HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

derleth

5,614 karma · joined January 2, 2011

submissionscomments
derleth··on CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store
> The phone home to provide statistics

What are they doing with those statistics? What could they do with them in the future? What could they be forced to do with them?

If it's so harmless, why isn't it opt-in?

> Every single website in the world does it

Obviously not. Websites don't have access to hardware the way CM does.

derleth··on CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store
So that's the standard we want to hold them to? Just a little better than Google?

Why isn't it opt-in?

derleth··on A search engine that removes the 1 million most popular web sites from its index
If that's the best way you have to promote your site, it must not be very useful.
derleth··on CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store
CM phones home by default. There's a word for software like that: Malware. The Play Store shouldn't have malware.
derleth··on CyanogenMod Installer Application Removed from Play Store
And, of course, CM still phones home by default, which is malware behavior, and not something we need to condone.
derleth··on Dear Spike Lee
There is no inconsistency here. Everyone thinks plagiarism is wrong.
derleth··on Dear Spike Lee
Try as you may, there's no inconsistency here. Everyone thinks plagiarism is wrong.
derleth··on Dear Spike Lee
Everyone thinks plagiarism is wrong.
derleth··on A search engine that removes the 1 million most popular web sites from its index
OK, you can stop spamming now.
derleth··on A search engine that removes the 1 million most popular web sites from its index
I think the idea was that the presence of ads indicates the advertisers had influence on content, which isn't true for a lot of websites which run ads.
derleth··on The string type is broken
Except these are all well outside the ambit of what programmers usually think of as text processing, so they won't try to solve them using the same tools.

More to the point, they sound hard, so people won't be so quick to claim they've solved them.

On the other hand, case-insensitive string matching sounds easy, even if it's actually somewhat difficult due to the language dependencies mentioned above, so people will claim to have a general solution that fails the first time it's faced with i up-casing to İ instead of I, or the fact the German 'ß' up-cases to 'SS' as opposed to any single character. (Unicode does contain 'ẞ', a single-character capital 'ß', which occurs in the real world but is vanishingly rare. As far as modern German speakers are concerned, the capital form of 'ß' is 'SS'.)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_%E1%BA%9E

http://opentype.info/blog/2013/11/18/capital-sharp-s-design-...

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/michkap/archive/2009/07/28/9850675.a...

http://www.personal.psu.edu/ejp10/blogs/gotunicode/2008/07/a...

derleth··on Half an operating system: The triumph and tragedy of OS/2
AS/400 isn't mainframe. It's midrange; smaller than a mainframe, and not as flexible.
derleth··on Half an operating system: The triumph and tragedy of OS/2
> So the new System/360 mainframe line would run the also brand-new OS/360.

Bad example. Really bad example: Not even IBM could standardize on a single OS for the System/360.

The System/360 went through a few OS iterations before OS/360 came along: OS/360 was late, as recounted in The Mythical Man-Month, so DOS/360 came along, then BOS/360, then TOS/360, and even PCP, which didn't support multiprogramming. Other OSes were CP-67, which became VM, MFT, MVT, and still more OSes on top of that.

To this day, there are multiple OSes for the architecture descended from the System/360, including Linux.

derleth··on CAR and CDR
I like them because they don't guide thought: They're abstract names for abstract concepts. They don't impose any interpretation on the ideas, they simply present them for what they are. Having to break down a less-useful conceptual model is even more difficult than building a more-useful one.
derleth··on The Insanity of Our Food Policy
> Wasn't that the exact same argument given to the expertise of priests and medieval scholars?

This is the "Experts were wrong before" dodge, which conveniently ignores how often individuals are wrong.

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Science_was_wrong_before

derleth··on The Insanity of Our Food Policy
> read from various sources.

Exactly. So, which other sources have you read from which confirm what Lustig said?

> phrenology was once accepted by "experts", as were electro-shocks for gay people. And don't get me started on economic "experts".

Oh, yes, the "Experts were wrong before" dodge, which is so beloved of quacks and alt-med nutballs in general. It so conveniently ignores the fact that lone people are wrong a lot more often.

> I'd only accept a consensus of lots of independent experts

So, where are all of the independent experts who agree with Lustig?

derleth··on The Insanity of Our Food Policy
> Can't you make up your mind on your own based on information

The problem with this is multi-fold:

Do you know what good information looks like, or are you going to be fed crap from a circle-jerk of sources which all repeat the same lies? This is a bootstrapping problem, ultimately: How do you know where to get the first info you use to tell crap from good information?

Experts largely agree with each other in most mature fields. This is part of what it means for a field to be mature. The problem is, a lot of the liars and scammers agree with each other as well, or at least the ones all selling the same scams do. How do you tell the difference?

Since I don't have time to become a Ph.D. in biology, medicine, or an allied field, I have to trust the experts. Nobody has time to be an expert in everything.

Also, 'make up your own mind' is predicated on the idea that you are making up your own mind, as opposed to baby-duck-like imprinting on someone who makes good-looking videos and can string words. The people who follow Alex Jones think they're thinking for themselves, too. Following a body of knowledge as opposed to a single charismatic guru is a hedge against this baby-duck effect.

And:

> without the need to appeal to expert consensus (which might as well be bogus and profit-driven?)

How do you know Lustig isn't bogus and ego-driven?

derleth··on Australis is landing in Firefox Nightly
As long as the themes I use keep working, great. One of the best parts of Firefox (which Chrome seems incapable of picking up) is that themes work: You can change the whole look and feel to what you want, as opposed to it being what some self-styled UI expert thinks you should want.
derleth··on BTC correction happening?
A little bit facetious and entirely wrong, sure.
derleth··on Shell script mistakes
> shell scripts aren't technically a programming language

Of course they are.

derleth··on Senate hearing on Bitcoin [video]
> only the secret service guy seemed to be very cautious; he never said the word bitcoin and mostly spent his time saying the secret service was awesome.

To make it clearer for anyone who doesn't know: The Secret Service is the primary government agency charged with investigating the counterfeiting of American currency. Protecting the President and other dignitaries is minor compared to that. That's probably why they're testifying in the Senate now to begin with.

derleth··on The Insanity of Our Food Policy
> the eventual victory of the federalists in the Civil War was, in effect, the creation of a new nation organized around industrial capitalism.

Which is why the war was started by plantation slave-holders: They knew that the only way to keep their slaves was to dissociate their economy and politics from that of the industrialized North. Even after they destroyed the concept of states' rights by passing the fugitive slave laws, they still weren't confident that slavery could endure when the North was going great guns without it. When the North proved that they could elect a President without pandering to Southern Slave Power interests by electing Lincoln in 1860 without a single Southern vote going to him, that was the last straw.

(The election of 1860 was, in effect, two elections going on in parallel: Bell v Breckinridge in the South, Lincoln v Douglas in the North. Except, of course, only one man could be President, and Lincoln won the Electoral College by a convincing majority.)

derleth··on The Insanity of Our Food Policy
Does any other expert agree with Lustig, or is it just him and a bunch of people who've watched videos by him?
derleth··on Advice from Harvard Business School's Class of 1963
> Death does not give life meaning. Life gives life meaning.

I never disagreed with this.

> You can choose to live each day to the fullest without embracing deathism.

I almost disagreed with this.

My point is that procrastination has its payoff as well, but, even if you don't die, the payoff from doing as much as you can is higher.

derleth··on Alcohol without the hangover?
> synthonol

Synthehol. Synthetic alcohol.

http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Synthehol

(Not nearly as interesting to engineers as the real stuff, which is apparently at its best when it's green.)

http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/By_Any_Other_Name_(episode)

derleth··on Alcohol without the hangover?
It's been said before, but the most dangerous date rape drug is alcohol.

GHB is new and unfamiliar, so it gets the worse rap, but alcohol has pretty much everything an date rape drug would have: It induces a loss of inhibition, a loss of motor control, a loss of language skills, and loss of consciousness with retrograde amnesia[0]. It also has one very important factor working in its favor: Social acceptance. Nobody gives it a second glance.

[0] Retrograde amnesia is a loss of memories formed before the event; in this case, the event is the point at which the person loses consciousness entirely.

derleth··on Advice from Harvard Business School's Class of 1963
> I don't plan on it.

Think about it game-theoretically:

If you live as if you'll die, and you don't, you'll have a much more interesting life, because you took advantage of it thinking you're living under the Sword of Damocles.

If you live as if life extension will keep you going, and it fails, you'll have a short, boring life, full of things you put off until it was too late.

Those are the extreme values of the matrix; if you work through the rest, I think you'll find that the most utility is always gained by living as if you'll die eventually.

(Living as if you'll die tomorrow is romantic and all, but it would prevent you from working towards any goal which takes more than less than a day to complete. It could also land you in prison, deported to a less-pleasant foreign country, or both.)

derleth··on My tmux setup
> It's a pneumonic for "previous"

I'm guessing this is autocorrect, but an autocorrect that knows 'pneumonic' (the Firefox spell-checker doesn't!) but not 'mnemonic' seems even less likely than a person who knows the first word but not the second.

Anyway, 'previous' is perhaps less likely to spring to mind than 'back' or 'reverse' or even 'last', each of which would have different mnemonics. ('Last' has a particularly good mnemonic if you keep your hands to the Holy Home Row, which is why vi users, who are most likely to worship at the Altar of the Home Row, can't use it.)

derleth··on Why Are We Building Jailbait Sexbots?
> The law is very cognizant of intent and willfulness.

Not in strict liability offenses, such as statutory rape. Which isn't entirely relevant to playing a game, until the legislature makes 'possession of child pornography' strict liability and includes drawings as being child pornography.

derleth··on Occupy Wall Street activists buy $15m of Americans' personal debt
> I don't want to risk inheriting their debts

You can't. Once the estate's gone, the creditors can pound sand because the person they contracted with is gone and all their assets are gone, too. They can't come after anyone else.

> Luckily she was able to somehow get her name off of the inheritance after the fact.

I seriously doubt this is possible even in theory.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →