HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dougmwne

13,708 karma · joined March 8, 2015

submissionscomments
dougmwne··on Mark Zuckerberg says Quest 3 'is the better product, period'
I think the facts are mostly on Meta’s side, even when you remove price. Meta is on somthing like 8th generation VR. Apple is a newcomer. The impressive Vision Pro tech just can’t stand up to 10 years of iterative product development. It’s not a iPhone moment at all, though I think Apple will end up being very competitive if they stick to it for a few years. Great for VR, great for Meta.
dougmwne··on Meta's big vision for face computers might be better than Apple's
This is not true.

Meta has done a significant amount of work on a range of productivity and general computing use cases. They are clearly exploring VR/AR as a full platform, not just a game console. They have almost feature by feature parity with the Vision Pro, plus a game console on top of that.

A few examples: Their past 2 headsets have had high quality passthrough cameras for MR. Quest Pro was specifically focused on productivity in a very similar way to the Vision Pro.

2d apps are supported and quite a few are available including MS Office apps, social media and messaging apps.

I don’t know what you mean by calling desktop mirroring apps a toy since the MacBook screen mirroring is exactly one of the hallmark Vision Pro features and apps like Immersed, Virtual Desktop and Horizon workrooms do the same thing in MR or VR.

There’s keyboard and mouse support for 2d productivity and screen sharing just like Vision Pro.

They have a a corporate sales program that includes remote device management specifically for corporate and industrial use cases.

And there been quite a lot of research work on codec avatars in virtual meetings that are extremely similar to Vision Pro. This is one thing that Apple seems to be ahead of Meta on.

dougmwne··on Mark Zuckerberg says Quest 3 'is the better product, period'
Because it’s an interesting product that many new to VR users would be curious to try. It’s also so expensive that nearly no one will buying it. But they can experience 80% of a Vision Pro media and productivity experience with the Quest 3, plus a bunch of VR and gaming experiences that the Vision Pro can’t do.
dougmwne··on Where did DNA come from?
I am a theist. I also find what you are saying pretty unconvincing.

Panspermia theory means there’s basically no bounds on how long ago life may have formed or how many trillions of planets may have hosted primordial soup waiting for the right interactions. Good statical analysis and biochem showing that it couldn’t have formed on earth would be better evidence for panspermia than divine genetics.

The universe and our existence is plenty awe inspiring to me. I don’t need to invent miracles or fit the evidence to the conclusion. I think it’s better to use our intellect and see where the evidence leads us rather than pre-supposing the nature of God.

dougmwne··on Vision Pro Review: Apple's First Headset Lacks Polish and Purpose
I agree. AR is dead in the water until we invent magic displays that may be decades away.

VR has some nice gaming and fitness applications and I think like handheld gaming as a niche, VR gaming will never take over completely but will always be its own little corner of gaming.

dougmwne··on Neal Stephenson was prescient about our AI age
I think it’s a lot more charitable to say that it’s writing for engineers who get excited about ideas. Lots of the ideas aren’t particularly realistic or plausible. The point of the technical sections isn’t for suspension of disbelief, it’s just for the fun of digging into new topics and speculating on how you might use it to build something. I’d say it’s a cousin of Randall Munroe’s what if series.
dougmwne··on Neal Stephenson was prescient about our AI age
Stephenson is an ideas guy. The books are just loose vehicles for all his ideas and things like plot, characters and (gasp) endings are not center stage.

There are so many ideas in his books, mountain upon mountain that it’s no wonder some of them ended up being real products in following decades. They are great fuel for the technical imagination.

dougmwne··on Vesuvius Challenge 2023 Grand Prize awarded: we can read the first scroll
I think we have learned not that you can’t think your way to happiness, but that for the sake of the consumer economy and worker productivity it’s best that you don’t.
dougmwne··on Vesuvius Challenge 2023 Grand Prize awarded: we can read the first scroll
That’s quite premature, but even if we are looking at a personal library containing only personal writings, you’d be looking at a massive increase of information on the ancient world, like a neural map of a single ancient mind that contained all their experiences and thoughts.

The worse case would be that it was 800 copies of the same scroll waiting to be sold off to other libraries.

dougmwne··on Vesuvius Challenge 2023 Grand Prize awarded: we can read the first scroll
It’s a 270 year archaeological and technological culmination. The scrolls were dug up in 1752. It took the collective developments of the Industrial Revolution, the sciences all our engineering and manufacturing prowess to discover, preserve and scan the scrolls. Then the final cherry on top of the current AI revolution that can create inferences and connections that are beyond the human mind to even understand. And out pops 2000 year-old wisdom of the ancients.
dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro and ADHD
Talking about the mindfulness and friction of opening apps, resizing windows and interacting with buttons is a terrible foreshadowing. The famed and fabled Apple UX magic seems to have possibly jumped the shark. I recall no such awkward friction when interacting with the Meta Quest menus. Each UI action requires zen-like eye focus? Someone should have vetoed that on the drawing board.

Apple seems to have made some important advances in passthrough, hardware and hand tracking occlusion. It seems they are probably 3-5 years behind Meta on UX and ecosystem. Meta also appears to be more advanced when it comes to gesture tracking and currently your hands can serve as both pointers and clickers quite well.

dougmwne··on Apple announces more than 600 new apps built for Apple Vision Pro
It’s interesting to compare these launch apps to the giant missing catalog of VR experiences on Quest. I see Synth Riders there though.

Is there a 3D maps app? I always considered Google Earth to be a killer app that was abandoned.

dougmwne··on Tried Vision Pro. Here's what I thought
I have encountered a few real benefits for VR.

It’s way more active than a game console. You stand, kneel, punch, swing your arms and break a sweat. It may not be a gym workout, but it’s not half bad if you were otherwise going to be on the couch.

Social experiences are person to person instead of broadcast. You talk with real embodied individuals instead of massive threads with thousands. It’s way more human than even a group chat. I can see it eventually surpassing FaceTime.

dougmwne··on Tried Vision Pro. Here's what I thought
Everyone reacts differently to VR sickness, but there are a few things you could try.

First of all, you should always stop the moment you feel any motion sickness. You more you try to power through, the worse it gets.

Don’t do anything with artificial locomotion. (Where your VR movement does not match up to your real life movement.) Many games have teleport options and snap turning instead of smooth. There are also some great roomscale games such as Superhot, elevent table tennis or Walkabout mini golf. You will eventually acclimate and be able to do smooth locomotion.

Some games have framerate options, put it to 90 or 120hz

Set up a fan and have it blow on you.

For me, I took about a month to acclimate, but after that can you play any kind of game and not get sick.

I have heard reports that Vision Pro also causes motion sickness for new VR users.

dougmwne··on Mistral CEO confirms 'leak' of new open source AI model nearing GPT4 performance
GPT-4 is an enormous model that took an enormous amount of training. The big news is that smaller teams are getting close to its performance on a small model that can run on a single GPU. No doubt many of these innovations could be scaled up, but pretty much only Google and Microsoft have the compute resources for the behemoth models(Not just the training, but the giant resources required to run the inference for hundreds of millions of users. Google already claims to have surpassed GPT-4 with their unreleased Gemini Ultra model. No doubt OpenAI/Microsoft is sitting on GPT-5 refining it just waiting to leapfrog the competition.
dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro review
Yeah, the Quest seems to be the spiritual successor to Wii sports. It’s the closest thing you can buy to that 2006 experience. The long dream of wielding a lightsaber on the Wii was finally realized on the Quest, to a quite satisfactory level.

And yet, from a gaming perspective, we still have to crack force feedback and natural locomotion before we have a holodeck. Maybe in 20 more years.

dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro Weighs Almost as Much as a 12.9-Inch iPad Pro
This is likely not a major issue for the first version. It’s is the general range of other VR headsets. Mostly a decent strap design will make it comfortable to wear for an hour, maybe two. The eye strain from a fixed lens means you won’t want to wear it much longer than that anyway.

Future versions will need to get a lot lighter and smaller to go beyond gaming and short uses to be something you’d use as much as a phone or laptop.

dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro Weighs Almost as Much as a 12.9-Inch iPad Pro
Do you have a source on that? I am curious if it’s a widespread issue or very rare.
dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro available for pre-order
It will be interesting to see some side by side comparisons to the Quest Pro which has both the eye and and hand tracking as well.

I was disappointed there were no controllers, even as an accessory since it means that most of the VR gaming catalog will never be ported to this awesome Vision hardware.

dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro available for pre-order
I attempted with the Quest 2 and it was far from doing the job well. Resolution is too low, optics too poor, headset too heavy and uncomfortable, battery too small. I’ve heard Quest 3 is better, but I am still very skeptical that the Vision Pro could be an all day device and replacement for a multi monitor setup. Possibly in a few years there will be a dedicated device for just virtual monitors designed for all day working. Xreal’s product is close but still very early adopter.
dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro available for pre-order
I don’t think that’s likely. It seems that the price is high because Apple wanted the 2030 headset today. If they get moderate success, they will release lower spec versions which will probably not match the Vision Pro for 2 product cycles. So the Vision SE 2 might be on par with the Pro 1. Pro 1 likely to be supported for maybe 6 years, assuming it’s not a big flop and Apple abandons headsets for awhile.
dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro available for pre-order
It seems like it’s also a dev device. Reports are that Apple is working on cheaper versions so the Vision pro provides an early adopter market and high spec device for developers. In a few years when they go for a mainstream launch there will already be an app and game ecosystem.

Different from a watch, some kind of mixed reality wearable will eventually replace phones and laptops, I am sure. It might still be several decades till the technology fits in a pairs of eyeglasses.

Consider this your 2050 preview, like the Apple Newton to your iPhone.

dougmwne··on Apple Vision Pro available for pre-order
Early reports are that the Vision feels quite heavy to wear. That’s almost certainly going to make it a bad choice for virtual screens for more than an hour or so.
dougmwne··on Ask HN: What would you do if you could start over?
I would have been a lot more aggressive about finding better roles in my early career. I had 2 good experiences for 4 years each, but I could have left both jobs after 1 year and had the same career progression.

I think my upbringing focused a lot on “stick it out” and “work hard and you will get recognized exactly like you deserve.” It was a passive laborer mentality from a blue collar area.

I took a sabbatical and after some soul searching realized it was more like “sharks that stop swimming drown.” Career and compensation took off after that.

dougmwne··on Ask HN: Why are resume gaps frowned upon?
As a former recruiter, I very much disagree:)

Even if a candidate passed a strong technical assessment, there are many other factors and skills that make a person a successful team member. A gap is just one of many possible signals that a person might not be a perfect employee. It’s a common sense question to ask for recruiters. They do not need to be explicitly told by their bosses to ask the question and it does not have much to say about the organization. All it takes is to talk to hundreds of candidates for various roles and see how inconsistent the candidates quality is and tie it back to employment history.

The ideal resume is a series of 2 to 5 year stints or promotions within the same company where each role is of increasing responsibility and level. 80th percentile candidates who want to work do not spent long periods of time unemployed. It’s always a matter of someone having major priorities beyond work or an inability to work.

And I say all this as a person who took a year break because I had priorities outside of work, then with awareness of that impact, aggressively jumped back into the workforce at month 12.

dougmwne··on Ask HN: Why are resume gaps frowned upon?
Schrödinger’s cat. It’s not illegal till the court looks at your situation and says it is. Companies do plausibly illegal things all day long.
dougmwne··on Ask HN: Why are resume gaps frowned upon?
Your brother in law’s situation is quite common. It’s exactly why this is a reliable signal on a resume to avoid or at least not be in the dark on candidates with baggage. There are very few saintly bosses out there ready to rehabilitate someone’s work ego and professionalism. As a recruiter, it was my job to find the warts on an otherwise excellent candidate so that the hiring manager could at least make an informed decision. Missing something big with a candidate reflected poorly on my attention to detail.
dougmwne··on Ask HN: Why are resume gaps frowned upon?
Illegal if you do it explicitly. Legal if you do it by proxy criteria and plausible deniability.
dougmwne··on Ask HN: Why are resume gaps frowned upon?
It’s most likely to be brought up by a recruiter during a 10 minute phone screen, and since a tru-hike takes maybe 6 months max, I wouldn’t expect you to get asked. If you went hiking for over a year, I think the recruiter might ask, but that it doesn’t really reflect on the company’s values, it’s just a standard kind of question any recruiter might ask if they get a sense there could be a problem there.

If the hiring manager asked about a short gap, that would be a bit wtf to me.

dougmwne··on Ask HN: Why are resume gaps frowned upon?
It’s not holding you back because you are jumping over the low bar. A year is not a particularly long gap and might even go unnoticed. But f someone noticed and asked, sounds like you had a great answer. That’s all you need.

Having no good explanation for a 5 year gap will probably get you filtered out.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →