HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

donttrustatoms

206 karma · joined May 27, 2014

COO/cofounder Oklo BS mechanical engineering BA economics MS nuclear engineering MIT
submissionscomments
donttrustatoms··on The Forgotten History of Small Nuclear Reactors
Interesting article.

The nuclear industry does indeed have a selective memory, and much of this interesting legacy is nearly lost.

But perhaps most rightly so. You cannot compare the designs of today with the reactors of the 1950s any more than you can compare the computers of 2015 with those of 1960.

The cost numbers are also dramatically incorrect because you are comparing apples to oranges. Wind and solar may produce a kw cheaply, but for correct pricing, storage that can fully levelize their production over a full day, a full week needs to be accounted for, and it frankly simply does not exist. The truth is that levelizer, with fracking's cheap prices, is natural gas. So for every solar and wind plant you have the same size of natural gas plant, regularly turning on and off. The other part not included in the price is carbon and emissions costs externalities. Natural gas is effectively "coal lite" and biomass burns more dirty than coal.

Let's restart this article/conversation with at least some correct bases.

donttrustatoms··on Mutant butterflies found in Japan after Fukushima nuclear disaster
This study was shown to be based on faulty statistics and method. For examination check out the following: http://www.thingsworsethannuclearpower.com/2012/08/frog-muta...
donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Absolutely. We talked to German energy heads that said they would invest but wouldn't tell anyone. :)

One thing we could use a favor from you. So, so so many people are saying "I support nuclear but I'm the only one"... you aren't! Believe me you're in the majority (70% in US support, although nuclear especially needs people like you, in the top of that group in knowledge/education to speak out and help educate) and that even this is changing... and just come out of the closet already. :)

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
nuclear fuel is 2 million times more energy dense than any other fuel (even more energy dense than that for solar or wind), and this reactor is 30 times more efficient than conventional reactors.

that means roughly 2 million times less transportation, less land use and less waste. (Land use comparisons: http://newenergyandfuel.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/LandU...)

How can we factor in the amount of CO2 removal lost by removal of millions of trees for wind farms? (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/10546071/Millions-o...) Or millions less train use in transport of coal?

It's a good point though. We should count not just that the reactor itself saves 200,000 tons of CO2 during operation, but also the frequently 10x that of fuel burnt to transport that diesel in conventional generators. So each reactor deployment may save 2 million tons of CO2.

Nuclear facilities are also much longer lived than many. Eg solar panel life degrades significantly after a decade. Wind turbines generally have a life of 15 years of so. So that's less concrete, construction, etc.

You're right it's tough or impossible to quanitfy. Intuitively, it all comes back to the energy density number. 2 million times more energy dense, no emissions or pollution in operation, and the "waste" is actually useful fuel which produces energy.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Thanks so much for the luck wishes! We will try to make the most of this luck. ;)

I'm glad you brought up the dirty bomb factor again.

The perpetuation of the myth of the dangers of the dirty bomb is truly sad. We all intuitively realize that the dangers of chemical warfare, biological dispersion (especially because it is transmissible long after the incident), and the dangers of bombs themselves are so much greater than some amount of radiation that decays rapidly and, by the nature of a bomb, is highly dispersed.

As an example of the worst possible radiological contamination (which would not practically be achieved by a dirty bomb to scale), read about the story of the "Atomic Man". In an instant, he received 500 times the "lethal lifetime dose." He died at 75 of unrelated causes. The atopsy showed zero cancer. The chemicals were terrible. the explosion was terrible. Ultimately the radiation itself was not as bad as expected.

In another example, studies showed mice fed plutonium dust had their lives expanded by 120%. See here for an overview of these types of studies and natural effects of hormesis. http://www.radpro.com/641luckey.pdf

It's my belief this disproportionate fear is really a tragedy, a play on the fears of uneducated people (again, fed by media since anything nuclear is like sex or plane crashes) that may ultimately cheat them from peace of mind and clean, reliable energy sooner. What if people refused transportation:vehicles, trucks, and planes because gasoline is highly combustible and kills so many per year? Our economy exploded with oil at the turn of the last century.

But that's a side point, sorry for digression.

Could this be blown up? 1) it's underground 2) it's surrounded by concrete that has been tested to be safe to drop from hundreds of feet in the air 3) it's a solid metal block. It doesn't have dispersion capabilities like other forms.

Unrelated fact since we aren't reprocessing: It's a common misconception that reprocessing is not legal in the US. It is. Also for instance, France does it and has been doing it for a while.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
fission. :) it can run several fuels as described in article.

Battery seemed to have stuck. it's not my favorite. I would say generator. battery apparently seems more innocuous.

Battery also feels accurate because the reactor will be more or less "plug and play" like a really, really, really long lasting battery that produces the same amount of power. It can also be used in "packs" like a battery.

Fundamentally, nuclear, just like coal or anything else is a source of heat. With different secondary packages, you can produce electricity or cogenerate steam.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
I love that you bring up the global scale. It's in the global scale things sound daunting. But it's in the global scale that what is really important becomes clear.

Maybe the most important fact it all boils down to is energy density. Nuclear is literally millions of times more energy dense than any other energy source. Practically, that means millions of times less waste. (See let's talk about physics baby http://www.thingsworsethannuclearpower.com/2013/02/energyden... )

Envision a world powered entirely by coal. Not pretty. Entirely by solar? Appealing PR, but besides being not at all possible it has it's own immense ewaste issues and those never decay away and that waste certainly cannot produce energy. Entirely by hydro? That means destruction of perhaps the largest swaths of ecosystems in the world. Etc. Take any qualms about a globe powered by nuclear and then multiply it almost by millions of times for the other sources.

Land use is another huge factor. See this graphic for comparison. http://newenergyandfuel.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/LandU...

As far as security forces, etc, it wouldn't likely scale like that but let's assume it does. Are numbers like a million well paying jobs spread worldwide actually daunting? How many military folk end their service time in the US alone each year? I was an intern in the Office of the Secretary of Defense for Economics and Manpower so I should remember but I looked it up. There are hundreds of thousands of former service members looking for jobs each year. ( http://www.civilianjobs.com/careeradvice/related.aspx) Thats leaving out more than 6 billion in other people.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Don't trust atoms, they make up everything. ;)
donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
The 4S is an order of magnitude larger, uses complicated flow, and has significant materials issues left to prove out.

You're absolutely right- this is completely different than high school dropouts coding.

How can a startup disrupt a large, established, stodgy industry?

For example, I studied automotive engineering before MIT nuclear grad school and worked in marketing for almost every auto manufacturer: how did Tesla do what the Big guys didn't?

It always starts with a simple, proven product and a niche market in need/willing to pay a premium.

That being said our team does have wide ranging experience. Our CEO worked at GE on their revolutionary reactor they more or less shelved years ago and are now restarting. He served on the board of directors of the American Nuclear Society and has a PhD from MIT. He has seen and worked in the industry from operations of a real reactor to fuel sales to weapons design at national labs to naval reactor design to big industry since high school.

The other good news is that the old dudes approve. We will probably soon publish our advisory board including retired regulatory high ups, industry folk who have successfully licensed, and retired high ranking army energy people. We are leveraging the decades of experience of fuel makers and materials experts... It's fun to see the gleam in their eye when they get excited to really build something.

Ultimately the question of why hasn't this been done before and wasnt possible before has several clear answers, but no answers for those convinced only large, established, old companies can be in these big spaces ripe for disruption. Maybe they are right, maybe not us, maybe not now. It's not easy but it seems inevitable at some point.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
You are right that there are explosions, but it isn't an explosion like an atomic bomb. You understand the difference, but unfortunately there is a fundamental misunderstanding for the general public that a reactor could function like a bomb. There just isn't the energy density to do that.

There was physical damage to structures at Fukushima but that didn't cause any real damage outside the plant or releases. The releases were leaks elsewhere (which were still not huge compared to natural radiation levels).

Chernobyl was due to a reactor literally geared for instability (search rbmk void fraction for details) in the Soviet union. It had no containment around the reactor. So a basic structure around the reactor would crumble with an explosion. But it wouldn't contain that much regardless since it wasn't designed to, and they frankly were arrogant and didn't care much about safety precautions.

As to the plenty of damage from Chernobyl, here's the facts: it has been highly studied over almost 30 years, it is a nature preserve, people who refused to evacuate still live there healthily, and they still operate a reactor on that site. Here's an article which examined and summarized the largest and most reputable medical studies on the Chernobyl aftermath. I was genuinely surprised myself. http://www.thingsworsethannuclearpower.com/2012/05/things-wo...

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
You're absolutely right that safety is a feeling, and we are thinking like you that having a full scale prototype that people and regulators could see, hug, feel, and basically test drive will help. It's just not big and scary. In fact, the amount of heat produced by the reactor a day after shutdown would be on the order of a hundred hair dryers. Sounds cozy :) loud but cozy.

Where the industry has failed in engaging new types of social media (HN, YouTube, reddit, quora, etc) people are stepping up. And honestly it's probably better this way.

On a side note, people don't realize but there's no big nuclear industry really. Our founders have met and spent time with executives from nearly every domestic utility company and all of them have different types of power in their portfolio. They have no real interest in promoting nuclear over coal. The uranium miners make no money compared to coal mines because, think of it, one two-millionth of the volume of nuclear materials is needed compared to the volume of coal. You've never seen a uranium train car, because reactors don't need to burn hundreds of train cars a day and put that in our air.

Compound that with the fact that anything nuclear is like sex and plane crashes for news media. :)

So it's a battle to get education out, but smart people like you on HN will win the day. I really believe it.

Also our charismatic CEO will do his best to stand on a reactor for you ASAP.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Great assessment and distilled description. We have literally spoken to people from lithium mines to chromium mines to remote oil or copper mines and they have explained this same predicament of difficulty of reliable power on site.

As far as unattended: in sum, the technology allows it, but the regulatory structure may not be comfortable with it in the near term. It's not the deal breaker you might think in terms of economics. We are talking about more reliable power at multiples less with prices that don't require the complicated hedging and regular bulk purchases as oil and gas. Generally, we are looking at staffing structure similar to oil rigs- weeks on, weeks off. As regulators and public understand operation, we could transition to remote staff managing sites. Truth is that the technology shuts itself down in case of any bad event (see EBR for similar, really amazing) and there would be almost nothing for on site personnel to do, but there is a perceived safety blanket with having a warm body on site.

Does that answer your question?

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
In the fuel manufacture for redeployment, it's more or less as simple as melting down and recasting. The distinction is reprocessing is generally way more complicated, frequently involves chemicals, and could separate out plutonium which gets people worried.
donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Ouch. :) you're dead on. we've tried to be one of the companies that focus more on doing than publicizing... but it's definitely not good if it mars reputation. Thanks for comment.
donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Great point. It's so true. It's exciting that having nuclear backing from groups like YC help people be less terrified (another nuclear group in YC is Helion!). Some great documentaries like Pandora's Box (on netflix) are helping. And generally, i think people are sometimes just relatively growing "less terrified" of nuclear than global pollution, climate change, ocean acidification etc.
donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
A couple side notes on TC article specifically for those interested:

1) NO reprocessing as somewhat indicated in article ("processing"). We use the low enriched used fuel from the reactor to make new fuel for the next deployment. We don't isolate dangerous parts as done in reprocessing which is the main concern with reprocessing.

2) True waste elimination- it's not just "less of a pain", which is definitely good: the reactor actually eliminates waste instead of just using it for fuel as some thermal types do (eg some startups seen in the media). Without fast neutrons, a reactor cannot burn the longest-lived parts of waste.

3) History on reactor regulatory process: Never before has a reactor been fully built and operated before licensing as somewhat indicated in final paragraph. That would cost $Bs. So, in all history of nuclear, they have built scaled models and spent hundreds of millions in scaled testing and modeling to prove that the scaled tests are accurate to what the full reactor will be like.

The UPower test reactor can be built to full scale for on the order of single digit $millions, which can be said with confidence because even a national lab built a similar reactor and produced electricity with tons of red tape for $100s k.

The heat transfer process has no moving parts and can be shown at full scale and tested to failure on the order of just $thousands, unlike the big boys with outrageously complicated flow loops, pumps, valves, secondary pumps, etc etc etc.

This means the UPower reactor has a chance at being the first commercial reactor able to use the streamlined "license by test" process.

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
To elaborate, The idea is that this is our Tesla Roadster to get to disrupt an out of touch industry, and to get to in-pain, in-need markets, and to get through regulation quickly. The next step is the scaled, grid-competitive reactor- our "model E".

The first ever commercial reactor was a micro reactor, just 5 MWe, outside San Francisco started by GE. These huge companies have lost their way in innovation and off-grid markets have changed dramatically in recent years.

How appropriate is it then for a new Silicon Valley company to start again, disrupting with a new competitive micro reactor...!

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
Great, great call to point out.

The author very unfortunately did not understand that there is NO "reprocessing" necessary for our reactors to reuse fuel. Why, oh why, don't we get to preview what they write. Wording is so important in such a massively misunderstood space.

It is a proven process utilized previously in fuel manufacture, and simply adds a little new fuel to existing used fuel. It does not involving isolating any portions of the fuel as done in reprocessing (which is the main "proliferation hazard" of reprocessing).

-COO UPower

donttrustatoms··on UPower (YC S14) Is Building Nuclear Batteries
I am one of the UPower founders. The key takeaways here are that the main hindrances to novel nuclear are (1) meeting regulatory and safety necessities without huge testing costs, which also require a customer interested in purchasing, and (2) competing with the grid, (3) huge scientific/technical risks if not yet proven.

UPower meets these by (1) being small enough to build a very tough, full scale emulator for testing, never before done in nuclear. (2) not competing on the grid, which gives immediate, in need customers which is also necessary for regulatory process to complete in (1). (3) using technologies and materials with decades of experience, in a new way, eliminating the huge uncertainties of many startups you see in the news.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2