HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dstorrs

936 karma · joined September 28, 2009

Full name: David Storrs

Gmail address: david.storrs

Software guy, serial entrepreneur, rationalist, occasional stand-up comedian, fulltime stand-up guy.

submissionscomments
dstorrs··on How Experienced Developers Can Handicap a Lean Startup
When MySQL came out it [...] said that speed of development and operation matters more than correctness. [...I]ts initial success stands as a testament to the principle that there are a lot of problems (particularly in the web area) where people [...] are tolerant of occasional problems.

I wonder if this would still be true today? Things are very different from 1994, when MySQL was born.

Back then, the Web was so small it was almost possible to visit every site. Site designers, site developers, and customers were all trying new things constantly and learning what worked. There weren't many expectations because everything was so new.

Today, my guess is that people have a much higher standard for e-commerce. But that's just a guess.

dstorrs··on Running a freemium web app? Here's a big reason we're growing.
I remember RuneScape, from ads in old Dragon magazines. But I always thought it was a pen and paper game. Was it originally a P&P before going online, or were the ads simply unclear?
dstorrs··on Ask HN: How do you explain closures?
Thanks, this looks like a good way to present it. Next time I'm in this position, I'll use this as my jumping off point for the discussion.
dstorrs··on Large Hadron Collider scuttled by birdy baguette-bomber
Are you kidding? This thing is miles across, operates at temperatures colder than space, and is intended to cope with energy equivalent to two aircraft carriers ramming into each other at flank speed. If there's a problem, they can dump all that energy and contain it safely within a few seconds or less.

You'll never have a system this powerful that can't be fouled up somehow...whether it's birds with bread or rats chewing the wires or just plain bad luck. But these guys have made the system safe and built it so they can go from "emergency shutdown" to "normal operations" in only three days.

The LHC is an amazing piece of engineering with fantastically good fault tolerance.

dstorrs··on Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory to Quantum Mechanics
Were we reading the same article?

"But when you accept the weirdness of quantum mechanics [in the macro world], you have to give up the idea of space-time as we know it from Einstein. The greatest weirdness here is that it doesn’t make sense. If you follow the rules, you come up with something that just isn’t right."

"You’re led to a completely crazy point of view."

"My own view is that quantum mechanics is not exactly right, and I think there’s a lot of evidence for that."

"INTERVIEWER: In general, the ideas in theoretical physics seem increasingly fantastical. Take string theory. All that talk about 11 dimensions or our universe’s existing on a giant membrane seems surreal.

PENROSE: You’re absolutely right. And in a certain sense, I blame quantum mechanics, because people say, “Well, quantum mechanics is so nonintuitive; if you believe that, you can believe anything that’s non­intuitive.” But, you see, quantum mechanics has a lot of experimental support, so you’ve got to go along with a lot of it. Whereas string theory has no experimental support."

"[My new book] is called Fashion, Faith and Fantasy in the New Physics of the Universe. Each of those words stands for a major theoretical physics idea. ['Fantasy'] is quantum mechanics at all levels...."

All of those quotes sound to me like pretty clear rejection of string theory and quantum mechanics and an implied rejection of much of modern higher physics. Yes, he accepts experimental proofs where available, but he seems to be saying that these theories are wrong because they don't make sense to him, or because they don't match the way we perceive the world. But when I look at the Hacker New logo, I don't perceive photons of wavelength 590 nanometers bouncing off my retina--I pereceive the color orange.

Personally, as I read this, I kept hearing Clarke's 1st law (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarke%27s_three_laws) looping in my head:

"When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong."

dstorrs··on Has Japan designed the world's best bike shed?
Wouldn't this be a simple incremental improvement--hold it by the seat post, for example? Every bike has one of those, and they are pretty much in the same place. You'd also need a pair of 'arms' to keep the front wheel from falling to the side, but they would only need to provide guidance, not support.
dstorrs··on Don't panic over the secret copyright treaty
True.

But he's still right about the "don't panic" part. Until this actually shakes out into the real world, we don't know how much of an issue it will be. If it's one of those things that no one bothers to enforce, then who cares? If they do try to enforce it, then there will be class action suits and it will eventually go away.

In short, I don't think we can prevent it, but I do think we can get rid of it if need be.

dstorrs··on Get things done. More building, less talking: A rule of thumb for raising money.
My suggestion would be to join a local college games club. There is tremendous overlap between techies and people who play non-mainstream games (e.g. Rail Baron, Dominion, RPGs, San Juan, Fluxx, etc). Playing card / board games with people for a few months, means you will:

a) have a lot of fun

b) make new friends

c) have a chance to get feedback on your idea

d) discover who the talented CS / designer / whatever people are, and get a pretty good picture of what they are like. If you're looking to take someone on as a technical co-founder (which I presume, from your mention of 'free tech talent') you'd better know in advance if you can stand to be around them.

General games club meetings are fun and will provide you with contacts and information on those contacts. If you want an in-depth picture of someone, get into a role-playing game with them. To use D&D references: do they play the cleric and heal the party, or the assassin and backstab their teammates? Do they hog the snacks? Can they listen to other players' suggestions politely and implement them if they are better than their own ideas? Do they participate in the group when it isn't their turn to speak, or do they have their laptop open in order to play WoW && IM && check email?

There may or may not be "right" answers to any of the above questions, but they will give you a lot of information to make a decision on.

You will also find that college games clubs consist of more alumni than current students. This is a great way to network to experienced people (techies among them). As an example, at the Columbia games club, we have someone who currently works at Google. I met my co-founder at CUGC.

dstorrs··on From Rejection to Acquisition in One Year: One Startup's Story
This is a great story and I'm happy for Mudge, but I wish the story had been a bit more detailed. It pretty much boiled down to "he had this idea, some friends liked it so he didn't quit, he got acquired". When I saw the title, I was hoping for details on what made it all come together.
dstorrs··on German man programs "Hello World" into wheat field
Here's a niche marketing idea for you: executable hedge mazes that print out paeans of praise to the owner of the maze.
dstorrs··on Ask Y Combinator: Notification information for W2010?
Thank you.
dstorrs··on Plumber vs. programmer: a face-off over an online directory
What left me puzzled was why HelpHive didn't simply de-list Conklin with an apology and a statement that it wasn't their intent to harm his business. It seems that this would have been the ethical thing to do, and would have resulted in some good publicity for them.
dstorrs··on Micro-documentary on "A cool tiny home tour: living in 96 square feet"
A complementary movement is co-housing (http://www.cohousing.org/). Co-housing is about intentional community--a group of people get together and deliberately choose to live in smaller houses with a shared common space. This space might include a library, playroom, media center, kitchen / dining room (although each house has its own, and you aren't obligated to cook or eat with the community), or whatever else the community decides. Every co-housing group does something a bit different. One specific example is http://www.mosaic-commons.org/ (Full disclosure: I was involved in Mosaic for a couple of years until my divorce.)

It's a pretty cool concept and tends to attract the kind of people that hackers like (smart, interesting, iconoclastic).

dstorrs··on Micro-documentary on "A cool tiny home tour: living in 96 square feet"
Depending on the age of the kids, you can try it out pretty simply--while the kids are off at college / summer camp / whatever, rent an apartment for a few months.

On the "paying for it" side, it's a balance between your financial situation / tolerance for risk; you can either pay the extra fee, or you can rent out the house (check out AirBnB, Craigslist, etc).

On the "logistics" side, you will have a bunch of furniture, clothes, etc which don't fit in the apartment. You can either leave those in the house or put them in storage, whichever works better for you.

Try to not go back to the house while you're living in the apartment, though--have your mail forwarded, etc. And if you find there is a box of clothes / books / kitchen gadgets / whatever that you haven't unpacked at the end of your apartment time, consider getting rid of it.

dstorrs··on The Double Opt-In Introduction by Fred Wilson
Not really. Anyone with money and a willingness to invest doesn't have trouble making connections. Their problem is making the right connections. Having a small but high-quality network is far more valuable to them than having a large network of people who waste their time and resources.
dstorrs··on People will pay for surprise
Disappointing review.

From the article:

Andy Nulman is Mr. Surprise. Go read his blog on surprise. But come back, ok? Better yet, stick around here for awhile, but bookmark his blog link in a separate browser window or tab for later enjoyment.

This article starts off with the above desperate-sounding request, which reminds me of a 1996 web site ("Please resize your browser to be <--- this wide --->"). It then goes on to make an assertion ("People will pay for surprise"), and then offers four "laws" of surprise which aren't really explained--what does it mean to say "Balls Beat Brains"?

Mr. Nulman may have written a great book, but this review really does him a disservice.

dstorrs··on US School Kids Are Doing Better Than Ever – But You Never Hear It
At the risk of sounding overly pedantic, I have a lot of trouble giving credence to an education-related blog article that averages roughly 1 spelling / grammar error per sentence in the first paragraph.
dstorrs··on Figuring out what your company is all about
I read his stuff occasionally and appreciate it when he makes a good point, which he does sometimes. At the same time, I feel a consistent smugness in what he writes. It's messages like "every other job in the city sucked" (and the implication that they still do) versus "FogBuz rocks", and "I don't want to live in 'lesser cities' [than New York]".()

There's also a lack of substance to much of his writing. Aeron chairs are what makes FogBuz great? Really? That's a pretty low bar to match. To me, a great company has purpose, vision, and smart-but-zero-ego people who enjoy working together to produce something that will actually make a difference in the world. Give me those things and I'll sit on a milk crate.

() (And, for the record, I live in NYC myself and think it's a pretty awesome city.)

dstorrs··on Equity investing in superstar individuals (not their companies, them)
A variant on this that I've seen proposed is: find a (medical student | apprentice plumber | law student | etc) that you think is talented and honest. Pay his/her way through school and provide enough money to get them comfortably set up. They now owe you free service for the rest of their career in that field.
dstorrs··on The Chinese Internet: Why the “Copy Cats” Win
The thing that impressed me the most was the discussion of the quantitative work they have done. Song Li has generated an enormous database of pragmatic, mathematically proven advice about how to be successful with the opposite gender...somehow, using it for nothing more than a matchmaking service restricted to China seems small potatoes. Granted, it was gathered from a Chinese-only audience, so some of it is probably locale-specific. I'd be interested to see the same thing done on a more global scale and then adapted for other uses.
dstorrs··on Daring Fireball: Pound the Quality
Most likely he means that Android developers don't need to deal with their apps being 2nd class citizens the way iPhone developers do. Unless you work for Apple:

1) You are restricted as to which parts of the SDK you can use.

2) Your app may be rejected for any reason, no reason, or whatever reason. The reason may or may not be explained, and may or may not make sense.

3) Even if it isn't rejected, it will still take weeks or months to get your app into the hands of customers.

None of this applies to Apple apps, of course. Therefore, independent developers are 2nd class citizens of the iPhone.

dstorrs··on Ask HN: What have you changed your mind about recently?
Don't be too hard on yourself, and don't go too far in the opposite direction. Kids do want boundaries, and they are happier when they have them. Watching my 8-year-old nephew's behavior bears this out perfectly; when he's given lots of input into plans and opportunity to negotiate, he acts like a demon and ends up melting down and unhappy. When given rules he's a happy angel.

I think the trick is to not open the floor to negotiation. If kids have reasonable objection or points you hadn't considered, they will raise the point and you can modify the rule. If they know that they are "negotiating" just to get their own way and that it won't work, they won't waste the time--and everyone will be happier.

That's my experience, anyway.

dstorrs··on Ask HN: Email for Startups?
Thanks, everyone. Based on your advice I went ahead and signed up for Google. We'll see how it works out.
dstorrs··on Please Criticize my Fitness Site that Stores Workout Programs
Single biggest thing you did right: Got an absolute minimum product up fast, then asked potential customers to criticize.

Things you could improve: As others said, not clear what this is. Explain it in 10 words or fewer, make them big, bold, and centered. The interface needs to improve...there are too many steps in creation / editing (why must I create the wrong name first, then edit it to correct value?), there's no way to create / modify multiple elements in one step, and it's not clear how many steps there are, so I quit out partway through.

Good luck with it.

dstorrs··on The false god of coffee
The productivity tracking he's talking about sounds like the Pomodoro technique. Check here for more: http://www.pomodorotechnique.com/
dstorrs··on The IE CSS Bug Which Cost Me A Month’s Salary
Some other options for x-browser testing:

http://litmusapp.com/browser-testing http://www.browsera.com/ http://www.spoon.net/browsers/

The last doesn't work for me (Mac using either FF or Safari) but the other two seem to. I haven't used any of these personally, and am not affiliated with them, just listing some options for others to check out.

dstorrs··on Linux: Linus Says, Linux Not Designed; It Never Was
Not challenging your point, just curious...do you know of any (non-human) animals that have harnessed fire? I don't mean in an "environmental" way, like looking for food along the edges of a burn, or having IR-sensitive vision, I mean actually collecting it, containing it, using it as a tool. Or is that a uniquely human trait?
dstorrs··on Introducing Raindrop from Mozilla Labs
Hear, hear! I read the first few sentences, saw "messaging"--strike one--saw a bunch of incoherent babble--strike two--then started skimming. Halfway down the page, I still had no idea what it actually DID, so I closed the page.

Could someone who was more interested than I was sum this up in a sentence? What does it actually do?

dstorrs··on How to Read Other People's Code -- And Why
>In writing my own code, I decompose until each function or method has a single purpose (f() does X, not X & Y & Z!),

I hear this one a lot, from a lot of different sources. In practice, it never seems that practical. Here's a trivial example: the dashboard-page function in our webapp. It needs to do all of the following:

1) verify that the user is logged in. If not, bounce them to the login page, then bring them back on successful login

2) collect the list of all their providers

3) collect the list of all their profiles

4) collect the list of all their account information

5) load up and display the appropriate templates to render the web page with the requisite information.

Now, points 1-4 are accomplished by calling other functions, true. But dashboard-page still needs to do 5 separate things.

dstorrs··on Some misconceptions about NoSQL
I think when zaphar said "sql database" he was just using common usage for RDBMS. Yes, "SQL database" does not have to mean "row oriented storage". But all of the commonly familiar SQL RDBMSs use row oriented storage.
← PreviousPage 8 of 10Next →