HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dls2016

1,438 karma · joined January 8, 2019

submissionscomments
dls2016··on Why it’s hard to buy deodorant in Manhattan
> Understaffing doesn't justify crime.

Noting the existence of theft throughout the ages is not an endorsement.

My point is that we should be careful who we ask to pay for enforcement. It's expensive to maintain a system of courts and jails for petty crimes. Rikers is a rather egregious example, but almost $1 billion per year where 85% of detainees are pretrial!

I think it's legitimate to ask to what exent the community should cover the enforcement cost.

dls2016··on Why it’s hard to buy deodorant in Manhattan
> Most of the comments here are ignoring the difference between regular old shoplifting and the trend driving the increase discussed in the article, which they're referring to as "organized retail crime".

I guess, but conversely I'd argue that organized retail theft has been around pretty much as long as supply chains have existed. That's the mob's bread and butter. The phrase "riding shotgun" is in common use. Perhaps mass shoplifting from the store is a new tactic, but personally I look at this situation and ask, "what has changed"?

For one, we've sort of collectively realized how terrible modern jails are (Rikers anyone?). And that's good.

A second conclusion I draw is that retail stores have been gutted... walmart-ized... every ounce of efficiency wrung out of them. Have you ever been to one of these massive retail outlets and had trouble finding anyone that works there? A few months ago everyone was clutching pearls about some 150 yd stretch of train track in LA that was continually being robbed... and I can make a wild guess that this was the result of 1) skeleton crews, 2) minimal security on the ground and 3) shipping containers that are running with sub-standard defense mechanisms because they're simply too much work (slows down loading, probably break a lot, etc.).

Yes organized crime should be punished, but these companies seem to throw up they're hands and say "Gee golly, we have no idea why $20 million dollars of merchandise watched by 5 overworked, low wage employees and 1 loss prevention officer is such a target! It's a mystery!"

I don't hate mega corporations (ok maybe a little), but they definitely have a hand in creating this situation. And it's rarely commented upon when discussing the recent rise in shoplifting.

(Edit: I forgot my favorite shoplifting fact... up until recently, reports showed that both shoplifting and wage theft "cost the economy" around $40 billion per year. Comparing prosecution rates of the two crimes is left as an exercise for the reader.)

dls2016··on Ask HN: What piece of code/codebase blew your mind when you saw it?
> boil down to the convolution of the signal with the impulse response of the filter

Not to be "that guy" but any linear, translation-invariant operator can be written that way. This is the essence of harmonic analysis.

dls2016··on Physicists rewrite a quantum rule that clashes with our universe
And my original "joke" is that the Schrodinger operator is unitary on L2 spaces (which is like a mathematical statement of conservation of "energy"), so if we're throwing out unitarity then I may as well throw out my phd.

I actually studied dispersive pdes (Schodinger, KdV, etc.), though not with a computer. In that study, the properties of the Fourier transform on L2-based spaces are very important.

The other joke is a that I do software now, so of course the phd was useless, haha!

dls2016··on An early disruption event is starting for the Polar Vortex
> Isn't it mostly all a give and take?

Water. A slight increase in global temperature means more water sloshing around in the atmosphere. Of course "the weather" is partially a result of how that water is distributed around the world... but in conjunction with a more "dynamic" atmosphere, this can lead to things like: weather events occurring in places they usually don't or more severe weather events or stranger timing than usual.

dls2016··on Physicists rewrite a quantum rule that clashes with our universe
Dang, I did my phd in L2-based spaces... completely worthless now!
dls2016··on Rust – A hard decision pays off
> but man Rust was a breath of fresh air with the amount of tooling that helped me solve problems

The tooling is the #1 reason I'd like to learn rust. I have not kept up with C++ and I'm not sure I ever will... sometimes plain C seems more straightforward. But those languages (C++ especially) have suffered from lack of standard tooling, in my opinion.

Even C# being a few years younger than Java seems to have made a huge difference in tooling availability (I'm sure having a single corporate driver during its lifetime made a difference, too).

I'm excited by the prospect of a compiled language with modern tooling.

dls2016··on Poly-time algorithm for deciding Hilbert Nullstellensatz. A proof of P=NP
"Ten Signs a Claimed Mathematical Breakthrough is Wrong"

https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=304

(I haven't looked at the paper linked in the title.)

dls2016··on Declining quality of consumer-grade products – 2009 fridge compressor autopsy
This sounds more like a critique of capitalism than anything.

What I find absurd is the re-badging of appliances. A clothes dryer or a gas furnace is a very simple device. So simple, in fact, that you will find the same control board inside a wide variety of seemingly "different" products.

dls2016··on Nepal's Kusunda language has no words for "yes" or "no"
‘tis not
dls2016··on Don’t call it a comeback: Java is still champ
I remember an intermediate OO class in Java 20 years ago... the existence of the El Camino was proof of the terribleness of both multiple inheritance and car analogies.
dls2016··on Spaced repetition can allow for infinite recall
See my other comment.
dls2016··on Spaced repetition can allow for infinite recall
Two articles I wrote at the time which hold up surprisingly well:

https://blogs.ams.org/mathgradblog/2010/12/28/spaced-math-re...

https://blogs.ams.org/mathgradblog/2011/03/10/space-math-rep...

And an example of some of my cards:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/z714xpq36nvn3o1/rudin.pdf?dl=0

If I'm being honest, I went overboard. Like I said, I literally memorized entire books. Entering cards into the system was the most difficult part. But it absolutely works! Had I stayed in academia, I would have loved to developed a set of flash cards to go along with course material.

dls2016··on Spaced repetition can allow for infinite recall
My (entirely uninformed… though I am a “doctor” har har) theory is that some sort of compression occurs in the brain. I also wrote out the answers to my flash cards by hand. I feel like these actions accelerate the compression process.

If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck…

dls2016··on Spaced repetition can allow for infinite recall
I was anti-memorization until I went back to graduate school for mathematics. I had forgotten (or never learned) a lot of things needed to pass qualifying exams. At some point I ran across the spaced repetition idea (maybe from the Wired SuperMemo article [0]) and I gave it a try. I ended up using it to memorize large portions of baby Rudin and Munkres' Topology, as well as some algebra and a bunch of qualifying exam questions.

The qualifying exams were difficult until I reached some "critical mass" of knowledge. Then I could regurgitate proofs and even attack novel problems easily.

There's an analogy here somewhere to the "leetcode" style of software engineer interview. On one hand qualifying exams and leetcode questions are a stupid gatekeeping mechanism, but on the other hand the best researchers/engineers I know have a huge number of facts and examples memorized and ready at their fingertips. I didn't think I needed to do so, but perhaps there is something to suffering through the rote memorization phase to make what comes next that much easier.

[0] https://www.wired.com/2008/04/ff-wozniak/

dls2016··on Using grape harvest dates to estimate summer temperature over 650 years
On one hand, named varieties are propagated via cloning (cuttings, tip rooting, air layering, tissue cultures, etc.)

On the other hand, new fruit varieties are bred all the time. Human breeding programs can produce huge variations in a few decades. I have pluot trees that are hybrid species developed very recently.

And think: 650 years ago, Europeans barely even heard of the tomato and potato!

Human pressure on agriculture can both speed things up and slow them waaay down.

dls2016··on Using grape harvest dates to estimate summer temperature over 650 years
To piggyback: most berries, and fruits in general, are grown from clones.
dls2016··on Roboticists discover alternative physics
Did you mean to reply to my other post? If so, you may be interested in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pontryagin_duality
dls2016··on Roboticists discover alternative physics
Piggy backing here... but this dimension-reduction or system-identification stuff always reminds me of Takens' theorem [0]. He even did some neural network stuff back in the "dark ages" of the topic [1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takens%27s_theorem

[1] https://clgiles.ist.psu.edu/papers/NC-2000-learning-chaos-nn...

dls2016··on The shadowy world of umbral calculus [video]
Yeah, the Fourier transform diagonalizes differentiation. Or in other words "differentiation is a Fourier multiplier". Integration is like a low-pass filter (you divide by the amplitude of a component by its frequency and so higher frequencies get quieter) and differentiation is "noisy" since high frequency components get louder.

d^2/dt^2(sin kt) = -k^2 sin(kt)

This idea is used in the study of partial differential equations, especially dispersive.

https://www.math.ucla.edu/~tao/preprints/chapter.pdf

dls2016··on Abolish the PhD (2016)
> Aren't PhD students working long hours already?

Depends highly on the field. I knew some materials science PhD students who were relatively well-funded to work in the lab (~$35k per year), but often spent nights and weekends baby sitting experiments. But there was no undergraduate materials science program, so no teaching!

I was in the mathematics department where most people worked as teaching assistants for $22k per year (summer work available) but otherwise did as they pleased. I would maybe meet with my adviser for a few minutes per week? And after you've taught calculus five times, you can kind of coast.

dls2016··on Abolish the PhD (2016)
Or, you know, unionize like regular workers. (Former UAW-represented PhD student, here.)

I then spent some time in the Swiss system as a postdoc... night and day! I went from the "American Riviera" (UCSB) to the "Swiss Riviera" (EPFL), and so living costs were about the same. But PhD students were paid more than twice what I was paid in the US.

Also much less teaching at EPFL, but that was probably due to differences in the "type" of institution.

(And what is a riviera?!)

dls2016··on Robinhood lays off 23% of staff
It does happen, though it’s a newsworthy event: https://nypost.com/2011/06/30/atm-receipt-showing-astounding...
dls2016··on What’s going on with Google and Facebook hiring freezes?
> Once Google and Facebook started growing it's clear they realized that every talented engineer on the market is a potential threat.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...

Remember that Google and Apple were caught trying to control the employment marketplace. Keep 'em happy, but not too happy!

dls2016··on Stranger Things is being edited retroactively by Netflix?
"In episode 2F09, when Itchy plays Scratchy's skeleton like a xylophone, he strikes the same rib in succession, yet he produces two clearly different tones. I mean, what are we to believe, that this is a magic xylophone, or something? Ha ha, boy, I really hope somebody got fired for that blunder."
dls2016··on Princess Mononoke: The masterpiece that flummoxed the US
I was joking about making me feel bad. What you said is the reason I only consciously watch one or two series per year. Many of them look great, but few hold my interest.
dls2016··on Princess Mononoke: The masterpiece that flummoxed the US
> Even their flagship offerings like Stranger Things are creatively bankrupt references for bored millennial parents.

Geez, as someone who doesn't actively watch TV (whatever the tween children or my millennial wife is watching), you're making me feel even worse about wasting time slogging through the entirety of the most recent season.

dls2016··on Leaked documents reveal Amazon’s process to review employees’ worth to Amazon
I tend to agree with people mocking this pov, but working as a university instructor… holy hell! There really are some very entitled and shameless people out there. I doubt it’s generational, though.
dls2016··on America’s favorite family outings are increasingly out of reach
Does anyone else think Disney’s rides suck, too?
dls2016··on Ask HN: What can you realistically manufacture in your garage?
My buddy and I did it last year. I wouldn't say you need a whole team. We picked an area and spent a two years honing an idea. He is a retired Air Force officer and had some contracting experience from the other side. I have a PhD in an unrelated field (math), a handful of papers and one unsuccessful NSF attempt. He learned all the application rules and took care of 100% of that stuff. I formulated the technical proposal and work plan, wrote the budget and the bulk of the technical writing.

My partner reached out to a few small business development centers but, while they were very eager to help, we ultimately received only very minor feedback and a general thumbs up. I'd say in the two years it took us to hone a winning technical proposal, my partner was able to become somewhat of an expert in the rules. During that time we also applied for a non-SBIR government grant, unsuccessfully, where we lost a lot of points for being a 2-man team. If you're willing to put in the time, it's very doable to write an application which follows the rules.

In fact, I'd say one thing we ran into was finding ourselves "inventing" rules because we were overly cautious with our compliance to what we thought were the rules. The application truly is the most difficult part of compliance for a SBIR Phase I.

The problems with our Phase I were purely technical. We weren't able to advance the state-of-the-art enough to be able to write a convincing commercialization plan. And I don't think there was any consulting firm we could have hired to fix that problem.

← PreviousPage 2 of 18Next →