HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dognotdog

678 karma · joined January 11, 2014

submissionscomments
dognotdog··on Take-Two Sues Enthusiasts Behind GTA Fan Projects Re3 and ReVC
It seems like using something that's reverse engineering to achieve "interoperability", in this case playing the games on modern hardware, is generally legal in the US/EU, as long as you also own a license to the original, which seems like is a requirement to use the Re* versions, as you need the original game assets.

Decompilation / reverse engineering is very different from "transcribing" a play. Transcribing a play, you would get back an almost exact copy of the source material, whereas decompiling is more akin to taking a car and measuring all the bits of it. You would certainly not get the original drawings or CAD files back out of it. You do not decompile "source code", but machine code, and the source code you get back is not a recreation of the original copyrighted code, but the decompiler's analysis of the machine instructions, stripped of the original design and intent (the creative work part which makes source code copyrightable in the first place).

Measurements (or information) in general is not copyrightable, despite what IP protectionism claims, and in this analogy the machine code is much closer to the mechanical pieces of the car that make it work than the original designs. Either way, the fair use / reverse engineering provisions already create an exemption.

The questions is wether there are enough legal loopholes to squash these generally allowed uses through some other parts of the law or licensing terms, eg. by claiming that some IP (patents, trade secrets) are infringed some other way by publishing the reverse engineered code.

dognotdog··on Sony’s new PS5 model weighs less because it has a smaller heatsink
Yes, higher exhaust temperature is not a direct indicator. For the same airflow, higher exhaust temperature suggests more energy being carried away, which can reduce chip temp, all else being the same. If the airflow was reduced, but the heat pipe improved, it could still be that chip temp stayed the same.
dognotdog··on A Dyson sphere around a black hole
Why do you think it's impossible? To me, it seems like all effects (eg. mechanical waves) would propagate at much slower speeds than the speed of light. This kind of control system experiencing significant delays and dead-times is not uncommon.
dognotdog··on Apple Has Opened the Backdoor to Increased Surveillance and Censorship
Framing relationships in this "triangle" is not new. As parent says, reality is a lot more complex, and this kind of frame-of-mind can be very detrimental:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karpman_drama_triangle

dognotdog··on School Shutdowns Will Cost Students a Staggering Amount in Lifetime Earnings
> Yet the harm inflicted on our children by government mandates closing schools isn’t just academic or financial.

Love it, the spin in this article is something to behold, including the many references to more articles with half-thruths from the same publication. It is a shame, because COVID's influence is indeed worrysome on minority and disadvantaged communities.

dognotdog··on Undetectable quantum computation and communication for alien civilizations
That is quite interesting, and makes sense! The spread-spectrum signal is a psuedo-random, but same sequence for all receivers, while the noise varies and should cancel out.

Though, if I am not mistaken, the laws of super-sampling hold in this case, and SNR is only improved by O(sqrt(N)) for N samples, so this approach will have practical limits as one has to place a very large number of receivers in range of the emitter (or do auto-correlations over a very long time window), with enough separation to make sure the noise isn't correlated anymore, if looking for a signal deep below the noise floor.

dognotdog··on Undetectable quantum computation and communication for alien civilizations
Ultra-Wideband Spread-Spectrum can be undetectable, as the signal can be well below the noise floor in any given frequency band, and only knowing the right key will allow you to perform a convolution to lift the actual signal above the noise. Without the right key, all you'd see is noise, and you wouldn't even know there was a signal.

see https://www.itu.int/itunews/manager/display.asp?lang=en&year...

dognotdog··on Resident Evil Village crack completely fixes its stuttering issues
A game’s animation and other in-game timing functions are very unlikely to be based on wall-time, instead typically relying on monotonic counters that are higher resolution, less overhead, and not potentially adjusted backwards or forwards while the game is running. Thus, disabling wall-time accesses for a crack should have little influence on game timing and animations.
dognotdog··on Book Review: A Philosophy of Software Design (2020)
> * unit tests are superb documentary as every dev can see how it is used and how it works at runtime.

Those unit tests have to be derived from somewhere, though, right? Hopefully, there are requirements docs -- but often those are too high-level, or omit details that were discovered during implementation, and in those cases I'm very appreciative of comments describing intent and purpose of a code snippet or function. Of course, like all things, comments rot without active maintenance and refactoring.

In a perfect world, code comments would be redundant, but they do provide a very low-friction way of documenting interesting bits while writing the code, while it takes a lot more effort to back-port information into requirements documentation.

dognotdog··on Zipcar Sucks and So Does App World
While a little bit of a rant (though fair, given the underlying frustrations), I do feel like it mirrors a lot of my experience.

Customer service is not being optimized, it is being optimized AWAY. Going even further, it seems as if it couldn't possibly be made this hostile (eg. endless hotline holds; being bounced to different reps several times; not being able to speak to a human at all) unless the goal was explicitly to make it as miserable as possible for the customer.

Problems will always occur, wether the company causes them or the customer, and humans need to be empowered to solve them effectively for all the edge cases where algorithms/AI/ML/etc can't, otherwise it's just a pile of misery.

What incentives are missing to actually improve customer service?

dognotdog··on Had Covid? You’ll probably make antibodies for a lifetime
FWIW, several non-vaccinated acquaintances of mine in different countries have gotten COVID for the 2nd time, though anecdotally somewhat less severe in the second round.

Is any data, yet, available about how reduced the contagiousness is for getting infected for the 2nd time naturally, vs. having the vaccine? For both catching and spreading it?

dognotdog··on Tune Your PID Controller
Yes, usually just clamp the integrator's accumulator value so that when the actuator is outside the linear control regime (eg. maxing out motor current because we're in the end-stop), the output of the controller doesn't continue increasing to infinity.

(Another way is stopping integration when control output is at its physical limit, usually in addition to a numeric limit.)

As with all other PID parameters, this is something you'd have to figure out more-or-less empirically.

Testing with hardware would be checking that controller outputs stop increasing while the actuator is blocked away from its target value, usually running with much reduced speed/current etc limits. Ideally, of course, run unit tests and SIL, before trying it on actual hardware.

dognotdog··on Tune Your PID Controller
"anti-windup" is usually implemented for PID controllers to avoid increasing the I part infinitely, and linear state-space controls do suffer from the same problem in naive implementations.
dognotdog··on Ask HN: As small-fry needing custom PCBs, how to deal with Covid part shortage?
I'm sure a lot of the MEMS sensors, etc, are indeed on those wafers. A large chunk of that and analog / hybrid circuitry is dominated by structures that don't benefit from super high density processes and large surface area wafers.

That the incentives would be so lopsided and the corporate structures so opaque as for it all to be politically driven is a scary thought, though…

dognotdog··on Time flies in Google Earth’s biggest update in years
Geez, I'll just go and blame the pandemic for a complete loss of sense of time on that! I could've sworn I saw a beta of that just not so recently, but I had no idea it's been mainstream for that long.
dognotdog··on Time flies in Google Earth’s biggest update in years
There's also https://earthtime.org/explore which is based off the same satellite imagery, but in the browser. And, it has a lot more available data layers with social, economic, and environmental data on a global scale.
dognotdog··on United B772 at Denver on Feb 20th 2021, engine inlet separates from engine
It looks it’s the “cowling” that was lost, not the protective shroud / containment around the fan (and the rest of the engine) that keeps the fan/compressor/turbine blades from becoming high speed radial projectiles when they break off at full speed.
dognotdog··on Cleaner parallel curves with Euler spirals
Is there a decent FOSS solver or algorithm for Cornu splines these days?

I did write a road digitizing tool for an internal simulation, based on raphlinus's thesis, about 12-13 years ago, but always had trouble with numerical stability.

It's such a fantastically better tool for vector art than regular splines, though, especially with higher-order continuity.

dognotdog··on Amazon competitor got our belt listing taken down by saying it contains drugs
Is this AI, really? And isn't it immaterial if it is in the first place? If it's a dumb algorithm or a smart one (or a random one, at that) locking out people without recourse, the result seems much the same.
dognotdog··on Amazon competitor got our belt listing taken down by saying it contains drugs
Arguably, this has nothing to do with AI, but an imbalance of power. From a business perspective, it makes perfect sense to do whatever is just good enough to turn a profit with minimal effort.

As long as there is healthy competition, there is enough incentive to do better, and a customer can switch services without experiencing significant hardship. However, with a lot of the big tech companies, that is no longer the case, and once you run into a problem there is neither free-market nor regulatory mechanisms that can help any individual solve their problem.

Currently, the big tech companies can eschew responsibility by claiming the rights of private business -- having very strong autonomy over how and with whom they do business -- and despite them being de-facto public utilities at this point, the claims are made that regulation is not necessary / not allowed / not productive / harmful. Why this is accepted is puzzling to me, as it is very commonly known macro-economic theory that the usually claimed self-regulating free-market mechanisms no longer work for when large imbalances, eg. monopolies, exist. We have the government explicitly for this reason, to create a counter-balance against forces so large that any individual cannot deal with on their own.

And while it is true that we can expect regulatory intervention to be difficult, especially as the political process cannot possibly keep pace with technology, it is indeed very strongly preferable to giving free reign to private entities with explicitly anti-consumer interests (eg. a corporation has to make their shareholders money, not protect their customers or the environment).

So what's the solution? Maybe regulatory agencies need to be given more teeth, including funding and updated charters. Yesterday's Cartel is today's Big Tech.

dognotdog··on Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 years
That doesn't seem to bad, all considered. 5% would be the natural number for any one year out of 20, to get to 0.4% from 5% in 20 yrs should be about 8 yrs of mean life per car, assuming exponential decay. I'm fairly sure this thought process is missing some fudge factor to make it exact, but seems about the right ballpark.
dognotdog··on Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 years
This is interesting, 0.4% in numbers or value?
dognotdog··on Architecture.md
I feel like for any long-running project, that person is at least ME. If I haven't written down some architectural information for complex projects, when I revisit a project after it being dormant for half year, I need to poke around to figure things out again.

If I have written down architecture notes in the first place, they are very helpful at this point; and if I haven't, it's a good time to start because I'll be acutely aware of the non-obvious parts as I re-familiarize myself with the code.

dognotdog··on Air pollution linked to higher risk of irreversible sight loss
> It mostly kicks up in the morning but I have no idea what is causing it to think the air quality is bad.

If it's a standard PM sensor, those usually have a high temperature correlation that needs to be compensated for, and turning on the heat in the morning would likely produce a false positive with only naive signal processing.

dognotdog··on Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features
USB 2.0 tops out at a theoretical 60MB/s, and in reality it is much slower, far below the read speeds of fast SD cards.

I appreciate that it’s good enough under some circumstances, but not always. Certainly not when taking several cards worth of photos a day, with only very limited time to do transfer, selection, and editing.

dognotdog··on Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features
Maybe consider that it’s more nuanced in real life.

That $12 card reader, even expensive USB-3 card readers, are often a lot slower than that builtin one. They get lost and broken, not even considering that when you’re on the go, many photographers will absolutely try to shed as much unnecessary weight as possible, as not many people are built like the hulk or have an entourage of assistants doing the heavy lifting.

I use my laptop a lot outside of an office, and having that multitude of builtin ports is an absolute must, as dongles are quite difficult to deal with in situations when I don’t have a flat surface to put the laptop on. That TB/Ethernet dongle I regularly do have to use has been a great source of frustration.

dognotdog··on The Toyota Production System (2013)
> correction of my sloppy wrong comments (wrong numbers).

It was not completely wrong. Being an employee gives you those benefits (eg you can stretch parental leave to 2yrs with part time work, the minimum vacation is 24 days instead of 30, but there's unlimited sick leave), and it is incomparable to the ridiculous PTO/PSL system in the US.

However, companies by and large only do this due to external pressure (govt, unions, competition), not any kind of inherent cultural benevolence.

In tech/engineering, this typically means that instead of direct hiring, hiring through agencies where people are regularly rotated out of projects to not have to become permanent employees, and without the regular benefits of the host company. Freelance tech work is actually becoming rare because German law has Duck Typing for determining employment status, so if you're de facto salaried, and the govt finds out, both the employer and employee suddenly owe all the relevant employment taxes, even years back, and because this has been abused and has been cracked down on, nowadays getting freelance work is difficult.

Of course, that somehow didn't stop companies from trying to pull the same scam with "gig economy" BS on the lowest paid workers the past few years.

dognotdog··on Societal Collapse
Or possibly we never before in history had the wherewithal to be aware of, diagnose, and treat mental health issues to the extent we can today?
dognotdog··on What’s the best non-smart TV sold today?
I've recently gotten a Philips 558M1RY, after not wanting to get a Smart TV because of UI and privacy issues. It is marketed as a "Console Monitor." I was going to attach a PC to it anyway, as I don't have traditional cable or an aerial. I gotta say it's a bit pricey for its size, though being 4K and HDR, it is not that bad. And I'm not limited to whatever clunky, ad-riddled UI the vendor chose, but can choose my own clunky UI for watching Netflix, etc.

If only HDR support on the PC side wasn't so terrible, it'd be a fantastic setup :/

dognotdog··on When DevSecOps goes wrong: a short lesson from Huawei's source code
With the standard practice where a 2nd team gets tasked with reducing code defects in existing code, with their only metric being reducing the number of defects (that the given tools generate), without regard to the quality of the fixes, and preferably staffed with high churn rate junior developers, the outcomes are not surprising.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →