HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

deogeo

6,740 karma · joined November 28, 2018

submissionscomments
deogeo··on Authoritarian nations are turning the internet into a weapon
You explained well why it's legal, but not why it's not a problem. Many things that are, and even should be legal, are also problems. Such as Fox ignoring whoever they choose - they certainly should have that right, but that doesn't mean it's not a problem when they present a misleading narrative.
deogeo··on Authoritarian nations are turning the internet into a weapon
If a society only allows 'harmless' speech, then it simply does not have freedom of speech, regardless of if it is enforced by law or private platforms. Much like in other areas (e.g. police powers), there is a balancing between rights/liberty, and security(1). At least when it comes to US law, this balancing was already done - the 1st Amendment embodies the opinion that allowing government censorship would be worse than allowing 'harmful'(2) speech.

That said, the situation has changed. Among other things, the ratio between the amount of speech, and the number of speakers or their resources is getting harder to determine, as is the origin of the speech(3), and the nature of the speaker. It could be an anonymous fellow citizen, a corporate shill, or an agent/bot of a hostile foreign government. The platforms themselves can also massively influence public opinion by suppressing some viewpoints, and promoting others (not by something as crude as censorship, but by changing the threshold of when a post goes viral). This effect is similar to that of media conglomeration, but harder to detect.

Personally, I lean heavily towards only banning "inauthentic behavior" (the mentioned shills and bots), as I believe Twitter refers to it, and allowing all other currently legal speech.

(1) Giving up some freedom may grant security from other people, but it reduces security against the state itself - the risk of abuse of authority increases, as does the harm a bad government can cause.

(2) Quotes not because I don't believe some speech is harmful, but because outside of a few narrow exceptions (probably coinciding with the exceptions to the 1st Amendment determined by the US Supreme Court), everyone has their own opinion on which speech is harmful and which isn't, and which should be allowed and which banned.

(3) Though the Supreme Court has on a few occasions ruled quite decisively in favor of anonymous speech.

deogeo··on BSNES & Higan Windows downloads removed because they were flagged by Google
We can expect https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21885959 to have the same effect on speech as this has for binaries.
deogeo··on Authoritarian nations are turning the internet into a weapon
Because speech is meaningless without an audience, and people on mainstream platforms don't all know about or agree with those platform's moderation/censorship policies.

Sure people shouldn't be "forced to listen to everyone's message", but what if it's a message someone does want to listen to, but the platform doesn't want to transmit? And since they don't even know the message exists, they won't be seeking it out on alternative platforms.

deogeo··on UK academics set to launch 'virus' software for online ‘hate speech’
> Tomalin's proposal would use a sophisticated algorithm which would evaluate not just the content itself, but also all content posted by the user to determine if a post might be classifiable as "hate speech".

Speak how the algorithm likes, or your posting will be penalized.

deogeo··on More drugmakers hike U.S. prices as new year begins
Good thing all those free trade agreements let US consumers import cheaper drugs from abroad. Just like corporations can take advantage of cheaper labor, consumers can take advantage of cheaper goods. It would hardly be fair otherwise..
deogeo··on Public Domain Day 2020
Because that would force media companies to compete with their own old content. If people could see movies from the 80s and 90s for free, many might choose them over newer stuff.
deogeo··on Bugged Planet
Do we know how much tougher the warrant requirement is in other countries?

Australia is expanding anti-protest laws [1,2], the UK police is helping blacklist union organizers [3], and sharing information on disabled people and activist with private companies [4,5]. And as China's influence on Australia and New Zealand expands, there's a very real risk surveillance abuse will get even worse. And of course if you dare turn surveillance around on those with power, you can expect consequences [6]. There are precious few countries where surveillance is only used to catch murderers and kidnappers. And even in those, you're helping set up suppression infrastructure that a malicious government can use if they ever gain power in the future.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/aug/20/queen...

[2] https://www.smh.com.au/opinion/nsw-antiprotest-laws-are-part...

[3] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-43507728

[4] https://www.themeteor.org/2019/07/27/gmp-shares-disabled-pro...

[5] https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2009/apr/20/police-intelligen...

[6] https://www.businessinsider.com/tweets-that-got-people-arres... - 10th tweet

deogeo··on Google to end 'Double Irish, Dutch' tax scheme: filing
> What Google did is not illegal.

That's why it's called a 'loophole' - when the letter of the law is followed, but the intent is subverted (or what people imagine what the intent should have been).

deogeo··on Bugged Planet
> Its use is being controlled by very serious judges/courts.

'Controlled' is an overstatement: https://www.popehat.com/2014/07/15/warrants-bulwark-of-liber...

deogeo··on Switching from Chrome to Firefox
Your first two changes seem to be the default now.
deogeo··on Taking a look at a covert CIA virtual fencing solution [video]
Perhaps the presenter views it as hampering a dangerous foreign power in its attempts to meddle with other nations. The CIA doesn't exactly have a clean record.
deogeo··on I’m on Medicare, but I still got stuck with a $25k hospital bill
Yet the US has approximately the same number of doctors per capita as Canada and the UK [1]. And the cost of healthcare in the US has sharply risen in the past few decades - presumably due to some unreported restriction in the supply of doctors?

[1] https://www.who.int/gho/health_workforce/physicians_density/...

deogeo··on I’m on Medicare, but I still got stuck with a $25k hospital bill
It's not entirely clear, but I think the plans that are 'banned' in that case are not "on top of" Medicare, but instead of. I.e. there's a contribution you'd pay to private insurance that you don't pay to Medicare under those plans. Because otherwise... why bother banning them?
deogeo··on I’m on Medicare, but I still got stuck with a $25k hospital bill
> doctors

You mean hospital administration and private equity firms buying hospitals and squeezing them for all they can.

deogeo··on I’m on Medicare, but I still got stuck with a $25k hospital bill
> banning private health insurance

I don't think anyone is opposed to letting people buy private insurance on top of the obligatory single payer. Does any country actually ban additional private insurance?

deogeo··on Case of Bricked Tesla
> The problem was a loose cable that needed to be tightened. My dad asked which one it was so that he could do it in the future, but he was told that's something only Tesla service centers could do.

We urgently need harsh right-to-repair legislation, or we'll be entirely at the mercy of corporations as to what they permit us to do.

deogeo··on French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold
You can apply the same argument to books. Every consumer/user/individual right you have is in some way "bad for the industry as a whole", and if they could take that right away from you, they could squeeze you for more money.
deogeo··on An Opinion on “Examining YouTube's Rabbit Hole of Radicalization” Paper
> After tussling with these complexities, my students and I ended up with nothing publishable because we realized that there’s no good way for external researchers to quantitatively study radicalization.

So did he start a twitter thread calling out all those articles about youtube radicalization as "not even wrong"?

> That’s the note on which I’d like to end: a plea to consider that the available quantitative methods can’t answer everything. And I want to thank the journalists who’ve been doing the next best thing — telling the stories of people led down a rabbit hole by YouTube’s algorithm.

The "next best thing" is cherry-picking data, I see. Is telling the stories of immigrant-committed crimes [1] also the "next best thing", or would his opinion change in that case?

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/22/trumps...

deogeo··on Columbia Uni student files first anti-Semitism complaint under Trump order
Even with ad-block disabled, I don't get any autoplaying videos on Firefox, sorry.
deogeo··on [dead]
Looks like some sort of MLM/get-rich-quick scheme.
deogeo··on What is being sent to Ubuntu in the MOTD?
This should really be included in Ubuntu's 'Privacy' settings.
deogeo··on Samsung TVs May Upload Screenshots for Automatic Content Recognition
I suppose if I film a sex tape and watch it on a Samsung TV, it will upload images from that as well.
deogeo··on A Journalist and a Scientist Break Ground in the GMO Debate (2014)
> eager to help make the global food system “more equitable, healthful and sustainable,” as the course mission states.

Imagine my shock when the article failed to address the effects of GMOs on economics and equitability, e.g. making it impossible to run a viable farm without dealing with GMO firms. Will the world be more equitable when every farmer in Europe has to pay a tax to Monsanto or be driven out of business? Not to mention letting the same incentives that gave us DRM, cigarettes, and sugary soda, now also write the genes of our food.

deogeo··on YouTube seeks 'responsibility'
The article does its best to avoid the phrases "free speech" and "censorship". They get only a single, off-hand mention, as part of someone else's position.
deogeo··on How Disinformation Hacks Your Brain
You're right, sorry. I was going by the summary in the search results. I should have linked one of the following instead:

"It aims to reframe the country’s history by placing the consequences of slavery and the contributions of black Americans at the very center of our national narrative.": https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/08/14/magazine/1619...

"The goal of The 1619 Project is to reframe American history by considering what it would mean to regard 1619 as our nation’s birth year. Doing so requires us to place the consequences of slavery and the contributions of black Americans at the very center of the story we tell ourselves about who we are as a country.": https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/12/20/magazine/1619...

"The 1619 Project is a major initiative from The New York Times to correct the record, reframing the country’s history by placing the consequences of slavery and the contributions of black Americans at the center of the national narrative.": https://store.nytimes.com/products/the-1619-project

deogeo··on Samsung TVs May Upload Screenshots for Automatic Content Recognition
> Your Smart TV transfers video snippets or TV tuner information in order to determine the programs watched.

Can this upload screenshots even if you use the TV as a mere monitor?

deogeo··on Lime Scooter Accounts Are Being Sold on the Dark Web
> although activists have privacy concerns around the sharing of this data

They should have concerns about the collection itself.

deogeo··on How Disinformation Hacks Your Brain
> "Sure tabloid X is all lies, but NY Times/WaPo/etc don't check facts"

I trust mainstream publications to mostly report accurately, but they also choose what to report. E.g. the NY Times decided to reframe US history around slavery [1]. Suppose, at the height of the refugee crisis, the Guardian decided to launch a project to reframe Europe's history around Islamic invasions and slavery [2,3,4,5]? Suddenly, it would become very clear there's more to journalism than only accuracy.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/column/1619-project

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottoman_Empire

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Vienna

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umayyad_conquest_of_Hispania

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbary_slave_trade

deogeo··on Japan Shrinks by 500k People as Births Fall to Lowest Number Since 1874
How silly of me to notice a pattern, when it was clearly labeled 'opinion'.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →