HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

donaldc

1,067 karma · joined March 2, 2009

submissionscomments
donaldc··on Arrington: Y Combinator Thinks Small
The VCs are not unbiased, objective observers of YC. It may be that some VCs have that particular issue with YC, or it may be that they don't like YC for other reasons, and their stated reason is just the professionally acceptable rationalization they've come up with.

Clearly, some VCs do like YC. Didn't Sequoia invest a few million dollars in them?

donaldc··on Zuckerberg to Donate $100 Million to Newark Schools
Newark spends about $22,000 a year on each of its 40,000 pupils, but only about half of its students graduate.

That's over $260,000 per student over 12 years!

It's great that Zuckerberg is donating about $100 million to the worthy cause of education, but in this instance I find it hard to believe that lack of money is the problem.

donaldc··on Ask HN: Are you saving for retirement?
so if you finally gave up work at 73 that's only an average of 5 years you need to live without an income

Not necessarily. A couple of reasons:

* Life expectancy in developed countries has been increasing by well over a year every decade.

* Life expectancy for someone at age 73 is notably higher; remember that the average of 78 includes everyone who has died before age 73.

Personally, I come from comparatively long-lived ancestors. I have no desire to find out when I'm 78 that I'm likely to live to 90 or 100, but have no money left.

donaldc··on I’m Giving Cable 6 Months To Live
Whether or not the author of this article is able to cut out Comcast, he's going to be at the mercy of one or another video content intermediary until either football stops making exclusive deals with said intermediaries, or until he decides that broadcasts of current football games aren't must-have content.

I'm not holding my breath for either of those to happen.

donaldc··on Big companies collude to hold down pay.
This is especially interesting in light of the recent stories about Google offering huge raises and incentives to keep key employees from jumping to Facebook. Good thing that Google and Facebook don't have a no-poaching agreement.

But not so good that all these other companies had no poaching agreements.

donaldc··on Google Fights Back In Battle For Talent
A new bubble would result from investors putting more money into tech companies that had no chance of success. Google raising pay for some of its engineers is not a bubble.
donaldc··on The Moral of the Kurzweil v. Myers Spat
50 million bits is enough to specify a human-level intelligence, but only if one has the appropriate machine. In terms of constructing an AI, the human genome is doing little more than taking clever advantage of ways to cause things in the physical world to self-organize (as per the book, Notes on the Synthesis of Form). Physical reality itself is the execution machine, is responsible for much of the end product, and has way more than 50 million bits of complexity.

If we are thinking of running our first AI on something resembling current computer hardware, then we are going to run it in a extremely impoverished environment, as compared with actual physical reality. This means that the AI-specifying algorithm will have less environmental complexity to work with than the human-intelligence algorithm does, and this in turn means that the AI-specification will need to be longer and more complex.

So from a practical standpoint, while one could in theory specify an AI in 50 million bits, in practice the first AI will need a much larger specification, and/or will need to run on some very powerful computer hardware.

Just how powerful can probably be estimated, but it has little to do with the fact that the human genome contains 50 million bits of information. In terms of determining when AI will happen, the 50 million bit argument is a red herring.

donaldc··on 100 Prisoners, 100 lines of code
In a real-world setting, it's hard for 100 prisoners to consistently assign the same ordering to a jumble of 100 boxes.
donaldc··on Google Invests $86 Million In Low-Income Housing
I stand by this comment.
donaldc··on 100 Prisoners, 100 lines of code
If the boxes are in a random jumble when the prisoner enters, there may be no practical way of having 100 prisoners consistently assign an ordering from 1 to 100 for the boxes. The approach outlined will then fail.

Were I a particularly evil warden, I could meticulously place all the boxes in the same such "jumble" after each prisoner left. One of the prisoners would certainly derive a different ordering of the boxes than one of the other prisoners. The approach might still have a better than random chance of succeeding, but it would be lower than that outlined in the article, since there are now two (or more) chances for a cycle of length greater than 50.

donaldc··on Google Invests $86 Million In Low-Income Housing
This is not the worst way to spend money, but really, if Google doesn't need the money for its business, it should just pay it back to its shareholders in the form of either stock buybacks or dividends.
donaldc··on How Entire Industries Become Unethical
This need not be legislated. If commercial renters were sufficiently biased in favor of places with an objectively determined square footage rating, landlords would provide it regardless of the lack of a legal requirement. The key is getting demand started.

This is currently an inefficient market, and more information would substantially improve it. And objectively measuring square feet is not particularly difficult or expensive.

What will probably happen is, eventually the misrepresentation of square footage will get so egregious that there will be a movement by commercial renters toward some sort of third-party measurement. The landlords will go along, because they want to rent their office space.

donaldc··on When to Make the First Offer in Negotiations
One of the points of the article was that, no, even in situations where a party objectively knows that the number given should not have any effect, it does anyway.

Human psychology often doesn't make rational sense.

donaldc··on De-emphasize Age, Refocus on Play
I think that this is a better and more constructive article than the various other age-related articles drifting around. It may very well be that the level of fluid intelligence is the real issue, and that this level is partially inversely correlated with age because, as time goes on, more and more people stop playing, and few ever start playing again once they've stopped.

Many people probably stop play-like activities because they consider it to be wasted time, much like sleep, and so it gets the axe when time is scarce. Perhaps if they realized its importance, they'd make time for it.

donaldc··on How Entire Industries Become Unethical
I think the real problem here is that the owners and leasers of an office space are the ones who are responsible for reporting the "square feet". The system would work just fine if an unbiased third party did the measurements.
donaldc··on Schwarzenegger: Public Pensions and Our Fiscal Future
Since UCB gets state funding, this may make the professor and his pension a part of the very problem he (the professor) is complaining about.
donaldc··on Apple Looking To Slice Up Cable 99 Cents At A Time
If people actually want Internet-only TV subscriptions, the market will force Comcast to lower their prices.

Perhaps yes, eventually, but it could be years. The market for high-speed internet connections in most locations is, at best, a duopoly, due to the high fixed cost of installing infrastructure.

By analogy, think of what unreasonableness the electrical company could get away with if they weren't regulated. The market for high-speed internet connectivity isn't that bad, but it's certainly not a free market in the same sense that pizza delivery is.

donaldc··on A High-Fat Diet Alters Crucial Aspects of Brain Dopamine Signaling
I wish the article would be a little more specific about what kind of fat they're talking about. Saturated? Polyunsaturated? Raw? Processed?

For example, if they're talking about processed polyunsaturated fat, it's probably a leap to apply the conclusions to raw butter.

donaldc··on Domains are inefficiently priced -- small domain owners are the problem
Fortunately, there's an almost infinite number of domains, even within the .com tld. It just requires a little more creativity than it used to to think of a catchy one that hasn't been taken.

Now, if we were actually running out of domain names, the way we're slowly but surely running out of IPv4 addresses, then we'd have a serious problem.

donaldc··on VCs And Super Angels: The War For The Entrepreneur
It seems like the most fundamental difference between VCs and Super Angels is that VCs have more checks and balances (and overhead) surrounding where they invest their money. With Super Angels, one person makes the final decision. For making $50 million bets, checks and balances seem like a good thing. For making $500,000 bets, perhaps one (very competent) person is the better approach.

Some of the appeal of the VCs and their checks and balances may be for reassuring the LPs investing in the VC fund, rather than with its actual effectiveness in improving investment decisions. As Super Angels invest larger and larger sums, perhaps we'll see to what extent the VC approach is (or is not) needed when large sums of money are involved.

donaldc··on VC Insanity: How the economics of venture funds explain the crazy things VCs do
Were I a limited partner, I can't imagine giving such terms to any VCs lacking a stellar track record. I understand why the rest of the VCs would want to position themselves thusly, I just don't understand how they can actually find LPs willing to go along with it.
donaldc··on VC Insanity: How the economics of venture funds explain the crazy things VCs do
What a mess of perverse incentives. I can understand how the best VCs can get away with insisting on such terms from their LPs, but how are the rest of the VCs able to get away with it?
donaldc··on Reflecting on 3 Years At Facebook
Agreed. Things are probably not as ideal as that post makes them sound.

What facebook is essentially saying with this post is: "We're an engineer/programmer-driven company. If you're a good engineer, you'd like working here."

The hoped-for effect is probably to continue attracting good engineers. Many companies that aren't engineer-centric probably wouldn't even know how to say this in their official blog, much less actually bother to say it. So the fact they're saying it still carries some weight.

donaldc··on Is Any Job Better Than No Job?
My point is that, whatever it is he's looking for, he's been looking for a year and a half, and hasn't yet found it. By the laws of supply-and-demand (the basis of the free-market economy) he's not offering a high enough wage.

Of course, it could be that his business is marginal enough that it wouldn't be profitable at a higher wage, in which case it's likely that the days of his business are numbered.

donaldc··on [dead]
I'm not sure how much of that info-page to believe. Right at the top it cites bottled water as costing $10/gallon, which is way more than I've ever paid.
donaldc··on I'm a nearly broke developer/entrepreneur and felt like venting
It sounds like you have yet to release a usable version. You mention that you worked on it a lot, and wanted the thing to be perfect, but a newly released product is never perfect. Get to a point where you can release what you have, and then incrementally improve it.

Since you'll likely be getting a job to support your own efforts, you probably want to reach an agreement with your current partners to phase them out, unless they have useful effort to contribute. Since they supported your effort for a number of months, though, they do have some sort of legitimate claim on some of the work you've done, so I'm not sure what the agreement would look like.

donaldc··on Is Any Job Better Than No Job?
part owner Mark Sperry says he has been looking for $13-an-hour machinists since early last year

Apparently, either they aren't needed all that badly, or else they're finding some. Otherwise, he surely would have raised the wage offered.

donaldc··on Ask HN: What should we eat?
Avoid dairy products is not something everyone agrees on.
donaldc··on The Future of Startup Funding
As the amounts invested in early stages get smaller, and some of the Series A rounds are replaced by angel rounds, there will be an economic incentive to move toward more standardized terms for these early rounds. The less money being invested at a given stage, the more conspicuous the lawyer fees for special terms will be.
donaldc··on The Future of Startup Funding
This is why it will be important as an investor to actually understand the business area that the startup is getting into. The problem with the dotcom bubble wasn't that there was pressure for investors to make a decision; the problem was that many investors put in their money without any clue as to even what the companies they were investing in actually did.
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →