HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dhoulb

99 karma · joined January 4, 2014

submissionscomments
dhoulb··on Evolving the Dropbox Brand
Urgh, gross. Visual vomit — totally impractical and communicates nothing.
dhoulb··on How Common Is Your Birthday? (2012)
The February 14 spike is particularly interesting as it’s an example of people _choosing_ a ‘positive’ date, vs just avoiding negative dates (holidays, 9/11, 13ths).
dhoulb··on How Common Is Your Birthday? (2012)
Really useful context, thanks!
dhoulb··on How Common Is Your Birthday? (2012)
I’s love to know that too. I assume some part of the September bump is “festive cheer”, which would still show in Australia. But it’d be fun to know how much was each.
dhoulb··on How Common Is Your Birthday? (2012)
It’s obvious people are able to influence some contol over this, I huess through inducement (or just holding it in??).

Avoiding holidays was the obvious trend, but there were two others I saw that made me chuckle:

1. People avoiding February 29, so they don’t give their kid that 1-in-4 birthday pain.

2. The spike on February 14! People want their kid born on Valentines (cute, but not really romantic...)

dhoulb··on Abstract Ideas Don’t Deserve Patents
If it's obvious in hindsight, it's still obvious.

The trade is: we give you a monopoly on the thing, you give us (the public) written step-by-step instructions on how to create that thing.

If instructions aren't necessary to create it — i.e. I can figure it out from just seeing it — then the deal is broken, and isn't serving public good any more.

They're getting their monopoly, what did we get? Zilch.

This is the problem with patent protection in our industry. We can recreate things pretty easily. In say, biotech, it's much harder to figure out.

I'm still behind just scrapping patents altogether though. It's adding process for process' sake. The same feeling you get when you have big section of unnecessary code, and ripping it out has a no effect on the result — patents feel like that chunk of code, before you rip it out. They seem like another area where people have created work for themselves effectively doing or creating nothing. If we got rid of them, not a lot would change, but millions of people would instantly have less weight on their brain.

dhoulb··on Follow-up on 4K displays for programmers
I think 39" is an awesome size for a monitor.

First up, I'll say I'm really not bothered about pixel density on a desktop machine. I love Retina on my laptop, but I never notice it's not there on my iMac - it's too far away from my face.

39" lets you do the wonderful thing I do with my secondary monitor right now - push secondary applications off to the side.

I imagine what I'd do with this amount of space is have my text editor and a browser window roughly in the middle, and have terminal, Git, chat, etc peppered all around the outside. Even with a 27" I'm constantly hitting the sides right now. My main monitor can't do more than text editor + browser effectively.

You get loads more productivity from additional space, I think for two reasons: less app switching, and being able to see EVERYTHING you're working on. Like taking over a fresh desk when you need to knuckle down on a task. In action films, when it gets serious, they go to a clean desk and unroll a giant map. Having a huge screen is the same thing.

I imagine in a few years programmers and geek types will have, maybe, a 60" curved display that takes up most of the desk.

dhoulb··on NHS England patient data 'uploaded to Google servers', Tory MP says
GCHQ has done some appalling stuff, but the Google network penetration was done by the NSA.
dhoulb··on NHS England patient data 'uploaded to Google servers', Tory MP says
I agree. I personally trust Google far more than the US or my own (UK) government.

It's the whole monopoly on force thing. I have no fear that Google will grab me out of my bed in the middle of the night.

With the UK government — even though I trust them to be pretty rational and fair, and to my knowledge I've done nothing that would warrant that treatment — there's always the worry that they have the ability to significantly reduce my quality of life (if they ever chose to) and I might not even deserve it.

It's always surprising to me the fear regular people have of companies doesn't extend to governments, who have far more power over their lives.

dhoulb··on NHS England patient data 'uploaded to Google servers', Tory MP says
NHS number is clearly ridiculous.

But, I can see why all the other data are statistically relevant in analysis.

Postcode, so you can track viral outbreak etc with a fair degree of locational accuracy.

Date of birth, so you could analyse if people born in certain seasons had higher incidences of various diseases. (You could probably drop the day and just have month, but there could be cases where there were more hospital deaths for babies born on a Monday, etc).

