HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

djokkataja

461 karma · joined October 30, 2012

submissionscomments
djokkataja··on CEO pay is up 78% over the past decade
Even if all you care about is whether you keep getting paid, being one of the owners of a business (even if it's one of many) suggests to me that you would have much more influence about whether you keep getting paid than you would in any business where you are not an owner.
djokkataja··on Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups
> Where, exactly, does the money to pay for their additional salary and jobs come from?

Why does anyone pay anyone else to do work for them? If this situation was actually zero-sum, then employees would get paid for a while until companies ran out of money, and then no one would ever get paid again. Fortunately, this is not a zero-sum situation, and people pay other people to do work in order to produce more value for the people paying for the work than they pay for the work.

For example, if I pay you $50 to put together $50 worth of components into a phone, I then go and sell that phone for more than $100. You get $50, whoever sold me the components gets $50, I get my sell price - $100 for the phone, and whoever buys it gets a shiny new phone. Everybody wins.

And it goes further! Everyone who made money takes their money and spends it on things other people have produced via their hard work -- or they invest it with some people for those people to try to make something more of that investment. Or they sit on it and spend it later, because they don't know what they want to spend it on right now. Whatever they do, the entire economy gets some action... eventually.

But let's say I'm kind of racist and sexist and biased in all kinds of ways and not necessarily aware of all the ways in which I'm biased, aka an actual human being. Then I might decide not to even consider hiring some people, because I think they wouldn't be able to do the work, when in reality they might do just fine, but my biases are getting the better of me. Then I might not hire as many people, and so I wouldn't pay as many workers to make phones, and I wouldn't pay for as many phone components, and I wouldn't sell as many phones. Now I am poorer, and the component seller is poorer, and the person I didn't hire is poorer, and someone out there doesn't get a phone. And the economy sees a little less influx of activity from everything we might have done and ended up not doing. Everyone is worse off.

But! If some policies are put in place to encourage me (somehow) to hire people that I might not normally consider due to my biases, then I might change my mind, and everyone wins more again.

So where does the money come from? I might be hanging onto some, hoping to hire some people, but I'm not spending as much as I would if I was hiring people I'm biased against. Or maybe some other companies besides mine hire more people that often face bias, and those companies expand and produce more and their new employees spend more buying all kinds of things (including the stuff my company makes), so my company gets buoyed up and now I have cash to spend to hire more people too. Or maybe I see the policy changes and decide I want to expand my business, so I seek out some investment or take out a loan.

The reason equality -enhancing policies are beneficial to everyone is that they make the total market bigger, faster. Money in a healthy economy doesn't run out and disappear; it flows. And if it flows productively to people who are currently relatively neglected in this regard, then everyone ends up better off, including the people who are not neglected in this regard.

djokkataja··on The future will have to wait (2006)
> If you don’t believe in the Future, unreservedly and dreamingly, if you aren’t willing to bet that somebody will be there to cry when the Clock finally, ten thousand years from now, runs down, then I don’t see how you can have children. If you have children, I don’t see how you can fail to do everything in your power to ensure that you win your bet, and that they, and their grandchildren, and their grandchildren’s grandchildren, will inherit a world whose perfection can never be accomplished by creatures whose imagination for perfecting it is limitless and free. And I don’t see how anybody can force me to pay up on my bet if I turn out, in the end, to be wrong.

We didn't stay dead.

We were supposed to. That was what I had learned, anyway. Short of magic, nothing was going to resurrect us after we died.

"You're not dead anymore, Mike."

That was the first thing I heard when I was Reawakened. I'd tell you about how I felt all kinds of astonishing tingly sensations and sat up in dazed wonder at the glorious euphoria of my shiny new bionic body, but who hasn't experienced that and heard about it and talked about it a million times already?

No, what was interesting was that I came from a generation that was supposed to stay dead. Before my generation, most people had religious beliefs of one kind or another whereby they would magically be resurrected, with their status afterward depending on various criteria. But my generation had learned that all that religious stuff was nonsense, unscientific magical thinking, so we were just going to stay dead.

"I'm pretty sure that I'm supposed to be dead," I asserted, looking suspiciously at the disappointingly stereotypically futuristically beautiful and androgynous figure before me. "Thus I can only conclude that the experience of my demise was a terribly convincing deception."

"Mike, I'm a doctor, not a simulation engineer," the figure said. "But you've hit the nail on the head. The experience of your life until now was a computationally rendered projection, a terribly convincing deception. You're likely not precisely the same person as the version of you that died in reality, but that Mike wouldn't have been precisely the same as the Mike the day before anyway. What matters is that you and your experiences are as close to those of the Mike who died in reality as everything and everyone can tell us. You're a full person now, full societal presence, participation and rights same as me and everyone else. We do not discriminate between people with simulated experiences and people with real-universe experiences. That would be unscientific magical thinking. It's the same basic hardware architecture for you and me, see," they tapped knuckles to the side of their head lightly. "The people you knew were simulated just as you were, and when they die in that simulation of the past, you'll get to meet them again, too."

This was obviously too good to be true. "What's the catch?"

"You're alive again."

"Damn. No, but really."

"You're alive again, Mike. This ain't heaven, it's more living. And you're not gonna just keel over and die like last time. This new body's more than slightly better put together, and we're more than slightly better at cheating death than we used to be. So the catch is no one waltzes away from consequences via old age anymore. Aaand society and people may have changed from what you're used to. A bit."

My shiny new balls tingled, alert to the mistruthing in that last "A bit." I paused, taking it all in. "So why are you here with that expectant look on your face?"

"Well, Mike. Ten thousand years ago you made a bet. And there's this clock running down, see, and nobody's crying."

djokkataja··on Tax the Land
The OP's specific point was based on a misunderstanding: that being unable to pay the land value tax would mean they would have to move to a different city because the cost of living in their original city would be too high. This might be a reasonable concern during a transition to a land value tax system, but once the land value tax has been in place long enough to see more efficient use of land actually happening, the cost of living would be going down. So the premise of their argument doesn't hold.

Put another way, their concern was based on them specifically paying more taxes on land while society stays the same in regards to use of land. But that doesn't make sense because they're not the only person who would be paying land taxes; everyone who owns land would be, and that changes everyone's incentives for how they use land.

If you mean the part about "how could this ever overcome NIMBY" / tradeoffs between people who already live somewhere and people who want to live somewhere, then yeah, that wasn't what I was talking about.

djokkataja··on Tax the Land
Yeah, this was already happening with people moving from the bay area to Phoenix.
djokkataja··on Tax the Land
> For instance, say I live in a very expensive city and I can no longer afford the land tax.

One of the major reasons that our cities become expensive in our "modern" society is that we don't have land value taxes. If we have a land value tax, then when someone decides they can't afford to keep paying the tax, they sell it to someone who can OR they find a way to make the things built on that property much more valuable so that the tax is affordable. It provides a very strong incentive for property owners to do things like tearing down single family homes and building multi-unit condos in their place. Because there are multiple units where there was previously only one, the cost of living actually goes down. This is why it's considered a very beneficial tax: it promotes efficient use of land from economic perspectives. (This also applies to businesses: if a business isn't able to afford the land value tax for their property, they have strong incentives to find a way to make the use of their land more valuable or to sell it to someone who can. And if the value of their land is going up more than they can afford, that implies that there likely are potential buyers who could make better use of it.)

For us to go from where we currently are to a land value tax would require a transition period, because it takes time to tear things down and build new things. But a society that was implementing a land value tax would see new properties opening up like I described above on a regular basis. So if you couldn't afford the land value tax, you would still be able to stay in the same city (and probably more cheaply and in a nicer, newer condo) unless you absolutely required a single family home or similar low-density housing.

djokkataja··on Microplastics found in live human lung tissue
Arguably ADHD could have benefits for people in hunter-gatherer lifestyles: https://faculty.washington.edu/dtae/manuscripts/eisenberg%20...
djokkataja··on Chrome 0day is being exploited now for CVE-2022-1096; update immediately
There's an update for the desktop browser: https://vivaldi.com/blog/desktop/minor-update-five-5-1/
djokkataja··on Flight characteristics of anomalous unidentified aerial vehicles (2019)
> arrest our own evolutionary development.

There is a sense in which there's not much point in aliens "uplifting" humanity: on our own, without external interference, we might develop in ways that would be hard for them to predict. And over the long term, the novelties of our self-guided evolution might prove useful to them.

For example, imagine if we had the tech to put a human brain in a cat (ethical questions aside). We'd probably then think it wouldn't be much good unless the hybrid had opposable thumbs, too. And then we'd think it'd be better if it walked on two legs. And so on, and so forth, until we have extra-hairy human beings with cat ears, which really wouldn't add much to our society (well, opinions might be mixed on that).

djokkataja··on Help preserve the internet with Archiveteam's warrior
Storing data is cheap and gets cheaper all the time. This isn't a super comparison, but the Internet archive's 2019 revenue is listed as $36.7 mil on Wikipedia (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Archive).

Hard to compare Bitcoin directly, but its market cap was around $1 billion in 2013 and cleared $1 trillion for the first time a little over a year ago.

I get that this article is about people using their personal computers to help archive things, but I don't think the Internet archive is ever going to be using resources even remotely as aggressively as cryptocurrencies unless they somehow turn all their archiving into cryptocurrency.

djokkataja··on Moral injury can occur in many contexts and populations, including the workplace
But if the cultural standard is that no one personally sacrifices anything in order to try to render better moral/ethical outcomes, how will people that become business owners and CEOs learn that they're supposed to be better?

And from their perspectives, why should they have to sacrifice additional wealth in order to make some more ethical decision? If they don't make some morally questionable decision, they may worry that a competitor will. No business leader wants to crash their own company; they like the feeling of importance they get. And sometimes they feel like their position makes them feel more important in society at large, too, not just at their own company.

Why should they have to make self-sacrificing choices and give all that up, when doing so would make them... like everyone else.

djokkataja··on Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star
Yep

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exoplanet#Nomenclature

djokkataja··on Starship Update [video]
> These days, the more confident-sounding and charismatic someone is, the less I believe there is anything interesting I can learn from them, and the less I trust them!

Probably a good metric anyway; if someone puts all their points into charisma, they have opportunity costs in other dimensions (excluding any "natural" charisma that some people may arbitrarily have, to the degree that's actually a thing or not).

djokkataja··on On Being Broke
Is it possible it was a cultural thing? This is reading a ton into small details and generalizing a lot but... You mentioned you were helping him "get his life straightened out"; maybe he felt like it was going to pull him away from the friends that he'd grown up with? Kind of a difference of subcultures: one subculture that's poor and that values loyalty to friends over most other things (money comes and goes) vs a subculture that values career and money over most other things. (Not that these values are necessarily always mutually exclusive... but sometimes it can be uncomfortable to straddle the gap.)

The other thing that makes me wonder if it's a cultural gap is that you mentioned he was going to be able to make twice as much as he was making before for doing the same thing. If it's the same work as before, what's the difference if not cultural? Learning to talk a certain way about the things you do, use more professional language, present yourself a certain way, and ditch the people you work with if you can earn more money doing the same thing. Then he's eroding his value for loyalty by learning to bullshit the people he work with on a regular basis, because he's acting in a way that's not how he normally acts, and he's established a precedent that he's willing to ditch his new coworkers for an entirely different batch if he can make more money by doing so. He might look at that and look at the friends and/or community he already has and decide he doesn't like where that path might lead him.

That could also explain why he ghosted you. He might feel ashamed because he feels that he owes you for genuinely trying to help him. But how can he repay you except by accepting your help? And explaining where he's coming from would only lead to an ugly conflict or you convincing him that he's irrational and should just take the job -- but he's already decided he doesn't want to go that route. If he cuts all conflict, nukes it from orbit, then he can get on with his life however he wants to.

djokkataja··on Recovering redacted information from pixelated videos
It's actually mentioned in the original article:

> Side note: The potentially most extensive research on the problem of programmatically unblurring mosaic'ed regions from videos was done by Japanese Adult Video enthusiasts. Javplayer automatically detects blurred regions and performs upscaling via TecoGAN, and another person spent months improving their custom GAN that was trained with leaked videos (search for "De-Mosaic JAV with AI, Deep Learning and Adversarial Networks").

djokkataja··on Microtargeting as Information Warfare [pdf]
> The whole point of free and open society is to avoid over reliance on a central authority and allow for emergent authority.

To me, "free and open society" suggests that the people of the society intentionally put limits on any authorities that can influence their society, whether centralized or emergent. Currently we've got two major emergent authorities: Alphabet and Meta. Neither of them has significant accountability to the people who use their services to obtain news and learn and communicate, and both of them have strong incentives to get people to spend more time using their services so that they can sell more ads.

> One little talked about counter strategy is just giving those same people targeted ads with better information.

Who gives the "better information", and who decides what information is "better" in the first place?

As a potential alternative (... very much spitballing here), what if there was a government-provided website where citizens could vote on potential regulations to be applied to companies that, say, provide media services and get over a billion hits per month? It could also be set up to let people provide supporting and opposing arguments and vote them up and down, and proposed regulations would have a limited period of time for voting on the regulation overall.

Something like that. And of course, companies would be able to say, "No, we really cannot change our software in [x] way because we would go out of business," but there could be room for discussion there, too. And I don't think these would be too unreasonable, because these companies generally succeed because tons of people use them and appreciate many of their services. The overwhelming majority of people are unlikely to vote for things to try to destroy these companies.

I think something like that coupled with an enforcement mechanism would provide a way to steer away from the underlying issues that have been polarizing our society and guiding people down rabbit holes to steal their attention, which prevents our society from being free and open. Things like the youtube autoplay button, targeted advertising, and the damnable youtube autoplay button.

And it would actually be able to keep up with rapid changes by tech companies, unlike legislation.

djokkataja··on Michigan DOT Snowplow Names
"You're a Blizzard, Harry" is fantastic
djokkataja··on Oh, 2022
> If there's a permanent Moon base - so what? Does anything really change? How? (What - in practical and economic terms, as opposed to symbolically - did the ISS change?) Can you even have a self-sustaining Moon base without relying on Earth. (Hint: not for a long time.)

In practical terms, permanent Moon bases could make it easier to get to the rest of the solar system:

> Perhaps a more immediate use for this water, though, is to make rocket fuel. Water molecules are made of hydrogen and oxygen, both of which are super useful for rocket propellants. The molecules can be split apart by running an electric current through the water (electrolysis), yielding hydrogen and oxygen, which can then be stored as liquids, ready to fuel a rocket.

> If only there were places for rockets to refuel somewhere along the way … like, perhaps, a service station orbiting the Moon. This could allow rockets to leave Earth with just enough fuel to make it to the Moon, where they could then re-fuel before moving on to the next destination. Alternatively, fuel from the Moon could be transported to a fuel depot in low Earth orbit, allowing rockets to dock for re-fuelling closer to home. Either way, it means a more efficient use of fuel and energy that could potentially allow spacecraft to travel a lot deeper into space and lower the costs of space exploration activities.

https://www.science.org.au/curious/space-time/mining-moon

I agree that it's not likely to be very significant if we're only looking 10 years ahead, but on a longer timescale, I think it will be almost absurdist to look at the little steps we took to get off planet as unimportant. Sort of like saying that Europe has been largely unaffected by Christopher Columbus getting in a boat and going for a joyride across the Atlantic, though I suppose there could be a case made for that.

> But behind this the real issues are psychological. The planet without toxic media and mad billionaires is a much nicer place than the planet with them. Many of the biggest trad-media offenders will be dead by 2030. Will they be replaced? Will there be a Metaverse Abstinence movement? Can one be engineered?

This is one way in which I see a Moon base as an important symbol even over the shorter term. Something that could prompt realizations along the lines of: "We're not stuck here on this planet, we can go elsewhere and live in other ways... so maybe we can live in other ways here on Earth, too. Our reality can be what we choose to make of it together, not an 'inevitably' shitty situation where one of us is stomping on the other's head forever."

djokkataja··on Does Georgism work? Is land a big deal?
In terms of ownership structure, yeah, that's pretty similar.
djokkataja··on Does Georgism work? Is land a big deal?
Just for fun, purely as a thought experiment...

Could digital "real estate" or "territory" be taxed in the same way -- not literal digital territory, like in games, but considering "ad spaces" as virtual territory? I suppose more generally, any "technology company" which primarily makes its profits by virtue of establishing a network effect, wherein they earn ever more money as more people show up.

One possible objection: there are fixed costs for sustaining the virtual territory. It doesn't just exist; at a bare minimum, sustaining the software requires servers which in turn require maintenance, and the software itself would require some developers to fix bugs. But these particular costs can be indicated and accounted for without too much difficulty.

Another possible objection: there are no competitors providing the virtual territory; there is only the one company. If they hadn't created it, it wouldn't exist. So... if this kind of tax was to be executed on virtual territory, the company would have to be broken up and divided into competitors that could attempt improving on things in different ways, and the infrastructure providing the virtual territory would have to be nationalized.

As an example, maybe the competitors can buy keywords from nationalized Google, and then they can change the ad space that people who search for those keywords see; they become the rentiers of that ad space. But to be able to afford the taxes on keywords that are in high demand, they have to improve upon those ad spaces. Maybe they provide a shiny gold effect and sparkles around the ad -- only if the people paying them to show ads for those keywords want it, of course.

djokkataja··on Kropotkin's 'The Conquest of Bread'
> Similarly, there is nothing to prevent a tyrant from arising who will create a system that is horrible in completely novel ways; or some clique gaining power and doing the same. I almost can’t believe Kropotkin doesn’t address this; but I have had the benefit of the history of the 20th Century to draw on, which produced e.g. Animal Farm. The Bolshevik revolution was still more than two decades away when the Conquest of Bread was written, and while Kropotkin did not live to see the formal declaration of the creation of the USSR in 1922, he himself was apparently not impressed by the dictatorial tendencies of the Bolsheviks.

Animal Farm is a critique of authoritarianism generally and Stalinism more specifically. Orwell was in revolutionary Spain, which inspired him to write Homage to Catalonia:

> I had dropped more or less by chance into the only community of any size in Western Europe where political consciousness and disbelief in capitalism were more normal than their opposites. Up here in Aragon one was among tens of thousands of people, mainly though not entirely of working-class origin, all living at the same level and mingling on terms of equality. In theory it was perfect equality, and even in practice it was not far from it. There is a sense in which it would be true to say that one was experiencing a foretaste of Socialism, by which I mean that the prevailing mental atmosphere was that of Socialism. Many of the normal motives of civilized life – snobbishness, money-grubbing, fear of the boss, etc. — had simply ceased to exist. The ordinary class-division of society had disappeared to an extent that is almost unthinkable in the money – tainted air of England; there was no one there except the peasants and ourselves, and no one owned anyone else as his master.

> — George Orwell

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Revolution_of_1936

> I expect that in almost all circumstances the type of anarcho-communism he espouses will eventually lead either to a form of authoritarianism, or to a chaotic state of semi-barbarism in the medium to long term, and to incredible suffering and violence in the short term. That doesn’t mean I disagree with him on principle - I disagree with his analysis of how the type of revolution he outlines, e.g. one based on expropriation, would progress.

Well, the Spanish anarchists were killed by fascists, and the Makhnovists before them were killed by the Bolsheviks (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Makhnovshchina).

But people seem to like anarchist ideas and especially direct democracy, so we have things like AANES aka Rojava (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_Administration_of_N...). I gather it's not considered real anarcho-communist or anarcho-syndicalist or anarcho-whatever, but it's definitely influenced by those ideas.

djokkataja··on Tech sector job interviews assess anxiety, not software skills (2020)
It strikes me as odd that interviews aren't collaborative. I mean, the really valuable information that interviewers want is whether or not the candidate is going to work well with other people there, right? So interviewers could work with candidates to solve some problem (maybe problems structured so that it's naturally convenient to divide them into two parts where each contributes). An external service could provide problems and software for shared solving to prevent interviewers from knowing the problems in advance (which would revert to them "testing"). And the shared problem-solving could be recorded so that interviewers could review it afterwards to decide more clearly how it went (maybe they felt like the other person did a lot during the shared problem-solving, but when watching it afterwards, they realize that the interviewer carried the weight of solving things).

I think this kind of context change would be tremendously empowering for candidates such as myself who get very anxious about situations in which they feel people are "testing" them but who actually love working with people. It would also be nice as a way to see what people are like to work with, from both the perspectives of the candidates and the interviewers.

PvE interviews instead of PvP interviews.

djokkataja··on Write thin to write fast
I think Hemingway mode is when backspace and delete are disabled. Ghostwriter (https://wereturtle.github.io/ghostwriter/) has Hemingway mode and another mode that they call "distraction free mode" which highlights just the current sentence.

FWIW I find it really distracting to have the current sentence highlighted because it means the file's appearance changes more than it otherwise would. Sublime Text has a "distraction free mode" (shift+F11) which goes to fullscreen, hides all menus, limits the current file width, and centers the file's contents.

djokkataja··on Facebook Renames to Meta
> You wouldn’t say that Facebook or Google are building their own Internet

Of course not; buying up competitors is much more practical (why build what you can buy?). So this is presumably the same strategy Facebook plans for any competing companies that make successful use of whatever open systems underlie "the metaverse".

djokkataja··on I don’t know how to count that low
> It just takes a long time to run a memory test on 32 GB of RAM

Maybe run memtest while you sleep? :)

> Or maybe it’s a thermal issue.

I'm no expert on thermal issues by any means, but I did have a laptop that overheated frequently in the past. It was very easy to identify that it was a heat problem, because the fans would start screaming and then it would reliably overheat and power itself off anytime I tried to do anything CPU-intensive with it. Sticking it in a freezer "solved" the problem.

Anyway, given that your freezes are completely random, it doesn't sound like a thermal issue?

djokkataja··on I don’t know how to count that low
> and I annoyingly frequently have had to reinstall the OS from scratch

Is there a story behind that?

djokkataja··on Why the ‘Big Short’ Guys Think Bitcoin Is a Bubble
It's less useful as money because so many people use it as a speculative asset.
djokkataja··on Speed Matters
Actually as a Vim user I have Ctrl+Backspace mapped for insert mode. But I learned Windows shortcuts before vim...
djokkataja··on Attempts to scientifically “rationalize” policy may be damaging democracy
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is almost exactly what Mountain_Skies is describing.

If I remember correctly, Peter Watts has a somewhat more realistic take on this in his Rifters trilogy (under the Novels section here: https://rifters.com/real/shorts.htm), where there's a brain in a box that sifts through loads of information and gives advice to political leaders. The trilogy as a whole is more... deep-sea cyberpunk than particularly centered on the brain in a box, though.

djokkataja··on Why Americans Die So Much More Than Europeans
Obesity rates are significantly higher in the United States than in Europe. https://ourworldindata.org/obesity#what-share-of-adults-are-...
← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →