If there is anything unclear you're interested in just let know. In my heart I feel I'm still just a McDonald's fry cook and feel like none of this is as scary as it might seem :)
1,343 karma · joined May 16, 2019
If there is anything unclear you're interested in just let know. In my heart I feel I'm still just a McDonald's fry cook and feel like none of this is as scary as it might seem :)
Then you can use the trained method on new arbitrary structures. If you've done everything right you get good, or good enough results, but much much faster.
At a high level It's the same pipeline as in all ML. But some aspects are different, e.g. unlike image recognition you can generate training data on the fly by running more DFT simulations
The idea is that to solve these problems you need to solve the schrodinger equation (1). But the schrodinger equation scales really badly with the number of electrons and can't get computed directly for more than a few sample cases. Even Density Functional Theory (DFT), the most popular approximation that still is reasonably accurate scales N^3 with the number of electrons, with a pretty big pre factor. A reasonable rule of thumb would be 12 hours on 12 nodes (each node being 160 cpu cores) for 256 atoms. You can play with settings and increase your budget to maybe get 2000 (and only for a few timesteps) but good luck beyond that.
Machine learning seems to be really useful here. In my own work on aluminium alloys I was able to get the same simulations that would have needed hours on the supercomputer to run in seconds on a laptop. Or, do simulations with tens of thousands of atoms for long periods of time on the supercomputer. The most famous application is probably alphafold from deep mind.
There are a lot of interesting questions people are still working on:
What are the best input features? We don't have any nice equivalent to CNNs that are universally applicable, though some have tried 3d convnets. One of the best methods right now involves taking spherical harmonic based approximates of the local environment in some complex way I've never fully understood, but is closer to the underlying physics.
Can we put physics into these models? Almost all these models fail in dumb ways sometimes. For example if I begin to squish two atoms together they should eventually repel each other and that repulsion force should scale really fast (ok maybe they fuse into a black hole or something but we're not dealing with that kind of esoteric physics here). But, all machine learning potentials will by default fail to learn this and will only learn the repulsion to the closest distance of any two atoms in their training set. Beyond that and the guess wildly. Some people are able to put this physics into the model directly but I don't think we have it totally solved yet.
How do we know which atomic environments to simulate? These models can really only interpolate they can't extrapolate. But while I can get an intuition of interpolation in low dimensions once your training set consists of many features over many atoms in 3d space this becomes a high dimensional problem. In my own experience, I can get really good energies for shearing behavior of strengthening precipitates in aluminum without directly putting the structures in. But was this extrapolated or interpolated from the other structures. Not always clear.
(1) sometimes also the relativistic Dirac equation. E.g. fast moving moving atoms in some of the heavier elements move at relativistic speeds.
The checklist includes:
1 are you using comments to manage obfuscated code? I.e. the comment isn't the problem it's the spaghetti code it makes the person feel entitled to write after
2 can the code just be a function with a clear name
3. Is the comment a non comment ?
<some others I forget the book is a great read>
That said. Plenty of times you need a good comment.
I say may because these things are complicated. I also suspect people here give better respect to food and might be eating a more balanced diet naturally
I live in Norway and just realized that they don't put iodine in their salt. (Actually a lot of minerals I would have normally gotten from enriched bread back home may or may not be added here). Locals eat a lot of white fish and get their iodine that way. But I don't and have started supplementing just in case.
We cannot know truly how these parameters interact at large scale and also how they interact with each other.
Is it really the case that openai has data that Google doesn't?
vore.website is free for anyone to use, and will never be turned into a vehicle for profit.
It's actually a brilliant name, what a way to keep away mainstream corporate interests