Gender and ethnicity are obvious.

dhoulb··on NHS England patient data 'uploaded to Google servers', Tory MP says
Rarr, scary database, rarrr.
dhoulb··on Inventor stumped by 43-year patent delay
No, sorry, this is a terrible idea,

Every broke idiot with a pen would write up every idea under the sun.

Companies, with resources to actually bring those ideas to life, would have to pay way more to be able to do so, driving up the cost of innovation in markets.

Also, presumably, a company would just pay a broke guy to submit the patent on their behalf, and pay them a small fee. Leading to a horrific industry of 'broke guy recruiters'.

Lone inventors are actually the primary group harming innovation here, not large companies (contrary to what your politics and gut might wish for). They patent some broad thing they have no intention of making, and sell those 'inventions' on for a quick buck to holding companies who make their money from suing people.

Patents need to not exist any more. For all the noise companies make about patents being important, if you took them away tomorrow, the world would be exactly the same. Nothing would change.

dhoulb··on Inventor stumped by 43-year patent delay
Wrong way round.

You want to know if clicks on illegal sources have an effect on legal sources.

Not if clicks on legal sources have an effect on illegal sources.

Yes, it's important.

No, they're not the same.

dhoulb··on Reddit to Give 10% of Its 2014 Ad Revenue to Non-Profits Picked by Its Users
Good responses, no need for the snark at the end though!
dhoulb··on GCHQ intercepted webcam images of millions of Yahoo users worldwide
Because of this article, that entire archive of pictures they're holding is now probably worthless, for blackmail value.

So, that's a plus.

dhoulb··on Engineers Allege Hiring Collusion in Silicon Valley
Wow, did Eric Schmidt run over his dog or something? Guy's got a serious bias!
dhoulb··on Tim Cook Rejects Politics of the NCPPR
Completely agree. Whether or not worker safety contributes to ROI should never be a question. Same with environmental impact.
dhoulb··on Tim Cook Rejects Politics of the NCPPR
Well, for Apple to collect that information would probably be significant work. What's the cost of swapping out bad metals in their batteries? Some of it is really hard to quantify.

But, it wasn't a serious request for information. That's what was wrong with the request — it wasn't one. They were trolling. And you don't feed trolls.

dhoulb··on Depression is an inflammatory disease; where does inflammation come from? [pdf]
Seems like taking action in the real world and avoiding sources of inflammation would have a positive psychological effect. Giving the person a feeling of control over one area of their life.

Surely that would be beneficial, whether or not the link between depression and inflammation is scientifically proven?

dhoulb··on Depression is an inflammatory disease; where does inflammation come from? [pdf]
Gluten intolerance isn't a binary state, it's a scale. Everyone's on it somewhere, but unless it's REALLY bad, you'd probably never get diagnosed or even tested.

Main benefit of avoiding gluten though is it's a simple rule that helps you avoid a lot of bad foods, and excuse it socially.

dhoulb··on Depression is an inflammatory disease; where does inflammation come from? [pdf]
Yeah, I imagine most good doctors know full well it's emotional/stress, but avoid telling the patients because it's not what patients like to hear, or they don't think it'll be helpful.

Pharmaceutical treatments for stress have some harmful side effects, whereas just sending them away with "don't worry about it" and a lollipop might go a good way to alleviating some of it.

dhoulb··on Depression is an inflammatory disease; where does inflammation come from? [pdf]
The effect might be that eating walnuts fills you up and makes you eat less potato chips. You're right of course, but don't underestimate how bad a place some people are coming from!
dhoulb··on Ask HN: How will Comcast provide better service for Netflix content?
I think your metaphor is kinda off.

Don't think of it like a stream, where some of the water can be separated off and filtered.

Think of it like a road system. All the roads between Netflix Town and Comcast City have to go through Cogentville, and the roads are PACKED. Traffic is crawling, really slow.

This deal is like opening a new six-Lane highway, direct from Netflix to Comcast, that allows everyone to travel really fast and avoids all the gridlock.

I don't think there was filtering before. I think Comcast just let the traffic get really bad, and was stalling issuing permits for the new bypass.

dhoulb··on Microsoft killed my Pappy
I don't hate Microsoft. But I don't exactly like them either.

They've made some pretty piss poor decisions over the last 10 years that have had some huge impacts. IE6 was bad, but I can forgive their ignorance on that — no-one knew any better at the time.

What I can't forgive is IE8, and the years since then that they've CONTINUED to make major-versioned browsers. If IE6 was a one off problem, it'd be fine. But with IE7, IE8, IE9, IE10, IE11, and new ones being released all the time, it just seems like MS don't realise it's a problem. No-one should be making browsers that don't silently auto-update at least once a month. It's physically harmful to the web ecosystem.

I don't care how good IE11 is now, whether they've caught up or not, I care about them putting a system in place that ensures everyone always has the latest web technology. Don't tell me it's not possible. Google and Mozilla have had it sussed for years now. (Apple could do with sorting themselves out on this too. Could also see them go in this direction since Blink split off.)

I can't help but think the version numbers are political? Some group in Microsoft trying to prove its worth by making a big deal about version numbers every year? "Look how much we care about the web, look at our new shiny browser. It goes to 11..."

The web would be way further ahead if Microsoft had stopped making browsers years ago. Millions of hours are wasted every year testing websites in dead browsers. Microsoft created this situation, and they've still not adequately addressed it.

Put your latest browser on everything you've ever made, stop calling out the major version numbers, release every month or so. That's how you'll get people to like you.

dhoulb··on WhatsApp put Facebook in a situation in which Facebook only could lose
$3-4b does sound about right - factoring in the market/investor factors this article goes into.

If they convince all of their users to pay the $1 next year, that's $450m in revenue, so 8-10x revenue is a reasonable price for a tech company (outrageous for any other industry, but it's tech).

But 40x revenue, that's just INSANE. I'm sure there's something Facebook could've spent $10b on that would've achieved the same goal (making Facebook more kid friendly). How about a free iPad for every kid in the US?... Not an outrageous idea.

dhoulb··on WhatsApp put Facebook in a situation in which Facebook only could lose
I have a couple of problems with the analysis.

First, users don't use WhatsApp because they're concerned about Facebook hoovering up all the data. They use it because their slightly cooler social influencer friend uses it, so they think they should too. Regular users don't care about Facebook from a privacy angle - they obviously do if it's splashed across CNN, but they forget again the next day.

Second, a factual error:

> Facebook’s business model on the other hand is built on the idea that the more a user interacts with Facebook (or Facebook-connected sites and apps), the more Facebook can earn, because it can present more ads.

Not more ads — _better_ ads. They already fill all their inventory. The difference is important. Better targeted ads annoy users less, but command a higher price from advertisers. And change 'giving them data' from a negative activity to a positive one!

Right now, Facebook's in a weird place. They know loads about me, but their targeting is still really crap. I don't know why they don't just add a 5 minute "improve your ads" survey, where they ask outright which ads they should be showing me. I'd happily tell them the sorts of things I buy loads of, if they'd promise to only show me ads about those things. Anything to get rid of belly fat ads.

If Facebook stored 10 times as much data about you, but the adverts were awesome and you wanted to buy every single thing, would you give them the extra data? HN users might not, but I think most people would.

dhoulb··on Ask HN: Do companies own your side project?
Things to watch for are:

A) You signed a contract that explicitly assigns ownership of anything you create to them B) You created it on equipment they own, or used any of their resources to make it C) You created it in time you should've been working for them

Generally speaking, the best way to avoid legal problems is not to piss people off too much. So don't build a direct competitor to them and you're probably fine. If you haven't done any of A, B or C, you'd probably win eventually, but could still end up spending money on lawyers just to make it go away.

dhoulb··on German tank problem
In case anyone is interested in the numbers, USA produced in the region of 50,000 Sherman tanks during the Second World War. 5-10x more than Germany. Plus the British tanks. It didn't take all that long to reach Berlin!
dhoulb··on Why Selling WhatsApp To Facebook Would Be The Biggest Mistake (2012)
NINETEEN BILLION DOLLARS can do quite a bit of world changing.
dhoulb··on By The Time You Give Them a Raise, They’re Already Out The Door
Like a cheap certain-to-flop ripoff of Hannah Montana...
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →