HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dominik

732 karma · joined May 14, 2008

product manager at youtube

my views are my own

https://dominik.net

submissionscomments
dominik··on Ask HN: How do you read RSS feeds?
I ask because I currently have about 100 feeds in Google Reader; most of them update fairly infrequently. I try to only subscribe to feeds that have full text, since I dislike excerpts because I have to open a new tab. That said, I try to read all my feeds, but often fall behind (260 unread at the moment). I find catching up takes too long and I just have to press 'Mark All as Read.'

Perhaps I need to adjust my approach to feeds to maximize my information/time; I tend to cycle between subscribing to many feeds and then unsubscribing from many. My biggest trouble is with feeds that are high volume (1 post/day or more) yet have interesting content. These can be enormous timesinks if I'm not careful.

dominik··on I just got sued for patent infringement for operating the voo2do.com todo list
I'd say that sounds like accurate speculation, but IANAL.
dominik··on Ask HN: what language should I learn next?
I'd recommend Python, so that you can play with Djgano.
dominik··on Ask YC: Building a software review website, what to use?
I'd recommend using WordPress and writing a custom plugin. You can write reviews as normal posts and just include your custom code in the review, e.g. "[software iSaber] iSaber is great because it lets me embrace my inner Jedi." The [software Saber] then gets parsed by your custom plugin, which converts it to whatever link/representation you want to use to software. For example of this in action (with books), see http://learningtheworld.eu/2007/amazon-machine-tags/

You can also use WordPress's categories and tags as navigation, and WP offers a whole host of plugins that you can use to quickly add functionality (e.g. ratings, see: http://www.lesterchan.net/wordpress/readme/wp-postratings.ht...). Since all of WP's plugins are open source, you can customize anything you use to your hearts desire.

I find the biggest advantage of WP is that it lets you focus on what's unique to your project and lets you iterate very quickly -- you get something working right away, and build up on it, with a lot of features built in from the getgo. The biggest disadvantage is that you have to work with the way WP works, which may not be appropriate for your particular application. Here, you want to do reviews and WP does a great job of dealing with blog posts, which are blocks of content just like reviews. I'd say it's a pretty good match.

If you don't like WP and want to write something from scratch, you can use Django or CakePHP or Rails, depending on your language of choice.

Best of luck!

dominik··on I just got sued for patent infringement for operating the voo2do.com todo list
Ack! Best of luck deflecting the lawsuit. Hopefully it won't be too hard, as there are so many other defendants. Lawsuits like this make me glad I'm a law student, so I can graduate and fight against them.

voo2do is a great service; I used it quite extensively two years ago.

dominik··on Linus Torvalds on security
Ah, thanks for the clarification.

I read too much into Linus's words.

dominik··on Linus Torvalds on security
From what I've seen, most security bugs chain a few normal bugs together. One oversight here, another there, combine them and you have an exploit.

The valid point I think Linus is getting at (perhaps I'm reading too much into it) is that if you solve normal, boring bugs, you prevent the much trumpeted security bugs from ever coming out. By heaping praise on the security team and ignoring the careful programmer who writes good code and eliminates bugs before they exist, Linus sees the community move towards a crisis-solving mode rather than a crisis-prevention mode. His view is that it's far better to focus on writing good, solid code that tests robustly rather than hyper-focusing on security at the cost of everything else. This is not to dismiss the importance of security; instead, it is a fundamental focus shift -- thus the example of OpenBSD, where Linus sees security paranoia has subsumed everything else.

dominik··on Documentation or death (or: the rise and slight drop of rails blogging)
Is it bad this post spurred my interest in Django, precisely because of its good documentation?
dominik··on Linus Torvalds on security
I don't think he's exploding at all ('cept for maybe the comments about the OpenBSD crowd).

He has a very valid point: all the boring normal bugs are _way_ more important.

Security bugs are just a special case of normal bugs, a test condition unaddressed.

dominik··on Warren Buffett’s 7 Secrets for Living a Happy and Simple Life
The secrets:

1. Happiness comes from within: "In my adult business life I have never had to make a choice of trading between professional and personal. I tap-dance to work, and when I get there it’s tremendous fun."

2. Find happiness in simple pleasures: "I have simple pleasures. I play bridge online for 12 hours a week. Bill and I play, he’s “chalengr” and I’m “tbone”."

3. Live a simple life: "I just naturally want to do things that make sense. In my personal life too, I don’t care what other rich people are doing. I don’t want a 405 foot boat just because someone else has a 400 foot boat."

4. Think Simply: "I want to be able to explain my mistakes. This means I do only the things I completely understand."

5. Invest Simply: "The best way to own common stocks is through an index fund."

6. Have a mentor in life: "I was lucky to have the right heroes. Tell me who your heroes are and I’ll tell you how you’ll turn out to be. The qualities of the one you admire are the traits that you, with a little practice, can make your own, and that, if practiced, will become habit-forming."

7. Making money isn’t the backbone of our guiding purpose; making money is the by-product of our guiding purpose: "If you’re doing something you love, you’re more likely to put your all into it, and that generally equates to making money."

dominik··on Windows now open source
Misleading title. The article talks about Linux distros that look like Windows and ends with this: "Microsoft products will never go open source. The above list is some flavor of Linux distribution targeted at new users with Windows background."
dominik··on Profitable After 3 Weeks
Out of pure artistic curiosity: What did linked article use to make those charts? They look nice.
dominik··on 3-D CAPTCHA: A way to fix the broken CAPTCHAs?
I harbor a strong distaste for CAPTCHAs. At best, they're annoying. At worst, they're infuriating, such as when I simply can't see the letters or when I stumble into a cross-site hosted CAPTCHA that requires JavaScript -- which I have disabled -- and then loses the post I was going to make when I press the back button to try again with JavaScript enabled.

I see CAPTCHA as a bandaid and I can understand why people turn to it: spam has reached epidemic proportions. That said, any form of CAPTCHA, either the existing form or the proposed 3-D form of this article suffers from two fundamental flaws: 1. It annoys users and makes it harder for people to contribute 2. Spammers will get around it eventually, and once one spammer gets around it, they all will

CAPTCHA bears similarities to copy protection schemes in these two flaws: both annoy users and merely are road bumps to the undesirables (spammers and crackers).

I think the solution is three fold: 1. Make it easy to post so real humans contribute 2. Filter spam aggressively 3. Incorporate trust mechanisms

Making it easy so real humans contribute removes obstacles (such as CAPTCHAs, registration, etc.) that get in the way of people posting. Every obstacle means less people will post. With community contributors at about 1% of visitors, there's a lot of room to grow by making it easier to contribute.

Spam filtering works because spam is fundamentally different from a valid post, and always will be. Bayesian schemes such as pg described long ago work well. Gmail, for example, does an amazing job of filtering spam. The few posts that get through are easily dealt with.

Trust mechanisms take advantage of the fundamental weakness spammers have: they aren't members of the community. A simple trust mechanism is don't auto-link links from posters with less than 10 comments. Since most spam contains links of some sort and most comments don't, spam will be predominantly affected by this. Once a posters get to 10 posts (or 10 karma), their comments retroactively get auto-linked. This is simple to implement, but reduces the impact of spammers significantly since their spam isn't accessible unless someone goes to the trouble of copy-pasting it, preventing accidental clicks by users. At the same time it doesn't punish new users, since their valid links will still be accessible and will become on equal footing once they grow into the community.

dominik··on I Finally Understand Closures
A closure is an implementation technique for representing procedures with free variables. -- SICP @ http://mitpress.mit.edu/sicp/full-text/book/book-Z-H-15.html...
dominik··on Y Combinator’s Slinkset Launches Hosted Reddits For The Masses
I've made an Internet Law slinkset: http://ilaw.slinkset.com
dominik··on It Takes a School, Not Missiles
A good review; the better parts are where the columnist, Mr. Kristof, describes the book and Mr. Mortenson rather than talking about his own opinion.

Most interesting: "To get a school, villagers must provide the land and the labor to assure a local “buy-in,” and so far the Taliban have not bothered his schools. One anti-American mob rampaged through Baharak, Afghanistan, attacking aid groups — but stopped at the school that local people had just built with Mr. Mortenson. “This is our school,” the mob leaders decided, and they left it intact."

"Mr. Mortenson has had setbacks, including being kidnapped for eight days in Pakistan’s wild Waziristan region."

Strangely, the columnist adds in "It would be naïve to think that a few dozen schools will turn the tide in Afghanistan or Pakistan," right after that, undermining his own point... ?

dominik··on Filtrbox Dials the Noise Way Down
Filtrbox's own FAQ describes Filtrbox as "a value-add layer between the millions of sources online and your browser or desktop," whatever that means.

At $200/year for the cheapest premium option, seems far too expensive. The free option limits you to just 5 "Filtrs."

I'm not sure what this is exactly. The linked article above makes it sound as if it were a glorified feed reader, but I signed up for a trial account and there's nowhere to import OPML. I can import Google Alerts, but that's it. More digging reveals I can import specific feeds, but not OPML, under the Account->Content tab of the dashboard (strangely not under the Sources tab where I first looked).

As a side note, the entire "Getting Started" instructions are all videos, with no text description anywhere that can quickly be skimmed or searched. I see videos as a fine complement, but not as the primary means of instruction since not everyone can always watch videos (e.g. no speakers/headphones/low bandwidth).

Finally, it takes the main filtrbox dashboard takes a while to load, as it is apparently one massive piece of flash.

dominik··on WordPress 2.6 released: "a more powerful CMS"
Some yummy changes; particularly the Wiki-like edit tracking.
dominik··on Y Combinator’s Slinkset Launches Hosted Reddits For The Masses
Excellent! I've been waiting a long while for something like this :)

Some suggestions: - When adding a feed, include feed detection code, so that I can type in a URL and have the feed auto-detected, instead of having to find the exact feed URL - Allow a threshold for downmodding like HN... only submitters with X or more karma can downmod.

This looks great and I look forward to seeing it evolve and get better!

dominik··on The web design guru web designers love to hate.
I think HN strikes the appropriate balance between good looks and good usability.
dominik··on Warning: Habits May Be Good for You
All that said, I'm uncertain how this article relates to "Hacker News." I can see a tangential relation by "hacking behavior through habits," but it's a stretch.
dominik··on Warning: Habits May Be Good for You
Good read.

The article speaks of the power of advertising to create new behavior patterns by influencing the public so that the public doesn't realize it's being influenced.

Advocacy groups like the article's subject learned these tactics from corporations, who have been perfecting these strategies for the past five decades.

dominik··on The web design guru web designers love to hate.
There isn't one.

All there is an email newsletter that just sends an e-mail every time he posts a new Alertbox. You can subscribe here: http://www.useit.com/alertbox/

Theoretically you could use email2rss to convert the newsletter into a feed.

Nielsen's views on email newsletters and RSS feeds (scroll down to the bottom for his analysis of RSS feeds): http://www.useit.com/alertbox/newsletters.html

dominik··on Hulu a consumer success but still a small business: Est. $12.5-25mm net revs
I used Hulu to keep track of Battlestar Galatica for the early half of this past season. Originally, Hulu posted episodes the day after they aired and didn't include any commercials. However, as the end of the season approached, Hulu -- without warning or advance notice -- delayed posting episodes until 8 days after they aired. Only after folks complained did they put up a schedule of airdates.

I also had the chance to watch several movies on Hulu; once again I found the service started excellent and got progressively worse. Early on, movies downloaded quickly and had no ads. Towards the end of May, however, Hulu started interrupting movies with ads in seemingly random places -- not in natural transition points but right in the middle of an actor's words. Furthermore, as they apparently hadn't secured advertising yet, these "ads" were just 15 seconds of static white text on a black screen that read: "Brought to you by Hulu's advertisers" or some such. I found these pointless since they didn't even name the advertisers or feature their logos. Disgusted with these pointless interruptions, I've since swore off Hulu.

In short: They had a good thing going at the start, but have proceeded to muck it up.

dominik··on Hacker News feeds
Excellent. I can now have a feed to keep track of all replies to my comments. Thank you!
dominik··on Re: Why Nerds are Unpopular
If schools didn't do sports, perhaps they could focus more on academics.

Unfortunately, as you astutely point out, football and other sports bring in "big crowds paying lots of money" -- something that academic competitions can't bring in. There isn't a National Computer Science League that gets televised each Sunday. American football exists as an American high school institution precisely because mainstream American culture heavily advertises and hypes it.

I'd love to see schools make sports subservient to academics, but I fear it'll never happen purely for financial reasons.

dominik··on Re: Why Nerds are Unpopular
How can you tell if you're popular?

I have fond memories of high school, but perhaps because I took just one class there while attending college classes and the local math and science center. Still, I "felt" popular at high school: people knew my name, said hi, were nice. Contrasted with my experiences at the math and science center: there folks weren't as friendly and bitter rivalries seemed to run amok.

dominik··on Lies We Tell Kids
I wouldn't quite say unequivocally that those are lies, or at least that true love is a lie.

The poem True Love by Nobel Prize Winner Wislawa Szymborska replies better than I can:

True love. Is it normal / is it serious, is it practical? / What does the world get from two people / who exist in a world of their own?

Placed on the same pedestal for no good reason, / drawn randomly from millions but convinced / it had to happen this way - in reward for what? / For nothing. / The light descends from nowhere. / Why on these two and not on others? / Doesn't this outrage justice? Yes it does. / Doesn't it disrupt our painstakingly erected principles, / and cast the moral from the peak? Yes on both accounts.

Look at the happy couple. / Couldn't they at least try to hide it, / fake a little depression for their friends' sake? / Listen to them laughing - its an insult. / The language they use - deceptively clear. / And their little celebrations, rituals, / the elaborate mutual routines - / it's obviously a plot behind the human race's back!

It's hard even to guess how far things might go / if people start to follow their example. / What could religion and poetry count on? / What would be remembered? What renounced? / Who'd want to stay within bounds?

True love. Is it really necessary? / Tact and common sense tell us to pass over it in silence, / like a scandal in Life's highest circles. / Perfectly good children are born without its help. / It couldn't populate the planet in a million years, / it comes along so rarely.

Let the people who never find true love / keep saying that there's no such thing.

Their faith will make it easier for them to live and die.

Edit: I can't figure out how to get CRLFs in the right places, so here's the link for the properly formatted version: http://www.cs.rice.edu/~ssiyer/minstrels/poems/694.html

dominik··on Lies We Tell Kids
Ah, alas that this essay ends. I hope there will be a follow up which may go into further detail in terms of how to go about erasing.

The entire concept of erasing ("unthinking"?) brings to mind the dialogue between Gandalf and Saruman in Book 3, Chapter 10. Specifically: "Gandalf stirred, and looked up. "What have you to say that you did not say at our last meeting?" he asked. "Or, perhaps, you have things to unsay?" Saruman paused. "Unsay?" he mused, as if puzzled."

← PreviousPage 6 of 6