HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dgreensp

3,476 karma · joined April 10, 2007

David Greenspan
submissionscomments
dgreensp··on Notes on Effective Altruism
Incredible article!

What strikes me about EA is the lack of values around family, community, or civics. If you value the life and happiness of every human on the planet equally, except maybe yourself, I’d venture to say you are not ok. You have no friends/family/connections/support/village/etc). Math and abstract virtue in the mind can’t replace that.

I don’t know that I’d sacrifice my life for any number of others. But I care about my friends and acquaintances. Some of them are not ok. I’d rather lift them out of poverty, or get them decent healthcare, than save a life on the other side of the planet. I’d rather try to influence voters and the political process in my own state and country, or help house the homeless in my town. I have about 400 Facebook friends, and some are billionaires, some are broke, maybe a few are homeless or on the edge of homelessness.

You can’t save the world if you can’t create a microcosm of the world you want to live in, around yourself, with real heartfelt connections.

dgreensp··on Show HN: Muse 2.0 with local-first sync
I skimmed the article, but what makes Android not sufficient to interact with Muse? I haven’t tried Muse, but I’ve thought plenty about building a local-first notebook app for thinking. Something about pen input or UI jank? Muse seems less general than I was thinking of it as being if only Apple hardware can run its core feature set…
dgreensp··on Hard to See: How trauma became synonymous with authenticity
Trauma is the consequences of abuse and ongoing lack of safety, in the body. It’s always been around. I think the use of public spaces to discuss, integrate, and heal people’s personal trauma is relatively new in our culture? Something like that. The rules of social interaction are changing. Being “witnessed” by one’s community or group, or someone, is part of shaking off trauma, but who? What counts as one’s community these days (online)? When do we hold space for whose trauma? There are some good questions there.

Bo Burnham is all about fake authenticity. That was actually a great example, as much as I like his stuff.

And “trauma porn” whose only purpose is to titillate is of course not of moral value. But telling people’s stories and sharing our experiences has value.

dgreensp··on Why I Quit Google’s WebAssembly Team, and How It Made Me Sick
Having a toxic job is not a sign of extreme privilege. Nor is facing a trade-off between having income and taking care of one’s mental or physical health.
dgreensp··on Infinite Mac
As a Mac user since about 1988, this brings back memories!

It's sad but the UI feels almost futuristic.

dgreensp··on Pathways Language Model (PaLM): Scaling to 540B parameters
When can we try using it?? :)
dgreensp··on Two Vexing Problems in Functional Programming
These problems have lots of other well-known solutions.

For large objects: Persistent data structures with path-copying. Batching small mutations (and using mutation internally in a way that doesn’t leak out). Using the type system somehow to distinguish cases where copying is not necessary (experimental in certain new languages). Structuring your program around a “data store” that is mutable.

For the “references” problem: Explicit references, like by ID. Or mutable “atoms” as in Clojure, which are maybe sort of like the “mediators” in the article.

dgreensp··on Ask HN: How does one affordably eat without cooking or cleaning?
Get in touch with why you are doing what you are doing, and what you really want. If you want to save money, you definitely can. Maybe you could think about what that money could be used for. There are plenty of other benefits to preparing food at home, too, cooking or not. It's more convenient, and more under your direct control. If you don't really care about spending less money, or you aren't willing to change anything about what you eat (e.g. sushi for lunch, Chinese food for dinner, and so on), just keep doing what you're doing. There are lots of common ways that people get their nutrients, though, without spending a lot of money, or cooking elaborate gourmet meals.

Do you care about nutrition? Do you need every meal to be a hot meal? Do you mind eating the same thing every day? I'm not going to tell you to eat fast food, but restaurant options span a wide price range, and you could start by being more price-conscious about breakfast and lunch, for example. And there are lots of things you can prepare at home that don't require "cooking," like toast, cereal, a sandwich, or a salad. I know plenty of people who, when they hit on their perfect salad or sandwich, wanted to eat it every day, or at least a few times a week. There's also a lot you can microwave, and not just TV dinners, but also steam-in-the-bag veggies, rice, and proteins like hot dogs, bacon, sausage, meatballs, and so on.

I don't know how old you are, but it sounds like you are single; do you want to have a partner? Kids? You'll need to at least be willing to wash a plate or wipe down a counter. Can you cut up a piece of fruit or a vegetable? Make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich? Instead of thinking about cooking, maybe think about assembling foods that you like (which may be raw or microwaved) into a meal that you like. If you don't like going to the grocery store, go once a week on Sunday and stock up. Or have someone shop for you.

I pay a housekeeper who does the dishes three times a week (and laundry and other tasks). This same person can also shop, and even prepare meals for you, which can be kept in the fridge and reheated. Some housekeepers who do these sorts of tasks don't also want to scrub your bathrooms, so keep that in mind (there's a line between housekeeping and housecleaning, but it can be blurry). It can be better to get a cleaning service once a month for that. But you can go on Care.com and find someone who is offering the set of services you need.

But also, think about the skills you want to have in life and don't be entirely utilitarian about it.

dgreensp··on Addressing Criticism of RISC-V Microprocessors
IANAE, but the article addresses why the arguments that assume these instructions need to be combined are usually not based on looking at the whole picture.
dgreensp··on US Copyright Office refuses application with AI algorithm named as author
The amount of autonomy that makes something a “person” has only ever been drastically understated in these sorts of discussions, I find. Like saying a future self-driving taxi would own its own business and keep its profits. That’s like giving a self-driving tractor the deed to the farm. It’s easy to personify things that demonstrate some amount of “agency” (moving around on their own, making decisions), I guess, but lots of things do that and it doesn’t make them legal people who can own property and the like. Even if it made sense to give a deed to a tractor, no one would do it.
dgreensp··on Flow Browser: Flow makes HTML faster
If you haven't encountered this browser before, I find it fascinating. It's meant for devices that aren't necessarily computers. For example, someone making a digital "sign" can use HTML and CSS, or dynamic HTML motion graphics, to create their content, and run it in Flow. It doesn't have to be able to run, say, Google Docs. However, the developer wrote a blog post about getting Google Docs to run, by fixing the necessary bugs and adding the necessary features: https://www.ekioh.com/devblog/google-docs-in-a-clean-room-br... For example, Google Docs keeps the focus in a hidden iframe, apparently, and Flow wasn't firing the right series of events when the focus traveled between frames.

The way I look at it, for a custom "browser engine" whose goal is to let you use an independent implementation of the DOM to create graphics and UIs that render on the GPU of an embedded device, it's delightfully over-engineered.

dgreensp··on What Color Is Your Monad
Interesting. What language is a good example of having effect sets? Koka?

What about the case of needing context like “correlation id,” from the article? Can that be modeled as an effect?

dgreensp··on Ask HN: What's the best way to monetize actual programming?
Have you heard of a guy named Paul Graham?

Obviously the advice “start a start-up” has some caveats, but this is Hacker News, I mean this whole site/community started with the idea that “hackers” should just start start-ups, for similar reasons to this.

dgreensp··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
To be clear, I was advocating against the “individual or collective action is pointless” position on climate change. I do think people should be thinking, talking, and acting, if they want!
dgreensp··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
It’s a fascinating article, but it lacks respect for people taking principled positions about this social issue. Progressives are fad-chasing sheep, supposedly, while anarchists are legit, but crazy.

It’s like the Jordan Peterson philosophy on climate change: People need to stop talking about it and caring about it, because anyone who does so is just virtue-signaling and basically being a shallow, useless idiot about it. When actually people are trying to figure out how to deal with the fact that our leaders and institutions are so out of touch with reality and stuck in their ways. But no, the important point is people in general are shallow and amoral, like me, but dumber.

Culture changes and drives change. Collective action eventually does something.

dgreensp··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
Yeah, all the positions people are taking (progressives, anarchists) about work, here, are in the right direction from the status quo. But saying that wouldn’t fit with the author’s “aesthetic.” :)
dgreensp··on Agatha Christie could afford a maid and a nanny but not a car
It’s consumerism and society being shaped for profit. It doesn’t actually cost much money for everyone to have a place to live and food to eat, but our economy (in the US) is considered healthy when people are shopping a lot and spending money on relative luxuries. Paying big mortgages on houses built by real estate developers to maximize profit. It should be a lot easier to live on not much money than it is. We exalted the “middle class” and their spending. That seems like part of it, at least.

I can’t believe people still repeat the old “productivity” canard from economists. There was this idea that technology makes workers more productive, raising wages, which hasn’t been true since the 1970s, because it’s just wrong. Technology makes companies more productive, and the workers make the same. Economists hold their wrong theory above reality and act like this gap is some kind of mysterious “dark matter” that defies the known laws of the universe. As I always say, when a company upgrades their copy machine to one that is twice as fast, they don’t pay the person who makes the copies twice as much. Also, without unions, and with an abundance of people to do the unskilled work needed, there is no force pushing wages up.

dgreensp··on The Matrix Resurrections estimated to lose Warner Bros $100M
> For every Spider-Man: No Way Home, Venom: Let There Be Carnage, No Time to Die, Dune, or Fast & Furious 9 that brings in big bucks, there’s a Space Jam: A New Legacy, The Suicide Squad, Tenet, or Raya and the Last Dragon that fails to turn a single penny of profit in theaters.

Tenet made plenty of money in worldwide box office sales, not counting DVD/Blu-Ray or streaming: https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Tenet-(2020) "worldwide box office is 1.8 times production budget"

Raya (budget $100m) also made money in theaters alone (worldwide box office $116m) despite being released in March 2021. Phew, I was going to be sad for a moment that Raya was some kind of failure, as if being included in a list that contained the new Space Jam movie wasn't bad enough.

Whoever wrote this article doesn't seem to know what they are talking about.

dgreensp··on My productivity app for the past 12 years has been a single .txt file (2020)
I think the real insight here is the calendar: it sounds like new tasks go straight onto the calendar, and that's how a to-do backlog is avoided! Interesting.
dgreensp··on My productivity app for the past 12 years has been a single .txt file (2020)
A text file is not difficult and impractical. "Number of features" is not what makes a tool practical.
dgreensp··on The death of feature engineering is greatly exaggerated
In the examples given, there is an existing pipeline from the “raw” input (CCD or unfused sensor data) to a simpler or less idiosyncratic thing (RGB pixel grid, position in space). The point seems to be, you still have a design choice to make about whether to use the raw or processed data. The processed data is conceptually cleaner to work with, but the raw data may be cleaner in the sense of more accurate. The processed data doesn’t depend so much on the details of the sensor (such as the layout of the pixels on the CCD), but it does depend on the details of the processing (in the sense that it relies on them).

That’s not the same as having to choose or design a set of features, though, I don’t think.

dgreensp··on HN Discuss: Why so few Hi-Tech companies address real issues?
I agree. To the people saying it’s not tech: It’s not as if AirBnB or DoorDash created new technology. There definitely are start-ups in the areas listed above, but I’d like to see more household names.

Investors invested $25 billion into Uber to make it into some kind of success. I recently heard a billionaire VC say that their fund will bring about the future we all want, and someone replied, “The future who wants?” and the investor replied something to the effect of, customers vote with their wallet. I found this very misguided. It matters what we, as a society, invest in, and what kinds of money-making machines we build, bid sky-high, and blindly keep throwing money at.

dgreensp··on “Open source” is not broken
That is pretty funny!
dgreensp··on How did this PayPal spoof email pass SPF, DKIM and DMARC
It’s actually a real email PayPal sends.
dgreensp··on An introverts guide to increasing energy
I don't think extraverts need any feeling of obligation to go to a party, that's just their version of curling up alone with a book.

In my experience, the most striking difference between extraverts and introverts is that extraverts enjoy the stimulation of being around people (whether it's a party, a small group, or one on one), potentially from the moment they get up to the moment they go to sleep. They might live with three housemates, meet someone for breakfast, have a phone call with a friend just to chat, and on and on, and they don't feel drained, they feel energized. It's as natural as being alone all day is for an introvert.

dgreensp··on An introverts guide to increasing energy
The definitions given in the article are the ones I would give; see e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraversion_and_introversion#...

I'm not familiar with the theory that only introverts have an "internal model" that needs updating. I would think we all run on models at various levels of cognition (given that the brain doesn't contain any actual "external world" in it, only models), which we update both in real-time and in later processing (such as while sleeping).

dgreensp··on Individuals Matter
Wow, how do I start a list of people to never work for.
dgreensp··on TypeScript: Control flow analysis for destructured discriminated unions
Well, tagged unions, like many TS features, are designed to enable type-checking on vaguely idiomatic JS code, aren't they? That checks properties of objects in if-else statements? It sucks that people aren't open to defining their structures in a way that aids type-checking, if that's what you mean!
dgreensp··on TypeScript: Control flow analysis for destructured discriminated unions
I don't think the language designers would consider this, because there is a difference in TypeScript between a property existing with type undefined and not existing, regardless of the fact that it might sometimes be convenient if a non-existent property acted like a property that existed and had type undefined.
dgreensp··on TypeScript: Control flow analysis for destructured discriminated unions
"never" is not really ever a good choice for a property/member type, because it is assignable to all types. A function that literally never returns could/should have a return type of never, for example, but if the function actually returns a value, you have a "value of type never" which is supposed be impossible, and never acts like any (because a contradiction implies anything).
← PreviousPage 6 of 30Next →