HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dgreensp

3,476 karma · joined April 10, 2007

David Greenspan
submissionscomments
dgreensp··on The Bitter Truth of Learning: It’s Tough, Unpleasant, and Often Pointless
Exactly! I think the OP read a comment that was really just encouragement in the form of, “You may not understand any of this now, but any time and energy you put into learning more will be rewarded with greater understanding; good luck!” which was not meant to be pressury or judgmental or moralistic, and read his own meaning of “no pain no gain” into it.
dgreensp··on Medium suspended our account and blocked access to all our published stories
Why not?
dgreensp··on Congrats Dropbox
That’s me in the bottom right in the striped shirt! Congratulations Drew, I am in awe.

I first met Drew at MIT, and first saw Dropbox when he was showing off what he was hacking on on his Windows laptop in a coffee shop in Cambridge at the start of the summer. My user id is 88, haha. The batch was tiny by today’s standards (what was it, 20 companies? less?). YC invested $5k plus $5k per founder, for food and rent and servers for three months, in exchange for 2-10% of your company. You could have office hours with Paul every week if you wanted. At the end of the summer, a bunch of us moved out west and lived in Crystal Tower in SF. When Drew raised $1m from Sequoia, I was shocked! YC founders at the beginning of the summer were generally two guys with an idea (if that), so raising VC out of the gate was rare. AppJet was another favorite of the batch, and we raised $90k from several angels to keep going. YC had already had its first acquisitions, like Zenter (presentation software acquired by Google).

In those days, the entire YC community was smaller than one batch today.

It is amazing to me to see start-ups I remember from back then still going, and even become household names. AirBnB (2008). Weebly (2006) is even older than Dropbox.

Way to change the world, PG and Jessica. And of course Drew and Arash!

dgreensp··on Diaphragmatic Breathing Exercises and the Vagus Nerve (2017)
Healthy, full breathing involves significant expansion of the rib cage in all directions. I wish people would remember this before spreading the advice, “breathe into your belly, not into your chest.” Your lungs are in your chest. (And contrary to the article, by the way, the “lower part of your lungs” is not “just above your belly button.”) Most importantly, do not lock your chest or inhibit its movement.

If you have poor posture and core support and a tight chest, I would say experiment with filling your lungs completely, and with engaging your abs very slightly on the _inhale_, to feel some of the sensations of full, supported breathing. Your core muscles create pressure that helps fully inflate your lungs.

Don’t listen to any admonishments about “breathing wrong” as your body will use them to create additional tension and restriction rather than relaxation and freedom.

dgreensp··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
Well I think it’s a difference in government, whatever the culture is. The government is not polling the people to decide whether or not to act in accord with the facts according to scientific consensus, it is just doing so.
dgreensp··on Picat: A Logic-Based, Multi-Paradigm, Programming Language
Example 1 makes this look like a very imperative language, otherwise why would you write out a “map” as an imperative loop? We are back to manually allocating an array the same size as an existing array, and having to remember to increment a counter at the end of a loop? I will write code like that only if there is a performance reason.
dgreensp··on iPhone Notches on Android Phones
I do think Apple puts more thought and creative attention into their hardware design than anyone else, or at least that’s their image, and based on that, it’s easy to see how they have (in addition) become fashion trend-setters in the industry.

So even if a design or detail is bad (according to me, or you, or most people, like a bad movie), a lot of thought went into it, and probably a lot of people will copy it! :)

dgreensp··on iPhone Notches on Android Phones
Yes, if anything, the notch seems like an obvious, but aesthetically questionable and therefore risky, move. Apple doing it, and people apparently liking it (...really?...) derisked it.
dgreensp··on Pricing low-touch SaaS
I agree, if you have a consumer product and are trying to get a place in the customer’s monthly budget for entertainment/recreation, a different set of rules probably apply. These cases probably aren’t as central to what is thought of as “SaaS.”
dgreensp··on Why I Quit Google to Work for Myself
You can absolutely work for yourself. Google has customers too. If you work for Google, there is you, Google, and customers. If you work for you, there is you, you, and customers. You could metaphorically think of your customers as hiring and firing you, sure, in which case you have potentially millions of “bosses” and you can decide which ones you want to try to appeal to.

Running a start-up can be a pretty good gig, too.

dgreensp··on Why I Quit Google to Work for Myself
If a manager of some kind were to notice the Slack messages and ping someone specific to help, that would be a perfect example of the kind of management that is so sorely lacking at so many companies. Many employees are too burned, or proud, to even put out an SOS... so a cry for help is actually a gift to management. If only it were someone’s job to think for a few minutes each day about each employee and notice if there is some small action that would help them.

Nah, let’s just alternate between micromanaging and being totally absent; fret about lack of productivity or lack of progress; maybe institute a daily stand-up.

dgreensp··on Pricing low-touch SaaS
It does seem like if your SaaS product is truly "just for fun" and does not save anyone time or make or save anyone money, or teach a skill, or otherwise help the user be more productive, then you are right. What is an example?
dgreensp··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
As an industry forum for engineers and people developing products, this is a great place to share positive and negative opinions about technology and how it impacts product quality. That’s good conversation.

Generic reactions to negativity, saying there are two sides to every coin, do not really contribute to the discussion, IMO, so I disagree.

dgreensp··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
The reason the causality sounds backwards is the GP is talking about secondary effects of what you are talking about — the other half of a vicious cycle.

We are already a decade into neglecting native app technologies in favor of web app technologies, because web apps were much easier to write and deliver than cross-platform native apps (and largely still are). It’s to the point where even big companies with lots of resources are hiring web programmers and web designers to build their UIs.

It’s interesting to me that mobile changes the trade-offs. The quality gulf between web and native apps is greater. The web sucks more on mobile, and expectations for native apps (animations, touch, etc) are higher. Mobile OSes also make it much easier for users to install and manage native apps than it is on desktop (because of the app store, no custom installers, no users locked out of installing apps by their employers as far as I know). I’m excited about React Native for addressing the cross-platform part.

We’ve learned since Java that even if you don’t have “write once, run anywhere,” you can still have “learn once, write anywhere,” a la React. Also, we expect apps to come with their own systems of UI widgets these days, not necessarily “native look and feel.” It really changes the game.

dgreensp··on Mice can inherit learned sensitivity to a smell (2013)
Note that the “inheritance” can come from the father, and also happens with in vitro fertilization.
dgreensp··on Why Tesla's autopilot can't see a stopped firetruck
This article is fluff/FUD when it comes to the implications about autonomous driving. “Autopilot” is a marketing term for a kind of cruise control. The article repeatedly tries to make the point that if “the best system available” doesn’t stop for stationary vehicles, how will self-driving cars ever work? However, Tesla’s Autopilot is not a self-driving system, it’s a cruise control system. Emergency braking systems are also not self-driving systems. The comparison is meaningless.

I say the same thing to the comments about the irresponsible “UX” of Autopilot for not handling this case. It’s more about irresponsible marketing, capitalizing on the enthusiasm for self-driving cars, potentially lulling overzealous customers to trust a cruise control system or emergency braking system with their lives.

dgreensp··on If you multitask, so will your team
I was in 50-person all-hands meetings for a product at Google, and there wasn’t the time or the context for anyone to give feedback on anything. At the time I felt bad about my inability to pay attention — without my laptop out I would barely have been able to stay in the room due to boredom — but the meeting really was a poor format and a waste of people’s precious time, attention, and energy, even at an hour a week.
dgreensp··on Fellow Engineers: This is where your money comes from
Yes, the original statement is totally reasonable:

Ultimately, I want a profitable product to be a byproduct of my excellent engineering, not have my engineering be just a means to an end, of getting to a profitable product.

In other words, “I want to work for a company that values engineering excellence.” And the reply is something like, “you don’t understand how business works”? It’s true that an understanding of the concepts in the article will help you recognize a good business so that you don’t go to work for a company started by engineers with no understanding of business themselves, but you don’t want to work for someone that has a knee-jerk reaction to bringing up engineering quality as something important, either.

dgreensp··on Impatience: The Pitfall of Every Ambitious Person
I think the author was contrasting being a “fair-weather,” unknowledgeable investor (in the stock market, or by analogy in prorjects) who buys in when things are going up and pulls out when they go down, versus being a committed, knowledgeable investor who waits for a specific opportunity.
dgreensp··on Driverless Hotel Rooms: The End of Uber, Airbnb and Human Landlords
Indeed, turning your hotel room or your office at work into a vehicle so that it can pick you up just seems like saving a commute by merging it with “being at your destination.”

So your commute takes on properties of already being at your destination, and being at your destination takes on properties of your commute or taxi ride — being in a space-constrained vehicle in motion, consuming power, creating and experiencing traffic, etc, not just en route but all day or all night!

dgreensp··on Why Am I So Lazy?
As someone who used to be much like the asker and is now a little more like the answerer, I cannot recommend this answer enough! It is so insightful and well-put.

Treat it as breadcrumbs from someone farther along on the journey of growth and self-discovery.

dgreensp··on Show HN: Sapper.js – towards a better web app framework
Hi Rich. On my iPhone, I get a 3-second delay between when I “swipe to go back” and when the page is usable/scrollable on the Sapper HN. When I first went to the site, via the link above, the top nav links did not seem to work reliably, and it may have been the same 3-second delay, but I’m only getting now when swiping to go back — maybe because the page is being reloaded from the server? It’s still quite a delay, though.
dgreensp··on The iPhone X
Waaaay over the top with glowing, hyperbolic language about how the X truly, truly this time “reinvents” the iPhone in a way unlike any device has ever been reinvented.
dgreensp··on My Internet Mea Culpa
It's not Web 2.0-era social networking, it's a kind of tech utopianism that's been around for decades. I agree that the article doesn't make a lot of sense if you never believed that the Internet was going to automatically bring about (or be) a utopia. It's also reasonable to argue that the Internet, for all its flaws, succeeds at being an agent of social progress.
dgreensp··on My Internet Mea Culpa: I’m sorry I was wrong. We all were
If the Internet, unbeknownst to most of us, is actually supposed to bring about a uniform world culture, or world peace, or no more secrets/privacy... well, who’s to say it isn’t succeeding? You wanted your idea of utopia on your schedule?
dgreensp··on A different view on Functional Programming
you might know that it’s usually defined by some of its features, such as: reification of functions, avoidance or banning of functions with side-effects, use of higher-order functions and so on

The "function" in "functional programming" and the "function" in "avoidance or banning of functions with side-effects" are two different words, by the way! FP is named after the math word, not the programming language word, which means different things in different languages but usually means a kind of subroutine. FP means programming in a style that emphasizes composition of mathematical functions, and in an imperative language this generally amounts to writing your subroutines in a certain way. It just so happens that many imperative languages call subroutines "functions."

dgreensp··on E Pur Si Muove
If your startup idea is actually offensive to people, maybe take a step back and think about that, or just do it anyway, who cares? Since when are entrepreneurs afraid of "speaking heresies" or "toxic reactions"... from whom? Investors? Friends at dinner parties? Are the reactions of San Franciscans really so unique? Somehow blaming a city for your idea's reception sounds suspect. Also, playing the victim. Getting called out on political incorrectness is not akin to being bludgeoned with a "club."

If you tend towards "constantly thinking about how everything you say might be misinterpreted," congratulations, you're neurotic, like me. It's just something you have to overcome enough to be comfortable expressing your own unique opinions. When you do this, you may find your controversial opinions are merely out of touch. Like you have an IQ of 180 and you've been reading scientific papers and you can prove there are only two genders... and now if you can't express this view over a beer in SOMA without getting some looks, you can't invent the self-driving car or something...?

dgreensp··on Simplicity Before Generality, Use Before Reuse
This article really hits home in terms of how people sometimes think about React components, and how I’d like them to think about them.

I sometimes hear, from other engineers working on a complex React app, that the point of React’s components is that every component is written to be “reusable.” Every component. This is used as a justification for “going general” immediately when writing a component. In reality, there is real work to make a one-off component into a reusable component, and that work can only be done in the context of having (or at least realistically imagining, not dreaming up as an exercise) multiple use sites.

What React components actually provide are the same things that modules and functions provide: encapsulation; limited dependencies; a calling convention. When you write a function, you try to keep the arguments to a minimum; you might say it makes the function more “reusable,” but there is still a big difference between a library function that is designed to be used from anywhere, and a private helper function that is not. React components are “reusable” the way functions and modules are reusable. A better word might be “usable.” :) You can reason about the use, even if there is only one use.

Making something “reusable” means making it general, and we’ve all had the experience that the article points to of taking some code that was intended to be general, but in fact is used in only one place, and remaking it so that it’s actually possible to use in a second place.

That said, I have many times in programming succeeded in boiling something down to its essence in advance, and writing the general thing first, followed by the specific thing. I suspect this is actually more about simplicity than generality, however. I’m thinking of cases of “bottom-up” development where you write the primitives and then the higher-level parts in terms of the primitives. Actually, maybe it is about generality too, and when you are testing out your primitives in different combinations, you are doing the work required for good generality (seeing lots of different cases and basing your decisions on that).

dgreensp··on Why your programmers just want to code
This article comes to entirely the wrong conclusion, and I am very encouraged at the number of commenters pointing it out.

Engineers engineer. They are highly trained professionals who are doing their job when they are figuring out how to build something, improve something, or fix something, often with the goal of being able to develop new features quickly without an inordinate number of bugs.

Your engineering team shouldn’t be running your business. Even if they have good ideas. And in practice, they will be overruled immediately, anyway, the moment someone with any real authority makes a roadmap or a key decision, because they are engineers. They aren’t answerable to the board. They haven’t studied the market and competitive landscape in depth. They can’t pivot the company.

There’s something perverse and The Office-like about diagnosing Jamie as a problem “but it’s not his fault.”

Engineer runs into boss’s office: “Sir, code quality is critically low. I suggest we begin paying down technical debt before it’s too late.” Boss, smiling to camera: “This is Jamie. When he started, he was a team player. He believed in the vision. He didn’t spend all day nit-picking about things like code quality. Look at him now! I don’t blame Jamie, though. I blame myself. If I had made Jamie feel like his big ideas and product insights were welcome here, early on, he wouldn’t have devolved into seeing himself as a mere code monkey.”

dgreensp··on Why your programmers just want to code
Let me know where I can find a company like this! It’s obvious to me that engineering quality is precisely what engineers should be worried about — the “how” as opposed to the “what” or the “why”. Like chefs should be focused on the food.

When you take the responsibility for building the right thing for the market, etc and smear it across all the engineers, some will step up and become informal managers, organically acquiring power in response to the responsibility put on them, while others who are too busy programming or not interested in taking on other jobs will realize they have responsibility that is out of line with their power.

← PreviousPage 12 of 30Next →