HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dgroshev

1,778 karma · joined September 30, 2014

submissionscomments
dgroshev··on Ubiquiti: Enterprise NAS, Built on ZFS
HPE Instant On is pretty nice. Zero problems over the last seven years. It literally just works, including seamless handoffs between multiple APs.
dgroshev··on A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown
You're missing the vast interconnected network of stuff that's required to sustain that home. From your home battery to cancer treatments that you might need to sewer that runs to your home, all of this needs to be made and sometimes replaced. Most of those things are still unavailable to most humans; in many places we still haven't built roads, much less sewers and water distribution systems.

Household electricity self-sufficiency obscures the vast requirements to support it and extend this self-sufficiency to billions of other people.

dgroshev··on UK set to announce social media ban for under-16s
Let's look at an actual case study of a police state.

I think we can agree that a state-controlled paramilitary force executing a political opponent in broad daylight, on camera, is pretty far along the "police state" spectrum, right? This kind of thing is entirely incompatible with freedom, and should be a wake up call for the civil society to weed out anything that led to that, root and branch.

Enter the execution of Alex Pretti. Days after it happened, it transformed into yet another partisan issue, a topic for discussion, something that can possibly be justified. Effectively, it was normalised on the social and classic media. Media that, in the US, are pretty "free" [].

Negative freedoms are insufficient to stop a police state. What stops the police state is political engagement and regulation, and that requires a more nuanced understanding than just "either free of regulation or embracing the police state".

: …for moneyed interests to control and influence. For all their problems, I'd argue that BBC is substantially freer than say Fox News.

dgroshev··on UK set to announce social media ban for under-16s
We do, objectively speaking. We have free elections, viable new political parties, working mechanisms of feedback from the population to politicians, and a constitution keeping up with the times (we had a constitutional change just this year).
dgroshev··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
How is it worse than I suggested? There's no "surveillance", for all intents and purposes it's just a hole in functionality requiring age verification to be filled. Article 1 doesn't guarantee that as a kid I can use my possessions to acquire a bottle of vodka.

You don't need to show a government ID, I never did. Also, I trust Apple-mediated age verification with a single bit output to any vendor much more than a random B2B SaaS.

More generally, the backstop on abusing system is always political. It can't be just a passive immutable barrier with any variation seen as a slippery slope (see the US government just buying commercial intel on citizens). Our political system just saw two ~new national parties spring up in additional to already established three (plus national parties) and MPs revolting at a mild inconveniences to their constituents. We're alright.

dgroshev··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
It's no more "warrantless search" than object recognition in your photo app. Signal deliberately misrepresents the policy, which is about connecting (already existing, local) object recognition to (already existing, local) established adulthood of the user.
dgroshev··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
It absolutely doesn't. However, the argument doesn't work when it's about connecting the "is the user a kid" bit to the existing and constantly running object recognition (phone cameras already run skin detection all the time to set white balance), so people invent "third parties" and "report people to authorities".
dgroshev··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
Ironically, the very OP statement is exactly that: trying to make the world a worse place because they believe that that is how the world works.

The solution to avoiding dictatorship is engaging in politics and preventing dictatorship directly through that. Trying to retreat into the (perceived) wilderness and build barriers to dictatorship doesn't really work. But since people drafting that statement don't believe that politics work and it is, in fact, possible to both have a vibrant political scene (we have what, five viable political parties vs the American two?) and not let kids send nudes, they try to drag everyone into the same mind frame.

dgroshev··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
This is really disingenuous coming from Signal who pioneered secure compute architecture for a number of useful features [1][2]. On-device checks are no more "surveillance" than Signal's private contact discovery is, and the same slippery slope argument applies there.

It's also technically incoherent: the exact same kind of "surveillance" is already applied by every single phone, because that's how the Photos app (or whatever it's called on Android) searches for cat pictures based on the text "cat". I can't recall any Signal statements about cat recognition technology leading to "reporting people to government authorities".

The "cover-ups" link right in the beginning is a real mask-off moment though. This is not a measured statement informed by the reality of modern Britain. It's an American view informed by the twitter cesspool and divisive rhetoric of the far right. It's a real shame to see Signal falling so low.

[1]: https://signal.org/blog/private-contact-discovery/

[2]: https://signal.org/blog/secure-value-recovery/

dgroshev··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
> There are various other potential methods to verify one's age, all of which are forbidden by OFCOM. Account age, zero-knowledge proofs, key signing, some kind of OAuth thing, physical tokens that require proof of age to buy, etc. The only permitted ones require your to link your real-life identity.

This is just not true. See 4.17 here, for example [1]

[1] https://www.ofcom.org.uk/siteassets/resources/documents/cons...

dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
What compelled you to write this? It's just a random point having no relationship to what you're replying to. Why have you typed this and pressed "reply"?
dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
The question is completely different from the point I was making. "X did bad things on their own" and "Y had absolutely no relationship with X at any point" are two points so blindingly obviously different that I'm having a hard time accepting that you are genuinely confused about the difference.

It's a motte-and-bailey fallacy that starts with countries and leaders having relationships in a global, interwoven world and ends with excusing a blood-thirsty dictator as if they had no agency.

dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
I don't think anyone engaging in a good faith discussion would make the conclusion you just made.
dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
To add some pretty hard data to this: https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/fiona-and-irans-role-in-the-...
dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
Saying that it's the invasions that created civil wars and suffering in Afghanistan and Iraq is just exceptionally ignorant. Here's a taster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Ba%27athist_Ir...

For all their failures, the allies never bombed cities with nerve agents.

dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
You can't just skip the currently present and urgent defence requirements because they're "politically sensitive" and then go twenty years back to support your point.

But even if you want to do that, why don't you go just a couple more years further and argue that Bosnians should've been left to be genocided?

dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
This is a luxury belief that requires the privilege of being unbombed. I invite you to explain this to Ukrainians.
dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
Do you expect the same standard to be applied to the NHS? "The expert claiming that cancer is bad was employed by the NHS five years ago"
dgroshev··on UK media fails to disclose defence sector links in nearly 60% of cases
"People who have seen the state of the military first hand are saying that we need to fund the military" is not really shocking or sinister.
dgroshev··on Palantir has hired more than 30 senior UK Government officials
Why?

Have you seen what Russia is doing to Ukraine?

What's wrong with a European company working on not letting the same (or worse) repeat in the Baltic states or Poland?

dgroshev··on BYD Seal 08 debuts with Blade Battery 2.0: 1,000km range, 5-min charging, 684hp
> Car ownership costs are the second biggest expense for most households after rent, and self-driving cars cut this in half.

Living in a hostel with a shared bathroom can cut the biggest expense (rent) by more than half.

Would you?

dgroshev··on BYD Seal 08 debuts with Blade Battery 2.0: 1,000km range, 5-min charging, 684hp
Sure, more people would use them, but it doesn't mean that the majority of people would trade normal housing with dedicated bathrooms (that are used only for a fraction of the day) for that. Normal housing market didn't die when dorms were legal to construct.

The savings that can be made from living in a tiny box with a shared bathroom instead of a regular American house are extreme and are much bigger than savings from not owning a car. Do you seriously think that will convince people and we will see the death of dedicated housing units in the near future?

dgroshev··on BYD Seal 08 debuts with Blade Battery 2.0: 1,000km range, 5-min charging, 684hp
You can make even larger savings by moving into a dorm tomorrow. Are you neglecting the numbers?
dgroshev··on How I leared what a decoupling capacitor is for, the hard way
I found Phil's lab content [1] [2] indispensable for just this. Phil is a great communicator and gives in-depth explanations, so I didn't just watch most of his youtube, but also bought his mixed signals course and was very happy with it.

Phil also recommends this lecture in one of his videos [3], which is still one of my all time favourite lectures ever.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/@PhilsLab

[2] https://www.phils-lab.net/

[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QG0Apol-oj0

dgroshev··on BYD Seal 08 debuts with Blade Battery 2.0: 1,000km range, 5-min charging, 684hp
Do you live in a dorm with a shared bathroom? Most of your home is only used a few times a day.

People buy cars because it's a little bubble of home away from home. They store their stuff in there, it smells like them, and they don't get stranger's vomit on a seat when they want to drive somewhere.

The "people won't buy cars because self-driving" take just completely ignores the human nature.

dgroshev··on F-35 is built for the wrong war
You keep saying "loitering" and then use one way ranges. If "loitering", where does the time on station come from? Are the drones refuelled? Do they land or do they just crash when they run out of fuel? Or is "loitering" just as a buzzword devoid of meaning?

No, prop drones don't "geometrically catchup". Shahed's extreme range achieved by flying really slow, the top speed (which they don't sustain constantly to conserve fuel) is about 185kph, for the maximum flight time of about 13 hours. US carriers officially can sustain 60kph indefinitely, and in practice they can go faster. That means on a straight line a Shahed can only gain 1600km in the absolute best scenario. In reality it's much less, because launching takes time and the average speed is slower.

The capabilities that you're describing are a fantasy.

dgroshev··on F-35 is built for the wrong war
This is just nonsense. An unmanned platform that can stay on station for a significant time and strike at hundreds of miles and have enough payload to deal significant damage and be fast enough to arrive in meaningful time and somehow survive approaching a carrier group (those planes have guns, remember? it's not just SM-6 spam) cannot be cheap because of hard physical constraints like the energy required to stay in the air. There are no such "COTS" platforms, DJI quads don't cut it across multiple dimensions.
dgroshev··on F-35 is built for the wrong war
That's because the modern weapon tech tree is vast and complex. It's not factorio, there are no factories that can switch from producing DSLRs to MWIR cameras. A playdough factory can't cast solid rocket motors. A Tesla manufacturing line can't just switch to welding 10cm steel slabs for tanks. Moreover, those military-relevant processes and techniques require know-how that gets lost if the processes are not run.

Small quad hype is just techbro delusion. Those quads have their place, but the vast majority of the defence toolkit needs to be much more sophisticated. For example, Ukraine is still struggling to manufacture a domestic ballistic missile four years into the war, despite having tons of funding, a ballistic program pre-war, and Western experts willing to help. If western countries stopped low-rate production that normally goes into stockpiles, the timeline to start manufacturing up would be similar.

dgroshev··on F-35 is built for the wrong war
Even a single Group 3 UAS like Shahed is larger than a lot of kitchens. They can't be assembled in civilian houses.

You're confusing short range, highly Ukraine-specific Group 1 quads with long range OWA drones.

dgroshev··on F-35 is built for the wrong war
The US absolutely has air supremacy in Iran. You don't roll out B-52s in a contested airspace. MANPADS have an abysmal ceiling height, they are largely irrelevant short of some very narrow circumstances.

Just for your benefit, stealth coatings and materials (not "paint") are a tertiary defence after shaping and electronic warfare.

Group 3 UAS can't be assembled in homes and office buildings in any meaningful numbers. They are too big. Even Group 2 is marginal. I think you're confusing Group 1 quadcopters with long range OWA drones like Shaheds.

← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →