colleagues and mentoring and cultivating their talents and enthusiasm for this work.”

According to the diversity statement grading guidelines, encouraging junior colleagues, regardless of race, earns the least points, unless you explicitly favor those of under-represented backgrounds: http://ofew.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/rubric_to_asses...

deogeo··on 'The West' is, in fact, the world's biggest gated community
> those who want and can afford to move to X, but are prevented because of a non-reciprocal policy by X.

It's easy to have open borders if hardly anyone takes advantage of it, so looking at reciprocity isn't very relevant. Faced with rising immigration, non-Western countries tend to adopt restrictions as well (see NPR link on Brazil).

Furthermore, China will only grant citizenship to ethnic Chinese, whereas the West takes in many Chinese immigrants, so in this case, the non-reciprocity is in the other direction. A quick search failed to turn up what restrictions other non-Western countries have, but there's no lack of border walls - a few random examples from every non-Western continent:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/india-installs-laser-wall...

https://www.seeker.com/why-india-is-building-the-longest-bor...

https://thediplomat.com/2019/01/will-pakistans-wall-work/

https://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonchang/2016/11/13/chinas-b...

https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2013/05/16/184524306/...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/22/western-sahara...

deogeo··on 'The West' is, in fact, the world's biggest gated community
Sure has a lot of immigration from outside the West for a gated community [1]. On the other hand, non-Western countries have near-zero Western immigration, or even inter-continental migration among themselves. So much so that, when viewed with a granularity on the scale of an India, China, or North-/Sub-Saharan Africa, they're nearly perfectly homogeneous, in stark contrast to the "closed, gated" West.

[1] https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2018/03/14/the-us-...

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
> If they do want scientists to be free to investigate the genetic and other bases of IQ further in order to find better answers

It's quite obvious they don't want that, so they can continue to stretch the remaining gaps in knowledge enough to fit the entire blank slate hypothesis inside.

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
So showing a correlation between environment and intelligence is clear proof that environment plays a role, but the same kind of correlation with ancestry tells us nothing? Even when economic [1] and environmental factors [2] are corrected for (to the best of our ability), and the differences persist?

No matter what the data is, you can always construct some convoluted theory by which ancestry doesn't play a role, just like you can keep adding spheres to make a geocentric solar system work.

[1] http://www.jbhe.com/latest/news/1-22-09/satracialgapfigure.g...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minnesota_Transracial_Adoption...

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
Apply principal component analysis to human DNA, and not only does race pop out, it even coincides with the 'socially constructed' categories [1,2,3]. A 2009 survey of physical anthropologists in Europe by Katarzyna Kaszycka found that 51% (N=123) recognize biological race - 33% in Western Europe, and 70% in Eastern Europe [4]. In a review of China's only biological anthropological journal Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 324 article from the 1982-2001 period that dealt with human variation. The researchers found that "all of the articles used the race concept and none of them questioned its value" [5].

[1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Principal_compon...

[2] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Individual-level_hum...

[3] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:3D_PCA_plot_of_Xavan...

[4] http://sci-hub.tw/10.1111/j.1548-1433.2009.01076.x

[5] https://lesacreduprintemps19.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/on-...

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
Dr. Francis is either unfamiliar with, or being profoundly misleading of, expert opinion, as surveys show:

"In the current study, EQCA experts wereasked what percentage of the US Black-White differences in IQ is, in their view, due to environment or genes. In general, EQCA experts gave a 50–50 (50% genes, 50% environment) response with a slight tilt to the environmental position (51% vs. 49%; Table 3). When EQCA experts were classified into discrete categories (genetic, environmental, or 50–50), 40% favored an environmental position, 43% a genetic position, and 17% assumed 50–50." - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intell.2019.101406

> I think this video [1], does a good job of attacking a lot of race science and intelligence

'Attacking' is a good description, as the author of that video went to great lengths to mislead. For example, he says the author of The Bell Curve doesn't understand what 'hereditary' means. But the definition the video author gives for 'hereditary', and the definition given in the book he's reviewing, match almost perfectly. So how did he come to that conclusion? He went out of his way to find a live interview where the book author fumbled his answer, instead of giving the definition from the book he's reviewing, or as you more accurately put it, attacking.

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
> Every result ever has pointed that all races and genders are equally "intelligent" and well-suited to the same tasks.

Really? The strongest rebuttals I ever saw boiled down to "it has not yet been conclusively proven impossible that all races are equally intelligent". Large meta-analyses certainly always find correlation, this one goes a long way towards showing there is causation as well: https://doi.org/10.1111%2Fj.1467-9280.2006.01803.x

deogeo··on 'Cancel Culture' Comes to Science?
I can point to specific examples of requiring candidates to be politically vetted before hiring: https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2019/11/19/mathematician...

You don't have to block science, if you can block the scientist.

Also take into account this is an official, open requirement. For something like that to manifest, it has to be preceded by a lot of bias.

deogeo··on Ask HN: Have you ever managed someone paid more than you?
Why couldn't you be the boss of someone more valuable than yourself? They're more valuable in their role - that doesn't mean they'd be better/more valuable than you in your role, of management.

For example, it would make perfect sense if a dean made less than one of their Nobel-prize winning professors. Or a coach that makes less than their olympic athletes.

deogeo··on Two States. Eight Textbooks. Two American Stories
Writing textbooks is political, but the battle starts much earlier, already in hiring - University of California requires all new hires to submit a political litmus test [1]. A story which, I couldn't help but notice, the New York Times failed to cover.

[1] https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2019/11/19/mathematician...

deogeo··on Google pushed to take action against Android bloatware
To cut off anyone claiming this is a dichotomy - on LG phones, you already get both. They come locked, but if you root them, you get a warning saying it's rooted during every boot.
deogeo··on Judge rules that student loan debt is dischargeable in bankruptcy
> The effect of making these loans exempt from bankruptcy just inflates their value which puts colleges into a position where they can inflate their fees - safe in the knowledge that banks will lend practically anything and students have very little choice.

While this is (was?) especially true for student loans, it applies to all loans - their availability increases prices, because there's more cash in the market. Forcing people to take loans, to the benefit of lenders.

deogeo··on FBI Surveillance Vendor Threatens to Sue Tech Reporters for Crime of Journalism
The very real threat of the legal system was used, backed up by the terrifying financial reality of a good legal defense. You can't honestly say that means the legal system wasn't involved. An easy test is - if the system were different, could the threat be less severe?

And I don't see why a preliminary ruling would mean 'vastly' more expensive - you can mostly re-use your work in the real case. And if it turns out to be without merit, you've saved yourself a lot of money. In the very, very worst case scenario, this system would cost 2x as much for the offense, and be vastly cheaper for the defense side. Definitely preferable to the current reality, where you can be forced to spend an arbitrary amount on legal defense.

deogeo··on Outlaw Universities – Discrimination in Academia
State funded schools are requiring new hires to be ideologically right-thinking. How is this not directly equivalent to the "Have you ever been a member of the Communist Party" question? And how is this getting so little attention? If Trump required school hires to submit a statement on their patriotism and how they helped make America great and secure, the media would have a stroke.
deogeo··on FBI Surveillance Vendor Threatens to Sue Tech Reporters for Crime of Journalism
Abuse of the legal system is definitely a legislative problem - the law has to work reasonably in the real world, not in some idealized, frictionless vacuum.

As for a solution - non-prejudicial defensive trials (I made that phrase up). Under this system, if someone sues you, you can at first ignore it. You'd get assigned a public defender, that would try to do a reasonably acceptable job defending you. You could cooperate with this defender, or ignore him. This defender will conduct a sort of mock trial. If you're found not guilty in this trial, then the lawsuit can't proceed, and you've lost no time or money. Only if you're found guilty (or infringing, or whatever outcome you don't like), can it then proceed to a real trial.

A sort of enhanced filter on whether a lawsuit has merit.

deogeo··on Paris syndrome
> northerners eating more noodles, while southerners eat more rice.

You don't have to look that closely to find diversity in Paris.

deogeo··on Paris syndrome
> 20 per cent of people living in the city of Paris are immigrants and 41.3 per cent of people under 20 have at least one immigrant parent.

Wow - that's a very fast demographic change.

deogeo··on Has J.K. Rowling figured out a way to break our cancel culture?
> I grew up as a trans child reading your books as an escape. I would often pick out names from characters to give to myself, before I ever felt comfortable in who I was. This decision, to support people that hate me, and want to do me harm. It brings me to tears... Why. Why?

Some of the replies to Rowling's tweet are surreal - not wanting to see someone fired is framed as some horrible attack. There's no distinction made between Rowling opposing the firing, and trans people being hunted for sport on Hogwarts. Equivalent to a libertarian saying "A 1% income tax to fund the police? It breaks my heart to learn you'd send business owners like myself to starve in Siberia."

deogeo··on Unremovable malware found preinstalled on low-end smartphone sold in the US
I've found that information on which phones have a directly connected baseband is incredibly hard to come by.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →