2,169 karma · joined November 24, 2010
The whole thing took maybe a couple hours of experimentation two years ago, and I've since been running with the same configuration.
Sure, but this behavior isn't any different from people dogpiling on attacking perceived 'SJW' behavior. Somehow Hacker News seems to be very sensitive to one kind of dogpiling while completely ignoring the other.
For example, I didn't see anyone here screaming about Timnit Gebru's being forced out of Google because her research didn't align with the company's vision. Most of the comments about the topic were people either defending Google or accusing her of being 'too lefty' and therefore deserving of the outcome.
So it seems that Hacker News isn't so much concerned about 'free speech' in the work place, but rather about certain kinds of free speech being allowed, while others... they are pretty ambivalent about.
> With regards to the rest of the post, I feel like you're fishing for things to be angry at me for, on the basis of a fundamental miscommunication.
Nah, I just thought your example was a bit apples and oranges, but no bad feelings.
You keep implying that the only possible reason people would denounce RMS's behavior is because they 'get rewarded' for it. I'm surprised you can be so certain about it, when it's perfectly possible they are doing it because they've suffered abuse themselves or have a genuine concern that certain arguments - even when made in good faith by a supposedly autistic person - might make other people feel uncomfortable or unsafe.
Imagine being a young freshman woman at your alma mater and someone starts waxing philosophical about whether a 50 something year old man having sex with a minor is assault or not depending on whether 'they presented themselves as willing'. Would you feel safe? What if the same guy is known around your alma mater as somewhat of a creeper? What if he's defending someone who is associated with a guy who owns an island where people go to have sex with underage girls and is now accused of having had sex with one of them? How safe would you feel then?
> Steve Klabnik is allowed to go around calling himself a communist without getting removed from anything, for example.
Weird that you'd somehow equate being a self-declared Communist (a political ideology) with defending pedophiles (a literal crime).
This can be also said of the 'anti-anti' crowd. Their whole objective is to moralize about how bad the 'anti' crowd is and telling them to shut up, while throwing a number of perfectly valid concerns out the window in the process. While most people in HN might leave it at denouncing the behavior, people have been doxxed, harassed online and in person for 'canceling' someone or something before.
BTW, I hate the 'cancel culture' term. I hate how it is used by people who - given the opportunity - would 'cancel' LGBT rights, immigration, etc. Every time I see someone using the term, I can't help but feel they've fallen for Propaganda 101.
If people are making the case that RMS is neurodivergent and therefore his behavior should be tolerated, shouldn't we be making exactly the same argument about the people you put on the latter group? Or is it only people we agree with that get the benefit of being 'neurodivergent'?
It’s very easy - and indeed I’ve seen it with my own eyes when I was younger - for communities that accept jokes about minorities or LGBT people to very quickly devolve into open fantasizing about actual physical harm of such people. Back in the early 2000’s gaming forums were rife with that kind of supercharged self-radicalization.
Having grown up in South America, I take the ‘jokesters’ wearing t-shirts with slogans such as ‘Pinochet did nothing wrong’ and ‘make leftists afraid of helicopters again’ extremely seriously. Several of my parents’ acquaintances were ‘disappeared’ by the last dictatorship. My dad - a student at the time who wasn’t involved in any kind of political activism - shaved his beard because he was afraid he’d be mistaken for a ‘commie’ and jailed or worse. All you need is a small percentage of idiots actually believing the ‘joke’ for real life consequences to follow.
I didn't.
> I wrote nothing that would preclude your scenario from being a possibility
That's kind of my point: there's a lot of questioning the motivations of the 'cancel culture mob' around these parts recently, but very little questioning of the motivations of the 'anti cancel culture mob'. It almost feels like there's a gaping blind spot there.
Unsurprisingly, a significant percentage of the 'anti cancel culture' controversy seems to be driven by a tiny fraction of people. One could even argue that both the 'cancel culture' and 'anti cancel culture' mobs are tiny. And yet, somehow, Hacker News seems to heavily favor the 'anti cancel culture' angle.
Go figure, huh?
So yeah, people who are there just to 'shit post right wing stuff' should definitely consider what they are doing.
Most people get over that kind of mentality by the time they are 20 something and working. Some don't, I guess.
My favorite ridiculous bit is when you pretend that all the stupid /g/ slang isn't designed around shock value. By your own argument, I guess pedophilia is acceptable and not transgressive of social norms as long as your audience is a group of pedophiles. I wish I could kiss that juicy multi-dimensional galaxy brain of yours!
BTW, there's nothing wrong about trying to be nice. Like, literally there's nothing more acceptable than being agreeable. But I guess that's too much to ask from someone like you who is clearly too cool for school and 'so based'.
I used to think like that when I was an edgy teen. I'm so glad I grew the fuck up.
With such great things as having a picture of 'soydevs', or such titles as 'Schooling a beta GNUTard', 'Virgin social media vs. chad RSS', 'Orderly dissolution of the United States into its component parts' and you know, about half of his videos having thumbnails with pepes and the kind of alt-right shit you used to see in r/TheDonald'... I'm sure he's just a nice Linux nerd who would never associate with the kind of people that idolized 'based stickman'.
Right?
We've structured society in a way that not everyone needs to be a farmer (or microchip designer/electronic factory line worker) for people to obtain food/devices that access the internet. Are you a proponent of 'give the fish' because you didn't build the device you are typing in?
I wish there was more advocacy around this. DanceSafe [1] sells inexpensive kits that people can use to test against most of the bad stuff (like NBOMEs).
// Given this enum
enum NumOrStr {
Num(i32),
Str(string)
}
// That allows you to define values like this
let x = NumOrStr::Num(10);
let y = NumOrStr::Str("hello");
// And some random code that produces a value z that is of type NumOrStr
let z: NumOrStr = ...
match z {
Num(50) => println!("Got my favorite number: fifty!"),
Num(n) => println!('Got {}', n),
String("hello") => say_hello(),
String(s) => do_something_with_string(s)
_ => println!("Default case, x = {:?}", x),
}A good example of how pattern matching simplifies code is given in the 'Patterns and Functional Style' section of PEP 635 [1]:
match json_pet:
case {"type": "cat", "name": name, "pattern": pattern}:
return Cat(name, pattern)
case {"type": "dog", "name": name, "breed": breed}:
return Dog(name, breed)
case _:
raise ValueError("Not a suitable pet")
The equivalent if statement would be kind of gross: if 'type' in json_pet:
if json_pet['type'] == 'cat' and 'pattern' in json_cat:
return Cat(json_pet['name'], json_pet['pattern'])
elif json_pet['type'] == 'dog' and 'breed' in json_pet:
return Dog(json_pet['name'], json_pet['breed'])
raise ValueError("Not a suitable pet")
One can imagine extending that to parse 6 or 7 types of messages.Another example is matching tuples or sequences: the equivalent if statement requires checking the length of the sequence, then extracting the variables, etc. The 'case' statement does all of that in one line.
In other words, as one of my university professors would put it: 'there's nothing that can't be written using plain ifs, adds and jumps, but that doesn't mean we all want to write in assembly with just 3 instructions'.
[1] https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0635/#patterns-and-funct...