HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dewarrn1

390 karma · joined March 19, 2011

I'm a cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in psychology.

david-e-warren.me

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/dewarren; my proof: https://keybase.io/dewarren/sigs/GlgzYFgXKgB60f8D9R19UZsu_JQQwZCOQyW9aQyAv7g ]

submissionscomments
dewarrn1··on What Happens When a Neurosurgeon Removes Your Hippocampus
"The surgeon claimed that the destruction was precise, but the autopsy actually determined that damage was much more widespread than expected."

This is flat wrong. Based on structural neuroimaging evidence, Corkin et al. (1997) showed that HM's resection was less extensive than Scoville's notes suggested, not more extensive. The more recent post-mortem analysis of HM's brain (Annese et al., 2014) concurs, and in fact gives an even more conservative estimate of the resection.

As a researcher who studies memory and works with severely amnesic patients, I think that it's important to point out that the precision of HM's lesion was unique in our field because every other bilateral hippocampal amnesic patient has a naturally-occurring lesion. Etiologies vary (herpes simplex encephalitis, anoxia, and, historically, Korsakoff's), but common to each etiology is the potential for widespread damage beyond the hippocampus and medial temporal lobe (MTL). Given that HM's surgery predated sophisticated neuroimaging methods, his case provided researchers of the era the very best possibility of isolating the cognitive processes that depended on the MTL. There have been many methodological and theoretical improvements over the intervening decades, but the work that Brenda Milner, Sue Corkin, and many others carried out with HM was seminal for the field.

Annese, J., Schenker-Ahmed, N. M., Bartsch, H., Maechler, P., Sheh, C., Thomas, N., … Corkin, S. (2014). Postmortem examination of patient H.M.’s brain based on histological sectioning and digital 3D reconstruction. Nature Communications, 5, 3122. doi:10.1038/ncomms4122

Corkin, S., Amaral, D. G., Gonzalez, R. G., Johnson, K. A., & Hyman, B. T. (1997). H.M.’s medial temporal lobe lesion: findings from magnetic resonance imaging. J. Neurosci., 17, 3964–3979.

dewarrn1··on What it is like being the only engineer in a meeting [video]
I've been in this meeting myself. The situation is nicely rendered in a scene[0] from Cryptonomicon in which a main character feels like a dwarf among hobbits.

[0] http://www.euskalnet.net/larraorma/crypto/slide8.html

dewarrn1··on Facebook acquires Oculus VR
No part of this acquisition makes sense. I just hope that the product doesn't disappear without a trace after a write-down in a couple of years.
dewarrn1··on P values are not as reliable as many scientists assume
Cumming had a short treatment of the subject published in Psych Science recently: http://pss.sagepub.com/content/25/1/7.short ; doi: 10.1177/0956797613504966.
dewarrn1··on Multiprocess Firefox
Works like a charm.
dewarrn1··on Ask HN: How do you back up your data?
I've been burned before, so now I use a mix of incremental networked backups and offsite storage. My home server runs ZFS, snapshotting every hour/day/week. Critical files get sent off to TarSnap each night. Friday nights, a script archives important data to a set of tar.gz files that are written out to an external HDD. Saturday mornings, I take the HDD to the bank and swap it with its counterpart in my safe deposit box. It's a bit cumbersome, but it works for me.
dewarrn1··on The Man Who Forgot Everything
Scoville was overambitious and underinformed, but it's also important to remember that HM was living with debilitating seizures that made daily life almost unbearable. And for context, this is the era in which Walter Freeman was perfecting frontal lobotomy techniques that eventually left tens of thousands of individuals with gross cognitive impairments. At least Scoville had the sense to realize what he'd done and stop.
dewarrn1··on The Man Who Forgot Everything
Anterograde amnesia is definitely a greater challenge for a storyteller than retrograde amnesia because the amnesic character is essentially static in the story, and that's one of the reasons that Memento is such an extraordinary film.

For another example, while it's not central to the story, Finding Nemo features a supporting character who has anterograde amnesia (Dory the fish).

dewarrn1··on The Man Who Forgot Everything
Those of us who study the cognitive neuroscience of memory have been waiting for Dr. Corkin to publish this book for a while. I'm looking forward to reading through.

Regarding another commenter's concerns about ensuring that severely amnesic patients are fairly compensated and participating of their own free will, this is a complex issue that those of us who study such patients deal with frequently. I can say of my own experience that patients we work with volunteer their time willingly, are remunerated for their participation, and can discontinue any task at any time. It's a privilege to work with people who have such a focal neuropsychologial deficit, and we take our responsibility for each patient's welfare during their time with us very seriously.

dewarrn1··on Should I buy LED or CFL light bulbs?
I had the same reaction at first, but then recognized (possibly after reading someone's Slashdot or HN post) that the slowly increasing output is actually quite welcome in some circumstances (e.g., late at night, first thing in the morning). It's not a feature that I'd request, but I don't mind the tradeoff now.
dewarrn1··on Happy 20th birthday Debian
Happy birthday, indeed! I love the independent spirit of the Debian project, including such extraordinary measures as wrapping their userland around the FreeBSD kernel in addition to Linux[0]. Recently, I've enjoyed using Crunchbang[1], a slick, simple desktop built on top of Debian. To the next 20 years!

[0] http://www.debian.org/ports/kfreebsd-gnu/ [1] http://crunchbang.org/

dewarrn1··on What is new in IPython 1.0
I suspect they'll wait a few more alpha-beta point releases before updating PyPI, but not sure. Any devs reading?
dewarrn1··on Switching to DuckDuckGo and Firefox
Searching the current page for links in Firefox (using ') is a great feature and one of the things I miss most when I have to use Chrome.
dewarrn1··on Edward Snowden Q&A
This is the impression that I took away from his remarks, too. However, this prompts a question: is it feasible to capture everything, store those data, and filter after the fact? How much traffic are we discussing, how much storage over what period, etc.? The costs to capture and store everything for any significant length of time seem astronomical; am I wrong? And if it's not everything, how useful is it?
dewarrn1··on Flickr gets new UI, new Android app, 1 TB free space
It's worth noting that if you cancel your Pro account (I just did), Flickr pledges to return the balance of your membership fee (prorated).
dewarrn1··on Light Table a year ago
I'm planning to develop a scientific programming class (likely focused on Python), and I'd love to make use of something like LightTable to make assignment, loops, and functions less opaque to first-time programmers. I think that this kind of UI has tremendous potential for exactly that application, among many others.
dewarrn1··on A beginner's guide to setting up Python on Windows
I'm an avid Python user. A beautiful aspect of the language is that, once installed (often as simple as running the default python.org MSI under Windows), the experience is essentially homogeneous whether the machine I'm running is Windows, Linux, BSD, OS X, etc. In short: preferences and politics aside, who cares about the underlying OS? Let's get things done!
dewarrn1··on The FreeBSD Foundation falls short of its 2012 fundraising goal by 50%
Netflix is conspicuously absent, for one.

https://signup.netflix.com/openconnect/software

dewarrn1··on Surface Pricing Announced - $499 USD
The "Touch Cover", which I'm assuming is the bit with the keyboard, will run you an extra $100-120. Given the attention to the Touch Cover in the promotional material MS has distributed, I'm surprised that it's even optional.
dewarrn1··on Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop
Interesting find: "Sherlock Holmes" avoids the Argument/Philosophy loop; "Poirot" does not.
dewarrn1··on What happens when you ask people to pick the lowest unique prime number.
This is an example of a Keynesian beauty contest [0].

0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keynesian_beauty_contest

dewarrn1··on Malcolm Gladwell asserts that Gates, not Jobs, will be remembered in 50 years
Or perhaps giving publicly is what you do when you want to rehabilitate a tarnished public image.

Regardless, Gladwell is taking the lazy columnist's approach of irresponsible prediction, intending to provoke indignation. There's plenty of room in history books, and both Gates and Jobs will have significant entries. I'll submit Edison and Telsa as examples of contemporaries in the same general field who both remain widely known decades after they passed on.

dewarrn1··on Vimbits: submit and vote on .vimrc tricks
Neat site! Tiny copy edit for you: "Share you coolest trick" should be "Share your coolest trick".
dewarrn1··on [dead]
It's a shame, mine has been a reliable workhorse for years. Perhaps collectible status awaits?
dewarrn1··on Poll: Do you touch-type?
I typed the way that you're describing for years, but with my dissertation looming I decided that it wasn't good enough. Having tried and failed to pick up QWERTY touch-typing in the past (it was very easy to relapse into my non-touch style), I tried Colemak and it stuck. http://colemak.com/
dewarrn1··on Selling a 300-Year-Old Cello
Not that this should necessarily be the final word on the matter, but a recent controlled study suggested that even experienced players can't distinguish old from new violins:

http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/01/02/1114999109

dewarrn1··on Scientists demonstrate Matrix-like learning with no conscious effort
This submission's title is misleading, and the original work could be better summarized as "improving at one task while doing another". The authors first determined a pattern of brain activation (indexed by blood flow) associated with the presentation of a target (visual) stimulus for a given subject. Then, they gave subjects real-time feedback about their brain activation while they performed a superficially different task. The trick is that the feedback on the second, different task was based on a subject's ability to cause the same pattern of brain activation (again, indexed by blood flow) that the experimenters first observed when the target stimulus was presented in the earlier session. Finally, subjects were tested on their ability to identify the target stimulus and others like it, and they showed a statistically reliable improvement for the (unknowingly) trained target, but not for other, similar items. It's fascinating, but suggesting that this is anything like what's been depicted in science fiction movies (yes, like The Matrix) is silly.
dewarrn1··on Castle.so Upload and share your files, beautifully.
Same, text file on Windows/Firefox. Other formats (PNG, SVG) were displayed in the browser without difficulty.
dewarrn1··on FreeBSD 9.0-RC1 Available...
This sounds like the standard "BSD is dying" canard from Slashdot and elsewhere, and without substantiation it doesn't merit a top spot in this discussion. BSD has been and remains a server-first OS, with desktop support for the latest and greatest processors trailing Linux by a substantial margin. On widely-deployed hardware, support is generally equivalent, and I'm quite pleased with recent releases for headless servers.
dewarrn1··on How the R-project is taking over statistical analysis software
This looks slick, thanks for the pointer!
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →