HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dgreensp

3,476 karma · joined April 10, 2007

David Greenspan
submissionscomments
dgreensp··on “tipflation” and “tip creep” are sparking a backlash
This just sounds like the author not liking to tip more than 20% and being concerned someone might judge them for that. There is “research” cited in the article, but not when it comes to supporting the headline, only to make other points. The fact that a professor of economics wrote an essay saying that somebody might have some negative feelings about tipping is not news. The comments here are sure to be way more thoughtful and balanced an exploration of the topic.

This part tells me the author is making up controversy and is not looking at things very reasonably:

> It's not only human workers who are asking for tips, but services like GoFundMe, a platform for people to fundraise for issues like emergency health costs. When people donate to a cause, the site asks for a "tip" to help it continue functioning. GoFundMe also charges a processing fee, which is deducted from the donations before the recipient receives the money; it doesn't disclose this processing fee when it asks donors to add a tip.

From what I can tell, the processing fee of 2.9% goes straight to the payment processing company (or most of it, probably depending on payment method). Plus it’s the only fee and this is very clear on GoFundMe’s pricing page. To drum up some idea that it’s an extra hidden fee that GoFundMe is not transparent about is ridiculous. They are presumably asking for tips instead of higher fees so that people can pay according to what they’re able to pay.

dgreensp··on Transcending Scaling Laws with 0.1% Extra Compute
By "transcending scaling laws" and "improve the scaling properties," do they just mean higher-quality output compared to using the same (or smaller) model size with previous methods?
dgreensp··on Show HN: WunderGraph – The simplicity of RPC with the power of GraphQL
I’m glad, actually! I had some more direct feedback that I didn’t submit. It wasn’t clear at first, for example, if it uses GraphQL or offers an alternative that is as powerful (the answer seems to be “GraphQL or TypeScript,” whatever that means). It says it’s a framework for any backend, but then the diagram has a special WunderGraph server in the middle of it. Most people haven’t thought about different ways to structure a backend, and even I (as someone who worked for Apollo, though right before it became Apollo) am not totally sure what it means to compose APIs using a graph. Or “transform a database into a toolkit.” A lot of full-stack developers still have only a vague notion of what Apollo does, I think. Also, does this new thing enable best practices and make them easier? Or is it trying to supersede best practices with new practices? I think a lot of education is in order.
dgreensp··on When was the term ‘directory’ replaced by ‘folder’?
In the 90s, as I remember it, Macs didn’t have anything called a directory, while Windows and Unix-based OSes had only directories (at least among geeks). I still use “directory” today if it’s in a Windows, Linux, or general context; “folder” in a Mac context. But I guess Windows switched to “folder” too at some point. But also, Macs are now BSD-based and I’m a programmer, so it’s directories when talking about command-line stuff.

Windows got “folder” by way of Macs, I’m pretty sure,

dgreensp··on Nick Cave on ChatGPT
There’s already a lot of creative work that is somewhat superficial and unoriginal but serves its purpose, for better or worse. There are pop songs I like, for example, where the lyrics could have been written by an AI (but the production and vibe of the music make up for it). The lyrics were actually written by a producer or two in an afternoon while they were having a good time and not taking it too seriously, just writing what sounded good (in constrast to the suffering-to-put-words-to-one’s-pain described in the letter). I think it’s possible to underappreciate how art can carry a message, and creative works can touch people in a way that an AI working by itself won’t because it has no reason to; it has nothing to say. GPT-3 is basically a fancy autocomplete. That said, will AI-generated works probably touch people deeply and make them feel things? Sure. It’s not hard to make humans feel things. And AI that is good at summarizing and reflecting things back to us will make us feel seen. It’s easy to underestimate AI and overestimate the genius of the poor artist who is trying to generate new ideas and produce work based on them at the limits of his human capacity for generating novelty and synthesizing output.

It’s already easy to generate mediocre work, and humans decide what gets popular, whether it’s the audience or the people choosing what gets made or distributed.

Movie scripts have been getting more superficial and less original, so if an AI writes a Spider-man movie and no one can tell, it will be because we’ve met in the middle.

dgreensp··on Show HN: WunderGraph – The simplicity of RPC with the power of GraphQL
Sometimes I imagine what it would look like if an old-school piece of technology like Sqlite had a buzzy marketing homepage. "The power of SQL meets the simplicity of a file. In your pocket." And the entire page would be a dozen taglines in large font at that exact same level of specificity.

This seems very similar to Apollo at the pitch level: GraphQL/graph-based backend architecture, free tools, sell backend software and services. The logo is even extremely similar to Apollo's. Apollo sells software to enterprises that have adopted GraphQL and do a lot of GraphQL. When you move away from that, the app framework/BaaS "market" is very crowded. Everybody wants a piece of the backend these days--the privilege of running some short or generic code for you in a datacenter for a fraction of a penny, with the promise that it's "easier" that way. Bouncing each user request between five different data centers (Auth0, application server, datastore, etc) is actually kind of slow, though.

I think it should be more clear from the landing page what is novel here; what differentiates it; what is a killer feature or moment of delight you can't get elsewhere; who is it for.

dgreensp··on FTX pre-mortem overview
Yup. And even as I read my own comment, I can hear someone saying, “The long-term thesis remains sound!” and “Lots of other funds had similar losses!” and “How were we supposed to know, it was a perfect storm!” Meanwhile building bubbles upon bubbles upon bubbles.
dgreensp··on FTX pre-mortem overview
So am I reading this right: If I have $1m of Tesla stock, and I borrow $1m to buy crypto, that’s zero “net borrowing,” because the stock is “liquid” so I can just repay the loan at any time. Then they both go down by 50%. Now I need more “liquidity,” i.e. to borrow more money, which apparently grows on trees.
dgreensp··on Tech companies are irrational pop cultures
An essay about academia (versus software engineering in industry) would probably make slightly different points. Academics definitely know their history.

Also, when an actual disruptive new technology is first invented, jumping on it and trying to do something with it is both trendy and arguably rational, but this is a relatively rare occurrence.

dgreensp··on Prosperity Comes from Eliminating Jobs, Not Saving Them
The idea that producing and consuming “stuff” is the end-all-be-all (more important than whether people have any money, for example) has already received too much emphasis in the last fifty years.

It’s like, as long as people are buying TVs, everything must be good. They must have money, then. Or credit cards. And the companies that make TVs make money, which makes the stock market go up, which helps people’s retirement accounts. Anyway, go buy more stuff, it’s good for the economy. That’s just capitalism and consumerism. Stuff being bought and sold benefits big corporations, and not people that much, increasingly so.

The current way we distribute money (and healthcare!) to most people is “jobs.” A human-centric view of prosperity would focus on whether people have what they need, and how to get money to people (which people do need, or else they need food, shelter, etc). If you assume arbitrary progressive changes in taxation and government, problem solved, I guess. Absent that, we need innovation in employing people, not innovation in making stuff.

I’m not saying automation is bad or “stop automating.” But as other commenters point out, the question is not just total wealth, but how that wealth is distributed. I hope everyone realizes that in 2023!

dgreensp··on There is no software maintenance
Agreed. The author says some intelligent things about why software has gotten so low-quality, and the experience of developing software and using software has gotten so bad, but they think it is a good thing.

Imagine interviewing for a job and the CTO says, "Here at HyperAgileCorp, we believe that software maintenance does not exist. We realized that software development is just the act of adding features to products, and, amazingly, there's no end to the features we can add. Using continuous integration and deployment, we are able to add and ship features fast enough that no part of the code is ever in a stable state. Because nothing is ever finished, there is nothing to maintain.

"You might think this would lead to bugs, but actually, bugs are an impossibility. To have a bug would require a deviation from the designed or expected behavior; a bug is a problem with the code. We don't do any design or have any expectations at the level of the fine-grained behavior of the software. Remember, this is a product, and products have features. Like, the other day, I wanted someone to add tables to our rich text editor. You should be able to click the little icon of a table and it should insert a table. That's a feature. Making the software crash less often could be considered a feature--that is, something we could implement. But we don't know if a missing feature is a "problem" until we evaluate how it impacts the customer and our bottom line. If adding a row to a table crashes the app 1% of the time, or 10% of the time, for example... true, that is an opportunity for a feature (not crashing) which could enhance some customer's experience of using the software, and maybe it could even lead to more sales and a more successful product. Keep in mind, though, that we have a lot of other features we are working on that will also enhance the customer's experience, and we have some ideas about how they could lead to a lot more sales.

"Besides, we ship new versions of our software every day. Even if something 'works correctly' or 'doesn't crash' today, a junior dev might change the code tomorrow and make it work 'incorrectly' again, according to somebody. And that's a good thing, because that change is probably part of some way we are making the product even better. We're not trying to keep this code the same. That's the old 'maintenance' thinking. 'Maintaining' something means 'preserving' it. Preservation is for jams and jellies. We're developers. Builders. That junior dev is probably building a big and important feature. It's not practical for him to understand all the code he's changing. His lack of experience doesn't matter, though, because, as I've explained, his code won't have any bugs and won't require any future maintenance! We'll just keep building."

dgreensp··on Why is the JavaScript ecosystem like this?
I like posts like this, because software with these properties does deserve to be roasted. It seems like no one can figure out or remember anymore what's wrong with it, though. It's a valid question.

But a couple clarifications.

I don't develop or distribute software that depends on Node, but I imagine deciding which versions of Node to support, or conversely require, for software like Ghost, is a bit like deciding which Java VM versions to support, or which browsers to support. That is, there is a lot of compatibility between Node versions, but do you just develop and test on the latest one, or do you make an effort to support more/older versions? In this case, Ghost seems to be tested on v12, v14, and v16. The author seems to mistakenly think that only the "Active LTS" version of Node gets security fixes, but that's not the case, v14 and v16 are in "Maintenance LTS" and receive security fixes. That said, their "ends of life" are in April and September of this year, for whatever that's worth. At the end of the day, I think it is considered easy to update and/or run multiple versions of Node. I'm don't know why an app written for Node 16 wouldn't work with a newer Node 18, though, that kind of stuff annoys me sometimes.

For the MariaDB support, I googled and found this note from the Ghost devs: "Note: MariaDB is not an officially supported database for Ghost. It just happened to work given the similarities with MySQL, but we optimize and test for MySQL 5 and 8. As of Ghost 5.0 we are clarifying that official support is purely for MySQL8 in production so that we can double down on DB optimizations." Maybe that's what we're talking about? https://github.com/TryGhost/Ghost/issues/14446

Now, the deeper trend that I think is misguided is the rate of iteration and breaking changes, and apps and libraries having too many dependencies. The problems propagate through the dependency graph. Someone releases a library, and then adds a bunch of features, and then rewrites it, adds features, rewrites it again. That's fine for some hobby project that no one is using. I think anything I say won't be appreciated by someone who hasn't experienced programming and computing any other way, e.g. writing Java applications in the 1990s and 2000s. Or even just using desktop applications in the 90s. Software used to sort of "mature" and then continue to be used and supported, while staying pretty much the same, for years. It wasn't constantly rearranged to use new versions of things that are constantly rearranged to use new versions of things that are constantly rearranged etc. etc. etc.

dgreensp··on Compromised PyTorch-nightly dependency chain between December 25th – December 30
I was developing in Java right up until Maven became popular. We used to just download jars. What would you say is the main difference with Maven/Java vs NPM?

My recollection is that Java libraries were larger, higher-quality, more stable, and better-maintained, and you didn't need as many of them. A Java jar was not a "package" but contained dozens of "packages" developed together. Jars tended to be self-contained or mostly self-contained; small dependencies would shipped inside. The idea of making npm packages as small as possible, like practically putting each file in a separate git repo, and publishing it as a separate artifact, emerged shortly after NPM itself, and it was radical, and not really particularly good. Java also has a much larger standard library, and between the packages that come with Java itself, the packages that aren't technically part of the standard library but were written by Sun/Oracle, and well-known third-party utilities, you didn't need a lot of third-party packages. And if you needed something tiny like left-pad and didn't have it, you'd probably just copy and paste it.

dgreensp··on Stable Diffusion macOS native app
Draw Things is only for iOS. You can try to run it on a Mac, but it crashes for me.

Also CoreML on a Mac seems to require macOS 13, which is reportedly buggy. I was going to update and changed my mind after reading people's experiences online. :(

dgreensp··on Freeform: a new app designed for creative collaboration
From the marketing, it seems targeted at groups of high school students who all happen to have thousand-dollar Apple tablets.

I’ve been using Macs since 1989, and I don’t get this. I’ll try it with my kids, though. We all have iPads. They use theirs for games at the moment, mostly. I don’t use mine much anymore.

dgreensp··on Piss-Weak Parenting
As a parent, I find the first part relatable.

Monster trucks are for boys or girls or whoever wants them IMO.

dgreensp··on TSMC founder Morris Chang says globalization and free trade 'almost dead'
Just because the US might be able to manufacture something high-tech again doesn’t mean the death of anything… like maybe globalization will get 5% less extreme, before turning around or doing whatever it does next? I don’t see how the existence of some small trend or force going against some huge dominant trend amounts to it being almost dead. Globalization is like capitalism. Calling it fragile is just mock victimhood or whining. Proponents push it forward regardless of the human cost. Democracy and human rights are fragile.
dgreensp··on Amazon shipped fake product, refuses refund until 'correct' item returned
At the start of the article it cites Amazon’s “declining profits,” but later it says Amazon’s $386 billion a year in profits is growing at a slowing pace and might start growing by less than 20% year over year. What hardship.
dgreensp··on The impotence of being clever
I agree, the writing is entertaining, but it doesn't stick to any particular points. If it did, there would be more accountability for the author to say things that lead to useful conclusions, I think. At times I found myself wondering what the author was getting at, but then they would move on.

Is talking about "culture" a way of lumping fiction and reality together? Fictional always-right, wisecracking detectives aren't real, but there are real detectives, and presumably some clever ones whose actual cleverness is of real practical use. Fictional scientists who are more passionate than logical aren't real, but there are real scientists, whose cleverness is presumably valuable. Realistic work of professionals doesn't make for good reading. Fiction is entertainment in the first place.

dgreensp··on The distinction between free speech as a legal right and cultural value
> We need a free speech culture to reap the benefits of free speech law

No we don't. This essay is trying so hard to say that while de-platforming may not be government censorship, it's just as bad. But it's not. In China right now, people are protesting in the street with blank signs because they aren't allowed to say anything about anything in public, and they are still getting arrested. There's a sort of slippery slope argument given in the article that we shouldn't be headed in that direction. But Twitter's content policies, for example, are in line with the culture and laws of Western nations as a whole. My understanding is some countries have hate speech laws that the US doesn't have. There is no "slippery slope to China," just the US wanting to be a rough-and-tumble outlier. It's the same kind of slippery slope argument that says having "normal" healthcare like other Western countries would make us communist or something.

Social norms are changing; that's not fascism. That hyperbolic metaphor has gotten out of control. We have a republic "if we can keep it," as the article says; losing our democracy to an authoritarian regime permanently (or for a long term) would entail a level of real suffering that is not comparable to (and has nothing to do with) it becoming permanently socially unacceptable to use a racist slur, say, in public discourse. There are no brilliant "ideas" embedded in sheer bigotry that we are missing out on, and giving less airtime to hate speech or misinformation is nothing more or less than that.

At the very least, the article claims to elucidate a "distinction" but actually blurs several things together, such as censorship; "canceling" (which can mean a lot of things but is sometimes just a simple result of public backlash leading to a TV show being canceled, and you can't force people to like some celebrity who committed sexual assault or is racist etc etc and see them the same way as before, or treat having a talk show on TV with advertisers as some kind of fundamental human right); and what ideas are considered worth discussing at academic institutions (which have always had their idiosyncratic preferences about what ideas merit discussion and research, I'm sure).

dgreensp··on The mysticism of Alan Watts (2018)
I think he got it well enough, it's just not his truth.

Like if Watts says, "Life isn't a journey, it's a dance," one can hear that and say, "Ok, I get what you're going for, I've reflected on it deeply, but for me, life is a journey, not a dance." And it's not necessarily true that, if one reflects deeper, and grows wiser, and puts down one's preconceptions, etc etc, they will eventually, in the fullness of time, realize Alan was right. That's the sort of presumptive condescension that is being called out.

dgreensp··on Run Stable Diffusion on Your M1 Mac’s GPU
Great. FYI, the issue with pyyaml was caused by the "--pre" flag. The reason installing it separately fixes the problem is because it installs it without the "--pre" flag, and then it is already installed when you install the requirements.

I haven't been able to make sense of n-samples and n-iters. Changing the former caused generation to freeze at 0%. Changing the latter seems to generate multiple images, even though the SD docs for n-iters are "sample this often".

dgreensp··on Run Stable Diffusion on Your M1 Mac’s GPU
Wow, I'm getting as low as 1.2 seconds per "step" (about a minute for a 512x512 image with default settings) on my 32 GB M1 laptop (2021, 16-inch).
dgreensp··on Run Stable Diffusion on Your M1 Mac’s GPU
I'm working on getting this running. Instead of "venv/bin/activate" I had to run "source venv/bin/activate". And I got an error installing the requirements, fixed by running "pip install pyyaml" as a separate command.
dgreensp··on Jonathan Blow on Societal Collapse (2019)
I disagree, Microsoft Word on a Mac in the 90s was lightning fast and rock solid.

Few apps start up instantly in 2022. Many require a good network connection and/or a half a gigabyte of RAM, for no good reason.

dgreensp··on Will Bun JavaScript Take Node's Crown
Installing a gigabyte of NPM packages (or whatever is being said to be faster) a little bit faster and a little bit worse is not that interesting IMO.

I actually use Deno right now because I only use a handful of third-party dependencies in my project, and I can use Deno’s bundler instead of webpack (even though that’s not its intended use). I’d rather simplify away the stuff that’s slow and complicated rather than making it faster and more complicated (less correct, less compatible).

dgreensp··on Every single time I open your software, I'm asked to download an update
I've been needing to vent about this. I have two kids and we play Minecraft, Starcraft, and other Blizzard games and Steam games, on the LAN; we have several computers, both Macs and PCs, in the household. The amount of "updating" that happens is absolutely insane. Blizzard games update themselves multiple times per day (I read somewhere that if it is updating this much, it is a bug and you should do a clean install or something, but it has always happened on all computers no matter what). All of these games have launchers, and the launchers also require updates, and even if you are playing single-player or on the LAN, you have to take the update. You have to sign in with your username and password. You have to use a different account, with a different email address, on every computer. I made the mistake of buying two iMacs with SSD/HD fusion drives for the household, which use very slow HDs, and then for a while I was booting one of them into Windows (until I bought a couple Windows machines for gaming), and Windows only used the slow HD. A forced Steam game update could take half an hour. Also the various launchers sometimes have bugs and get stuck in a bad state, like at one point the Blizzard updater got stuck in "updating" mode and refused to start Warcraft III. Which should not need daily updates in 2022!
dgreensp··on Nobody optimizes happiness
> Everyone I know is scheming for the future. They’ve got big goals and get up every day and work like mad to try to achieve them.

> Like—say your startup goes public and you become a billionaire. What now? What will you buy, where will you live, what will you eat for lunch?

First of all, the everybody/nobody in this article is scoped to the author's circle/bubble.

IME, a lot of founder types are pretty happy just working and not doing much else. After their company IPOs, they will probably just start another company. They aren't necessarily working to retire.

Having enough money that you don't have to work is never a bad thing, IMO. I have a chunk of money right now from selling some stock, not enough to retire (with my lifestyle), but enough for now. Boredom is a lot easier to solve than not having enough money. (I have kids, and lots of code I want to write; I'll always be busy, and if I'm bored it's because the things I'm busy doing are boring.) I'm sure it's fair to say that retiring takes some adjustment. You can take some time to get in touch with yourself. You can work if you want. You have a lot more options.

The reason people don't focus on their happiness IME is they weren't brought up to. I was brought up to go to school every day, do my homework, and achieve. Not to prioritize myself and building a fun, joyful, fulfilling life for myself. It's a matter of culture. And there are also stages of life where it makes sense to focus on one's career.

dgreensp··on Writing: A misunderstood activity
Perhaps the author: posits skill when isn’t.

Yeah, something seemed a little “off” about the writing style, in an unusual way. This is “real writing,” I take it?

dgreensp··on Parti: Pathways Autoregressive Text-to-Image Model
It's really true. Politically, I am a progressive (in US terms). The way these companies describe the problem and solution -- the model data reflects our culture back at us, so we are not giving anyone access to it -- is so nonsensical as to leave me wondering if there is a "real" reason, or is that just how they think?
← PreviousPage 5 of 30Next →