HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dewarrn1

390 karma · joined March 19, 2011

I'm a cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in psychology.

david-e-warren.me

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/dewarren; my proof: https://keybase.io/dewarren/sigs/GlgzYFgXKgB60f8D9R19UZsu_JQQwZCOQyW9aQyAv7g ]

submissionscomments
dewarrn1··on An Ex-Cop's War on Lie Detectors
I wouldn't be in cognitive neuroscience if I thought our methods held no promise, but there's a vast gap between reconstructing images from visual cortex responses and accurately determining whether a person is lying. Farah et al. [0] recently summarized the best available evidence and concluded as follows (emphasis mine):

"... different policies should be considered for different applications of fMRI-based lie detection. We do not join calls to ban fMRI-based lie detection across the board. Despite the enormous shortcomings of the current evidence ... we suggest that restrictions should be proportional to the outcomes and principles at stake. Risk reduction in dating calls for different standards of certainty and different protections of individual rights than the interrogation of terrorist suspects."

[0] http://www.nature.com/nrn/journal/v15/n2/abs/nrn3665.html

dewarrn1··on An Ex-Cop's War on Lie Detectors
There are already commercial operations using (or claiming to use) fMRI for lie detection [0]. I can understand the potential appeal of similar positions for applicants — there's a scarcity of academic jobs for even highly skilled cognitive neuroscience PhDs.

As I've posted elsewhere in these comments, the best available evidence suggests that fMRI is no more useful than polygraph for lie detection. Unfortunately, the power of brain images to induce credulity in otherwise intelligent people is well-known [e.g., 1].

[0] http://noliemri.com/

[1] http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12152-007-9003-3

dewarrn1··on An Ex-Cop's War on Lie Detectors
fMRI as a method is not bankrupt or ill-founded. However, as the study you linked shows, it is susceptible to statistical artifacts that must be controlled to support rigorous conclusions.
dewarrn1··on An Ex-Cop's War on Lie Detectors
Don't believe the hype. Applying fMRI methods to lie detection is at least as problematic as the polygraph. Here's a good review:

http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15265160701842007

dewarrn1··on Continuum Analytics Raises $24M Series A for Anaconda Python and PyData
Excellent news! The Anaconda distribution has been great for me, and CA's policy of free academic licensing for their go-fast extensions [0] is the cherry on top.

[0] https://store.continuum.io/cshop/academicanaconda

dewarrn1··on SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure
So with a 5.5% margin the $1.6 billion contract would be expected to yield $88 million in profit? Given what I'm assuming are large R&D expenditures on top of launch-related costs, I wonder whether the business is sustainable.
dewarrn1··on Super Mario Bros. 30th Anniversary
I think s/he means that the HTML source includes ASCII art showing Mario:

<!------------ SUPER MARIO BROS. 30TH ---------------

               \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
               \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
            \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
            \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
            #########++++++###+++
            #########++++++###+++
         ###+++###+++++++++###++++++
         ###+++###+++++++++###++++++
         ###+++######+++++++++###+++++++++
         ###+++######+++++++++###+++++++++
         ######++++++++++++###############
         ######++++++++++++###############
               +++++++++++++++++++++
               +++++++++++++++++++++
            ######\\\#########
            ######\\\#########
         #########\\\######\\\#########
         #########\\\######\\\#########
      ############\\\\\\\\\\\\############
      ############\\\\\\\\\\\\############
      ++++++###\\\+++\\\\\\+++\\\###++++++
      ++++++###\\\+++\\\\\\+++\\\###++++++
      +++++++++\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\+++++++++
      +++++++++\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\+++++++++
      ++++++\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\++++++
      ++++++\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\++++++
            \\\\\\\\\      \\\\\\\\\
            \\\\\\\\\      \\\\\\\\\
         #########            #########
         #########            #########

--------------- THANK YOU! -------------->
dewarrn1··on B. B. King, Defining Bluesman for Generations, Dies at 89
A legend. My first exposure was through his participation in U2's Rattle and Hum album/rockumentary [0].

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRHV-HWhqWQ

dewarrn1··on Used ThinkPad Buyer's Guide
Looks like FreeBSD runs relatively well on many ThinkPad models: https://wiki.freebsd.org/Laptops
dewarrn1··on A FreeBSD 10 Desktop How-To
Agreed, I like FreeBSD a great deal. I especially like Nicole's guide because it's so matter-of-fact. By following her instructions, I think anyone with *NIX experience could get a similar setup working without too much hassle, and that's a great contribution.
dewarrn1··on BitTorrent's Maelstrom browser enters open beta
I've been using it for about 6 months and I've been very satisfied.
dewarrn1··on Thunderbird Usage Continues to Grow
Yes, URL appears in the statusbar on Windows 7 Thunderbird 31.5.0.
dewarrn1··on An Introduction on How to Make Beautiful Charts with R and ggplot2
ggplot2 is a very elegant language for describing how to draw your data. Two great books for interested parties: the R Graphics Cookbook [0] which has tons of ggplot2 examples and gets you plotting immediately; and ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis [1] written by the author of the ggplot2 library and providing a very thorough description of this implementation of the "Grammar of Graphics".

[0] http://amzn.to/1AhyEdE

[1] http://amzn.to/1B4OSq9

dewarrn1··on An Introduction on How to Make Beautiful Charts with R and ggplot2
Decent references. I find myself doing similar, final-draft touch-ups with plots for manuscripts.
dewarrn1··on An Introduction on How to Make Beautiful Charts with R and ggplot2
R has a built-in Cairo-based SVG output device that allows you to write out any plot in a vector format: http://www.inside-r.org/r-doc/grDevices/cairo. It's great for publication-quality plotting.
dewarrn1··on An Introduction on How to Make Beautiful Charts with R and ggplot2
ggplot for Python [0] is coming along nicely. My own recent use suggests that for basic plotting, most of the expected functionality is there. More advanced displays, such as faceting, are still in progress. Overall, I've been impressed.

[0] https://github.com/yhat/ggplot/

dewarrn1··on CrunchBang Linux: The end
Not bloat, configuration. That is, I suspect the parent comment is not suggesting that these Debian installations are bloated, but that their default configuration leaves much to be desired.

In my own use, I found Crunchbang to have the UX polish of a large distro with the overhead of a minimal distro. An excellent combination that will be greatly missed.

dewarrn1··on A woman who can't feel fear
First, I should point out the original work of Ralph Adolphs, the Damasios, and Dan Tranel on this case [0]. It's a short, important paper that started this whole line of investigation based on the single extraordinary case of SM.

In my interactions with her, SM was uniformly happy, and it's my impression that she's like that in everyday life as well. A former labmate, Justin Feinstein, wrote an interesting paper based in part on observing her in real-world settings [1]. He didn't observe fear in any of a variety of potentially frightening contexts — she generally confronts such contexts with laughter or wonder.

Regarding love, she's deeply attached to her family. I distinctly remember stopping when we walked past the hospital chapel so that she could pray for members of her family. I can't say as much about grief, but she never seemed anxious in any of the time that we spent together, and she certainly never got angry or even upset.

[0]http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7990957

[1]http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21167712

dewarrn1··on A woman who can't feel fear
I've had the privilege of working with the patient described in the podcast. She's unique in any sense of the word.
dewarrn1··on DigitalOcean now supports FreeBSD
Regarding custom kernels, DO says that BSD will be able to boot them: http://disq.us/8lqxh7.
dewarrn1··on Why Our Memory Fails Us
False memories of the kind that Chabris and Simons discuss are ubiquitous in healthy people, and there are lots of interesting wrinkles in the literature describing these memory errors — here are two of my favorites.

First, even individuals with extraordinary memory abilities are susceptible to false memory phenomena [0]. People with what's been called "highly superior autobiographical memory" (HSAM) can, for any given date in the last decade or two, tell you what they did, what they ate, and what the weather was like with extraordinary accuracy. However, when tested with standard laboratory tasks that induce false memories, they are just as vulnerable as typical individuals.

Second, focal brain injury may reduce susceptibility to false memories [1]. Full disclosure, this is some of my own published work. We investigated the effects of damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) on false recall in a standard laboratory test involving lists of conceptually similar words (the DRM task [2]). Patients with vmPFC damage showed reduced (but not abolished) false memories relative to healthy comparison participants. This is especially interesting to us because vmPFC appears to be necessary for decision-making in complex situations, particularly when prior knowledge must be integrated into ongoing behavior. We believe that deficits in decision-making accompanying vmPFC damage may stem from the same root cause the reductions in false memory that we observed. Regardless, we’re not recommending vmPFC resection for healthy people seeking more accurate memory (not yet, anyway).

Although these are highlights, empirical work on false memories and other kinds of memory errors extends back more than a century. It’s a fascinating domain, and I very much enjoy working in it. More information on a variety of related topics can be found at my website [3] and in my published work (see Publications).

[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24248358

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24872571

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deese%E2%80%93Roediger%E2%80%9...

[3] http://david-e-warren.me

dewarrn1··on Big, bad Amazon
This may be a silly question, but could publishers simply set up their own Amazon storefronts? That is, could I buy a book from "Hachette, fulfilled by Amazon" if Hachette was willing to set things up on their end? I'm sure that the current dispute would make this approach untenable, but I have to wonder why publishers aren't using Amazon services to sell books at their preferred prices.
dewarrn1··on Why Are Americans So Fascinated with Extreme Fitness?
Earlier comments are already critiquing the author for suggesting that exercise is a bad thing or that particular exercises don't work, but that perspective misses the point. The author isn't criticizing exercise itself, but she is instead observing the almost religious focus on suffering that happens to be embodied by approaches such as Crossfit. I admit to being puzzled as well.

I am perplexed by the degree of what I might call fitness elitism that exists in a nation as fundamentally unfit as the US (I'm American, BTW). I'm seeing a lot of comments about how simple exercise isn't effective and HIT is a necessity, etc. HIT is great, but it's a pretense to suggest that running, biking, or aerobics that raise your heart rate without being tortuous are not also effective exercises that can drastically improve one's health. I feel that there is an unnecessary focus on very intense exercise programs when simple cardiovascular conditioning that nearly anyone can do has the potential to drastically improve the health of so many.

dewarrn1··on Consider the Lobster (2004)
DFW's commencement speech at Kenyon is another terrific example:

http://web.archive.org/web/20080213082423/http://www.margina...

dewarrn1··on Consider the Lobster (2004)
Yes, it's all part of the experience. Reportedly, DFW liked the idea of jarring readers out of a steady progression through his text and used all kinds of notes to effect this.
dewarrn1··on A Chinese Man, a $50 Billion Plan and a Canal to Reshape Nicaragua
No. NPR derives about 5% of their funding from US, federal, state, and local governments. Source:

http://www.npr.org/about-npr/178660742/public-radio-finances

NPR certainly has its own biases in reporting, but it is not solely funded by the US government and it is not a US government mouthpiece.

dewarrn1··on Daskeyboard 4 Professional
Agreed, the MS 4000's split design helped tremendously with my ulnar nerve irritation. Keeping my wrists aligned with my forearms is the key. I've also been keeping an eye out for a mechanical keyboard in a similar form factor without any luck. The few alternatives that I've seen are such an enormous price premium over the 4000 that I can't justify the expense. Maybe I'll be the second contributor to your putative Kickstarter campaign.
dewarrn1··on How Twitter Can Avoid Becoming the Next AOL
Gonzo journalism targeting a tech audience.

Turning back to Twitter, I like the service, and find 140 characters refreshingly brief. I don't know how to preserve it, but they've got huge mindshare and should be able to leverage that profitably.

dewarrn1··on The Art of Unix Programming (2008)
OK, so you don't think much of ESR. Any alternative recommendations in the same topic area?
dewarrn1··on "Host your own GitHub" using Gitlab and Dokku
I like the idea of hosting my own web-accessible repository, but am most familiar with Mercurial. Does GitLab support non-Git repositories, or is there an alternative that does?
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →