HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

drawnwren

1,466 karma · joined January 30, 2016

submissionscomments
drawnwren··on GDPR After One Year
Do people believe that children have a right to privacy from their parents?
drawnwren··on Uber, Lyft drivers manipulate fares at DCA causing artificial price surges
It seems to me that Uber's counter argument would be that they aren't obligated to offer a contract to all contractors equally. They would further argue that Uber's product is availability of drivers vs the rides themselves (remember they are only the middle men) and that they provide preference (in a binary manner) to contractors who allow them to provide consistent availability.
drawnwren··on Keybase and Stellar is live for everyone
Yeah, I would say linux _is_ unworkable for laymen. If crypto were trying to sell itself as infrastructure, I would agree with your statement. But 'just wait for the nice pretty layer' is what people have been saying about btc for the last 10 years.
drawnwren··on Keybase and Stellar is live for everyone
I don't mean to attack you. It's just that there is a large gap between well-engineered and easy to use.

I am 100% certain you're a better developer than I, and that lightning is not a result of poor engineering. But if a layman can't pick it up and use it in under 5 minutes, it's unworkable (if you're targeting laymen).

Crypto is full of genius engineers, and product folks, but I think there is (and always has been) a usability crisis.

Thanks for your work on both Linux and Lightning. I look forward to the day you can point to this comment on HN as being ridiculously dated.

drawnwren··on Keybase and Stellar is live for everyone
I agree that crypto could be valuable.

But, (1) the lightning network has been repeatedly attacked as unworkable trash and (2) there needs to be a reason to make crypto transactions other than drugs or vaguely crypto-anarchist philosophy.

(b) Tether's recent scandal has made all stable coins fairly suspect.

(d) The makerdao system has some pretty serious problems. High liquidation rates and skyrocketing fees both come up.

If anything, crypto has taught us (through the plethora of 2018/19 crypto scams) that revokability is a feature of transactions that is _valuable_.

I'd say my biggest takeaways from crypto, currently, are that there is not such thing as 'without having to trust the other party' and that all of the middlemen in the current financial system do provide more value than just taking a cut (while that value is probably not proportional to the cut that they take).

All that said, I'm still optimistic on crypto. However, I think it's unrealistic to expect it to replace a significant part of the web in its current form.

drawnwren··on Facebook sues analytics firm Rankwave over data misuse
My argument made an appeal to the emotional state behind both situations.

> Popular vote would always decide in favor of urban centers and rural citizens would be neglected yet expected to pay taxes.

The point is that disenfranchisement of a large group of people would lead them to seek action against the government. You could pick the Civil Rights Movement if you think the Revolution doesn't fit the bill for some reason.

drawnwren··on Facebook sues analytics firm Rankwave over data misuse
Yep, the left narrative around the Electoral College seems dangerous to me as well.

I think any argument against the Electoral College has to also include an argument against the Senate. Or is two senators/state acceptable?

The founding fathers clearly considered the effects of having large population centers and attempted to account for it in the House.

A system with no representation for the smaller states would lead to exactly the same scenario that caused the U.S. to be founded. Popular vote would always decide in favor of urban centers and rural citizens would be neglected yet expected to pay taxes.

drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
> That's not what is happening here. The police are not purchasing access like an advertiser would; they are receiving special access for the purpose of tracking suspects.

Yes, but my point was that we're only arguing about how much someone should have to spend to gain access.

> The SCOTUS of the 1960s was very clear -- routing your communication through a corporate party does not,

But my point, _again_, is that they were _not_ clear that you have some expectation of privacy after _selling your personal data on an exchange_.

drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
I'm unsure if you're being disingenuous or legitimately don't understand the wording.

"To identify and suggest products or services that might interest you" -- means your data can be shared or sold to be used in advertising models.

"To provide you customized user experiences, including personalized product and service offerings;" -- same

"We may ... provide access to, or disclose ... location data without your approval to ... operate and improve ... our business," ellipses added so you can see it literally says we can give your data away for money.

drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
In that case, you haven't entered into an agreement whereby advertisers may know the contents of your phone conversations in order to better target you with ads. If you had, I imagine SCOTUS would rule differently. It seems to me that this debate is merely about price. If the police were buying your location data off of a service that offered it, how would they be any different than advertisers?
drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
That's patently false. It's in that giant ToS that you didn't read and did sign. Here's where it is in T-Mobile's ToS [1]. You're looking for either, "To identify and suggest products or services that might interest you; To make internal business decisions about current and future product and service offerings; To provide you customized user experiences, including personalized product and service offerings;" or "If your device is turned on, our network is collecting data about the device location. We may use, provide access to, or disclose this network location data without your approval to provide and support our services, including to route wireless communications, operate and improve our network and business,"

1 - https://www.t-mobile.com/responsibility/privacy/privacy-poli...

drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
I do agree that 'don't interact with the modern world' seems like a ridiculous solution.

Personally, I think GDPR was a reasonable first step down the path of regulation. I would personally like to see a regulation in the US that forced companies to offer data reselling as an add-on to a base package. As a programmer in 2019, I think it's a bit hypocritical of me to opt-in to the industry that is responsible for the situation we are in while saying 'regulation is the solution here'.

But it's important to note that we've moved from a legal to a moral question. Legally, I believe the government is currently in the right. Morally, the situation sucks and we should change it.

drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
I don't think that applies here. I'm specifically not saying that producing data makes it public. Rather I'm saying allowing a third party to resell your data with impunity necessarily obviates your ability to control the dissemination. If you've given control of your data to a third party, you have no control. Full stop.
drawnwren··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
It sounds dystopian, but I'm not really sure I disagree with the government here. We allow our personal data (to include real time location) to be collected and sold on third party exchanges. I'm not sure there is a strong argument for the government needing a warrant to access the data given how freely we already disseminate it.

The solution would be to not disseminate it, but we, as a collective, have agreed to not make privacy a concern so far.

The biggest irony of all is, as we saw with gdpr, most hn users are nominally for privacy until regulation is implemented and we realize that we(most programmers) are the people making a living off of the current state of privacy.

drawnwren··on Planting 1.2T Trees Could Cancel Out a Decade of CO2 Emissions
Op provided a clear explanation of their argument. I don't think they argued that we need more CO2 just provided an interesting perspective on a different time scale. No need for ad hominem attacks.
drawnwren··on New study shows grim outlook for future of Air Force pilot shortage
As an Air Force vet, I think he accurately identifies the problem but I don't think the solution is what he thinks it is. The Army has been flying with Warrant Office pilots for years. They make less money, but they don't require a college degree so they have a _much_ larger pool of applicants.

The solution is to disentangle leadership and piloting. Currently, because they're all officers, pilots view themselves as leaders of men. However, as the author of this post says, the most leading a pilot will ever do is lead a flight of jets. Piloting has always been a tactical skill, and its place as an officer-exclusive job makes it incorrectly perceived as a gateway to a strategic career.

You only needed a high school degree to fly in WW2, and I honestly believe the Air Force should be hiring pilots based solely on ability to fly vs credentialism.

As a funny aside, the Air Force originally gave up Warrant Officers so that they could have have higher ranked enlisted personnnel (E-9). Afterwards, all of the other services complained that their enlisted personnel were outranked by the Air Force so they got E-9s and didn't have to give up their warrants.

drawnwren··on The New York Times sells premium ads based on how an article makes you feel
I would add that the NYT is a very niche case. Their target audience has been educated coastal liberals for some time. It may be that this is a result of their audience and not predictive of an underlying phenomenon.
drawnwren··on San Diego Implemented City-Wide Streetlight Surveillance
Your logic doesn't leave room for the possibility that there is a correlation between electability and ability to raise funds. I.e. the candidate most likely to win raises more funds and not vice versa.
drawnwren··on Giant Military Contract Has a Hitch: A Little-Known Entrepreneur
Why did you answer your concern before you presented it? I'm genuinely confused.
drawnwren··on U.S. to ground Boeing 737 Max 8
4. The issue was pilot operation of the aircraft. Apparently it was possible to disable the old 737 autopilot with stick input despite that not being the method prescribed by the procedures. MAX didn't involve simulator training, so a less disciplined crew in MAX might not correctly disable autopilot in an emergency despite the procedures for doing so still being correct.
drawnwren··on College Cheating Scandal: An Admissions Officer Speaks Out
In Korea and Japan, they use the one test system and have the highest suicide rate among high school students. It also makes their high school lives hell and their education system lackluster at best. I would advise caution.
drawnwren··on Porsche's Taycan EV has pulled in more than 20k deposits
1. I don't know if there is enough volume there. 2. If there is, the weight balance of the car would be fucked.
drawnwren··on NSA’s top policy advisor: It’s time to start putting teeth in cyber deterrence
You're trying to present a completely different argument but presented no justification.
drawnwren··on Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Day Care
As someone who was adopted, this seems excessive. Unless someone is adopting a newborn, adoption carries a significantly different set of requirements than childbirth.

Also, calling adoption birth for same sex couples is weird. My mother is my mother but in no world did she give birth to me.

drawnwren··on Pompeo Hints at Huawei Ultimatum to Countries Buying Equipment
Fwiw, any vet will tell you the craziest firefights in Afghanistan were always when we went for the opium. Terrorism has been in bed with drug smuggling since the beginning.
drawnwren··on Algorithmic auditors are exposing employee expense fraud
Unfortunately, I don't think coke dealers are in the practice of providing itemized receipts.
drawnwren··on Make School (YC W12) gains accreditation for 2-year applied CS bachelor’s degree
That's a good thought, but low tuition costs mean CS professors at California community colleges are making close to nothing.

Warning, anecdotal evidence, but I took CS at CCSF and when asked how to tell if a number was prime in Java, the professor responded "I don't know, google it. There's probably a function that does that."

drawnwren··on U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute
I suspect Spotify would prefer to have their app on iOS without using Apple's distribution channel if they could.
drawnwren··on Amazon HQ2: Advanced talks about second headquarters in Northern Virginia
This comment is hilarious to me. Quintuple your salary? I worked in consulting for 5 years, and I can assure you that Amazon is already paying less for equivalent candidates. I'm not sure what you think happens in government consulting, but it is nothing like government employment.

Edit: The strategy you outline re: government employees is already employed by all of the large government consulting firms. Amazon is late to the game and behind the ball with their lack of awarded contracts. They might be able to catch up, but contracting is one field that has repeatedly shown itself to be resistant to disruption.

drawnwren··on Antiwar Movement Spreads Among Tech Workers
That's because it's not an antiwar movement. It's a self empowerment movement disguised as an anti war movement. It's the same reason we didn't see any real difference on war policies between the candidates in 2016. People aren't currently concerned with war. They're concerned with feeling good about their choices re: war.
← PreviousPage 7 of 16Next →