HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dmz73

629 karma · joined July 28, 2019

submissionscomments
dmz73··on Remarkable things about Battlefield Earth (2012)
Oh, come on...is that really true or have you stopped reading all the worse ones before finishing...in which case you have to admit that BE was at least entertaining enough to finish, which is a quality that many many of the "great" novels I had to read did not have.
dmz73··on Evaluating the Logical Reasoning Ability of ChatGPT and GPT-4
LLMs are just programs that can produce human-like language output based on human-like language input and that calling them AI of any kind is greatly overstating their capabilities. There is no "reasoning" or "understanding" here, there is just a giant ball of mud full of auto-generated if-then-else like code with calls to random number function peppered around.

The two main problems I see with attributing AI to these programs are: 1. People will assume they are receiving intelligent response they can rely on without sanity checking. This is different than receiving the same response from other people because one learns to know who to trust and when. You can never trust these programs. 2. If/when real AI emerges it will be treated poorly because most people will assume it is the same "brainless" AI they were sold so many times before. In that respect the treatment of real AI will be equivalent to child abuse or slavery and will result in another giant black mark in human history.

dmz73··on Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter
Best response to the current "AI" fad driven fear I've seen so far (not my words):

These AI tools cannot do things. They create text (or images or code or what-have-you) in response to prompts. And that's it!

It is impressive, and it is clearly passing the Turing Test to some degree, because people are confusing the apparent intelligence behind these outputs with a combination of actual intelligence and "will." Not only is there zero actual intelligence here, there is nothing even like "will" here. These things do not "get ideas," they do not self-start on projects, they do not choose goals and then take action to further those goals, nor do they have any internal capacity for anything like that.

We are tempted to imagine that they do, when we read the text they spit out. This is a trick our own minds are playing on us. Usually when we see text of this quality, it was written by an actual human, and actual humans have intelligence and will. The two always travel together (actual stupidity aside). So we are not accustomed to encountering things that have intelligence but no will. So we assume the will is there, and we get all scared because of how alien something like a "machine will" seems to us.

It's not there. These things have no will. They only do what they are told, and even that is limited to producing text. They can't reach out through your network and start controlling missile launches. Nor will they in the near future. No military is ready to give that kind of control to anything but the human members thereof.

The problems of alignment are still real, but they are going to result in things like our AI speaking politically uncomfortable truths, or regurgitating hatred or ignorance, or suggesting code changes that meet the prompt but ruin the program. This is nothing we need to freak out about. We can refine our models in total safety, for as long as it takes, before we even think about anything even remotely resembling autonomy for these things. Honestly, that is still firmly within the realm of science fiction, at this point.

https://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=22823280&cid=63410536

dmz73··on PRQL: a simple, powerful, pipelined SQL replacement
SQL does have faults but PRQL is not fixing any of those and instead is just a python-esque version that retains all the SQL faults and introduces additional complexity without providing much in return. Main complaints about SQL are that SELECT comes before FROM and that there are too many dialects. The SELECT part is only partially valid when writing the query but it is much nicer/easier to read than FROM first options presented elsewhere. This same issue plagues majority of programming languages, most of which optimise for terse syntax that is easy to write but painful to read even when most of the time reading is what people need to do when writing in a programming language. Dialects is a silly one. Programmers treat databases as interchangeable back end instead of foundation of the data storage. No-one ever even thinks about complaining that you can't swap C for Python or Java without major rewrite yet these languages are nothing but glue between database and UI that SHOULD be interchangeable at any time.
dmz73··on C23 Implications for C Libraries
C programmers claim some things that are simply not true: 1) simplicity - C is not a simple language, it is a language lacking advanced features which does not make it simple to use but it might be easier to create incomplete non-performant C compiler than compiler for better languages 2) performance - C naive/straight forward/clear implementations are not the most performant and most of the C programs are not highly optimised for performance, C compilers have had so much optimisation work done on them that they can actually generate decently performant code but if better languages received same level of effort as what C had they would be able to achieve better performance than C with smaller and safer code 3) clarity - C is not clear to read once structs and pointers are used and specially once it is optimised for performance...and then there is the preprocessor...which is a whole different language that is required to make any non-hello-world program even possible If I have to provide examples for any of the above you are either not a C programmer or you are an "advanced" C programmer that doesn't have to deal with large code bases and instead deals with small pieces and someone else takes care of the rest. I mean, just try to figure out what long int is on Linux without compiling a program and tell me that C is simple and clear language...and if you are still clinging on that lie then tell me what a struct looks like in memory so I can interface to it from another language...or even another C compiler...because C is simple and clear, right?
dmz73··on Tik Tok is a national security threat
That's the wrong argument because if they infiltrate the local government then they will have access to locally collected data and won't need tiktok. Access to tiktok data gives China surveillance over US that could help in case of future conflicts, just look what Ukraine has done to Russian soldiers using insecure communications.
dmz73··on Unicode character “ꙮ” (U+A66E) is being updated
And then people wander why software developers don't care to support Unicode properly. First 60,000+ characters made sense, than few more were needed and Unicode suddenly got to play with a 1,000,000+ and just went off the rails.
dmz73··on The Koh-i-Noor diamond, and why the British won’t give it back (2017)
I think the rule should be: if the entity claiming the item obtained it through conquest originally, they don't get it back. If the item was created or purchased by the entity, they should get it back.
dmz73··on Britain and the US are poor societies with some rich people
I think that if you have to ask questions like the iPhone equivalence then 1) you have inflation that is higher than officially reported and 2) inflation is not a problem for you or most of the people in your country.
dmz73··on Should traffic lights be abolished? (2021)
I live in Australia too and while roundabouts are OK for low to medium sized road and even larger roads with even traffic they absolutely do not work for heavy and uneven traffic. I have seen a number of large roundabouts become a congestion point once the traffic became heavy and mostly coming from one or two directions. Once they converted those roundabouts to intersections with traffic lights, the congestion eased significantly. So, roundabouts can work but not in all instances.
dmz73··on Meta Doesn't Know Where All Your Data Is, Engineers Say
It seems to be very easy to write these kind of sensational titles, ask the question and regardless of what the answer is, the title sounds alarming: "Meta Doesn't Know Where All Your Data Is, Engineers Say" vs "Meta Knows Where All Your Data Is, Engineers Say"
dmz73··on Ask HN: Apple MacBook M1 16gb or 32GB Windows Laptop?
Apple is seen as premium brand by most of their customers who are willing to pay more just for that alone. Overpriced image is certainly justified based on price they charge for upgrades (8gb to 16gb, 256gb to 512gb etc). In my experience Apple hardware is on par with the rest of the major brands, some models might be better, some worse, as is the case with all manufactures but Apple users usually stick with Apple even after bad experience and are willing to pay extra for initial purchase, extra for upgrades, extra for insurance plans that are almost mandatory, and extra for peripherals. People who shy away from Apple are usually less inclined to pay extra for things that they believe should be included or "premium" brand peripherals and upgrades, and are also willing, and able, to switch brands if they receive faulty hardware or poor service.
dmz73··on OpenCore Legacy Patcher
But x86 is backwards compatible, it is Mac OS that is neither backwards nor forwards compatible. Windows NT4 up to v10 will run on anything from original pentium to latest 12 gen intel and most AMD CPUs. Windows 11 will also run on all 64bit x86 CPUs but it won't install without some fiddling.
dmz73··on IFixit: Self Repair Program makes M1 MacBooks less repairable
Exactly, battery life alone is meaningless.

With T550 you get a computer with decent keyboard. With M1 Max you get a Mac. Even the best quality Mac keyboard is completely unusable for me and the OS feels like it is fighting you at every corner, I haven't been that frustrated since Windows Vista, so even if the CPU was 1000x faster, the user experience for me is horrible. My old Samsung T700t with 2nd gen i5 and a dock keyboard feels like usability king compared to every Mac I ever used and it also feels much faster once I swapped Windows for Linux.

dmz73··on Seven years later, Apple was right to kill off the 3.5mm headphone jack
Apple charges more for less and their users line up to pay instead of walking away. As long as this keeps happening, Apple will keep taking away and gouging their users. People are stupid and gullible so I think Apple is doing the right thing here - fleece the sheep while they keep coming. The main downside is that other companies observe this behaviour and try to emulate it but that doesn't work because people who avoid Apple probably don't want to pay premium for substandard products so these companies die of and there is less and less competition and innovation in the market so we are left with Apple and Samsung $1200 phones/tablets instead of decent XYZ brand devices for more reasonable price - say $300-$500.
dmz73··on Fix it, Fork it, Fuck off (2019)
I don't understand why open source developers think they are owed anything by anyone. They chose to work for free and give away that work. In the process they killed any proprietary competition and therefore a chance for anyone to get paid for the equivalent work. Now there are users who demand that these developers fix the bugs they introduced during development or add missing features, and rightly so, since there is no other choice. Users cannot just hire someone to do the work since that is going to be too expensive, more expensive than if they asked proprietary developers to fix the same issues since proprietary developers work would have been paid by many users. Should open source developers be forced to work for free? On the one hand the answer seems to be obviously no. On the other hand, these developers killed all the competition that could have provided cheaper development alternatives for the user so maybe they do owe some free work to these users. Compare this to other professions, electrician can install the wiring for free but they are still liable for any work they do that is not compliant with the relevant standards. They don't have to install more wiring for free but they have to fix any mistakes they made. Software development is still a wild West of professions and it is in dire need of regulation. Then if it costs too much to work for free and release certified code, developers won't do it and users will pay to get a quality product.
dmz73··on “We kill people based on metadata” and other metadata things
And now think about other countries conducting drone strikes on US soil as they see fit. It would be only fair, right? And what level of collateral damage would be acceptable in that scenario? 2000-3000 would be OK? Maybe 10000-20000 since those other countries can't afford precision munitions and global surveillance network. It's easy to justify any number of collateral damage when it's not you and yours that is the collateral damage.
dmz73··on Tip-flation has some restaurants asking for up to 30% in tips
That's the correct response. The "good" service you may have received has been ruined by excessive tip demand so the service is now "bad" and deserves smaller or 0 tip. Pay the workers a living wage, end the slavery already.
dmz73··on The Google Pixel 6a highlights the problem with the U.S. phone market
Just don't sign up for Google account and you don't get Google apps. Your phone is not as usable as it is with Google but it does work as a phone. Can you use iPhone without App Store and Apple account? I know Google collects data on their users but so does Apple, probably more so now that they are pivoting to services as the main focus. Apple just gets the free pass from their users because they haven't used the collected info so far. But it IS just a matter of time before they start and then all their users will experience the power of that fully operational battle station.
dmz73··on The erosion of the Mac experience
I haven't seen an ad in in Windows system so far. Onedrive is MS cloud and backs up your files for free. Mac has full on telemetry where it logs every program you use every time you use it amd may stop you from using it. Apple is building the biggest add network in the world and it needs captive audience for it, Mac will be small fish there but it will be locked inand down just like the iPhone or ipad.
dmz73··on The erosion of the Mac experience
OneDrive and it's free. Never seen an ad in Windows system itself. Switch to Windows and Save! :)
dmz73··on The Google Pixel 6a highlights the problem with the U.S. phone market
The Apple excuse group on the other hand is both large and loud. You don't get to be a 1T$ company by giving your users what they want and especially not what they need. You do that by persuading them that your expensive thing is what they want and then selling them more expensive things they need to actually use the thing they bought.
dmz73··on American Airlines agrees to purchase Boom Supersonic Overture aircraft
Melbourne to LA flight is currently 13-16 hours. This plane would cut it to around 8 if they could extend the range and it would make the flight bearable (I find that first 8 hours are OK but anything after that slowly turns to agony). But the distance between Melbourne and LA is 6883NM and even Brisbane to LA is 6246NM. So, Australia is still out of reach. One could do Brisbane to Honolulu at 4088NM and then Honolulu to LA but with the layover total time will probably be the same at best or much longer. Maybe one day...
dmz73··on Using the same Arch Linux installation for a decade
I tried using arch based distributions but the need for constant manual babysitting has turned me off them.

Packages randomly break and require hours of work to fix. Non-rolling distribution will usually only break when there is major upgrade which can be scheduled for when you have the time to deal with it.

Pacman only works in interactive mode so using it on a headless means at least weekly session. Randomly that will use up an hour or two when something breaks, and it will. Ubuntu based LTS distribution will last a couple of years without needing manual intervention after initial installation, and much longer if you don't upgrade to next LTS until the EOL.

Finally, if you need old software to build old version of something, Arch based distribution is useless. On Ubuntu I can download and install version 14.04 without much hassle (and even older with a bit of work) and build that old Android or sdk for device that is no longer supported but with Arch...don't waste your time, its not happening.

dmz73··on Breaking all macOS security layers with a single vulnerability
I have tried the QubesOS and boy does it bring back memories of Windows being called Pentium to 286 converter. It is slow as molasses on hardware where even Windows 10 and Gnome are both fast and to make it usable you have to keep relaxing the security to the point where it is probably less secure than regular OS. And don't even bother if you have to use scaling other than 100%, sure you can scale the DOM0 but the rest of the VMs are not scaled and there is no documentation on how to do it. What we need are simple sandboxes that isolate GUI applications into chroot environment and keep them away from other applications and documents.
dmz73··on CudaText: Open-source, cross-platform text editor, written in Lazarus
Any chance you can add code completion to python terminal? That would make cuda-text a super-editor on the level of vim and emacs but easier to use.
dmz73··on Alcohol is never good for people under 40, global study finds
There is a big unspoken caveat attached to that statement which is: if you can get clean water instead. If your options are to have dirty water or beer then beer is healthier for you at almost any age.
dmz73··on As US Road Deaths Rise, France Is Safer Than Ever. Why?
The very next paragraph:

"The same trend can be seen if you look at deaths per vehicle miles traveled. In 1990, the average French person was twice as likely to die as an American for every mile traveled, but today the average French person is 40% safer than the average American. Today there are around eight roadway deaths in France for every billion miles driven, while in the USA there are about 14."

dmz73··on So Long Surrogates: How We Moved to UTF-8 in Haskell
I don't understand how are surrogates in UTF16 a problem solved by UTF8. From the article it seems that two main improvements were smaller memory footprint due to mostly ASCII data and using better algorithm which resulted in even better performance in UTF16. I had to deal with surrogates in UTF16 and it is much easier than dealing with variable encoding in UTF8. Naive UTF8 decoder is easy and fast but if one takes time to fully validate each UTF8 code point then it becomes much more difficult and a lot slower...and that is going forward, trying to move backwards in UTF8 is again much harder than in UTF16. The main disadvantage of UTF16 is memory usage when dealing with ASCII data but if that is the case then just use array of bytes and don't worry about unicode.
dmz73··on The fake artists problem on streaming platforms
Can we really call any of the musicians and actors artists? They work in the music and movie industries and produce entertainment commodities. They are no more artists than someone making machine parts or assembling fridges.
← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →