HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

diognesofsinope

225 karma · joined July 19, 2021

submissionscomments
diognesofsinope··on The Sick History of Public Education
I've always thought it was weird how the 'Information Age' has barely changed an institution entirely based on passing information to new generations (education).

Bryan Caplan (economist at George Mason) wrote The Case Against Education (https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691174655/th...). IMO, he's definitely too provocative and it's certainly not perfect but he makes really good points on modern education. My version of a summary below:

1. There's an enormous return to attending 4-year university. 4-year degree holders on average ~400k over there life time than high school graduates. This is somewhat suspicious, because it's not obvious 'HST 105: History of Ancient Greece' is imparting labor market skills.

2. Economists says education builds (1) 'human capital', i.e. education causally makes individuals more skilled and thus labor market success. There are two other stories: (2) action bias which is that universities simply selected people who would have been successful whether or not they went to college or (3) signaling theory which is that the degree communicates to employers you're smart, conforming, punctual, can accomplish ~4 year goals, etc...basically you're a 'grade-A worker'.

3. Bryan lobbies for the signaling theory. A flurry of educational psychology research is presented and it's impressive. A good example is there's almost (A) no scientific evidence that 'learning how to learn' or 'transfer of learning' or 'critical thinking' are taught well in classroom. It's shocking how this appears on every syllabus but that actual research that classrooms can impact this essentially doesn't exist. (B) The fadeout effect, where giving students extra education does boost tests scores for those individuals, but if you track them for the next 5 years the effects fade out -- like many things there's regression to the mean (C) Memory isn't as reliable as we think -- this has been very important in the judicial system that has historically relied on witness testimony. I don't remember anything from my 'History of Rock and Roll' class when I was a freshman.

4. Non-psychological critiques are that (1) the econometrics almost never include the stat that ~50% of all students who attend 4-year college don't graduate (some transfer, so that number is a bit difficult to calculate). But almost nobody guesses baseline of ~50%. The returns to college look good because of survivorship bias. (2) Labor econometrics in general is weaker than we think...for example, how do you operationalize 'experience' -- almost all academic studies on discrimination, pay gaps, etc. have this problem. (3) There's extremely strong evidence and intuition that getting the degree matters, i.e. if go for 4 years but don't graduate returns are much lower.

There's a ton more in the book, but those are the big parts. I was a teacher for 5 years and it's crystal clear to me that 'passive learning' isn't nearly as useful as 'active learning', but for classroom management reasons active learning is rarely viable. Active learning also makes the teacher look like they're not doing much work, which is bad for their bargaining.

diognesofsinope··on Elite Underproduction
Exactly my thought:

A CS degree from Stanford almost has to start at at least 90k.

diognesofsinope··on Economic costs of war
I chalk it up to politics (politicians) -- the reality is the Republicans would never live 9/11 down if they didn't go to war.
diognesofsinope··on Economic costs of war
But, have you seen how nice the houses are in Northern Virginia? /s
diognesofsinope··on Law school applicants surge 13%, biggest increase since dot-com bubble
>I will quibble with your first point a bit. Law is a profession that attracts large numbers of people who default into it because they can’t think of what to do with their liberal arts undergraduate degree. It’s a demanding, detail oriented, analytical job, and many of those people become quite disillusioned with it.

Underrated comment -- literally half of all lawyers I've worked with (financial regulation) admit they chose law because they didn't like math.

diognesofsinope··on Simple Systems Have Less Downtime (2020)
Because then you can employ more of your lawyer buddies to consult on the complexity.
diognesofsinope··on Simple Systems Have Less Downtime (2020)
The other side of the coin is that complexity creates jobs because you need individual who guide you through it.

Lawyers and bureaucrats careers are based on this complexity of criminal justice systems and government administration, respectively.

diognesofsinope··on Why is the university of California dropping the SAT?
Exactly! It's about reducing evidence and accountability, along with increasing enrollment ($).
diognesofsinope··on Why is the university of California dropping the SAT?
That's because Richard Sander from UCLA Law has demonstrated fairly well that there's a really good chance that affirmative action is a net negative for those it's trying to help.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Sander

They should oppose it because it likely harms black people.

diognesofsinope··on Why is the university of California dropping the SAT?
Funny story in Malaysia it's well known that if you get sick you want a Chinese doctor because the Malaysian government discriminates heavily against the Chinese, and thus the ones that actually become doctors are only the elite.
diognesofsinope··on First lethal attacks by chimpanzees on gorillas observed
They've turned climate change into the new boogeyman, which is a shame since it's an important issue.
diognesofsinope··on Airbnb raises violent crime rates in cities as residents are pushed out
Not originally me from here: https://old.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/olwous/airbnb...
diognesofsinope··on Airbnb raises violent crime rates in cities as residents are pushed out
First, getting into really major concerns, this paper suffers from some serious potential for omitted variable bias. The goal of this study is to find the causal effect or treatment effect of Airbnb on violent crime: "This study tested the hypothesis that the arrival and growth of Airbnb, or home-sharing platforms in general, may increase crime and disorder in neighborhoods..." In other words, we want to know what would happen to violence if we could push a lever and increase or decrease Airbnb directly. A regression of violence on Airbnb tells us how violence tends to change with changes in Airbnb in the data. If there's some other factor that affects both Airbnb and violence (or affects one and is affected by the other), then the regression is going to find the mismash of the causal effect of Airbnb and the causal effect of that other factor and put it all on Airbnb.

This is especially problematic because the authors find changes in Airbnb penetration are correlated with census tract characteristics:

For Airbnb density (Fig 3a), we see that census tracts in the urban center (northeast on the map) show relatively high Airbnb presence from the beginning, but that in recent years the tracts with the highest level of Airbnb penetration emanate further out into surrounding, more residential neighborhoods.

This can be addressed by controlling for the confounding factor. Alternatively, we can look at a specific scenario where Airbnb penetration changed for reasons that almost certainly couldn't affect violence, and use that variation to find out how violence responds to Airbnb penetration.

Unfortunately, the paper only controlled for median income in the primary specification and percentage of black/Hispanic residents and homeownership rates in the robustness check (these additional controls are not in the database). This paper simply does not do enough to eliminate potential other explanations for why Airbnb penetration may be correlated with violence in a census tract without causing it.

I'm not that familiar with the crime literature, but from a very brief look at the abstract of one random paper, factors like economic inequality, poverty rates, population density, and divorce rates could predict violent crime. All of these could affect Airbnb penetration, such as through property prices (another potential confounding variable) or through amenities for tourists.

For example, increases in population density could both increase crime and increase Airbnb penetration (more amenities or maybe it's easier to buy new houses than existing houses). Or maybe Airbnb penetration increases more in areas with higher income inequality because there are cheap units near areas with rich amenities, and it's higher income inequality driving crime and Airbnb penetration. It could even be something unrelated to Airbnb that just so happened to affect urban and residential areas differently over these years. For example, maybe these regions had different changes in police presence during that time.

Second, another major concern is the potential nonstationarity in violent crime and Airbnb penetration. Airbnb has a very clear trend of increasing over time, as shown in Figure 1 of the paper. You can imagine violent crime also having a very clear time trend where this year's value depends heavily on last year's value. Controlling for year and neighborhood fixed effects, both a regression of violence and Airbnb penetration on its lagged (prior-year) value finds a coefficient of roughly 1, which indicates the presence of a time trend (technically you need a coefficient greater than or equal to 1, but coefficients close to 1 also produce similar problems with short time series like this one).

When you regress any non-stationary data series on another, you will always find a strong relationship between the two. That's true even with non-sensical relationships like GDP in the US and total recorded rainfall in Cambodia since Jan 1, 1900. You can think of time as the confounder which affects both series. Here, time is increasing both Airbnb penetration and violence. Even if they have nothing to do with each other, a regression will find a strong correlation between the two.

To avoid spurious correlations due to time trends, the most common way is to remove the time trend by looking at the change in the variables rather than their absolute values. That cancels out the time trend and allows for proper inference. This is why studies in finance usually look at returns (changes in values) rather than asset values. If we do that for this data, we again find the coefficient on Airbnb penetration becomes insignificant. To conclude, the very least we can say about the results of this paper is that it is incomplete. Plenty of standard controls for crime are not included, which weakens the ability of the paper to argue Airbnb causally leads to more violence. Further, the authors did not properly handle the presence of non-stationary data.

diognesofsinope··on Airbnb raises violent crime rates in cities as residents are pushed out
I mean, it is an investment. However the success of that investment basically means depriving future generations of a home, which they are fine with doing, clearly.
diognesofsinope··on Good Riddance, TurboTax. Americans Need a Real ‘Free File’ Program
The threshold is > ~100k living abroad to pay taxes.

Almost nobody pays this. Moreover, it's not ridiculous that if you're a tycoon traveling the world and you're implicitly using US citizenship as your escape card, you should pay taxes.

Anyone who has lived abroad knows most countries don't want to jail/detain other country nationals.

diognesofsinope··on Collectors are also confused about that $1.56M Super Mario 64 sale
This seems plausible. My first thoughts were (1) fraud like you said or (2) money laundering.
diognesofsinope··on Time to assume that health research is fraudulent until proven otherwise?
Agreed, you can definitely work from home, but you're being quite charitable -- 'let's assume their behind closed doors with no accountability and do everything we expect'.

This is basically how we ended up in the replication crisis to begin with. There's little to no accountability and people assume they're working hard and being honest.

5% of all degree granting universities are R1 or R2 research universities, e.g. Harvard, Stanford, etc. The vast majority of professors aren't obligated the conduct research or apply for grants.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_university https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/articles/how-...

diognesofsinope··on Time to assume that health research is fraudulent until proven otherwise?
Similar to how in psychology replication studies when they asked professors to predict which studies would and wouldn't replicate I think they were ~75% correct.

Replication was ~50%.

They have an idea of what is bullshit, but there's a very strong culture of 'don't call others out on bad research'

diognesofsinope··on Time to assume that health research is fraudulent until proven otherwise?
Not only this, academia is a really cushy job.

When I was an economics RA literally half of the econ professors didn't work Fridays and barely worked summers. It was incredible you get paid 150k with that kind of schedule.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2